News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:07AM (#20450119)
Could you articulate this “big difference” a bit more? So far the only one I can parse from your comment is ease of access, driving to a clerk versus walking to my desk.

That doesn’t seem particularly convincing. Or at least I don’t see how this feeds into the privacy “conundrum”

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by paulsutter on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:16AM (#20450847)
Take for the example Norway’s rules (cited below) that tax returns can be viewed by anyone, and the list of who viewed each record is also public. This requires limitations on how the data can be reproduced.

If you need to drive to see a clerk it’s a lot harder to get access, and that’s a reasonable barrier. The clerk can also have reasonable limits on how many you can request and whether you can make a copy. Each of these rules do have an impact on how widely information is used or disseminated, and can limit data mining style use. Note that some of these limitations (like preventing a copy) can be more difficult when accessing from a website.

So yes, there are many useful limitations than can be placed on sharing of data that have a real practical impact on privacy.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by reacweb on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:15AM (#20450839)
You can read the car plate of cars passing in front of you. It is public information. If you can easily gather the location of all cars at any time, it becomes a big privacy problem. You can identify husbands cheating...
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by wool_gather on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:07PM (#20451335)
Indeed. I can't help thinking that the fact that some piece of tech makes a qualitative change like this means that there's some fundamental flaw somewhere with the way we associate a person with a public record or identifier. But I'm not really sure what that flaw is, or what to do about it.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by pixl97 on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @01:51PM (#20452299)
Nobody is sure how to solve it because the problem is with people and the culture we have built around having actual privacy in the past. Technology has essentially robbed us of it, which is problematic as technology solves lots of other problems so we just cant get rid of it.

This is really similar to the music industry and the problem of piracy. Bits are easy to copy and hard to prevent the copy of.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @02:03PM (#20452393)
I believe that if volume, processing, or accessibility of some new technology or information stream changes the access patterns to that information, that implies that the nature of that information gathering and accessibility needs to be re-evaluated.

A cop calling in a suspect license plate is one thing, an automated system reading all license plates at all intersections and tracking every vehicle in a city is different, and should have regulatory or judicial oversight applied in light of the new access. The fact that any one of those plates could have been seen at each intersection by a cop who happened to be there does not mean that license plate readers don't change the nature of that information.

A lawyer asking a clerk for a transcript of a call regarding a pending case is one thing. Transcribing all calls and getting a text message when someone called 911 yesterday and mentioned your name is a big difference.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by mruts on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:12AM (#20450160)
I could be wrong but maybe one is recursively enumerable and the other is not? i.e at a clerk you need to know what you’re looking for in contrast to a list of records that you can just look through.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:14AM (#20450194)
The records are no less public in either situation? They can be accessed by anyone, regardless if they’re actively looking for a specific record or stumbling across one while scrolling through their local clerk database on a Saturday afternoon.

I still don’t understand the conceit.

If one were to say checking documents out from a central clerking office acts as a check or something against unauthorized and potentially unethical use of public records, well then yes absolutely I can see some merit.

As delivered presently, not as much.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by lisper on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:48AM (#20450563)
> The records are no less public in either situation? They can be accessed by anyone

No, that's not true. If you have to physically go to the county clerk's office then you have to physically be in the country. That is a significant barrier.

An example that is even more salient than 911 records: if you make any political contribution in the U.S. you are require by law to give your home address which then becomes part of an FEC database that can be accessed by anyone on earth with an internet connection.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:02AM (#20450709)
You're correct, it is a barrier, it makes things more difficult for the requester.

How you request it or where you are when you make the request doesn't change the legal status of the record itself if a data set has been made public by your state legislature.

If your local laws say you have to make the request in person, so be it. It's still an open record that can be queried and retrieved by members of the public.

If your local law say you may make your request online at a specific web address, so be it. It is still an open record that can be queried and retrieved by members of the public.

The mechanism or methodology of requesting a public record does not change a public record factually and legally being public unless local law says so (or FOIA if we're dealing with a federal agency, but since the context here is 911 calls, this is much more likely going to fall to a how a state legislature decides to protect/expose public records).

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by lisper on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:08AM (#20450757)
Everything you say is true. Nonetheless, as someone who makes political contributions, it matters to me whether a Rumanian hacker can get my home address while sitting in their basement in their underwear, or if they have to get a U.S. visa and travel to my home town in order to do it. That is a salient difference to me, irrespective of the legal status of the information.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by RHSeeger on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:02PM (#20451292)
You're talking past each other. One of you is talking about whether or not it's public, the other about how accessible it is. They're distinct, but closely related, topics.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:10AM (#20450775)
You have a valid concern. I do not intend to dismiss it but I will offer this is why I put forward the caveat previously that absent legislation that acts as a buffer against unauthroized or illegal use of public records (which almost every state has provisions in their record keeping laws over already), the mechanism doesn’t change or alleviate these concerns.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by kd5bjo on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:25AM (#20450948)
We need to weigh the purposes and drawbacks of policies and try to strike a balance in practice. In the case of public records, the purpose presumably is to fight corruption and maintain an informed electorate; the injury to personal privacy a major drawback.

Adding a cost to get the information is one way to adjust this balance— it ensures that the person making the request values the information for some purpose, at a level higher than the imposed cost. Then, when you pass regulations about appropriate and inappropriate motivations for using this information, there’s a standard against which the judge and jury can compare the proffered reasons for accessing the data.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:31AM (#20451004)
We need to weigh the purposes and drawbacks of policies and try to strike a balance in practice. In the case of public records, the purpose presumably is to fight corruption and maintain an informed electorate; the injury to personal privacy a major drawback.

100% agreed. Monetary costs for records is a common approach to this, although many agencies allow for the costs to be waived at the request of the querying individual. It's entirely up to the queried agency to decide if they want to waive those costs or not, and it's a roll of the dice if that agency will bless you with waived fees.

Another way agencies have added "cost" to the requesting practice is through complicated and lengthy forms that are mailed to the local agency (and some agencies, I will offer, absolutely will NOT let you just walk in and hand over a form ABC-123, and require it to be mailed with a postmark). At least, complicated for the individual making the request. These forms though I think do a very good job of helping records divisions enumerate the type of requests that come in, the volume at which they are received and provides an excellent catalog for the types of data most commonly requested by the public to make searching and disseminating the requested records more expedient for clerks and court reporters.

But I absolutely agree, additional policy crafting is necessary to answer some key questions:

1) What should be released and how

2) What is the appropriate mechanism for making a request and what systems of work are engaged by jurisdictions in issuing a release

3) What are the conditions for a legally appropriate and publicly-interested release

I think this is as true for 911 calls as it is querying a comptroller for city budget items.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @05:15PM (#20453971)
Scale, rate, time, and distance matter.

Fundamental changes to these, matter. Even small ones. Especially big ones.

Moving the needle a few percent (or fractions of a percent) can be game-changers in business or politics through threshold effects.

Moving the needle by orders of magnitude is effectively an entire new physics regime. And that's what we're seeing here.

Just because Y is "the same as X" doesn't mean that Y is X, if the rate of change is 10x, or 100x, or 1000x, or 1,000,000x greater. A 10x change gets you from walking speed to a car. 100x is an aircraft. 1,000x is an ICBM. The Tsar Bomba is Greek Fire ... at scale.

Infotech advances change costs by factors of millions to billions, far outside the scales above: ICBMs compunded, several times.

And such changes have massive unintended consequences.

Information technology is the perception and feedback system of society as a whole. Changing properties of information perceptibility, parsibility, storage, retrieval, processing, and distribution of information fundamentally changes entire social orders, and often not for the better. Lowering costs makes marginally "profitable" -- often in the rents-extracting sense -- applications more tractable. In that context, religious and political propaganda, yellow journalism, advertising, noise pollution, popular demagogues, urban legends, email spam, robocalls, stalking, harassment, pseudoscientific myths (flat earth, antivax, truthers, birthers), media (social or otherwise) smear tactics, and automaded extortion are entirely predictable outcomes.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by rubinelli on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:51AM (#20450599)
One can be used to automate extortion. For example, sites with mugshots popped up once they were online. If you got arrested for any reason and didn't want potential employers to see your mugshot in the first page of a Google search, you had to pay these sites an "administrative fee."

Similarly, you could post 911 records with addresses if they were available with a simple request, and I can see how that could bring property prices down, depending on the kind of incident.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:58AM (#20450668)
One can be used to automate extortion.

So the difference is automation?

Suppose someone used Microsoft Office to quickly template and print envelopes with the addresses of 10 different municipalities and stuffed them with boilerplate requests for public information, and then used the responses from those municipalities to carry out extortion.

Should the law act differently towards the individual who mails a lawful open records request than the one who queries for records via HTTP if they used the same records, provided by the same municipalities and jurisdictions to carry out unlawful activity post hoc?

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ghaff on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:11AM (#20450785)
I would have thought it obvious that friction is very much a part of the equation that has historically gone into deciding what information should be public, what should be formally sealed, and what should be actively expunged from the public record to the degree possible.

Suppose I hire an investigator to conduct a (legitimate) investigation into a political opponent, high-level hire, etc. including past addresses, any arrests, mentions in newspapers or online, anything they've written, etc. They'll dig up a lot of information, some of which are public records and some of which is simply publicly available information.

Are you seriously trying to argue that there is no difference between an in-depth targeted investigation of an individual and that same information being available about everyone to anyone on the planet with a press of a few buttons?

Sure, you can argue that there is no privacy and people should just get over it. But there is a significant practical different between information that there's some friction to access and information that's indexed and freely available to everyone with a computer.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:20AM (#20450890)
Are you seriously trying to argue that there is no difference between an in-depth targeted investigation of an individual and that same information being available about everyone to anyone on the planet with a press of a few buttons?

This would be pretty close to it however

Sure, you can argue that there is no privacy and people should just get over it

on the opposite side, no, this is absolutely not what I'm arguing.

If querying a public record online gives rise to a sufficient argument that public harm is being caused, legislatures are not ignorant of this, and they are certainly not deaf to it. At the Federal level, SCOTUS recently reversed a decision of how to answer that very question with regards to Food Stamp data and how it can be queried, and even if it should be queryable at all: https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/food-marketing-i...

All of my comments here I am trying to make as objectively as possible without passing judgement on any concern or aspect of it, but simply remark on how open records laws are implemented and how laws affect those records and the ones who query them.

Any assertion that I am making an assessment or judgement about the people involved runs contrary to my motives in even bothering to comment here.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by landryraccoon on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:03PM (#20451307)
Why only consider automated extortion, and not automated data analysis for good? For example, looking for patterns of systemic discrimination or racism that could easily be explained away as coincidence when looking at only a single incident, but is blatant when taken in aggregate? Or automated searches for suspected corruption or bribery?

I think the bias should be in favor of transparency. Automated information gathering can be used to protect the public as well as for harm.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by UnFleshedOne on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @01:39PM (#20452189)
I suspect for every one bot combing records for evidence of corruption (run by a local concerned citizen) there will be thousands of bots run by disinherited Nigerian princes looking for easy marks and for dirt to use for social engineering.

On the balance you will get one corrupt official fired for a whole bunch of people scammed, extorted or otherwise taken advantage of.

Think back to history of spam for example, I recall it reached huge percentages back in the day, before effective measures were introduced. Even now spam traffic is 45% of all email traffic.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @05:17PM (#20453999)
Because massive cost and scale shifts entirely change the regime:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20453971

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by mruts on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:17AM (#20450221)
So could you ask the clerk to produce every piece of information he has? Would he be obligated to give it to you?
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:20AM (#20450253)
Depends on the jurisdictions’ open records laws I would imagine yes they more than likely would be. Presumably if they have such statutes, some jurisdictions have provisions to catch such types “burdensome requests” and either slap a heavy fee for processing such a request and hopefully deter the requestor, or they appeal to a higher court when denying the request entirely

But otherwise if a state has open records laws and you make a lawful request for a large body of publicly available records then I’m inclined to say by definition the clerk is required to provide them provided all requirements of the request are satisfied.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by nvusuvu on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:17AM (#20450219)
It allows voyeurism.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:25AM (#20450304)
Of whom?
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by testvox on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:16AM (#20450215)
You could just ask the clerk for all the records, this is what public records databases do. They drive around to all the court houses and make copies of all the public records, put them into one big database and sell access to it.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:29AM (#20450355)
Or if my city has a web application in front of this database I can not leave the house and do my research comfortably in my own environment.

Still not seeing the privacy implication of driving for records and clicking for them when discussing a public record that by definition, is in the public interest carried out by wards of public service (public service answering points).

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by nitrogen on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:09AM (#20450770)
You have been highly active in this thread and it doesn't seem like you are trying to understand the other viewpoint. Do you have a personal stake or other underlying assumption in the matter that might be biasing you to a particular conclusion?

If you don't see privacy implications to releasing recordings of e.g. people experiencing medical emergencies (medical records are otherwise clearly protected) then perhaps you need to reevaluate your understanding of what privacy means to different groups of people.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:14AM (#20450825)
Do you have a personal stake or underlying viewpoint

Yes. I work in a directly advisory position with various municipalities across the united States implementing online open records systems of engagement, among other systems of public accountability and answer these types of questions every day.

I had been intending to avoid appealing to job titles in discussing the matter but this is my profession and the question of legal access and barriers to access weighed against public interest is a topic that happens in every meeting I sit in.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ghaff on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:23AM (#20450921)
Let me just suggest that you may be too narrowly focused on the legal status of the information. This is indeed important. But, as I and others have noted and given examples of, as a practical matter there's a big difference between information that anyone in the world can mass download to a computer and information that requires someone to show up in person at a clerk's office and pay for a paper copy.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:24AM (#20450934)
Let me just suggest that you may be too narrowly focused on the legal status of the information.

When we're ostensibly talking about records that were made public by law, I think that focus is 100% warranted.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ghaff on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:32AM (#20451015)
>We're ostensibly talking about records that were made public by law so I think that focus is 100% warranted.

One last comment. Yes. But I'd argue (and I imagine you agree) that many of the tradeoffs considered when those laws were passed reflect, among other things, that "public record" didn't originally often equate to big publicly accessible database.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by wool_gather on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:13PM (#20451380)
In addition to this, laws can and should be changed, if we have a discussion about whether they're fulfilling their purpose -- like in this thread -- and realize that they're not.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ambicapter on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:15PM (#20451396)
legality != morality, and this comment chain seems to be more focused on the moral aspects of privacy rather than the legal ones.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:38PM (#20451605)
this comment chain seems to be more focused on the moral aspects of privacy rather than the legal ones.

Sure. Fair. Valid.

Except it's really more nuanced than just saying "legality != morality", especially when the rubber meets the road, and when it comes time to actually implementing systems of recording (and potentially disseminating) the public's interaction with their local jurisdictions and municipalities, and I think those nuances get lost when sitting on the periphery of installing policy and reading about statecraft compared to being inside, operating the levers and pulleys and-as the phrase goes-"watching the sausage get made"..

That's why I'm being so willing to challenge some of the notions shared here today: I'm trying to be the voice of the insider and expose some of the reasons why certain things may be the way they are with regards to public data and open records.

You're right legal does not necessarily mean moral, but when it's time for measurable outcomes and results of human actions, and interactions between citizens and their local governments the legal framework does a much better job of delivering those outcomes and results on a consistent basis than most others, and is the framework we use of keeping the operators and participants equally consistently accountable (most of the time, anyway).

The focus, again, I say is warranted.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by nitrogen on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:42AM (#20457356)
There are definitely many public records that should be as widely available as possible, so good work helping municipalities with those. I don't think people are saying that all searchable records are problematic. They are saying that some uses and some specific types of records are problematic -- those that do more harm than good.

As an example, if hypothetically I were a victim of some embarrassing emergency, I wouldn't mind being part of anonymous aggregated statistics, but I definitely would object to anybody but myself and essential personnel having open access to the 911 recording, and I definitely wouldn't want my employer or neighbors to know any details or anything linking me to them without my permission or a substantiated court order, released under seal.