Without knowing the details, I can't say whether a €2000 fine was disproportionately onerous or a slap on the wrist.
https://www.businessinsider.com/nhs-trust-fined-for-leaking-...
The ICO might well consider a similar breach worthy of a bigger fine now.
It's almost like laws can work.
This is where Outlook with their *@outlook.com and apple’s new system really do shine.
Commiserations to those affected :(
https://www.rosepartner.de/blog/bussgeld-fuer-offenen-e-mail...
He was fined solely based upon the email addresses being visible to all recipients, not because of the content of his mails, said a spokesperson. However, he was a repeat offender in terms of privacy, who in the past was warned, then fined for similar stuff.
I'm a little bit torn on that one. The fine seems excessive for what he did (and the email addresses seem to be a list of already public journalist and press contacts) and it certainly looks like somebody in the govt got annoyed and threw the book at the guy in retaliation. Then again, he had ample warnings, and choose to ignore those warnings.
It really is analogous to most govt fines e.g. speeding tickets: the government (the police) gives you a ticket, and if you pay it then OK, no court involved, but if you challenge it then the courts get involved.
But more generally, the government should and does get priority access to the courts already. Criminal courts exist solely to serve the government; you cannot bring criminal suits as a citizen yourself, only civil suites. Also, e.g. in Germany the government and legislatures (federal and state) get priority access to e.g. the constitutional (supreme) court. A mere mortal cannot just file suit directly in the constitutional court, but has to go through the lower instances first (unless there is something similar to a class action petition, showing a sizable chunk of the population sees the same issue and wants it decided). Members of the parliaments and IIRC of the cabinet are allowed to file suit in the constitutional court directly. The reasoning here is that if it was allowed for citizens to petition the highest court directly, then the court would do nothing else than write rejection letters for bullshit petitions. While the govt and legislatures incl the parliamentary opposition of course represent the people (in theory) and aren't stupid morons wasting the courts time (in theory).
PS: Google was already fined €50M for GDPR violations, and there is probably more of those in their future. Facebook got fined €10M so far, IIRC, also with more to come. And don't forget the billions of Euros worth of antitrust fines against Google and Microsoft, e.g.
But using CC instead of BCC causes a massive leak of personal information, especially when either the subject being discussed or the people on the list are sensitive. In my life this has mostly been annoyance at large org stuff, but my wife has had this happen with a sensitive medical practice and we were not in the US so HIPAA did not apply.
I don't think fines are the only solution, of course. But I think fines should be on the table and it's easy to me imagine a circumstance where 2k euro would be appropriate.
The argument back then was that they were overreacting, that we didn't understand how Europe works, that you'd only get fined after repeated warnings about violating procedures etc.
I'm sure the private person was dumb for doing what he did, but that doesn't invalidate the general point: unless you're sure you that can afford making these kinds of mistakes, don't provide a service on the internet that might be used by EU citizens.
The benefits, whatever they might be, just don't justify the risks.
This site makes no mention of warnings and escalations, and ICO at least doesn't normally announce that for individual cases. Though they do put out aggregate stats. When they have fines are clearly shown as arising in a small minority of cases.
https://iapp.org/news/a/germanys-first-fine-under-the-gdpr-o...
Which goes to show why the regulators get the discretion to decide appropriate action from warning only to maximum fine. Without context and aggravating and mitigating factors we can't know, which was my point. If a penalty is disproportionate there's well worn appeal tracks.
Other comments seem to point to the small case in OP comment being some guy running a list to harass people, which seems like a huge aggravating factor to me. Maybe he got one warning, maybe in context he didn't deserve even that.
True. But I doubt that even the most ruthlessly efficient GDPR enforcement authority could multiple enforcement requests between mid July and end July.
There's potential time for quite a few ignored warnings before prosecution, but I don't know and can't find out from here if or if not.
Very likely that they just ignored it.
DOT
sounds good
I agree it's a difficult problem and it's hard to define boundaries, but some level of competence is welcome when handling data that belongs to other people.
If you start some internet service, I expect you not to lose my data (in some lame way, s.h.), just like I expect my car mechanic not to destroy my engine.
edit: to give it context, I closed my programming website with thousands of active users that I had for almost 20 years because of GDPR, I'm not a big fan of it, but what I like even less is when complete incompetence when handling personal data results in zero consequences
All sorts of civil offences and crimes can be mistakes. While "it was an accident" might lower the penalty it doesn't negate the fact the mistake was made and people might have been hurt.
The idea that we should hold companies that profit off people's personal data blameless if they manage to "make a slip-up" with it is absurd. The only other industry where we accept those kinds of mistakes is Wall Street and we all know how well that policy has gone.
>profit off people's personal data
Have you "decided to create a business around destroying the environment" and "profit off CO2 emissions" because your office is heated in the winter? GDPR is not specific to the adtech or data brokerage industries.
It was purely a hobby affair that was a net loss, but Google ads ($10 per month) reduced the cost somewhat.
Those ads probably made it a for profit business.
I shut the thing down before GDPR, but if I hadn’t it surely would have been an excellent reason to do so.
Those are the kind of websites that you lose.
I consider that a loss.
It is doable, if you have the lawyers and the time. But that's not a degree of scrutiny you want to gamble your life savings on for a personal project.
I might need it later is not a clear reason!
HN doesn't need to know or share your username to post your comment, it is clearly possible to run a message board without usernames, and conversations could be maintained by generating a random pseudonym for each thread.
Pure FUD.
EDIT: Downvotes don't change reality. The OP is spreading FUD.
Edit: unless the website was actually abusing users privacy in which case I'm glad it is gone.
Now he has "decided to build a business around profiting from the abuse of personal data" and the consensus in this thread looks on his destruction with glee.
This is typical FUD. GDPR allows backups. Right to be deleted doesn't mean grovelling through backups. If those snapshots are rotated out after e.g. 3 months he is fine.
And regarding sanitizing altitude. Again pure FUD. There is no way that that would be a problem.
Of course if he stores the data in a personally identifying way and then is either incompetent or abusive then he could attract a fine...
In the real world GDPR enables such websites because users can trust that he has to follow some minimum standards.
>After the controller succeeded to identify the data subjects he refused to comply with the deletion request, arguing he is legally obliged to retain backup copies according to the Accountancy Act and internal policies. Since he did not properly inform about these policies, the NAIH held the controller breached the principle of transparency.
So maybe if his backup regime were precisely specified in his privacy policy. But even a conflicting legal requirement is no defense, here.
Regarding minimization, 4 other cases:
>During an inspection, the Lithuanian Data Protection Supervisory Authority found that the controller processed more data than necessary to achieve the purposes for which he was a controller.
>Data was not only processed if adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which they are processed
> The video surveillance subject of the proceedings is therefore not limited to areas which are under the exclusive power of control of the controller.
> The Commissioner considered that the aim could be achieved by referring only to the initials of their name and/or their faces being blurred and/or publishing photographs drawn from a distant distance
"Of course if he stores the data in a personally identifying way..." GDPR cares not for identifying but for identifiable. It's GPS data. If someone uploads data pertaining to their home, workplace, frequent travel routes, etc. then it is definitely identifiable.
Regarding FUD, it seems FUD is exactly what the DPAs intend, since they are punishing rather than helping when asked for advice!
>Kolibri Image had send a request to the Data Protection Authority of Hessen asking how to deal with a service provider who does not want to sign a processing agreement. After not answering Kolibri Image in more detail, the case was forwarded to the locally responsible Data Protection Authority of Hamburg. This Auhtority then fined Kolibri Image as controller for not having a processing agreement with the service provider.
https://kolibri-image.com/causa-datenschutz/
Google translate:
https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=de&tl=en&u=htt...
tl;dr
The Data Protection Authority of Hessen suggested Kolibri Image to draft their own data processing agreement and get Packlink, located in Madrid, to sign it. [1]
Kolibri Image then stated that they would "leave things as they are", which was incorrectly interpreted to mean that they'd use Packlink without an agreement instead of not using Packlink in the future.
In addition, Kolibri Image forgot to update one of their six data processing agreements on various websites which still mentioned Packlink, so their clarification of the matter was not believed.
Finally, the case was dropped because it (partially?) happened before the 24th of Mai.
[1] Drafting a data processing agreement for Packlink is of course not very practical because who knows how they handles their data and why would Packlink sign it in the first place if they don't want to offer a data processing agreement. In addition, the cost of drafting and translating the agreement is much more expensive than the savings from using Packlink as a shipping processor.
In any case, I agree that fining after asking for advice is not a friendly move.
You make a fix in the email system that accidentally emails everybody at the same time? (It almost happened.) Oops. There's your exposure to some nice fine.
You don't need to be abusing somebody's privacy to be concerned about legal exposure. Just like there are asshole companies, there are asshole users as well who can make your life miserable.
Any hobbyist who doesn't take this kind of exposure into consideration is naive.
https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=d8d0c69a-620e...
Seems like an appropriate fine. Or do you think I should be allowed to collect 150 e-mail addresses, then e-mail them out to all 150 other people, after some of them told me not to do that?
[1] https://www.rosepartner.de/blog/bussgeld-fuer-offenen-e-mail...
The sender is also non-repentant and is running some sort of hate campaign.
This isn’t a one time slip up, it’s a 10 times slip up and chances are there were a lot of warnings this guy didn’t want to listen to. So he was hit where it hurts. Poor guy, it’s like he was caught speeding ten times and then got fined.
In Poland we actually have a sort-of tradition, AFAIK started by one of computer security portals, where if you find yourself on the receiving end of such CC-instead-of-BCC, you kindly tell the company responsible that this can and should be picked up with data protection regulators, and it would be nice if they e.g. paid ~500-2k EUR equivalent to a charity of their choice.
I'm totally 100% in support of this against companies. Less so about private individuals, though a 150-people newsletter is kind of thought-out and organized thing, and then 2k EUR in Germany is probably less than a monthly paycheck. A hard hit, but survivable without loss of life quality.
The linked article suggests that the guy was sending out angry political rants and criminal accusations to thousands of people a day, which adds a further twist.
Nothing I've heard about this case sounds to me like an innocent mistake that a reasonable effort was made to correct.
I've accidentally smacked people on the street before (gesturing, probably). That's technically a crime, but it'd be crazy to prosecute me for a little mistake like that. But it's not crazy that hitting people is a crime and that people do get prosecuted for it in egregious cases.
I personally think ~$15 per leaked email is a reasonable fine. I bet this guy and everyone else who reads this article won't accidentally leak emails again, and that's great.
In fact, I'd argue that leaking an email that exposes a private association with a mailing list to other unknown people has much clearer potential for damage than any of the privacy issues that big companies get fined for. And yes, CC leaks do happen (not a lot, in my experience), but I'm personally upset about it every time - much more so than when I find out Google didn't get my consent before recording half of my internet activity. Just because the violation is something that "happens a lot" because it can be done by accident by a careless individual doesn't mean it's less serious.
If a behavior is harmful and we want to stop it, but it's difficult to prove direct damages and therefore civil suits have been ineffective at curbing the behavior, then it seems like a reasonable public policy to impose fines on engaging in the behavior without requiring actual damages be proven in court.
(And if it's easy to innocently accidentally engage in the behavior, it seems reasonable to first issue warnings, and then impose fines if the behavior continues repeatedly.)
Yes, proof of weaponized gdpr use indeed (for very specific filtering cases of gdpr use).
So if a EU citizen's email id was part of the list, will it be liable for action according to GDPR?
Well, against people who publicly share private info of 150 other people who trusted them those emails. 2K euros is not that huge money in Germany, it's not like they'll loose their house over it, and that certainly is a practice that needs to be stopped. Just being an amateur is not an excuse when you deal with other peoples' data.
What didn't they like about this person, and what proved that to you? And what proved that was the impetus for this fine?
Someone was fined 2000 euros for using CC instead of BCC in his little mailing list newsletter of 150 people in Germany.
"The fine was impossed against a private person who sent several e-mails between July and September 2018, in which he used personal e-mail addresses visible to all recipients, from which each recipient could read countless other recipients. The man was accused of ten offences between mid-July and the end of July 2018. According to the authority's letter, between 131 and 153 personal mail addresses were identifiable in his mailing list."
Poor guy.
This seems to be proof that the GDPR is being weaponized against people and organizations one doesn't like.