Then the environment changes in one, or in two ways. People move to another country, or not, and their culture gets exposed to modernity/the demographic transition. If they move to another country the culture they’re surrounded by will change, which will change when their children think it’s appropriate to marry, how many children they want, etc. It will do nothing to their genes, including their desire to have children.
But all over the world the selection is ongoing. As time goes on the proportion of the population that wants lots of children increases and so do the number of large families.
Genetic and sociological explanations can both be true at the same time. Mormons have more children than average for sociological reasons. They value and honour child rearing and family life far, far more than normal Americans. People whose parents had 6+ children also have more children than average, possibly partly due to role model effects, but mostly because they like children. There’s nothing incompatible about these explanations.
Not all religions have the same effect on the outcomes, ignoring that in the studies is misleading.
I guess it shouldn't be hard to conceive where Islamic parties start having a major voice in elections because of demographics.
Overall religion is secondary at best, but economically weak tribal/familiy social nucleus cultures vs established nation states that provide reliable social safety not just for relatives.
"It's the Economy, stupid", look at fertility rates of Saudi Arabi, Iran, UAE Poland vs Nigeria.
And what was found is that females from south-east Asia had a big drop in fertility whereas Turks continued to have large families, comparatively.
So, no, the above research specifically disproves your argument.
Not quite to the extent of some white European populations, sure, but very far from the "breeding like rabbits" image that politicians use to drum up fear among uninformed voters.
> the "breeding like rabbits" image that politicians use to drum up fear among uninformed voters
The fertility rates of muslim immigrants are far higher than the natives which will lead to a decisive demographic and political shift, which is what those politicians are talking about.
So if first generation migrants have a greater fertility, it can indeed affect demographics to a large degree. Because you need exactly one generation to do so. Obviously.
And it should also be obvious that lower fertility stems from multiple factors. Birth control is one, modern work structure is the other. I am certain there are more.
FRANCE: "We show a convergence towards French standards that differs across groups of origin. Women of Southeast Asian descent deviate from the fertility pattern of their parents, while those of Turkish descent preserve their parents’ cultural heritage. These different paths of adaptation between groups partly reflect cultural distance between parents’ country and host country. They also depend on family social capital, family structure, and family values. Access to a higher level of education is a crucial factor in erasing differences between groups" https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02081758/document