News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by YeahSureWhyNot on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:15PM (#20370643)
I don't think americans need the 'couple of hundred mbps' on their cellphones in metro areas as much as they need decent 3g coverage in other parts of the country, especially in seasonal touristy places where visitors don't know where things are or where to go. In my personal experience, almost all of ski resorts and beach towns on the east coast as well as small coastal towns and wineries in California have this problem.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by tomohawk on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:23PM (#20370672)
The telcos have been fibbing about their coverage of rural areas. They do that to attract customers, but they also get subsidies for coverage. There is no independent verification of their claims. Yet another example of government not being competent when handing out money.

They're in the process of pulling out 3G in some rural areas I've been to. There's even less coverage than before.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by reaperducer on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:50PM (#20370840)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. It's true that wireless carriers lie about rural coverage because they don't think anyone will call them on it.

The State of Vermont did, though: https://www.burlingtonfreepress.com/story/news/local/vermont...

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by ianai on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:55PM (#20370876)
OP twisted it against government. I’d say it’s more a symptom of needing more government. The US has had many decades of turning government back away from market oversight to many disastrous effects. (I still upvoted them though. )
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by tomohawk on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:06PM (#20371599)
If we're going to have these large regulated monopolies, then the regulator had better be competent. Either set the rules to allow market forces to work or suspend market forces and regulate the monopoly/oligopoly. In the AT&T days, you couldn't own any telco equipment (not even a phone) - you had to rent it. The inventor of the answering machine was not AT&T, so you could buy one but not legally hook it up. Long distance was next town over and cost north of $2 / minute. On the flip side, we had Bell Labs and lots of redundancy and everyone had the same service.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by rayiner on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:30PM (#20372090)
Nobody in this discussion is a monopoly. U.S. cellular service has less market concentration than: cell phones, mobile operating systems, e-commerce, mobile phone operating systems, web browsers, or search.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by GauntletWizard on Saturday July 06, 2019 @09:25PM (#20373067)
One of the hardest learned lessons of the twentieth century was that you didn't need collusion for a duopoly to become a monopoly. We have four major carriers, everyone else leases their bandwidth. They don't talk to each other, but their deals are a subtle form of signaling, and they have arrived at a monoplistic market, even with competition.

Several rational actors with complete public information can still collaborate just by their actions alone. There's an entire category of "Hat Puzzles" [1] that involve extracting information from other players moves. The big four (Verizon, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile) don't need to collude to arrive at a stagnant, uncompetitive market. They have found an equalibrium that benefits all of them, and would hurt any who attempted "competition".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hat_puzzle

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by rayiner on Saturday July 06, 2019 @10:59PM (#20373334)
You can’t just hand wave and say that because price coordination is possible, it’s happening. You have to tie your theory to the facts. Sprint and T-Mobile offer dramatically lower pricing, so there can’t be price coordination. There is no carving up of the market—the service area of the four carriers mostly overlap. In the LTE era, there is very little barrier to switching. (All the carriers offer big switching incentives.) Capital expenditures remain enormous across the board.

What exactly is the sign of lack of competition? In the last ten years, I can think of few pieces of tech that’s gotten better faster than cell service. When the iPhone 3GS came out, you could get peak speeds up to 2-3 Mbps. On my XR, I’ve gotten 100 Mbps+. That factor of 20-30 increase is about the same as the increase in iPhone CPU performance over that time (which itself has been a stupendous success story). Maybe GPUs have improved faster? Certainly not desktop CPUs, or mobile or desktop operating systems, or web browsers, or search.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by ianai on Saturday July 06, 2019 @10:37PM (#20373271)
That’s a very straightforward explanation of market concentration! Thank you!

I wish people better understood how monopolistic power harms everybody. It results in false scarcity trade offs, for instance. But that’s abstract.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by enraged_camel on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:09PM (#20370955)
Wait, so companies are potentially not meeting the terms and conditions of the subsidies they receive, and this is somehow the government’s fault?
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by cglace on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:49PM (#20371151)
The government not policing the deal would certainly be their fault.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by enraged_camel on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:53PM (#20371175)
Is the government intentionally not policing it due to nefarious reasons, or do they simply not have the money and/or the expertise to police it?
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by closeparen on Saturday July 06, 2019 @08:05PM (#20372798)
Giving out incentives without the resources and expertise to ensure we’re actually getting the intended benefit is squarely in the middle of “the government’s fault.”
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by notatoad on Saturday July 06, 2019 @03:54PM (#20371527)
it's not really a question of expertise, if you don't have it you can hire it. And as long as they keep giving out more subsidies, it can't really be a question of not having enough money either.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by enraged_camel on Saturday July 06, 2019 @05:32PM (#20372104)
You can hire expertise, assuming you have the budget for it. And that budget is completely separate from the pot of money out of which subsidies are doled.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by notatoad on Saturday July 06, 2019 @07:12PM (#20372604)
>And that budget is completely separate from the pot of money out of which subsidies are doled.

but there's no reason that has to be true, other than "that's the way it is". The money itself is fungible.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by rayiner on Saturday July 06, 2019 @06:39PM (#20372461)
The accusation is actually the opposite: https://www.forbes.com/sites/janetwburns/2018/12/13/fcc-says....

The subsidies are only given for areas that don’t have coverage currently. One national carrier is accused of overstating coverage in rural areas to keep subsidies from being given to rural cellular carriers. To get the subsidy, you’d want to understate the coverage.

EDIT: Previously, I incorrectly stated there is no subsidy for cellular. I forgot about Obama’s Mobility Fund. Phase 1 was $300 million in 2012, and Phase 2 was planned to be about $450 million per year over the next ten years. But that’s halted at the moment. Note that annual capital expenditures by the big 4 cellular providers is $55 billion annually. You’re talking about a really tiny investment by the government in the most underserved areas, not something big enough to really influence the coverage map.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by kurthr on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:28PM (#20370698)
Agreed, 5G is probably better to support very dense areas with adequate coverage, conventions and stadiums would be examples, I agree... that's not where I have issues. The US is not that dense, while other countries are. I think delaying rollout here isn't such a problem.

I wish 5G had addressed the data and meta-data security model for wireless communications. If that had also been targeted, it would have mitigated a lot of current concerns.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by Nokinside on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:57PM (#20370890)
The benefit to rural areas comes from Low-band FDD. It will come maybe a year later because current 5G chipsets don't support low-band FDD spectrum yet. Low-band FDD 5G is cheaper to deploy and more energy efficient and yet provides more bandwith than existing 4G. 5G home modems will become very popular in rural areas.

Besides, roughly 80 percent of Americans live in urban areas. Why should 5G deployment wait for the rest.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by reaperducer on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:37PM (#20371094)
Besides, roughly 80 percent of Americans live in urban areas.

Are the 20% who live in rural places not full Americans who do not deserve something simply because of their geography? I hope you don't like eating, using a computer, or living in a house because those are the people who grow your food, mine your minerals, and cut your lumber.

Why should 5G deployment wait for the rest.

No one is saying wait. They're saying that there's no need to hurry through a major deployment that delivers only minor benefits.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by notatoad on Saturday July 06, 2019 @03:57PM (#20371547)
When you make the decision to live in a rural area, you know that you're giving up a lot of the conveniences that you take for granted when living in a city. For most people who live in rural areas, slightly worse cell coverage is a perfectly acceptable tradeoff to not having to deal with the noise, crime, and crowding of cities.

Nobody deserves 5G.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by reaperducer on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:07PM (#20371605)
When you make the decision to live in a rural area, you know that you're giving up a lot of the conveniences that you take for granted when living in a city

Are you under the impression that when the stork is delivering babies, it asks them where they want to live?

There is a subset of people who choose to live in rural areas. But they are not a majority. And the remainder shouldn't be condescended to as if they made a bad life decision and are being punished for not wanting to live in a city.

Nobody deserves 5G

I'm not arguing that they do. But there are an awful lot of people in this thread who are OK if 3G and 4G never finish rolling out in rural areas as long as they, themselves, get gigabit 5G connections.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by notatoad on Saturday July 06, 2019 @07:10PM (#20372600)
>there are an awful lot of people in this thread who are OK if 3G and 4G never finish rolling out in rural areas as long as they, themselves, get gigabit 5G connections

i think those people are simply not making the false conclusion that we can improve rural coverage by preventing the improvement of urban coverage.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by Nokinside on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:50PM (#20371155)
No hurry means no American startups providing new types of applications and services that 5g can provide.

US has no companies selling 4g/lte/5g infrastructure for carriers, maybe the US won't have startups selling services either.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by jorblumesea on Saturday July 06, 2019 @03:14PM (#20371299)
Furthermore, if anyone actually read the article, the 5G race is a "winner takes all" affair where the winner will reap hundreds of billions in economic value and shape the future of communications. There are enormous stakes here, from economic to national security.

I encourage everyone to read this study: https://media.defense.gov/2019/Apr/04/2002109654/-1/-1/0/DIB...

The implications of losing the 5G race are huge and it's sad to see a serious level of misinformation and ignorance being represented here. The idea that a delayed roll out is considered acceptable is completely misunderstanding the game we are playing.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by axaxs on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:24PM (#20370674)
I'm inclined to agree. It seems TMobile is the only one going after low band, long range stuff with their band 71. ATT/Verizon seem full steam ahead on their short range clusters. That's fine, but I'll take coverage over speed any day, and I'm sure most would agree.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by jinglebells on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:01PM (#20370912)
5G doesn't solve a bandwidth problem, it solves a latency problem. 4G has a latency of ~50ms, 5G is more like 1ms. 50ms is noticeable in areas like remote robot control, video conferencing, remote surgery etc.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by kylec on Saturday July 06, 2019 @03:59PM (#20371555)
Video conferencing works just fine with 50ms latency, and the other two are very niche
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by jinglebells on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @12:10PM (#20393283)
Yes... is it possible the other two are niche because we can't do them with the current infrastructure?

Computers used to be niche, not everyone had one. That's not how technological progression is made though.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by anticensor on Sunday July 07, 2019 @05:01AM (#20374215)
50ms latency means 20fps max. No cinematically smooth pictures.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by pkolaczk on Sunday July 07, 2019 @05:55AM (#20374375)
Latency doesn't affect frame rate. It affects... well, latency. 50 ms is perfectly fine for video and audio. And 4G actually is capable of much lower latency. I get pings at around 20 ms in Poland. 50 ms was achievable on 3G (HSPA+).
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by anticensor on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:23PM (#20384691)
I assumed full-live (fresh frame comes strictly after previous one), not quasi-live.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by pkolaczk on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:37PM (#20431497)
That still doesn't imply lower frame rate. Frames are pipelined.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by fakeslimshady on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:59PM (#20370904)
I would love to have higher bandwidth as would most IT related professionals. Thats been true since the days of analog modems.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by deelowe on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:34PM (#20370725)
Isn't this problem the reason 5g includes specs for microcells? I think 3g coverage in dense areas is a spectrum issue.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by Merrill on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:34PM (#20370726)
5G can eliminate the need to provide fiber or cable to the home. Instead, radio is used for the last hundreds of meters. Physical drops into homes are expensive to install and maintain.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by jws on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:11PM (#20370967)
I just had fiber pulled into my home. It was no more difficult than the copper line which preceded it (which we used as a messenger to pull the copper through my buried conduit.) An aerial install would have been identical to copper.

Just for ongoing cost… I've been in the house for 30 years. I've had new copper pulled three times (twice for adding ISDN lines back in the day and once to bury the service). The copper lines have over the years required days of effort for the linemen to work their way back toward the switching office looking for bad connections. Every spring for a few years I used to have problems from moisture ingress to the lines. My neighborhood is older than telephones. All of the pairs on the poles were in use and they had to work their way back through the lead clad lines to repair mine instead of just switching to a good pair. Eventually in the days of DSL they lost me as a customer because they couldn't (or wouldn't) afford to give me a clean enough pair of copper for reliable service.

So from the phone company's standpoint they made a capital expenditure which was long overdue to nail up fiber to the poles, and for a 4 hour truck roll they got me back as a customer for probably a decade.

The fiber on the poles is made for easy installation. There are ports already in place for each house. The installer rolls out some bulk fiber in a black cladding with some sort of tensile element. The cross section is smaller than a copper line, so it fits anywhere the copper is. I didn't see how he terminated it after cutting, but it didn't take long.

… and my upstream speeds are now 50 times faster than the cable company could provide. Happy nerd.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by sgt101 on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:54PM (#20371185)
how far are you from the switching office?
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by jws on Saturday July 06, 2019 @04:43PM (#20371821)
About 1km as the fiber goes. It’s easy to see why we are an early install. High income area, relatively dense free standing houses, all aerial poles. It doesn’t really get any easier than that so the telco can say “we have gigabit fiber in xyz”. Well, a small percent of xyz, but they don’t have to mention that.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by CharlesW on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:05PM (#20370935)
> 5G can eliminate the need to provide fiber or cable to the home.

4G can too, but it's a very niche option and will remain so with 5G and beyond until mobile operators stop thinking of themselves as mobile operators.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by asark on Saturday July 06, 2019 @02:51PM (#20371170)
Yeah. Higher cost, usage caps low enough to be worth mentioning, and mobile operators seem a lot more likely to do really weird crap to my traffic. Fix those and who needs a physical line? Until all are fixed I'll keep the fiber.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by sroussey on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:46PM (#20370816)
mm 5G stops at the wall/window and doesn’t make it indoors.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by matthewmacleod on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:50PM (#20370839)
That’s really not a problem with an outdoor antenna though. I think the idea is that 5G would be used as the last mile carrier into some kind of CPE.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by ianai on Saturday July 06, 2019 @01:53PM (#20370864)
Also we already have a model for bringing weak signals into the home through antennas-even roof mounted.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by Merrill on Saturday July 06, 2019 @03:53PM (#20371518)
A clear glass window is about a 10 dB drop at 28 GHz. Windows with film and foil-faced insulation in walls result in more like a 20 dB drop. The obvious solution is a CPE in the window that converts to WiFi within the dwelling.

Alternatively, use the sub-6 GHz bands. The end game by whatever means is that all the cords are cut and radio is the ubiquitous connection technology.

Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by anticensor on Sunday July 07, 2019 @05:03AM (#20374221)
High-speed modes of 5G are like that. Sub-5Ghz modes of 5G-NR also exist.
Re:U.S. is behind on 5G rules and deployment by sroussey on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:49PM (#20425811)
Yeah, that’s why I said mm 5G. Curious... what is the sub-6 speed increases in 5G over LTE?