News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Waterluvian on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:35AM (#20324623)
Do you mean every company or everyone?

The reason I don't want to share my tax return is that it reveals my income. The last time I revealed my income it created a lot of negative relationships.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Barrin92 on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:46AM (#20324699)
I think complete fiscal transparency would be uncomfortable for a pretty short amount of time before people adjust to it, and the symmetry of information as a result would be extremely helpful.

People ask for a lot of fixes to say, pay inequality between men and women, but I think transparent salaries would go a long way and are a fairly simple mechanism. I have very rarely made the experience that pay inequality, if properly justified, was taken the wrong way.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by colmmacc on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:57AM (#20324773)
I like the idea of full income and tax transparency for the reasons you mention, but worry that some of the negative consequences can be long-lived and very hard to tackle.

For modest earners, their public income can become a kind of super credit rating; it can gate access to some businesses and services, or establishments that want an aura of exclusivity, like social clubs. In effect it can make it harder to jump levels on the ladder.

For high earners, their public income can lead to gouging and an unwillingness to discount. A car dealership or a contractor might use it to gauge price sensitivity.

I'm sure there might be complicated social outcomes too. Would dating change in a world with transparent salaries? Would neighborhoods and neighborhood diversity? For the worse, or better?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by cbzoiav on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @03:27AM (#20342333)
Several countries have forced CEO pay to be published in hopes to guilt them into taking less pay.

In most cases it ended up skyrocketing as a result. CEOs could see exactly what every other CEO was on when negotiating. Meanwhile boards didn't want to pay under market rate and be blamed for cheaping out if things went wrong.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Barrin92 on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @03:33AM (#20342365)
>Several countries have forced CEO pay to be published in hopes to guilt them into taking less pay.

That's the wrong intention and not what I described in my post. Maybe in those countries CEO salaries were non competitive or too low compared to the value that a CEO provides. I explicitly said that I see transparency as a mechanism to rationalise salaries, not make them more egalitarian everywhere.

But where I think it without a doubt will have an equalizing effect is between people doing equal work but being compensated differently. That effects ordinary workers more than extraordinary talent.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by raxxorrax on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:51AM (#20324733)
I would not want it since employers are in a better position to use that info against you. So bad luck.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by alexanderdmitri on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:02AM (#20324815)
What they pay everyone else and what companies generally pay for the position would be on the table too, so you'd have leverage too right?

Market transparency is good!

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by raxxorrax on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:44AM (#20325149)
I am currently working for a family owned business that is about 1.2 km away from my home. It doesn't pay as much as a larger publicly traded company would pay for my qualification and experience. If my potential new employer would know about my comparably low income, he will have a much harder time paying me significantly more or even just the usual market rate and negotiations would be that much harder. Due to other effects it could even lead to him questioning my competence, an often observed behavior. (there are other ways he could find out, but that is another discussion).

Frankly, I am not that interested in what others are payed. This is something I can negotiate with my boss myself and isn't my business for other people. And I don't want others to know about my income either. You can be sure that people will judge you by your income and feel superior if they make even 10 bucks more. Even your friends might get jealous about your income.

Some people see a value in discretion and some people do not. I belong to the former. There is just so much baggage attached to that shit that it isn't attractive to me at all.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by pledg on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:50AM (#20324728)
This is what happens in Sweden
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Sverigevader on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:59AM (#20324785)
Great example. You do know that we can call our version of the IRS(Skatteverket) and simply ask for any persons taxes and find out how much they make? Including capital gains. All you need is their social security number (personnummer) which if you don't have you can also get from a different branch of Skatteverket! You simply need to narrow it down to a distinct person.

Try it, it's fun! You get more leverage that way.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by literallycancer on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:09AM (#20324874)
So since it shows you how much people paid in taxes, all the people who optimize their taxes properly look like they aren't making all that much, right? It doesn't seem as useful as people in this thread expect it to be.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by jacknews on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:34AM (#20325081)
I believe it shows income, and taxes. So you can judge both.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by lvh on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:56AM (#20324766)
Sweden releases the summary numbers, not the entire return, and controls access to the list.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by hutzlibu on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:45AM (#20324692)
"The last time I revealed my income it created a lot of negative relationships. "

Why? With coworkers who were jealous?

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by Waterluvian on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:46AM (#20324701)
I make about the same as coworkers. About twice as much as my previous coworkers but I want them to know that they're wildly underpaid and lied to about what fair market value is.

No, in laws and neighbours. Mother in law assumed all tech is paid the sams: poorly. Because her son is paid poorly for his IT job. So when I bought a house that was significantly larger than hers, the relationship changed. She felt lied to all these years.

I also made the mistake of speaking to a neighbor forgetting that everyone comes from different walks of life. So my house that will be paid off in 7 years with one income was "a humble purchase" while my neighbor and his wife are apparently struggling to keep their house with two jobs. I felt awful about my misstep in words. Really a slap in their face.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sergiotapia on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:01AM (#20324801)
This has been my experience as well. You learn quick to shut the fuck up about finances - _especially_ to friends and family. It taints relationships beyond repair. If you haven't make this mistake and read this comment, count yourself lucky and learn to shut the fuck up about it.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sct202 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:28AM (#20325036)
The only time I'm more open about finances is with people who I know are roughly equivalent to me or above, and usually we chat about expenses rather than income.

Although with those friends we've danced around the income part enough that we know the general income range of each other. I had a situation with work co-workers where we were all the same level and years of experience and we shared salaries, and people got a little salty over <$500 / yr differences.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by thedaemon on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:32AM (#20325603)
Paying off your house in 7 years is not normal. You are a very lucky person. Remember and respect that.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by nicoburns on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:44AM (#20324683)
Well that may not be a bad thing in the longer term. It creates an incentive for the rich to reduce income inequality.
Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by sdrothrock on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:45AM (#20324694)
I don't think this just affects "rich" people.

It could also be that Waterluvian had a low income and that affected his relationships.

Or it could be that it just differed in a direction (up or down) that his peers didn't expect or appreciate for whatever reason.

I can think of a lot of reasons revealing my income would affect various relationships I have (whether that's a good thing or a bad thing isn't relevant), even though I wish it wouldn't. Information about money does change the way people treat you.

When I was a kid, people knew my family wasn't doing so well and I'd get lots of well-intentioned charitable offers from friends and friends' parents that just made me feel really bad about myself, so there's one way that having a lower income revealed can affect relationships in an apparently positive way that's still uncomfortable.

Re:America needs to see Amazon’s tax returns by josefx on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:55AM (#20325252)
I had coworkers that where hostile to the very idea of equality. Get paid the same as them? They were worth twice as much. Take a pay cut in exchange for some other bonus? They deserved the bonus more than you and they would get it without the pay cut (they didn't, especially not after trying to add their own terms to it). There was nothing positive to informing them of the pay of anyone else.