News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:29AM (#20324593)
America, and the world, should see everyone's tax returns.

What's the big secret? If you're proud of what you earn and the taxes that flow from that then show it. If you're not proud, then that should be exposed too.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jedimastert on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:52AM (#20324741)
There are several problems:

1) There are many people in my life who would make it much more difficult if they knew how much I make. I've kept it from them for a very good reason and they're definitely the kind of people who would just go and look that kind of stuff about random people they know. This would tell them how much I have in investments and property as well.

2) It would necessarily reveal far too much personally identifying information or not serve the purpose you'd want it to. If I had ran away from an abusive or stalking relationship, they could simply look up the state and municipality I pay taxes in, and what company I worked for, making it almost trivial to find me. This could also mean finding (and targeting) anyone that works for a certain company.

3) It would be far too easy for companies to use this information for any number of purposes. I'm currently getting a huge amount of mail about moving companies and brokers because my landlord publicly put my condo up for sale. It could get much worse than that.

4) If I'm the daughter of an extremely conservative family but I'm working at a strip club, even if I'm "not proud" of what I do that give no good cause to expose it to the world.

These are the situations from off the top of my head and already it would reveal far more information than I'm comfortable with. "If you have nothing to fear than you have nothing to hide" is never an appropriate excuse to curtail anyone's privacy.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by freddie_mercury on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:04AM (#20324826)
Tax returns are public in Sweden, Finland, Norway, and Iceland.

Do you think your 4 examples are endemic problems in those countries?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by vidar on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:09AM (#20324871)
In Iceland the returns are not public in their entirety, just the total taxable income and the total bill due.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:14AM (#20324919)
Yes, I perhaps misspoke when I said tax returns. Of course the actual individual deductions should not be public, only the gross amounts.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by mbeex on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:20AM (#20324968)
Probably not, but these are not the only or even the most significant problems. Social control for example, belongs to the more important ones. Made easier (also their dark sides) especially in consensus-driven societies, most scandinavian countries adhere to.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by bildung on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:30AM (#20325056)
Isn't social control exactly the intended goal? IMO this is the whole point of the article: If the public knows about Amazons tax returns, the expected result is public (=social) pressure against Amazon.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by mbeex on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:50AM (#20325211)
My answer went to the parent, not the article. The problem is another one in this case (privacy and her value). And in this context (mutual) social control has the mentioned dark sides, that should be considered.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by ben509 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:18AM (#20324950)
I'm sure they're resourceful enough they've figured out how to work around those problems, but wouldn't it be simpler to not create the problem in the first place?
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sparkling on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:26AM (#20325020)
So what do i have to do to get someones tax return in e.g. Sweden? Whats the process?
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by socialdemocrat on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:12AM (#20324907)
Most of your points are strawman arguments to be fair. People complicate these matters far more than they actually are. How do I know?

Because what you pay in taxes has been public information in my home country Norway for many decades. None of the problems you mentioned have been an issue.

As hard as it may seem, Norway values BOTH transparency AND privacy more than the US. So there are lots of laws which protect your privacy.

1) It does not state HOW you make your living. Just roughly how much you pay in taxes and how much you earn. The details are left out.

2) There are always systems in place to help protect citizens with special needs for more privacy.

3) Companies in Norway cannot pass around information about you to each other or store information about you it does not strictly need. It is not like the US where companies can en masse huge amounts of data about customers and sell it to each other. Information gathering for commercial purposes is quite restricted.

4) As a rule in Norway, you are informed about people obtaining information about you. E.g. if a company does a credit history check on me, I will get a mail stating exactly what company credit checked me and word by word, what information they where provided. The credit check info leaves out a lot of the details that would be available in the US.

Same goes if somebody checks your taxes and income. You are informed of who makes the check and what info they have been provided.

I hope this gives an idea of how you can in fact embrace greater transparency while at the same time promote stronger privacy laws.

I can remark that Norwegian politicians and CEOs are among the lowest paid in the world despite Norway being among the richest countries in the world. I think our long tradition for transparency is a contributing factor to that. Not so fun to be greedy when it is obvious to everyone.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by TheCondor on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:58AM (#20325269)
What’s the best way to provide oversight for the IRS? There should be some openness just to verify that they are doing their job properly. I don’t deny the privacy issues but there is this intensely powerful federal agency that it’s nearly impossible to have real oversight for.

Most of your examples also seem to impact those that present differently than they really are, I’m not saying that that’s not a valuable ability but it’s interesting. I wonder how much of our current political situation is due to believing or rejecting how others present...

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:57AM (#20324770)
4) If I'm the daughter of an extremely conservative family but I'm working at a strip club, even if I'm "not proud" of what I do that give no good cause to expose it to the world.

Why would "strip club" be exposed? Only the amount you make should be. Your arguments all seem rather selfish. I realise the proposal might be extremely uncomfortable for some, but consider the overall benefits.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by ben509 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:08AM (#20324861)
> Why would "strip club" be exposed?

Because the EIN is listed on the W-2, which is filed as part of the return.

And if you're going to reply that you meant some abbreviated form of the tax return, then:

The "what have you got to hide" class of arguments you're using to insist we expose an abbreviated version would also apply to expanding the abbreviated version to full disclosure. And you might be reasonable enough to stop, but that doesn't mean others will be.

People have strong motives to want to dig into political opponents or people they don't like, and we know from history the "what have you got to hide" question and friends are routinely used in trying to eviscerate 4A and 5A rights.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:16AM (#20324939)
OK, I see that point, I think only the gross amount of your income/taxes should be public, not any individual deductions etc.

But my argument is not so much "what have you got to hide", but more "we're all in this together".

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by close04 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:10AM (#20324879)
I see a case to opening up your tax returns if you want to touch/receive public (state) money under any shape or form. I mean if you're expecting everyone to contribute to your well-being then be prepared to offer something in return(s).
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by notahacker on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:33AM (#20325077)
Taxable incomes which appear remarkably high for a young, attractive person who works an "evening shift" alongside their study course might be something of a giveaway

(And yes, people jumping to entirely the wrong conclusion is another potential issue...)

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by nhumrich on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:40AM (#20324659)
Public companies? Sure. Private companies and individuals? No. They can have good reasons to keep their finances private. Just think about how much profiling will happen about a person if you were able to look up their finances first. This applies to job interviews, sales processes, etc.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by socialdemocrat on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:20AM (#20324972)
We have had this in Norway for decades already and it does not pop up as a problem the way you describe it. Part of that is because in addition to focus on transparency, we also promote privacy. Yes that may seem like an oxymoron, but here is a way to give you an idea:

If I ask for you credit history or how much you earn or make in taxes, then you will be informed by the government in letter form, exactly what information I was given about you, as well as my name and address.

That makes it a lot less attractive to snoop around in people's data. Hence in Norway it is mainly news organizations that do these kinds of things in relation to writing articles. Otherwise you make yourself look foolish.

Also it is a bit odd that Americans should be so concerned with privacy as you privacy laws are rather weak to begin with. E.g. unlike Norway you can administer drug tests to any employee in the US or do criminal background checks on all new hires. That would be highly illegal in Norway. Only business which can prove to the government that such checks are vital to the type of the business they do would be allowed to do such checks. E.g. working with children.

Basically the US focus its "privacy" laws on hiding information important to the wealthy, while those at the bottom of the latter have most of their sensitive information easily exposed.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:46AM (#20324697)
Yes a very good point about job interviews.

But if salaries were transparent, there would be much less reason to beat about the bush regarding job offers - It would be quite clear what the going rate was, and how that related to executive pay, etc.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by literallycancer on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:06AM (#20324841)
Usually people who make a lot don't make most of it as salary.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:31AM (#20325059)
true, but the tax return would illuminate that
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by leetcrew on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:01AM (#20325291)
instead of mandating that the financial details of individual people's lives be public, why not just require companies to publish a mean and stdev for each position's compensation? seems like that's all you really need to figure out if you're getting a fair deal.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Waterluvian on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:35AM (#20324623)
Do you mean every company or everyone?

The reason I don't want to share my tax return is that it reveals my income. The last time I revealed my income it created a lot of negative relationships.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Barrin92 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:46AM (#20324699)
I think complete fiscal transparency would be uncomfortable for a pretty short amount of time before people adjust to it, and the symmetry of information as a result would be extremely helpful.

People ask for a lot of fixes to say, pay inequality between men and women, but I think transparent salaries would go a long way and are a fairly simple mechanism. I have very rarely made the experience that pay inequality, if properly justified, was taken the wrong way.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by colmmacc on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:57AM (#20324773)
I like the idea of full income and tax transparency for the reasons you mention, but worry that some of the negative consequences can be long-lived and very hard to tackle.

For modest earners, their public income can become a kind of super credit rating; it can gate access to some businesses and services, or establishments that want an aura of exclusivity, like social clubs. In effect it can make it harder to jump levels on the ladder.

For high earners, their public income can lead to gouging and an unwillingness to discount. A car dealership or a contractor might use it to gauge price sensitivity.

I'm sure there might be complicated social outcomes too. Would dating change in a world with transparent salaries? Would neighborhoods and neighborhood diversity? For the worse, or better?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by cbzoiav on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @03:27AM (#20342333)
Several countries have forced CEO pay to be published in hopes to guilt them into taking less pay.

In most cases it ended up skyrocketing as a result. CEOs could see exactly what every other CEO was on when negotiating. Meanwhile boards didn't want to pay under market rate and be blamed for cheaping out if things went wrong.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Barrin92 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @03:33AM (#20342365)
>Several countries have forced CEO pay to be published in hopes to guilt them into taking less pay.

That's the wrong intention and not what I described in my post. Maybe in those countries CEO salaries were non competitive or too low compared to the value that a CEO provides. I explicitly said that I see transparency as a mechanism to rationalise salaries, not make them more egalitarian everywhere.

But where I think it without a doubt will have an equalizing effect is between people doing equal work but being compensated differently. That effects ordinary workers more than extraordinary talent.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by raxxorrax on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:51AM (#20324733)
I would not want it since employers are in a better position to use that info against you. So bad luck.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by alexanderdmitri on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:02AM (#20324815)
What they pay everyone else and what companies generally pay for the position would be on the table too, so you'd have leverage too right?

Market transparency is good!

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by raxxorrax on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:44AM (#20325149)
I am currently working for a family owned business that is about 1.2 km away from my home. It doesn't pay as much as a larger publicly traded company would pay for my qualification and experience. If my potential new employer would know about my comparably low income, he will have a much harder time paying me significantly more or even just the usual market rate and negotiations would be that much harder. Due to other effects it could even lead to him questioning my competence, an often observed behavior. (there are other ways he could find out, but that is another discussion).

Frankly, I am not that interested in what others are payed. This is something I can negotiate with my boss myself and isn't my business for other people. And I don't want others to know about my income either. You can be sure that people will judge you by your income and feel superior if they make even 10 bucks more. Even your friends might get jealous about your income.

Some people see a value in discretion and some people do not. I belong to the former. There is just so much baggage attached to that shit that it isn't attractive to me at all.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by pledg on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:50AM (#20324728)
This is what happens in Sweden
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Sverigevader on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:59AM (#20324785)
Great example. You do know that we can call our version of the IRS(Skatteverket) and simply ask for any persons taxes and find out how much they make? Including capital gains. All you need is their social security number (personnummer) which if you don't have you can also get from a different branch of Skatteverket! You simply need to narrow it down to a distinct person.

Try it, it's fun! You get more leverage that way.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by literallycancer on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:09AM (#20324874)
So since it shows you how much people paid in taxes, all the people who optimize their taxes properly look like they aren't making all that much, right? It doesn't seem as useful as people in this thread expect it to be.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:34AM (#20325081)
I believe it shows income, and taxes. So you can judge both.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by lvh on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:56AM (#20324766)
Sweden releases the summary numbers, not the entire return, and controls access to the list.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by hutzlibu on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:45AM (#20324692)
"The last time I revealed my income it created a lot of negative relationships. "

Why? With coworkers who were jealous?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Waterluvian on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:46AM (#20324701)
I make about the same as coworkers. About twice as much as my previous coworkers but I want them to know that they're wildly underpaid and lied to about what fair market value is.

No, in laws and neighbours. Mother in law assumed all tech is paid the sams: poorly. Because her son is paid poorly for his IT job. So when I bought a house that was significantly larger than hers, the relationship changed. She felt lied to all these years.

I also made the mistake of speaking to a neighbor forgetting that everyone comes from different walks of life. So my house that will be paid off in 7 years with one income was "a humble purchase" while my neighbor and his wife are apparently struggling to keep their house with two jobs. I felt awful about my misstep in words. Really a slap in their face.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sergiotapia on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:01AM (#20324801)
This has been my experience as well. You learn quick to shut the fuck up about finances - _especially_ to friends and family. It taints relationships beyond repair. If you haven't make this mistake and read this comment, count yourself lucky and learn to shut the fuck up about it.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sct202 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:28AM (#20325036)
The only time I'm more open about finances is with people who I know are roughly equivalent to me or above, and usually we chat about expenses rather than income.

Although with those friends we've danced around the income part enough that we know the general income range of each other. I had a situation with work co-workers where we were all the same level and years of experience and we shared salaries, and people got a little salty over <$500 / yr differences.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by thedaemon on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:32AM (#20325603)
Paying off your house in 7 years is not normal. You are a very lucky person. Remember and respect that.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by nicoburns on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:44AM (#20324683)
Well that may not be a bad thing in the longer term. It creates an incentive for the rich to reduce income inequality.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sdrothrock on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:45AM (#20324694)
I don't think this just affects "rich" people.

It could also be that Waterluvian had a low income and that affected his relationships.

Or it could be that it just differed in a direction (up or down) that his peers didn't expect or appreciate for whatever reason.

I can think of a lot of reasons revealing my income would affect various relationships I have (whether that's a good thing or a bad thing isn't relevant), even though I wish it wouldn't. Information about money does change the way people treat you.

When I was a kid, people knew my family wasn't doing so well and I'd get lots of well-intentioned charitable offers from friends and friends' parents that just made me feel really bad about myself, so there's one way that having a lower income revealed can affect relationships in an apparently positive way that's still uncomfortable.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by josefx on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:55AM (#20325252)
I had coworkers that where hostile to the very idea of equality. Get paid the same as them? They were worth twice as much. Take a pay cut in exchange for some other bonus? They deserved the bonus more than you and they would get it without the pay cut (they didn't, especially not after trying to add their own terms to it). There was nothing positive to informing them of the pay of anyone else.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by dsfyu404ed on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:35AM (#20324620)
This always gets trotted out by people who make good money and who's family and friends basically all make good money. It's like the personal finance instance of saying "I have nothing to hide so I don't need privacy".

I'd rather not have the in-laws knowing exactly how much I make or have my next employer know exactly how much more they're offering than the last one thank you very much. While I understand that in some countries tax returns are public, those countries are very different than the US in a multitude of ways (which are beyond the scope of this comment, I'm not going write a wall of text, those invite nit picking).

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by amelius on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:40AM (#20324657)
> I'd rather not have the in-laws knowing exactly how much I make or have my next employer know exactly how much more they're offering than the last one thank you very much.

But on the flip side, you'll know exactly how much your colleagues make.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by cj on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:50AM (#20324722)
> But on the flip side, you'll know exactly how much your colleagues make.

Can’t you also ask your co-worker if you care to know?

My thought is this also risks creating unnecessary resentment in the office. (Most people will react negatively finding out a colleague makes $10k more, even if that colleague has more years of experience - people don’t think about compensation rationally)

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by lvh on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:43AM (#20324680)
By framing it as a flip side it sounds like two sides of a “fair” coin, but for the vast majority of people their relationship to their employer is one with a serious power imbalance.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by amelius on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:05AM (#20325327)
By knowing what your coworkers earn (just like your employer knows!) you decrease the power imbalance.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by lvh on Monday July 01, 2019 @12:34PM (#20327039)
You missed my point: the incentive to remove that balance already exists among workers (eg pay self-disclosure), but now companies know exactly how much you make. There’s no positive worker outcome to companies having that information.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by cbg0 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:59AM (#20324791)
> But on the flip side, you'll know exactly how much your colleagues make.

For most large companies you can already research what the average salary is for a specific position on sites like glassdoor.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sokoloff on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:03AM (#20324817)
Which is something that I don't care about in the slightest.

Taking privacy away from people and giving them something of no value to them in trade is a poor justification for change.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by raxxorrax on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:56AM (#20324767)
Which would immediately form a hierarchy.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by amelius on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:38AM (#20324643)
I agree with the general point, but not with the argument:

> If you're not proud, then that should be exposed too.

What if I'm not proud because I earn only half of what my neighbor earns?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:49AM (#20324718)
They show off a nicer and newer car than you? Buy more expensive garden ornaments? Throw bigger parties?

Really, so much is wasted to display wealth superiority.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by i_am_nomad on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:44AM (#20324689)
Imagine the data-driven marketing gold rush that would ensue from having everyone’s tax returns be public.

That alone is reason enough not to do it.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by LoSboccacc on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:47AM (#20324703)
> What's the big secret

upper middle class people are juicy targets, rich enough to get some profit, not enough to have proper security. what could go wrong exposing them all in a nice list, indexed and sortable, right?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:52AM (#20324737)
Juicy targets for those scheming criminal lower classes?

How is public financial exposure different from living in an affluent area, having an expensive car, etc, etc?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by cbg0 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:56AM (#20324764)
Well, you can live in a not-so-affluent area and drive an average car and be very well off, as some people do to avoid attracting attention.

On the other hand, someone driving an expensive car is not necessarily well off, there are quite a lot of people living paycheck to paycheck that drive "expensive" cars.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:28AM (#20325044)
And so how are you then "at risk" if you live modestly, since there is little to rob?

Kidnap? It seems a little ridiculous for most cases.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by adventured on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:59AM (#20325278)
> And so how are you then "at risk" if you live modestly, since there is little to rob?

I know a guy - we'll call him Mr. Frugal - he's worth, I'd estimate, $5 to $10 million based on what I know about his income and assets over the last 30 years (I know a fair bit to make that estimation). An old family friend, he's in his 70s at this point. He built his wealth from nothing, very slowly, and is a notorious penny pincher (the most extreme version of it I've ever seen). He lives in the same house he has owned since the 1960s; it's worth $150k-$175k today.

This man would be a very ripe target for any number of schemes. Targeting his bank accounts / investment accounts / personal identity, credit, and so on. That's entirely ignoring any kidnapping or blackmail type risks. It doesn't take more than a few moments of consideration to understand how his finances being made so public would make him a target for all sorts of criminals. That despite the fact that he lives very modestly and there is nothing in his home to indicate such wealth. His wealth is held outside of his home, and that's where you would target him. Frankly, given this is HN, I think it's pretty silly obvious that the physical contents of a home often are not the best target for thieves / criminals today.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by SapporoChris on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:02AM (#20324811)
You might consider reading The Millionaire Next Door, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Millionaire_Next_Door One of the big surprises in the book was the number of millionaires that live very modest lifestyles.

They become millionaires and stay millionaires because they don't change their frugal spending habits.

Now certainly these people living modestly don't have assets at home that are juicy targets, but they would be juicy targets for kidnapping and extortion.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by TheLuddite on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:33AM (#20325075)
Maybe this will force them to start spending their money and enjoy life?

If they don´t - someone else will take their stash and have fun with it.

Win-win.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by michaelt on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:45AM (#20325161)
I think the point jacknews is making is: Today, 40% of people with a given wealth level show it off, and 60% keep it quiet.

If tomorrow nobody could keep it quiet, it doesn't mean the 60% would all get kidnapped, because today the 40% aren't getting kidnapped.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by LoSboccacc on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:17AM (#20325442)
how unimaginative. it's the golden pot for identity fraud. it's a prime target for marketers and scammers. heck, even if you only disclose income data and tax paid, by the amount of tax deducted from the total and comparing it with historical data there's a good chance to figure out if someone had large medical expenses.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by lvh on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:51AM (#20324735)
A full tax return contains a lot more information than a summary number (“what you earn and the taxes that flow from it”).

What benefit are we trying to achieve and how does applying that to most corporations get that? Saying we should have it for publicly traded companies makes a lot more sense than every private company let alone every person.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:37AM (#20325104)
Why should it secret? I mean the gross amount, not the details.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by pjc50 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:53AM (#20324752)
In addition to the other reasons not to do this, it's a huge enabler of political or family harassment.

It can be made to work in societies that are already pretty open and equal, but in a highly unequal society like America?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:38AM (#20325115)
LOL, causality.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sigzero on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:47AM (#20324709)
Sorry, it isn't anyone's business but mine and the IRS.