News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by andybak on Friday July 05, 2019 @04:38AM (#20360856)
Could someone with more time than me summarize how they reached the conclusion that fertility was heritable? It seems very counter-intuitive unless I'm misunderstanding the precise meaning of "heritable" that enables them to draw this conclusion.
Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by barry-cotter on Friday July 05, 2019 @08:02AM (#20361844)
Every other psychological trait is heritable[1], why wouldn’t desire to have children be?

[1]http://humancond.org/_media/papers/bouchard04_genetic_influe...

Genetic Influence on Human Psychological Traits

There is now a large body of evidence that supports the conclusion that individual differences in most, if not all, reliably measured psychological traits, normal and abnormal, are substantively influenced by genetic factors. This fact has important implications for research and theory building in psychology, as evidence of genetic influence unleashes a cascade of questions regarding the sources of variance in such traits. A brief list of those questions is provided, and representative findings regarding genetic and environmental influences are presented for the domains of personality, intelligence, psycho- logical interests, psychiatric illnesses, and social attitudes. These findings are consistent with those reported for the traits of other species and for many human physical traits, suggesting that they may represent a general biological phenomenon.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by mxfh on Friday July 05, 2019 @05:03AM (#20360956)
So far the consesus was that migrants from traditonally child rich societies, acclimated already a generation later at local lower levels if prosperitiy and education level was reached as well. So it's the economy and social stability through the state that replaces children as the only "pension and care" provider for retirement.

FRANCE: "We show a convergence towards French standards that differs across groups of origin. Women of Southeast Asian descent deviate from the fertility pattern of their parents, while those of Turkish descent preserve their parents’ cultural heritage. These different paths of adaptation between groups partly reflect cultural distance between parents’ country and host country. They also depend on family social capital, family structure, and family values. Access to a higher level of education is a crucial factor in erasing differences between groups" https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02081758/document

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by barry-cotter on Friday July 05, 2019 @08:14AM (#20361911)
Desire to have children has been under selection only since the demographic transition. Most of the world has less than two generations of selection, most one, some none. As such we would expect to see a lot of variation in desire to have children. The only group I’d be willing to bet money have notably higher desire to have children than other human populations are the French because that’s where the demographic transition started. For everyone else on average we should expect more or less the same mean and variance.

Then the environment changes in one, or in two ways. People move to another country, or not, and their culture gets exposed to modernity/the demographic transition. If they move to another country the culture they’re surrounded by will change, which will change when their children think it’s appropriate to marry, how many children they want, etc. It will do nothing to their genes, including their desire to have children.

But all over the world the selection is ongoing. As time goes on the proportion of the population that wants lots of children increases and so do the number of large families.

Genetic and sociological explanations can both be true at the same time. Mormons have more children than average for sociological reasons. They value and honour child rearing and family life far, far more than normal Americans. People whose parents had 6+ children also have more children than average, possibly partly due to role model effects, but mostly because they like children. There’s nothing incompatible about these explanations.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by acqq on Friday July 05, 2019 @05:41AM (#20361165)
I suspect that “Southeast Asian” women observed had different religion than those where “fertility pattern of their parents” is preserved.

Not all religions have the same effect on the outcomes, ignoring that in the studies is misleading.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by car12 on Friday July 05, 2019 @05:59AM (#20361236)
What it is pussyfooting around is that there is not that drastic of a drop in fertility rates of muslims.

I guess it shouldn't be hard to conceive where Islamic parties start having a major voice in elections because of demographics.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by mxfh on Friday July 05, 2019 @06:34AM (#20361416)
By numbers, global fertility/population trends and religion are not a "muslim" one, that's a made up western "identity" problem. If anything it's catholic to evangelical sectionism, if you look at Western Africa.

Overall religion is secondary at best, but economically weak tribal/familiy social nucleus cultures vs established nation states that provide reliable social safety not just for relatives.

"It's the Economy, stupid", look at fertility rates of Saudi Arabi, Iran, UAE Poland vs Nigeria.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by car12 on Friday July 05, 2019 @06:44AM (#20361472)
The post that I was replying to was talking exactly about fertility rates of second, third and beyond generation immigrants in Netherlands.

And what was found is that females from south-east Asia had a big drop in fertility whereas Turks continued to have large families, comparatively.

So, no, the above research specifically disproves your argument.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by FeteCommuniste on Friday July 05, 2019 @08:02AM (#20361843)
Fertility rates across better-developed majority-Muslim countries have been plummeting: https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&...

Not quite to the extent of some white European populations, sure, but very far from the "breeding like rabbits" image that politicians use to drum up fear among uninformed voters.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by car12 on Friday July 05, 2019 @08:30AM (#20362009)
How is the statistic of lower dipping fertility rates inside Muslim countries of relevance when talking about:

> the "breeding like rabbits" image that politicians use to drum up fear among uninformed voters

The fertility rates of muslim immigrants are far higher than the natives which will lead to a decisive demographic and political shift, which is what those politicians are talking about.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by raxxorrax on Friday July 05, 2019 @06:35AM (#20361421)
If you want to know anything about future demographics, just look at a school. Should not be that hard honestly.

So if first generation migrants have a greater fertility, it can indeed affect demographics to a large degree. Because you need exactly one generation to do so. Obviously.

And it should also be obvious that lower fertility stems from multiple factors. Birth control is one, modern work structure is the other. I am certain there are more.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by benj111 on Friday July 05, 2019 @05:27AM (#20361078)
"how they reached the conclusion that fertility was heritable?"

Isnt it obviously true? If you don't breed you don't pass on your non breeding genes, if you do breed....

Living organisms are literally breeding machines, that's all they really do. Natural selection favours those who do it better.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by mynameishere on Friday July 05, 2019 @06:20AM (#20361338)
It's beyond obvious. Strange that people are arguing against it.

And, going one further, in the past people had children as a matter of rote. Now, it has to be a deliberate, overcoming the obstacle of modernity, in a sense. In the same way smallpox had a habit of reducing the population's potential, so too (by a different mechanism) does education, birth control, abortion, etc. A subset of the population will effectively become immune to those things.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by j_wtf_all_taken on Friday July 05, 2019 @01:18PM (#20364131)
Would you then also argue that two smart parents have a much higher chance of having a smart kid than two of average intelligence? If not, why not?
Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by benj111 on Friday July 05, 2019 @02:53PM (#20364845)
I think you might be misinterpreting the parent.

When they refer to education reducing potential, they mean higher education levels generally correspond with a lower birth rate, for a variety of reasons. So smart parents having smart children does seem to fit with that.

Or am I misunderstanding what you're getting at?

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by j_wtf_all_taken on Friday July 05, 2019 @06:25PM (#20366376)
I did mean the "genetic heritability" part of intelligence, if all other factors stay the same (i.e. assuming a scenario as described in the paper, where no environmental factors change) and everyone gets the same level of support in education etc.

Hope that helps to clarify.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by j_wtf_all_taken on Sunday July 07, 2019 @10:09AM (#20375142)
Since the discussion in the thread here seems to have stopped, I'll skip to the conclusion:

Both fertility and intelligence are not as simple as the color of someones eyes. Lots of genes play a role, so the combination of two favorable gene-sets does not necessarily lead to a still favorable gene-set. Therefore, there always seems to be a "regression toward the mean", so don't worry, one or two generations cancel out all "preexisting conditions". Therefore, in every practical sense, both the heritability of intelligence as well as the heritability of fertility are negligible compared to other factors.

Of course children of more intelligent parents tend to get a better education, for example, i.e. those children can develop more of their potential, but here we're back to environmental parameters. But hey, this is good news, because it also works the other way around - dumb parents can have smart kids! So even if dumb people breed like rabbits, we just gotta make sure schools are properly funded to educate those children properly so they can develop their potential!

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by DissidentSci on Tuesday July 09, 2019 @12:39PM (#20393663)
Intelligence and fertility are known as complex traits. The fact they are complex doesn't mean they are not acted on by genetics: they are just highly polygenic. Almost all attempts to measure the heritability of intelligence have reached estimates between 50 and 80%.
Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by j_wtf_all_taken on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:57AM (#20409862)
Did you really read my post?

Anyway, I often hear that claim of 50-80% but I can never find the publications backing up that claim. Can you list some, please?

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by DissidentSci on Friday July 05, 2019 @07:35AM (#20361707)
The three law's of behavioural genetics:

“First Law: All human behavioural traits are heritable.

Second Law: The effect of being raised in the same family is smaller than the effect of the genes.

Third Law: A substantial portion of the variation in complex human behavioural traits is not accounted for by the effects of genes or families.”

Beyond that though, the genetics of human fertility is pretty well understood. Here's a (now fairly old: from 2016) GWAS study on human reproductive behaviour: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27798627

They show genetic correlations between reproductive traits and other behavioural traits in Figure 3. You might find it helps you develop an intuitive understanding. Happy to answer questions if you have any.

Re:The heritability of fertility makes world population stab... by j_wtf_all_taken on Saturday July 06, 2019 @08:37AM (#20369347)
> You might find it helps you develop an intuitive understanding. Happy to answer questions if you have any.

Isn't "intuition" basically the opposite of "science"? Shouldn't we try to answer questions about the latter, not the former?