News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @10:29AM (#20450355)
Or if my city has a web application in front of this database I can not leave the house and do my research comfortably in my own environment.

Still not seeing the privacy implication of driving for records and clicking for them when discussing a public record that by definition, is in the public interest carried out by wards of public service (public service answering points).

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by nitrogen on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:09AM (#20450770)
You have been highly active in this thread and it doesn't seem like you are trying to understand the other viewpoint. Do you have a personal stake or other underlying assumption in the matter that might be biasing you to a particular conclusion?

If you don't see privacy implications to releasing recordings of e.g. people experiencing medical emergencies (medical records are otherwise clearly protected) then perhaps you need to reevaluate your understanding of what privacy means to different groups of people.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:14AM (#20450825)
Do you have a personal stake or underlying viewpoint

Yes. I work in a directly advisory position with various municipalities across the united States implementing online open records systems of engagement, among other systems of public accountability and answer these types of questions every day.

I had been intending to avoid appealing to job titles in discussing the matter but this is my profession and the question of legal access and barriers to access weighed against public interest is a topic that happens in every meeting I sit in.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ghaff on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:23AM (#20450921)
Let me just suggest that you may be too narrowly focused on the legal status of the information. This is indeed important. But, as I and others have noted and given examples of, as a practical matter there's a big difference between information that anyone in the world can mass download to a computer and information that requires someone to show up in person at a clerk's office and pay for a paper copy.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:24AM (#20450934)
Let me just suggest that you may be too narrowly focused on the legal status of the information.

When we're ostensibly talking about records that were made public by law, I think that focus is 100% warranted.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ghaff on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:32AM (#20451015)
>We're ostensibly talking about records that were made public by law so I think that focus is 100% warranted.

One last comment. Yes. But I'd argue (and I imagine you agree) that many of the tradeoffs considered when those laws were passed reflect, among other things, that "public record" didn't originally often equate to big publicly accessible database.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by wool_gather on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:13PM (#20451380)
In addition to this, laws can and should be changed, if we have a discussion about whether they're fulfilling their purpose -- like in this thread -- and realize that they're not.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by ambicapter on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:15PM (#20451396)
legality != morality, and this comment chain seems to be more focused on the moral aspects of privacy rather than the legal ones.
Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by dvtrn on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @12:38PM (#20451605)
this comment chain seems to be more focused on the moral aspects of privacy rather than the legal ones.

Sure. Fair. Valid.

Except it's really more nuanced than just saying "legality != morality", especially when the rubber meets the road, and when it comes time to actually implementing systems of recording (and potentially disseminating) the public's interaction with their local jurisdictions and municipalities, and I think those nuances get lost when sitting on the periphery of installing policy and reading about statecraft compared to being inside, operating the levers and pulleys and-as the phrase goes-"watching the sausage get made"..

That's why I'm being so willing to challenge some of the notions shared here today: I'm trying to be the voice of the insider and expose some of the reasons why certain things may be the way they are with regards to public data and open records.

You're right legal does not necessarily mean moral, but when it's time for measurable outcomes and results of human actions, and interactions between citizens and their local governments the legal framework does a much better job of delivering those outcomes and results on a consistent basis than most others, and is the framework we use of keeping the operators and participants equally consistently accountable (most of the time, anyway).

The focus, again, I say is warranted.

Re:Going Quiet: More States Are Hiding 911 Recordings by nitrogen on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:42AM (#20457356)
There are definitely many public records that should be as widely available as possible, so good work helping municipalities with those. I don't think people are saying that all searchable records are problematic. They are saying that some uses and some specific types of records are problematic -- those that do more harm than good.

As an example, if hypothetically I were a victim of some embarrassing emergency, I wouldn't mind being part of anonymous aggregated statistics, but I definitely would object to anybody but myself and essential personnel having open access to the 911 recording, and I definitely wouldn't want my employer or neighbors to know any details or anything linking me to them without my permission or a substantiated court order, released under seal.