News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Jerry2 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:36PM (#20289456)
TFA starts off with a piece of actual news and then veers off into rumors and unsubstantiated BS which is presented as facts.

>Apple is in the process of migrating its Mac line to ARM processors as it looks to reduce its reliance on Intel.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ksec on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:58PM (#20290548)
No one has even try to give any convincing argument for ARM on Mac. And yet everyone seems to believe it as Fact.

1. There are articles that suggest Apple could move the Macbook, MacBook Air to their own ARM SoC, and leave the higher end MacBook Pro, Mac Pro, iMac on x86-64 for Professional Apps. In the case How is the Macbook different to iPad Pro with Keyboard? It is one thing to have a transition between two ISA, it is another thing to have the platform permanently on two ISA.

2. Is Apple going to spend hundreds of millions a year just to invest into Mac Desktop / high performance CPU, for use in iMac and Mac Pro CPU that runs from 100W to 220W. The Desktop Mac represent 20% of all Mac unit, that is roughly 4M. Majority of those are iMac, not iMac Pro or Mac Pro with high TDP.

3. If Apple want to lower its reliance on Intel ( After it has all of its modem and wireless patents sort out with Intel ), why not just use AMD to leverages the price or switch to AMD. AMD gets the PR win for Apple using it, win win for both companies.

4. The rumours would have some ground before WWDC, but Apple just announced a monster Mac Pro. Catering for real Hollywood professionals and Rack Mount Mac Pro for Servers.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by npunt on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:58AM (#20292792)
See my comment on another part of this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20292762

1. MacOS and iPad are similar, but distinct user experiences. Its more than hardware (one with keyboard, one without), its about those differences in experience. Apple is nothing if not patient about introducing change to computing paradigms and experiences, so it's fine to co-exist for a while. Switching to ARM gives them better margins, better control over price, better control over physical chassis constraints, better control over features offered, access to a better chip team than Intel's, and now TSMC and/or Samsung's better EUV processes. E.g. features-wise, Intel still isn't shipping LPDDR4 chips, something the 4 year old iPhone 6S had.

2. Basically, x86 becomes a co-processor, just like how discrete GPUs are handled. This avoids having to compete with tiny sliver of market that wants Xeons.

3. AMD is a lateral move, with exactly the same lack of control over core technologies problem. Also AMD is historically not as reliable a supplier for volumes that Apple has.

4. See #2 and my comment. Also, they needed to intro Mac Pro to satisfy / shore up existing Mac contingent before they abandoned entirely. This is a multi-year journey.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ksec on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:12AM (#20294514)
Because all these hypotheses assumes Co-Processor model works. And as far as I know,It doesn't. You cant move process between different ISA, not to mention memory access.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by wcfields on Thursday June 27, 2019 @08:30AM (#20293803)
> 2. ... x86 becomes a co-processor, just like how discrete GPUs are handled ...

That's become my hunch too in the transition to ARM, with Apple producing a SoC that integrates an entry level x86, with usual 2 upgrade options. Eg the next product line would be:

$1599 -- Dual-Core 1.5ghz A14 + Dual-core 1.2ghz x86

$1899 -- Quad-Core 1.9ghz A14 + Quad-Core 2.4ghz x86

$2199 -- Quad-Core 2.5ghz A14 + Quad-Core 2.7ghz x86

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by als0 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:12AM (#20294041)
To me that sounds way too costly (especially if they need to be an x86 licensee). And managing a heterogenous platform (HW/FW/OS) is damn hard without even considering the user experience standards that Apple are proud of.

I think they will take a different approach. Put a decent keyboard on a future iPad Pro. Make iOS more like macOS. And then they'll eventually kill macOS.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Steko on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:19AM (#20291723)
> In the case How is the Macbook different to iPad Pro with Keyboard?

Why is this a problem? Maybe they phase one of them out when they make the change? Or maybe leave them as slightly differentiated products like the jumble of different laptops they already have.

> Is Apple going to spend hundreds of millions a year just to invest into Mac Desktop / high performance CPU, for [Pro]

This seems like a number you just made up. Here is a comparison of last year's A12 ($50?) and a 2017 Xeon 8176 ($5K?):

https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/9midcx/apple_really_...

> If Apple want to lower its reliance on Intel ( After it has all of its modem and wireless patents sort out with Intel ), why not just use AMD to leverages the price or switch to AMD. AMD gets the PR win for Apple using it, win win for both companies.

Well they're fed up with Intel and there's the price gap but the primary reason is that the chip performance is rapidly converging so there is a massive opportunity to create a unified platform. Further they've been able to create a year plus performance gap between themselves and the competition in mobile on a commodity platform and with third party fab - if they do the same thing in desktop the Mac platform could really take off and they could go after the console market too.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ksec on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:00AM (#20292517)
>This seems like a number you just made up. Here is a comparison of last year's A12 ($50?) and a 2017 Xeon 8176 ($5K?):

You will have R&D just for the high TDP CPU, you don't just magically scale up your Phone CPU and expect it to work in a Server / Workstation. And that CPU has comparatively small volume. I.e The Unit Economics does't work.

The only Unit Economics would work better is to follow a similar strategy as AMD, where you have a single die and they are replicated across the 45W to 220W product line. This is a small sub 100mm2 Die Size with 4M yearly unit. But that is excluding the complexity of I/O where EPYC had a 400mm2 I/O die.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by sjwright on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:10PM (#20291433)
Reasons?

- Cost

- Motherboard size

- Performance per watt

- Battery life

- Custom optimizations

I see no impediment to Apple running two CPU architectures in parallel for a decade. Arm for ultra-portables and base model Macs, Intel for mid/top spec macs.

Then eventually once the worldwide ecosystem becomes less x86 dominated, I could imagine Intel chips being a BTO option for people who need it, possibly even implemented as a secondary CPU available through a hypervisor.

But why does anyone really care about x86 vs ARM anyway? Assuming 100% of Mac software is recompiled, the only thing which would affect me is having Windows VMs with native speed... And I could easily replace that with a headless NUC and Remote Desktop.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by megaremote on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:05PM (#20290578)
> No one has even try to give any convincing argument for ARM on Mac. And yet everyone seems to believe it as Fact.

Yes, everyone believes it is coming, just like they believed the iPhone was coming, the iPad was coming, the Apple watch was coming.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by dwaite on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:02PM (#20291414)
So will this be released before or after the Apple Television?
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by timthorn on Thursday June 27, 2019 @02:25AM (#20292178)
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:17AM (#20292867)
The Apple Car too! Wait...
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Razengan on Thursday June 27, 2019 @08:36PM (#20300392)
I will: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20280920 (Apple buys autonomous driving company Drive.ai)

There are enough news to support such rumors than there are news to discredit them.

But of course, there are stories like AirPower too.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by etaioinshrdlu on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:38PM (#20289983)
I don't think I could use a Mac for software development anymore if they switched away from Intel.

So much of my work is dependent on running linux executables in Docker for later deployment on a server running Intel. That is certainly extremely common.

I also need a Windows VM quite frequently for the odd program that only runs in Windows, or if I need to run Visual Studio one day. Windows is also very important for me to keep around so I can test software products in the same environment as other windows users, and there are definitely a handful of windows users out there.

Sure there may be alternative options in both areas but I'm not interested in solutions that work 80% of the time. I can't let my development environment get in the way of my work.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by jchw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:36PM (#20290745)
It would be slightly less convenient, but it probably wouldn’t affect your development capabilities so badly. Pretty much any Dockerfile that works on x86 should work on ARM. Linux runs totally fine on ARM. If anything, the worse problems are with Linux desktop and games software that assume ARM == embedded and attempt to use EGL and GLES.

There are, of course, many Docker repositories that lack ARM images, and you couldn’t use the exact same build locally as in production, but I think those are not actually huge, unresolvable issues. (The latter is straight up a non-issue with a good CD pipeline.)

Windows 10 also runs on ARM platforms, with the ability to transparently emulate Intel. I’m sure this is or will be usable inside of VMs even if dual booting is not an option.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/porting/apps-on...

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by StudentStuff on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:46PM (#20290796)
Most linux desktops work fine on ARM chips FYI. GPUs in the ARM world are usually just for OpenGL used by video games.

Video decoding/encoding is handled by a VPU (not GPU), HDMI is handled by a separate HDMI PHY, and most of these components have mainline, libre kernel support if you use an Allwinner based single board computer.

Microsoft has started branding some Mali GPUs as DirectX 11 capable, though YMMV on using these features.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by jchw on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:49PM (#20290807)
Sure, but many games and applications are hardcoded to use EGL and GLES (which is not always available for desktop ARM.) For example, I believe Qt4 makes the assumption that ARM = GLES.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday June 27, 2019 @03:41AM (#20292448)
> There are, of course, many Docker repositories that lack ARM images, and you couldn’t use the exact same build locally as in production, but I think those are not actually huge, unresolvable issues.

I'm not sure thats true. At the very least its going to suck for the first year as gaps are being filled, but those differences might matter too. I would hate to have to duplicate every single Dockerfile just because of this, as engineering orgs are typically heterogenous (win/lin/mac).

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by jchw on Friday June 28, 2019 @03:47AM (#20302285)
Should not need to duplicate the Dockerfiles; they should work as-is. The repositories may not contain aarch64 builds, but just like docker repos can contain windows container builds alongside linux, they can contain aarch64 alongside amd64, at the same URL, with the same tags, and in fact I think plenty of official images already have that.

Few images should need Dockerfile changes unless they are bootstrapping from scratch. People are already using Docker and Kubernetes on Raspberry Pi and other small ARM devices.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by microcolonel on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:19PM (#20290646)
> So much of my work is dependent on running linux executables in Docker for later deployment on a server running Intel. That is certainly extremely common.

Are you writing code that is hand-tuned for codegen on one architecture, or which relies on custom assembly to meet basic performance requirements? Because unless you are, I don't see what the issue would be with multiarch, assuming you don't manually compile the binaries for your containers.

Also AArch64 cloud servers are a commodity available from at least Amazon right now, and the hardware is available on the open market.

Not to mention, if you're running Docker right now, it's not running natively on macOS anyway. If you're just looking to test basic correctness, then surely you can run your dockers in QEMU or whatever AMD64 DBT/emulator is made available. Apple has a history of shipping good emulators (namely Rosetta and the 68k emulator) for their previous architectures when they change ISA.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by tatersolid on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @10:34PM (#20291280)
> Are you writing code that is hand-tuned for codegen on one architecture, or which relies on custom assembly to meet basic performance requirements?

Actually, most modern dev stacks do exactly this. You typically have some core libraries or runtime that includes heavily optimized or even hand-assembled crypto primitives. Even bog-standard “mainstream” Java or .NET code calls into system libraries which use AES, GCM, or SHA-256-specific instructions for accelerating TLS.

TLS is in just about everything.

You really need to develop and QA on the expected deployment platform

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by microcolonel on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:24PM (#20291488)
> "Actually, most modern dev stacks do exactly this. You typically have some core libraries or runtime that includes heavily optimized or even hand-assembled crypto primitives. Even bog-standard “mainstream” Java or .NET code calls into system libraries which use AES, GCM, or SHA-256-specific instructions for accelerating TLS. TLS is in just about everything."

Sure, but when it comes to platform enablement, that only really needs to be done once per vertical/native dependency. AArch64 has all of those things you listed. Don't know about .NET (though there's not that much .NET development on Linux, at least not when compared with the amount of Node and Java), but OpenJDK, Node, C/C++/Rust/Go toolchains all have mature support for AArch64, among others.

It's obviously less mature than the 40-year-old x86 ecosystem, but it's basically all there. Furthermore, the ease with which new ISAs can be adopted by toolchains and libraries is accelerating, so POWER and RISC-V are also getting there in terms of software availability.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by tatersolid on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @11:44PM (#20291595)
There are so many different flavors of AMD64 that it’s not even a single target from my perspective. Check out the quantity of compiler flags and ifdef statements you see in just about everything.

I’ve seen binaries in production run at 30% of the speed seen DEV/QA. These would also segfault every few hours. But debug builds ran fine in production.

Root cause in that case was the Intel server had some hardware instructions available that the Intel developer and QA systems didn’t. The runtime chose to use these fancy new instructions, which turned out to be a buggy and slow code path.

Again, if you’re not doing DEV/QA on hardware (and OS, dependency, and firmware versions) that differ from production you will eventually be bitten.

Everything is so complex and there are so many layers involved it is impossible to have confidence. Containers make this worse in my opinion by adding another complex (and buggy) abstraction layer.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by webaholic on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:10PM (#20290232)
May be by the time Mac has an ARM processor, your deployment server might also be an ARM server. :)
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by onion2k on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:18AM (#20292874)
I don't think I could use a Mac for software development anymore if they switched away from Intel.

A clear message that's been coming from Apple over the past few years is that developers are not a market they care very much about. I strongly suspect a lot of us won't be using Macs for development in the future.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Veen on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:30AM (#20292918)
They certainly care about Mac developers and iOS developers.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by protomyth on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:54AM (#20293016)
Looking at the state of documentation and their general lack of responsiveness, I really don't understand where the idea they care is coming from.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by onion2k on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:59AM (#20293615)
Do they? The App store is so full of automatically generated cookie-cutter apps with minor cosmetic differences that no one can really make a successful app any more. It's a lottery of who gets an Editor's Pick. That's not developer friendly.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Veen on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:58AM (#20294981)
Really? My iOS devices are full of high-quality applications that I bought on the App Store: Omnifocus, Omnioutliner, IA Writer, Pixelmator, Bear, Devonthink, Carrot Weather, Overcast, and dozens more.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by onion2k on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:30AM (#20295304)
I'm not suggesting there aren't great apps out there - I'm saying they're effectively impossible to find, and new app developers pretty much can't break in any more. There are 100 terrible apps for every good one, and you'll never find some of the best apps out there using the app store because of that noise. Finding new apps is driven by word of mouth, curation, etc. Apple themselves add practically nothing to the ecosystem, and certainly not enough to justify their 30% cut.

The list you added to your post is a good example of this - all those apps are examples of things that had a community outside of the app store before they had iOS versions. They're not good or successful because of Apple, but in spite of Apple.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by bin0 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:25PM (#20290344)
You know one of the great things about VMs? They're cross-platform. I'm guessing once the same amount of optimization is put into arm has has been put into x86, the performance ought to be comparable. I'm also about 99% sure docker can be run on arm (RPIs support it, right?).

With that said, I sincerely doubt Apple will kill x86 wholesale overnight. I'm guessing there will be a transitional period of quite some time.

Also, windows has been doing a ton of work around getting onto arm. I managed to test on my rpi 3, and it was pretty good. it would probably be very doable.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ihattendorf on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:43PM (#20290465)
Cross platform sure, but cross architecture will kill performance.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by rbanffy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:01AM (#20292525)
Not necessarily. JIT ISA emulation that generates native code for the host ISA has been done for ages now.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by etaioinshrdlu on Thursday June 27, 2019 @08:39PM (#20300412)
My understanding is that you could expect, very roughly, maybe a 50% performance hit using best of breed emulators translating from one ISA to an other ISA nowadays.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by FrojoS on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:55PM (#20289639)
>The company initiated a plan several years ago to replace Intel chips in its Mac computers with processors based on the ARM architecture as early as 2020.

Really sounds like they have some detailed knowledge, but yeah, no source is mentioned.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Despegar on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:13PM (#20289789)
They linked to their previous reporting that they're working on it.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-02/apple-is-...

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by r00fus on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:50PM (#20290071)
Does that count to cite oneself? Doesn't pass my veracity check.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by pfundstein on Thursday June 27, 2019 @12:43AM (#20291823)
Of course not, but sadly this is what Bloomberg has devolved into.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by HeWhoLurksLate on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @05:49PM (#20289585)
That particular "fact" does have some substance to it- In the past, Apple has switched as they feel that CPU horsepower is holding them back (keep in mind that they really want people to buy new every year) and they have already started moving their lineups over to ARM- their iPads have been ARM forever, and they have a pretty big knowledge base in it now.

EDIT: I think you may have been referring to the 9to5mac article- I'm going to leave this comment here, but the current article is way more specific.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by monocasa on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:23PM (#20290330)
The difference here is that the previous ISA changes have been accompanied with massive benefits. The 68k to ppc transition came with ppc being able to emulate 68k code faster than any 68k you could buy (in an interpreter, no JIT!!!), and the native ppc code was just ungodly fast comparitively. Ppc to x86 was less dramatic on raw perf, but was accompanied by a huge gain wrt perf per watt, and you could still emulate ppc on Intel about as well as you could run on a native ppc (with a JIT this time).

But now, Moore's law is in the process of hitting a brick wall. Those big wins for free just aren't there. And if there's a x86 to arm JIT, it's either going to be single core, or the arm cores are going to have to have a stronger x86 like memory model, thus negating a huge part of their architectural win.

IMO, Apple's going to make their own x86 chips because the base x86_64 patents are going to expire real soon now, and they have enough patents from the crazy amount of fabless acquisitions to potentially cross license the rest.

Processors are commodities now, and that's really going to shake things up in crazy ways.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by NikkiA on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:06PM (#20290585)
> The 68k to ppc transition came with ppc being able to emulate 68k code faster than any 68k you could buy (in an interpreter, no JIT!!!)

This simply isn't true, it wasn't until the G3-300 was released that the 68k emulator could run 68k code at 40MHz comparable speeds, and that was after 10 years of ppc601s and 603s running 68k system binaries at slower than quadra speeds on 180 and 200MHz processors.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by scarface74 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:10PM (#20290905)
The 68k to ppc transition came with ppc being able to emulate 68k code faster than any 68k you could buy (in an interpreter, no JIT!!!), and the native ppc code was just ungodly fast comparitively.

Neither part of that statement is true. I had an LCII with a 68030-40Mhz card before upgrading to a 6100/60. The 6100/60 (601-60Mhz processor with a half speed bus) was much slower running 68K software than my LCII. It was about the same speed once I bought SpeedDoubler.

Also, between the slower bus, the slow shared graphics memory and System 7 on the PPC being emulated, it felt much slower than a decent 486-DX2/66 or a Pentium-60.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:46PM (#20291065)
Yep and Macs of that era were also horribly unstable due to lack of memory protection, and this seemed even more complicated by the 68k emulation. Crashed all the time. At one of my offices there was a constant problem with Macs crashing if FileMaker and Netscape ran at the same time.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by scarface74 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @09:49PM (#20291086)
That’s true but in all fairness, it was a point of nerd pride if your operating system could handle a Netscape crash. Netscape was horrible on every single operating system it ran on. People seem to forget that IE was actually better than NS around IE 3.0.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by rbanffy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:05AM (#20292544)
Netscape was so bad, in fact, that they did rewrite it from scratch into what is Firefox today.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by mutt2016 on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:41PM (#20290452)
Also Intel isn't the only maker anymore. Anybody can have a chip made by that other company TSMC and whatnot.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by bshipp on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:19PM (#20289832)
correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the reason they moved to Intel chips in the first place because their homegrown CPUs couldn't keep up?

Has that calculus changed in the meantime?

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by esmi on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:22PM (#20289865)
They switched because Freescale and IBM couldn’t keep up with Intel. Apple did not make CPUs at that time.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%27s_transition_to_Inte...

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by bshipp on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:47PM (#20290046)
Fair enough, I always associated PowerPC with Apple and assumed they were the driving force behind it's use.

Regardless, that makes the financial calculus even more suspect as they would have even fewer units to amortize the cost over. But I don't work for Apple, and quite frankly the CPU market could certain use the injection of some more competition.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by IOT_Apprentice on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:57PM (#20290541)
Fewer units? They have arm processors in every iPhone, iPad and AppleTV. At least 70 million units a quarter. The Mac CPUs would need more cores/threads (perhaps octocore).
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by protomyth on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:21PM (#20290658)
Apple and assumed they were the driving force behind it's use

Quite the opposite. Apple, according to the book The Race for a New Game Machine, was an unprofitable demanding customer. The scale of the XBox 360 and PS3 dwarfed Apple's usage and IBM made several decisions that were contrary to Apple's needs. PowerPC for the embedded market has been the primary driver of PowerPC development.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by rbanffy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:09AM (#20292560)
At some point IBM offered Apple the Cell processor.

I'm glad Apple opted to move to Intel then. The Cell is the hardest thing I ever tried to write code for.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by protomyth on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:57AM (#20293029)
IBM made decisions about the Cell PowerPC that made it unsuitable for Apple (no out of order) and offered the 970 as compensation. We all got to see how those promises played out.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by monocasa on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:13PM (#20290262)
They helped a little with the overarching design (the ISA of the vector unit was pretty much Apple designed) but they never made any chips themselves AFAIK.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by tyingq on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:22PM (#20289869)
I think a lot has changed. Maybe not the ability to consistently lead Intel, but at least a larger portion of end users that would find an ARM laptop "good enough" exists now.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by noir_lord on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:49PM (#20290062)
AMD is beating intel on price and performance and they have a fraction of the resources of Apple.

Intel is behind on process and has been for a couple of generations right as everyone hits a process wall.

For the first time since I got into computers in the late 80s Intel looks vulnerable.

As to whether Apple would go ARM on a MacBook who knows, I’d guess they wouldn’t but they could straight buy AMD in cash so it’s not beyond the realm they could tool up for desktop class ARM.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by bshipp on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:58PM (#20290141)
Indeed, AMD is finally in a good position after years wandering the desert. That said, this current strong performance is the result of years of R&D, something that would have to be built from the ground up if Apple was to try and replicate it.

I can't help but think there must be some secret benefit to make them pursue such a risky endeavour for something so tangential to their comparative advantage. Apple doesn't sell custom components, they sell consumer experiences. They must be planning on going a completely different direction with iOS to warrant custom processor technology.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by IOT_Apprentice on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:01PM (#20290562)
Umm, you do realize that Apple has a large design team and outsources Fab to TSMC? Their iPhone/iPAD/AppleTV hardware platforms already run on their own ARM chip design. They SHIP over 70 MILLION units a quarter. They have the R&D teams already churning out new designs each year.

How is this risky?

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by sprafa on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:31PM (#20290381)
I suppose hiring people like this (and this is he one we hear about they could have hired 20-30 people without anyone noticing) is a way to shortcut such R&D
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by xxs on Thursday June 27, 2019 @02:58AM (#20292293)
but they could straight buy AMD in cash so it’s not beyond the realm they could tool up for desktop class ARM

The cross licensing deal (of AMD on x86) with Intel would be off. Pretty much AMD is not sellable in this regard.

AMD could produce/design an ARM chiplet, attached with infinity fabric to their Zen2.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by LgWoodenBadger on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:52PM (#20290821)
If Apple bought AMD, they'd lose out on all of the Intel-licensed IP because of the poison pull in the cross-patent licensing agreements between Intel/AMD in case of an AMD acquisition.

At least, that's according to what I've read about it.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:10PM (#20290233)
Notably, AMD isn’t ARM.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by Doctor_Fegg on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:20PM (#20289842)
PowerPC wasn’t really homegrown.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by gumby on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @07:00PM (#20290156)
Though Apple was part of the original PowerPC consortium, and back then also had a chip team.

Then again Apple was also the other partner (with Acorn) in founding ARM.

Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by melling on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:40PM (#20289998)
I believe Mark Gurman does a good job with his rumors.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by w0mbat on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @08:15PM (#20290633)
The article also describes the 14 years since Intel Mac was announced as “nearly two decades”.
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ltc5505 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:11AM (#20294039)
TFA = This F---ing Article?
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by dejawu on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:18AM (#20294086)
The Featured Article
Re:Apple Hires Key Chip Designer From ARM as Own Efforts Ram... by ltc5505 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:53PM (#20298625)
That makes sense. Thank you!