News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by brentm on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:50PM (#20291087)
I think overall we should consider this process a very positive thing, FAA and Boeing (and Airbus as well) are all going to learn a lot from this process which will make air travel safer in the future. It's unfortunate that it took two tragedies to get us here but if you look at the history of aviation improvements this isn't the first and it won't be the last time.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by cjbprime on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:33PM (#20291278)
The reason people are outraged is that "don't use a single sensor to decide that the plane should perform an uncontrollable nose-dive" isn't the outcome of new learning. That wasn't competent airworthiness seventy years ago. It's a lesson the industry thought it had already internalized. We shouldn't applaud mistakes of the distant part being repeated recklessly as some kind of improvement.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by jussij on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:56PM (#20291380)
What amazes me about this whole sorry saga is what appears to be blatant deception on the part of Boeing.

Boeing somehow tricked the FAA into believing, from the pilots perspective the 737-MAX and 737 were the exact same plane.

That allowed the plane to enter service quickly as it meant the pilots would not require any flight simulator retraining.

What we now know is the 737-MAX is nothing like the 737 and the level of deception that seems to have occurred is concerning.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by cmurf on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:28AM (#20291759)
I wouldn't say the 737 MAX is nothing like the 737 NG, they're quite a lot alike in important ways, but there are clearly significant differences. And there should be an aggressively adversarial system to determine whether the difference is significant enough to warrant a separate type certification for the MAX variant.

I'm not at all amazed by Boeing's blatant deception and blame shifting. They've done this before, and with this same model of aircraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_rudder_issues

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by sopooneo on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:02AM (#20291675)
I don't think they "tricked [them] into believing". More like "talked them into accepting".
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by bronson on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:30AM (#20291767)
More like deceived: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.seattletimes.com/business/b...

Whether it was intentional to meet the schedule or accidental, we may never know.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by taneq on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:56AM (#20291860)
The only difference between these two descriptions is whether the FAA implicitly understood that the MAX is NOT the same as the 737. If yes, then they were talked into accepting it anyway. If no, then they were tricked (unless Boeing genuinely believed that there was no difference, which is clearly false.)
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by nolok on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:44AM (#20294842)
The kind of people who work at the FAA jobs where those decision are made know enough about planes to realize that a different engine placement is not without effect. That alone means they should at least have done extensive testing internally, which they didn't since it was pretty much clear they used the older 737 simulators / didn't have 737 MAX simulators.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by salawat on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:46AM (#20294860)
This is a very common phenomena that as Quality Assurance you specifically have to work around when talking to regulators, and there are in fact, white collar cultural norms in place which shape the way most corporations I've worked at talk about potential regulatory risks.

For one thing, if you bring up any questions regarding an issue at all, the preferred medium of communicating it until a decision is made tends to be direct person to person with no electronic paper trail. (This insulates the company from getting caught out by E-Discovery in case of legal troubles).

Secondly, there's the practice I call anchoring. This is where you go to the regulator with a very narrow, refined question looking for an answer, explain why you think it's a good idea, and hope they don't think too much into it before saying yes you can do it. If it works, you have a document stating the regulator told you it was okay when you asked. To prevent this, you have to go to your regulator and give them a high and wide view.

A) What is the problem B) What are the relevant regulations impacted C) What additional risks are created with both answers

Businesses can be a bit squirmy when engineering folks start getting too chummy with compliance. I know I've found a good one when I don't get funny looks when asking if something questionable sounding has been run passed Compliance.

Everything I've read in this investigation reeks of anchoring toward the FAA. Especially given the whistleblower testimony as reported in the 60 Minutes Expose on the MAX.

[1]https://m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DaO7_indbfME&ved=2ahUKEwje2...

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by mantap on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:48PM (#20291340)
What seems to have happened is that the system was originally designed with more conservative parameters. Testing showed that these parameters were insufficient to prevent a stall so they "turned it up to 11", and didn't re-evaluate the original design.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by salawat on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:53PM (#20291370)
It wasn't that it wasn't sufficient.

It was that they found similar behavior happening in a low-speed part of the flight envelope. That required increasing the authority and losing the G-load safeguard.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by jussij on Thursday June 27, 2019 @08:38AM (#20293838)
> "turned it up to 11", and didn't re-evaluate the original design.

In other words they thru all engineers principals out the window.

Now there is no doubt this is exactly what happened.

But the bigger question is why did this happen and why was it allowed to happen?

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by computerex on Thursday June 27, 2019 @01:30AM (#20291967)
This isn't some previously undiscovered issue in aviation. This is plain and simple Boeing prioritizing cost savings over human lives. It is as simple as that. There are no technical takeaways to be had from the two tragedies that took place. The only takeaway is that Boeing betrayed everyone but their pockets.
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by crististm on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:36AM (#20294195)
short term thinking vs long term consequences...
Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by cmiles74 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @08:55AM (#20293941)
I would prefer that Boeing be put out of business, rather than "learning a lot from this process". I think that the word "unfortunate" is too conservative to cover this situation.

A corporation is not a person and punishment isn't always the answer, but we are looking at a lot of deaths and this new issue sounds like it could have caused even more. If the FAA had missed this one we could have been looking at another crash. Maybe putting Boeing out of business would serve as a cautionary tale to the remaining companies in this space that they should be making more conservative choices when it comes to development of a product that has the potential to injure or kill such a large number of people.

As it is, I'm not sure what the moral of this story is for Boeing. Is it that the company is "too big to fail"? It is that they need to tough out the bad press to really be successful?

I worry that maybe it's something along the lines of "you have to crack a few eggs to make an omelette."

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by whyenot on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:09AM (#20294024)
Boeing is never going to be "put out of business." They are too important to the US economy and US national defense for that to ever happen.

What could happen (but still unlikely) is that those within the company who made the decisions that led to the deaths of 300 people could be held to account in a court of law.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by BorRagnarok on Friday June 28, 2019 @05:58AM (#20302849)
> What could happen (but still unlikely) is that those within the company who made the decisions that led to the deaths of 300 people could be held to account in a court of law.

Sorry, I laughed. That will never happen. Boeing may go under, but those rich bastards will always be able to stay out of jail. Name me one exec of a plane manufacturing company that has gone to jail over a crash. There aren't any.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by BorRagnarok on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:43AM (#20294237)
> FAA and Boeing (and Airbus as well) are all going to learn a lot from this process which will make air travel safer in the future

Yeah, right. Until they start cutting corners again for economic reasons. There's absolutely no change in any of those organizations driven by this incident or by an increase in standards or by safety, there are no new regulations, it's all a dog and pony show driven by money and saving their asses.

"if you look at the history of aviation improvements this isn't the first and it won't be the last time"

And that's a great argument for just letting the next horrible accident happen in a few years. Until people start demanding that at least the goal of those organizations should be Total and Complete Flight Safety, the FAA and Boeing will cut corners because "accidents will always happen, this isn't the first and it won't be the last, so who cares". Accidents will stay a calculated risk for them, in stead of something that just should never ever happen.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by navigatesol on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:46AM (#20294270)
>There's absolutely no change in any of those organizations driven by this incident or by an increase in standards or by safety, there are no new regulations

How fast do you think this stuff can happen?

>And that's a great argument for just letting the next horrible accident happen in a few years.

The next horrible accident is going to happen in a few years, sorry to tell you.

>Accidents will stay a calculated risk for them, in stead of something that just should never ever happen.

I'm going to assume you're no engineer.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by salawat on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:01AM (#20295006)
>I'm going to assume you're no engineer.

I'm pretty sure what you're trying to get across is that Engineering is the business of enabling the taking of calculated risks, but you're doing it in a needlessly inflammatory way.

And the poster you're responding to isn't necessarily wrong either. Just because engineering allows us to identify, analyze, and calculate the impact of risks does not free us of an obligation to always favor the most conservative approach in living up to the obligation to comport ourselves in a manner consistent with serving the Public interest.

Remember the Iron Ring in all things.

Re:FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes by BorRagnarok on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:22AM (#20302427)
> How fast do you think this stuff can happen?

Above I posted a seven year old documentary about the 787 Dreamliner, and there were the same problems of Boeing doing the FAA's work. So to answer your question: I don't really know, but it seems to be decades at least before anything changes, if at all. And that's really appalling.

>I'm going to assume you're no engineer.

I am, actually.

As an engineer you can calculate a risk like: this part under this type of load will fail at x, and then design so that x is never reached (or in a million years or so) to make a design safe.

A manager can calculate risk like: if we sell 5k planes, and we can make them $1000 cheaper by using a part that will increase the likelihood of a crash by only 2%, since the chance of a crash is already very very low, we might as well use the inferior part and make $5m extra. That way I can buy that third mansion I want.

Both are calculating risk. The engineer calculates for safety, the manager for his stock options. Which do you think is better?

My point is, the goal should always be complete safety. Even though engineers know that that is impossible, and even though lots of managers don't care at all about safety. We should still strive for it. Total flight safety should be the goal, not a byproduct of good engineering.

That's why we have the FAA in the first place, because we don't trust those managers at Boeing to make the right decisions, because experience learned us we shouldn't.

We trusted on the FAA and Boeing to hold that goal of passenger safety to the highest standards, but they betrayed that trust completely by letting Boeing do the FAA's work! Isn't that completely bonkers? Perhaps we just should scrap the FAA as well and let the Europeans certify all planes. I don't know. But right now there's nothing but ass-saving going on, and that doesn't restore trust in either of those organizations.

Lot's of people should be going to jail for this, but they wont, because they're rich and can buy their way out. Everybody knows this. That's the way the United States works. Justice is only for the rich and powerful. That's how Boeing can kill 300+ people and get away with it. As an engineer, this worries me greatly.