News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by caiocaiocaio on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:31PM (#20257182)
Google any recipe, and there are at least 5 paragraphs (usually a lot more) of copy that no one will ever read, and isn't even meant for human consumption. Google "How to learn x", and you'll usually get copy written by people who know nothing about the subject, and maybe browsed Amazon for 30 minutes as research. Real, useful results that used to be the norm for Google are becoming more and more rare as time goes by.

We're bombarding ourselves with walls of human-unreadable English that we're supposed to ignore. It's like something from a stupid old sci-fi story.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by corodra on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:55PM (#20257389)
Those are the absolute worst. A recipe with someone's jackass life story for 2000 words. You start to wonder if it's even a recipe at all. You have to scroll for a good minute, hoping you didn't miss the recipe. Then come the ads that reformat the size of the page. Everything jumps around and you have to rescroll again.

Exactly why I stick to cookbooks in the past year or so. More and more, "fuck the internet", long live murdering trees.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by dheera on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:59PM (#20257419)
One thing about cookbooks is that the massive barrier to actually publishing and distributing is a natural filter for credibility; most cookbooks have tried-and-true recipes and are either authentic or a genuinely good adaptation by a skilled chef author.

The internet is full of garbage recipes that either just don't work, inauthentic, and uncreative, all at the same time.

As far as murdering trees go -- let's not forget that libraries and e-books exist.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by com2kid on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:15PM (#20257572)
The flip side of this is that the cookbooks rarely have super niche recipes. Even some of the highest rated "authentic" cookbooks have the flavor level tuned way down to be more "suitable for American tastes".

The best cooking tutorials are barely translated Youtube videos. Or even better, recipes going through Google Translate.

(Or get a multi-lingual friend... :) )

Cook's Illustrated also does some 100% legit international recipes, they are smart enough to A/B test against the country of origin and try to match up the flavor profile with ingredients that are available in America, which can be more work than just directly translating to "closest cultivar of a plant".

I've also enjoyed the organic explosion of low carb cooking that has happened online. I have been witness to the community growing from its very beginnings less than a decade ago when it was just some people trying to make weight loss taste good, to professional level chefs jumping in with their recipes. It is now possible to source low-carb recipes online that can go toe to toe with any other genre of food (e.g. https://alldayidreamaboutfood.com/chocolate-hazelnut-sandwic...).

Of course there is also an explosion of low-carb blog spam. Ugh. I do sometimes miss when everyone in the community was there because they loved just trying new things out and sharing their experiences. The same SEO problems exist...

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by corodra on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:04PM (#20257951)
I absolutely understand what you're getting at. But, I have a reason to disagree. I find cookbooks help expand the cultural horizons to cooking. Only because you can get "authentic" cookbooks of other countries. The Polish ones I have, are in Polish. So, that's easy. The French ones I have, though in English, are written either originally by Frenchies and translated or they also know English and have a good editor. Same goes for Japanese, Thai and German. But I also look for keywords about their grandmother. Best way to know the authentic level of a cookbook in English is how much they admit they're stealing from their grandma. The higher, the better. Especially if they talk about struggling to get the right ingredients.

Honestly, I miss absolutely nothing from the internet when it comes to cooking. But I also wanted to be a chef. So I studied how to properly cook long ago and I cook almost every day... so I'll admit in already an outlier. Still, the way the internet treats cooking is retarded. It doesn't surprise me that people don't like to cook if they grew up with the internet as a learning resource. All these people overcomplicate easy recipes and substitute anything because it makes them feel like pretty snowflakes.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by dagw on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:28AM (#20261505)
is how much they admit they're stealing from their grandma.

Does that still work? Most people's grandmas today where very much alive and cooking in both the 70s, 80s and even 90s and thus as steeped as anybody in all the international influences and 'foreign' ingredients that those decades brought.

the way the internet treats cooking is retarded.

And here you and I disagree. I like the way that 'modern' cooking is willing to revisit well established and 'sacred' truths about food and put them to the test. Perhaps a housewife in the 1920s isn't the authoritative source on the best way to prepare a dish, and even if she is there is no way to know without someone actually testing that hypothesis. Sites like Serious Eats and all the sites they begat bring both rigor and the joy of experimentation back into cooking. I mean why not substitute one thing for another just to see what happens or apply the 'wrong' technique to a standard dish? Many a dish that is considered a 'classic' today no doubt got their start that way.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by rorykoehler on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:48PM (#20259476)
Cultural is just one dimension. I've had to change my diet drastically recently for health reasons and the niche I fall into (no starch, no dairy, very low sugar others known as no dairy keto) is barely catered for, even on the Internet.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by ip26 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @10:21PM (#20260030)
Although the trouble sometimes with "authentic" cookbooks is they occasionally depend on a certain level of shared intrinsic knowledge of the cuisine! That's a tough one to solve on your own.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by bigmanwalter on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:44PM (#20268267)
It's amazing really. My other half's family is Greek and it took me years to get the hang of some of their simplest recipes. The whole time they were saying "It's only olive oil and salt! What can be so difficult?""
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by dheera on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:18PM (#20257594)
> The best cooking tutorials are barely translated Youtube videos.

Yeah I love those. The "random grandma with a gopro" tutorials always work, modulo language barrier. The video editing is crap and you sometimes have to keep fast forwarding while stuff is cooking but the recipes are good.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by jrumbut on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:59PM (#20258944)
Could you give us a link to a great random grandma with a gopro video?

I have been to what I thought was deep in the Internet recipe mines and never saw this.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by evilduck on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:13PM (#20259559)
Probably not a GoPro but Chinese food channels seem to fit this description fairly often. Here’s one https://youtu.be/fz_aSsuhg8Y
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by jrumbut on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:03AM (#20260462)
I learned a dozen things watching that video. Wow, thanks to you and the chef there.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by com2kid on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:48PM (#20268317)
If I live to be 90 I'll still never have the confidence to peel ginger like that...
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by throwaway8879 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:49PM (#20259691)
You may like the "Pasta with Italian Grannies channel" channel. I recently discovered it and it's the best.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by lapnitnelav on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:57PM (#20259723)
I don't know why but I find it really relaxing to watch those kinds of cooking video with a slower pace.

It's good to slow down and enjoy those fairly simple things.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by CondensedBrain on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:34PM (#20259629)
>> "I've also enjoyed the organic explosion of low carb cooking that has happened online. I have been witness to the community growing from its very beginnings less than a decade ago when it was just some people trying to make weight loss taste good"

This is way older than a decade. I knew people getting into it and sharing recipes on Usenet. The current boom is new, but online low carb communities are ancient in internet terms.

It wasn't very palatable back then, but people sure did try.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by guelo on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:48PM (#20259920)
The original low carb fad was Dr Atkin's diet in the late 90s.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by DrScump on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:16AM (#20261463)
Atkins goes back to the 1980s, and keto diets well preceded him.

There was already an active Usenet community for lowcarb diets in the late 1990s (alt.support.diet.low-carb).

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by corodra on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:13PM (#20257554)
In my experience, ebook cookbooks get annoying when you have dirty fingers and the screen goes dark because you forgot to switch it back to always on. And there's a great tendency that the recipe is always fucking formatted so you have to scroll more or "turn the page". Cookbooks, at least the ones I own, are all formatted so you never have to turn the page. Seems silly, but that's important.

Yeah library, to check if you want to buy it or just write down a handful of recipes.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by bscphil on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:41PM (#20259658)
My strategy is to bookmark the sites of the people who have good published cookbooks. You have a much better chance of getting good recipes from someone who knows what they are doing, as you said, but you also get the additional convenience and variation from being able to search online.

In my experience, these sites tend to be less spammy too, but there's certainly variation there too.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by p1necone on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:44PM (#20259461)
I don't know about that - for every one 'Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat' there's 99 'middle aged white persons easy diet fad of the year 5 minute meals'. Published cook books dont really seem better to me.

There seems to be two distinct 'genres' of cookbooks. One written by people who have studied cooking, and one written by people that have studied marketing.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by ip26 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @10:18PM (#20260022)
It gets better. Or, well, worse. Last time I ran into one of those, I wanted to make curry. After the 2000 words gushing about how it was the most delicious thing ever and how they "couldn't even", the recipe was to pour a jar of premade curry over rice.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by thehashrocket on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:19PM (#20259832)
We started using an app called Paprika that parses the page and extracts the recipe.

Although, I will admit, my youngest daughter and I get a kick out of the stories. We even try to predict which theme the writer will go with. Some are like Christmas Hallmark movies. lol.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by pascalxus on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:24PM (#20259397)
oooh but look at all that "Dwell time", that's how google's algorithm knows you're having a great time.

I switched over to duck duck go several months ago. it's just as good as google for almost everything.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by batiudrami on Sunday June 23, 2019 @11:27PM (#20260258)
The reality is these stupid recipe websites are just reproductions of other people's recipes anyway. Look for an "adapted from" credit - it will only have minute changes. Maybe they halve the cream somewhere "because it's too rich for their family" or something.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by cylinder on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:30AM (#20261291)
Yep, maybe using magazines and other gatekeepers of quality was not such a bad idea.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by anderspitman on Sunday June 23, 2019 @10:24PM (#20260040)
Blame the web, not the internet
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by loco5niner on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:31AM (#20264507)
For most of us "the web" = "the internet"
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by Gene_Parmesan on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:04PM (#20257958)
Re: recipes, one of the potential reasons for this is that bare recipes are not copyrightable by law. Courts see them as algorithms, almost -- e.g., there are only so many ways to cook a grilled cheese sandwich.

> 17 U.S.C. 102(b): In no case does copyright protection for an original work of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery, regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied in such work.

So it's been a tradition in the recipe space for decades to include lots of descriptive "filler" text when you're writing your recipe book/blog. That filler text is copyrightable, which gives you legal recourse against people who might try to wholesale copy your work.

Of course, in the modern world, it's definitely true that they can also help with SEO. And honestly I wouldn't completely discount the idea of people actually reading them -- I know my wife has gone through phases where she has a couple different blogs bookmarked and will read through them to get ideas, but also because she liked the writing of the author.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by notatoad on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:07PM (#20258665)
Subscribing to r/baking has been enlightening. The people who write those pages of text you have to skip over to read their recipes actually think they're adding value and that the readers of their recipe blogs are there for the stories as much as for the recipes.

Maybe they're right and some people do love the stories, but they're definitely not just there for SEO anymore. At the very most cynical interpretation, scrolling through the story is the "cost" of the recipe - the blogger gets an ego boost thinking thousands of people want to read all about their life, and the readers get a recipe.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by TAForObvReasons on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:21PM (#20259388)
Many essays-before-recipes summarize the experimentation process, what worked and what didn't, why an unconventional ingredient is used, why no stock is used when traditional recipes call for it. Without the context, many recipes just seem wrong and some real gems would be passed over
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by MereInterest on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:41PM (#20259899)
When those are the case, I really like it. Things like The Food Lab are joys to read, because they go into the detail of why ingredients are present and what variations/substitutions preserve the flavor of the dish. But those are few and far between. Most of the time, the filler consists of stories and anecdotes about the childhood memories that the recipe invokes, followed by the exact same recipe as is on a dozen other sites.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by detaro on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:08PM (#20258351)
That's not quite the same as the pattern the parent describes I think: There's a longer post before the recipe, not integrated into the recipe.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by plotteddancer16 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:42PM (#20258530)
Ya, I believe the OP was talking about the five pages of story-telling before the recipe that requires you to annoyingly scroll until you find the recipe ingredient list. I came here for a cookie recipe, not a story about how you discovered you liked oatmeal cookies when you were 12, but then became a raisin-cookie fanatic, before moving back to chocolate chips, when you suddenly remembered your Grandma baked you peanut butter cookies as a kid. /sic
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by corodra on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:18PM (#20259372)
Oh, you forgot all their allergies. Every cook on the internet has an allergy to everything but the substitute. "That's when I found out I'm allergic to flour, eggs, milk, butter, salt, chocolate, meat and fruit. Here's my healthy recipe for chocolate chip cookies made from tofu, himalayan sand, gerbil presents and wheatgrass." No! First, it's not a chocolate chip cookie then! It's an unholy abomination of sadness. Wheatgrass is just lawn clippings! Something is wrong with you!

Look, I have the very sad allergy to hazelnuts... I love hazelnuts... but they don't love me. Also soy. Soy is borderline deadly to me even in small amounts. So, I can't have asian food without cooking it myself. Fish sauce sans soy fermentation is my substitute. I do get the allergy issue and being left out in many foods. But I find it so damn hard to believe that all these people are allergic to everything but these "healthy alternatives" that end up being nutritionally empty. Then they wonder why they're suddenly anemic. Then they don't get enough sun because their skin "suddenly" became sensitive. Then they have depression issues. Then they can't shit straight. Then they start cutting back on other foods. Then they have to live on horse pills.

Sorry, rant. Got angry.

Fun argument to have with the next anti-vaxxer you meet. If they argue about mercury or lead being in vaccines, agree with them. Just flat out agree with how terrible it is. Then ask if they like Himalayan sea salt. There's like a 99.9% chance they love it, along with essential oils. "You do know there are more trace amounts of mercury and lead in Himalayan sea salt than in vaccines?" You will then agree with me that mental gymnastics needs to be in the next Olympics. It's amazing how they'll talk around it. Make some popcorn, open a beer and watch the show.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by theturtletalks on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:34PM (#20257209)
So true. Whenever I look up something now I just add Reddit afterwards. It's been working well so far, but I guess that can be manipulated as well.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by rlucas on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:40PM (#20257753)
There’s a reason that works (sorta, mostly, and when it does).

The infrastructure of web navigation and search is foundationally built on textual, first party published content that enjoys some presumptions of good faith authorship: that it was written to be read, by a reader, and meant to be informative, persuasive/argumentative, or recreational/entertaining.

Think: journal articles, Usenet debates, faq compilations, RFCs, product spec sheets, forum postings, IRC logs, ur-blogs, even the original social media content types (tweets, wall posts, comments).

The cycles and epicycles of architecting atop this “real” content gives us mechanisms that reward and incentivize content produced neither for the ends of the writer writing nor any reader reading, but rather in service of manipulating search and driving ux patterns of various darkness.

All the good stuff on the internet is reborn in a spasm of returning to people creating content they care about for other people who care. Then eventually with success it gets polluted into shit with bots, seo, mass media and agencies, influencers, etc.

One silly rubric I use is: could this page / app / venue have been there in 1999? If so it’s probably worth reading. If not, who knows.

(Of course there are cesspools that qualify too, like the chan world and certain subreddits, but there were cesspools in the early days of the web as well.)

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by CondensedBrain on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:00PM (#20257430)
Site searching Reddit can at least give some ideas for different words to try. Most of my problems finding things on Google stem from its declining ability to make a reasonable guess based on what I put in. It's not enough to have a word anymore. You have to know the right keyphrase or it shows a whole different world of results.

It used to show its best guess, then branch off from it with less specificity and more variety and, in general, a result reflecting what I meant within a few pages. Now Google is so desperate to get it right on result #1 that it never admits failure no matter how many pages you go.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by bash-j on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:11PM (#20259793)
When I search for free software I usually put forum in the search terms as it helps filter out the malicious sites and the software where they clearly ripped off the free software but ask for money to unlock the pro version. Plus I get to read why people recommend the software.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by outime on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:39PM (#20257240)
Not OP but yes, I’ve also been doing this for a long time and it does help.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by minitoar on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:45PM (#20257305)
Or “wiki”.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by carlob on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:28PM (#20259092)
or use duckduckgo's bangs
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by nunez on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:48PM (#20259685)
site:reddit.com; after every search!
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by avip on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:36PM (#20258508)
Try google something like "how to do X on Y" or "what's the shortcut key for A in B".

You have to crawl through piles of garbage like a racoon to find the one-liner you were looking for.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by Avamander on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:03PM (#20259747)
I have a good example for this, try googling how to make Linux ask for a password when using sudo.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by mars4rp on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:42PM (#20257273)
yes, at the beginning Google got a huge market share because they were able to return the better result and don't return spammy and unrelated results.

but they are not doing that anymore, it is really hard to find a not spammy (what you described) result on Google these days.

and other search engines are only copying the Google algorithm we need to get back to judging a web page by its content, AI should be able to help now or soon.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by graeme on Sunday June 23, 2019 @01:46PM (#20257308)
Google actively encourages the recipe sites to add the fluff.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by cylinder on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:32AM (#20261299)
Why doesn't Google disrupt itself -- the most concise, cleanest pages that focus on what the user is actually looking for (recipe, not a narrative) should be #1. It's even in Google's interest!
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday June 24, 2019 @09:48AM (#20263468)
I think their market share encourages them to do nothing. You actually have to offer a good product to grow market share, then slowly run it, then users switch to a new product which originally starts good, and the cycle repeats.

Nobody would start using Google Search in its current format.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:30AM (#20263856)
It has, and that's mentioned in the article. If you want to be #1 on the search page, buy an ad, because that will always appear above every "organic" search result.

Ads are Google's bread and butter, and has been for the entirety of its existence as a public company.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by jeffk_teh_haxor on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:41PM (#20257762)
Re: recipes, you might be interested in this browser extension, which skips to the actual recipe text:

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/recipe-filter/ahlc...

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by dagw on Monday June 24, 2019 @09:21AM (#20263279)
Google any recipe, and there are at least 5 paragraphs

I just Googled Peking duck to try something at random. Of the links on the front page, one was to wikipedia, one was to an article about Peking duck, and the rest where recipe sites (BBC Food, Allrecipes, Serious Eats etc.) or serious looking/sounding food blogs that had the recipe front and center. I don't know if it's a geographic thing (I'm in Europe) or if Google has learnt my preferences, but finding 5 reasonable sounding recipes for Peking duck with Google was trivial.

Edit: Played around some more and spotted an interesting pattern. If a look up typical US dishes, like Key lime pie or BBQ brisket, then I got results more like the ones you describe. But looking up more 'international' dishes like Peking duck or coq au vin then the results where almost all good quality recipes.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by jacques_chester on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:12PM (#20257541)
> Google any recipe, and there are at least 5 paragraphs (usually a lot more) of copy that no one will ever read, and isn't even meant for human consumption.

And here I just thought people were basically self-absorbed wankers.

My most recent impression:

"I first learned about this recipe from my dog's aunt who was a lenape indian during the pre-cambrian era and she something something memories of childhood blah blah dinosaur steaks yap yap tedious digression on gritty herbs fluff fluff and so I was talking to my local grocer who put me onto an organic vegan gluten free biomagnetic interspordidial hyperflorpic gmo-free meg-free bpa-free taste-free free-free that reminded me of the time that..."

JUST FUCKING TELL ME HOW TO COOK THE BEANS JANET

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by marcosdumay on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:45PM (#20258222)
People are lazy and mostly do not want to write a 1000 words essay around the recipe they want to share.

It takes a very unique kind of person to write those things. And those are the ones Google is giving all the voice, while taking it away from normal people.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by clairity on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:42PM (#20259664)
that really made me laugh - i'm glad i had no liquids in my mouth at the time. =)
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by wmeredith on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:38PM (#20259449)
You could always, stay with me here, pay for content. Cooks Illustrated (no affiliation) is an awesome resource for those interested in recipes that are proven without the garbage.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by ggggtez on Sunday June 23, 2019 @11:13PM (#20260175)
>Google "How to learn x"

On the other hand, if you Google "How to do X" you will often find a youtube video in the top results. But it will skip the intro and jump right to the important part.

Sure there is a lot of garbage out there (e.g. everyone uploading 10 minute videos to hit the YouTube optimzation algorithm) but it does seem like Google does try to cut through some of the SEO garbage to get you the useful info faster.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday June 24, 2019 @09:52AM (#20263508)
The fact you have to skip the intro to YouTube videos speaks to Google's algorithms. Even if people don't have ten minutes to say about a particular topic, they'll upload it.

When people find out the metrics to getting more views, they become meaningless.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by api on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:42PM (#20259197)
This starts happening the instant a medium becomes a potential source of revenue. Look at most average TV: endless repetitive nonsense plots, drama, and other filler to serve as a medium for ads.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by SantalBlush on Sunday June 23, 2019 @11:13PM (#20260174)
Don't forget video games and loot crates! Most big-budget games are just a formula to encourage kids to shell out more money.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by deogeo on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:00PM (#20259288)
Is this the internet we are warned wouldn't exist without pervasive ads and spying?
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by ajmurmann on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:06PM (#20257974)
What I don't understand is why Google doesn't hell ban these pages. It seems trivial, at least as a human, to detect them. You don't even need to do this for all of them. Just banning a few hundred will deter everyone else.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by reaperducer on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:46PM (#20259220)
What I don't understand is why Google doesn't hell ban these pages

Because Google doesn't have a financial incentive to show you quick, quality answers to you questions.

Google makes more money from you flailing around and fruitlessly searching over and over than giving you the right answer the first time.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by mindcrime on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:02PM (#20259744)
Google makes more money from you flailing around and fruitlessly searching over and over than giving you the right answer the first time.

That will work right up until the time somebody comes along and build a search engine (or other app) that will just "give you the right answer the first time."

For all their size and power, there's really nothing - in principle - stopping somebody from coming along and doing to Google, what Google did to Altavista. Yes it would be hard to execute, which may be why it hasn't happened... yet.

Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by hombre_fatal on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:05PM (#20258333)
What exactly is being hellbanned here? Any web page with an uninteresting preamble like most articles and blog posts online?
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by novia on Sunday June 23, 2019 @07:09PM (#20259325)
Spammy websites. A flag tool given to long time Google account holders would be helpful.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by Angostura on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:53PM (#20258907)
To be honest, I just tend to use one recipe site now - BBC Good Food. I ended up subscribing to the magazine since I was getting so many recipes from there. The user ratings on the recipes don't seemed to be gamed either - since there is no incentive to do so.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by cylinder on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:33AM (#20261300)
I just add "serious eats" to my searches.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by didibus on Sunday June 23, 2019 @10:25PM (#20260041)
Ya, but how do you deal with it? You're just fighting a tug of war. Unless we go hack to curated content or paid, it is always going to be algorithm against SEO in an infinite race.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by baddox on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:14PM (#20258032)
See also: most long-form journalism.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by pbourke on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:58PM (#20258612)
Long-form journalism is what it’s advertised to be, at least.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by tayo42 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:49PM (#20257814)
Recipes are really bad on Google. There are also some odd aggregator sites I guess? Or just seem to copy from other places. Idk what their story is but they have tons of low effort recipes
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by chrischen on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:52PM (#20258571)
Also superficially relevant recipes or just regurgitated content.
Re:The internet is an SEO landfill by hidiegomariani on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:58PM (#20258941)
bounce rates are supposed to demote this kind of content, even tho it doesn't seem to work properly imo