News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by pjc50 on Monday June 17, 2019 @07:35AM (#20201897)
A human paying attention assisted by a computer paying attention is always going to be safer than either separately. It's just that a mostly self-driving system erodes human attentiveness.

And we're not going to get to a system that's so much safer as to render human attention irrelevant without a much more solid and theoretically sound approach to safety engineering.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by zaroth on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:11AM (#20202529)
I find, for example, in heavy stop and go traffic my car drives safer on AutoPilot than I do manually. I can get tense or fed up with stupid drivers around me causing me to drive less than ideally, while the AutoPilot just smoothly moves along, perfectly centered in the lane, never caring if the car ahead stays stopped too long, never getting flustered from being cut off.

Switching on the AutoPilot also makes me suddenly care a lot less about optimizing for that 1/10th of a second here and there. When the car’s driving, I get there when I get there. I can just relax and the traffic matters that much less.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by aidenn0 on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:08AM (#20203084)
I do not know how safe I am in heavy stop-and-go because I completely zone out. Traffic is pretty light where I live now, but in other areas, I've had the subjective sense of falling asleep, only to "wake up" several miles down the road an hour later. That's really scary.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by clairity on Monday June 17, 2019 @03:45PM (#20206613)
stop-and-go on a freeway during the day (e.g., rush hour) is probably the safest and easiest set of real conditions for self-driving. speed is low on average and the opportunities for surprise are limited, as you likely won't meet other objects unexpectedly going much faster or slower than you.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by cardiffspaceman on Monday June 17, 2019 @04:49PM (#20207221)
What about motorcycles?

My favorite expansion of the overloaded motorists' workload is when "firemen" holding "boots" get in traffic lanes during the morning commute in order to gather donations. Is that in the model?

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by clairity on Monday June 17, 2019 @06:37PM (#20208041)
that happens for you? panhandling happens here on the on-/off-ramps, but i don't see panhandlers on the actual freeway.

in any case, i'd guess current algorithms can detect that fairly reliably in the noted conditions, since self-driving cars also trained on urban streets.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by cardiffspaceman on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:44PM (#20215028)
The collection happens in the lanes where cars are waiting for a traffic light. The result is that traffic goes through more slowly and backs up through the off ramps and on the slow lane that feeds one of the off ramps.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by m463 on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:29AM (#20209792)
> never getting flustered from being cut off.

But sometimes it would be nice to have a 0 below the 1-7 following distance setting. (sort of like going to 11)

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by dsego on Monday June 17, 2019 @07:45AM (#20201952)
As assisting systems mature, we will get humans paying less and less attention to driving. Just last night I was watching air crash investigations and there were a series of accidents on a 777 where the pilots where "expecting" the airplane do something because usually the automated system picks up the slack, well except in that particular circumstance when the accident occurred. And these are trained pilots and they understand these systems fairly well (at least when they are told about them). I don't think the general population will ever be trained or have a deep understanding of their car's assistance modes, they will expect it to work. Overall, cars will probably be safer, but we are probably going to witness freak accidents as a combination of driver inexperience and software bugs.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by nradov on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:55AM (#20203594)
You're probably thinking of a different airplane? The Boeing 777 is pretty much the safest airliner and hasn't had any "series of accidents".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777#Accidents_and_incid...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by dsego on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:29PM (#20204608)
Maybe not a series on that same type. The crash investigation was about a pilot moving from an airbus to boeing, and it was a 777. The plane did what it was supposed to but the captain didn't know what he was doing. It was on an approach to SF and several people died, someone got run over by a fire truck. The series of accidents mentioned was probably attributable to pilots vs automation and not only to that particular plane model.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by hodgesrm on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:03PM (#20207365)
You are thinking of Asiana Flight 214. Pilot error was the main cause of the accident though there were contributing causes like auto-pilot documentation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asiana_Airlines_Flight_214

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by pishpash on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:27AM (#20202670)
Not even true in theory. A human and a computer can disagree and be less safe.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by lowlevel on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:55PM (#20207768)
Exactly why I turn off all assist systems in our vw. I can't tell you how many times it misread the lines and nudged my steering into oncoming traffic. Eventually everyone will realize this stuff is just a bad idea.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by m463 on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:25AM (#20209776)
I think it would be nice to have a heads-up display (or other status system) that shows what the AI is seeing. That way it would actually be "assist".
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by melling on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:03AM (#20202044)
No, it isn’t.

Perhaps in the short-term, but if you listen to Elon Musk compare it to like having elevator operators, it makes sense that computers will eventually do a much better job and humans will only introduce problems.

https://www.zdnet.com/article/elon-musk-on-teslas-autopilot-...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by lm28469 on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:10AM (#20202085)
> if you listen to Elon Musk

If you listen to Elon Musk we have fully autonomous cars every 2 years since 2015 and we'll have Mars cities in 2050.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by anchpop on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:11AM (#20202533)
A couple Mars colonies in 30 years doesn't really sound that optimistic to me
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by lm28469 on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:06AM (#20203066)
It's insanely optimistic by every single metrics I can come up with. The only way I'd buy it would be to redefine "colonies" and "cities" as "10 guys in a 50 sq meters rigid tent who need constant supplies from earth and are 1 mistake away from death" aka the space station but on the ground.

He's very good at PR moves, but sending a rocket to space and getting it back in one piece, which is very impressive, is nothing compared to actually going to mars, which itself is nothing compared to building a city on a planet where everything is opposed to human life.

Tesla and Space X have a very high "hype factor", and sure they're probably the best at what they're doing, but he is insanely overselling it. Look at that timeline: https://www.inverse.com/article/51291-spacex-here-s-the-time...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by pjc50 on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:19AM (#20202603)
How many moon colonies did we have 30 years after the moon landings?
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by melling on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:34AM (#20202731)
None, because we didn’t want to spend the money.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by neuronic on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:04AM (#20203044)
If you look at what APOLLO has cost back in those days maybe then you'd understand why we didn't.

Landing a few people and picking up a few rocks and taking a few selfies cost, inflation-adjusted for 2019, a whopping $288.1 billion [1].

This money was spent to "stick it to the communists" because they were winning at the space race (first man in space, etc...). We just happened to get a bunch of benefits along the way.

The several more hundred billion that would have followed if we decided to build entire colonies - with a multitude of massive problems still not figured out today - would have been a hard sell over the decades it would have taken to construct.

I mean just look at operating cost of MIR and ISS and that's in LEO...

[1] http://www.planetary.org/blogs/casey-dreier/2019/reconstruct...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by melling on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:58AM (#20203620)
Sure, I absolutely do understand the cost. You picked the largest estimate?

Because there are many different numbers:

http://www.thespacereview.com/article/1579/1

https://www.quora.com/How-much-did-the-Moon-Mission-cost

The point is that it’s a matter of cost, and not a technical problem. The Apollo program was a “rush job” done in 10 years. Much of the technology had to be invented.

There an interesting BBC podcast called 13 Minutes to the Moon for anyone interested in finding out more about the Apollo program:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w13xttx2

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by smileysteve on Monday June 17, 2019 @07:52PM (#20208478)
> If you look at what APOLLO has cost > inflation-adjusted for 2019, a whopping $288.1 billion

When I was reading that, I was expecting a much higher number than the one I ended up reading.

That's < the cash Apple has on hand, approximately as much revenue as they make a year.

That's 1/2 of the annual U.S. military budget.

It's 1/3 of a small portion of the 2008 bailout.

===

If you annualize that by the 10 years it was spent in, the only discretionary funding significantly less than that is Food and Agriculture.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by neuronic on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @09:27AM (#20223110)
This is not the most money a nation has ever spent on any singular object. I am not saying that. I also firmly believe that it was worth it!

But the difficulty is in

a) allocating this money b) convincing the public that removing this money from, say education, is a good strategy

A good chunk of people seriously require heat warnings on their hot coffee to realize that their coffee is hot. I don't hold high hopes in making a voting majority of people understand long-term global benefits.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by UncleMeat on Monday June 17, 2019 @07:56PM (#20208510)
Is there any evidence that people want to spend the money for mars colonies?
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by D-Coder on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @01:12AM (#20209965)
<raises hand>
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Infernal on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @12:08AM (#20209709)
For that matter, how many moon landings did we have 30 years after the moon landings...
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by close04 on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:08AM (#20202071)
Depends what you consider short term. Do you expect autonomous cars to get to human level in all conditions in the next 5 years? 10? 25?

Most likely computers will become far better than humans at some point. But it may be far enough in the future that it doesn’t really contradict the point made above. Contrary to popular belief, “640K should be enough” isn’t the kind of statement meant to cover all eternity.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:34AM (#20202221)
"A human paying attention assisted by a computer paying attention is always going to be safer than either separately."

No. Stating something as a fact without analyzing it in the slightest is bad.

Example:

(1) Only a computer is "paying attention" performing the "assisted emergency breaking" role. The computer has an effective reaction time of 1/100 of a second. Within 2/100 of a second of a qualifying event, the vehicle will be in full antilock brake mode.

(2) A human and a computer are "paying attention" performing the "assisted emergency breaking" role (this is a little silly in that the human is already the primary brake operator...). The computer still has 1/100 s reaction time, but the human's reaction time is 25/100 s. What exactly is the human bringing to the table? It is true that the human may detect an actual threat the computer doesn't...however that slow reaction time means it likely won't make a difference in the outcome. On the other hand, the human may "detect" a false alarm, and emergency brake by mistake. That activity often leads to wrecks!

I submit that the computer-only emergency brake assist is safer than the combination of human and computer. Further, all of these "human in the loop" systems suffer from a fatal flaw - the inability of people to pay attention unless it's absolutely crucial.

The way people use Tesla Autopilot shows that full autonomy is necessary, and will in fact be safer than any "assisted" system.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by radcon on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:54AM (#20202393)
> I submit that the computer-only emergency brake assist is safer than the combination of human and computer

You're choosing to ignore the fact that computers still make mistakes.

My friend's car (an Acura) recently slammed on the brakes @ 70mph because it mistakenly thought a car in an adjacent lane was in his lane. Had there been someone following close behind him, it probably would've caused an accident.

This is not an uncommon occurrence, especially with Honda/Acura's system. You can find tons of complaints online about AEB systems reacting to false positives.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:20AM (#20203196)
"You're choosing to ignore the fact that computers still make mistakes."

No, but I'll unequivocally assert that the human false alarm rate is much higher than that of computers.

"My friend's car (an Acura) recently slammed on the brakes @ 70mph because it mistakenly thought a car in an adjacent lane was in his lane. Had there been someone following close behind him, it probably would've caused an accident."

Does it have a readout indicating what it "thought"?

It seems possible that the car in the other lane drifted, and the computer thought it was changing lanes into the Acura. Braking was appropriate in that circumstance.

"This is not an uncommon occurrence, especially with Honda/Acura's system. You can find tons of complaints online about AEB systems reacting to false positives."

That may be, and I suspect a fix will be forthcoming which will address every Honda/Acura on the road (or new models, worst case).

Meanwhile, humans will continue to look down at a text, hamburger, or whatever, and then panic when a few seconds later they look up and think they're in trouble. Not to mention driving tired, drunk, high, angry, or stupid.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:39AM (#20203423)
BTW, I did mean to make one more point regarding:

"Had there been someone following close behind him, it probably would've caused an accident."

And of course the person running into the braking vehicle would have been at fault. In most cases, only assisted emergency braking would help, since most people follow way too close on the freeway - human reaction time isn't fast enough.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by FabHK on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:43AM (#20202302)
Presumably, GP means as a whole, confronted with the entire array of challenges, not for a single simple task at which the computer happens to be unambiguously better.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by tomatocracy on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:43AM (#20202304)
The human can often predict that some type of avoidance will be needed several seconds earlier in a way that computers can't at the moment and thus avert the need for emergency braking entirely.

The two can, and should, be complementary.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:18AM (#20202587)
"The human can often predict that some type of avoidance will be needed several seconds earlier in a way that computers can't at the moment and thus avert the need for emergency braking entirely.

The two can, and should, be complementary."

What you're saying is true, but doesn't fall under the purview of "assisted emergency braking".

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by notahacker on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:45AM (#20202840)
But AEB as a fallback for when humans fail to anticipate the hazard well enough to avoid the need for emergency braking altogether falls very much under the purview of the OP's statement that "a human paying attention assisted by a computer paying attention" is the safest option.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:09AM (#20203719)
Sure, but that isn't the discussion at hand. That's overall autonomous driving, and in that case, the computer would ideally be anticipating hazards like a human would - only better.

You know, not driving tired, drunk, high, angry, or stupid...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by vageli on Monday June 17, 2019 @08:49AM (#20202351)
> "A human paying attention assisted by a computer paying attention is always going to be safer than either separately."

> No. Stating something as a fact without analyzing it in the slightest is bad.

> Example:

> (1) Only a computer is "paying attention" performing the "assisted emergency breaking" role. The computer has an effective reaction time of 1/100 of a second. Within 2/100 of a second of a qualifying event, the vehicle will be in full antilock brake mode.

> (2) A human and a computer are "paying attention" performing the "assisted emergency breaking" role (this is a little silly in that the human is already the primary brake operator...). The computer still has 1/100 s reaction time, but the human's reaction time is 25/100 s. What exactly is the human bringing to the table? It is true that the human may detect an actual threat the computer doesn't...however that slow reaction time means it likely won't make a difference in the outcome. On the other hand, the human may "detect" a false alarm, and emergency brake by mistake. That activity often leads to wrecks!

> I submit that the computer-only emergency brake assist is safer than the combination of human and computer. Further, all of these "human in the loop" systems suffer from a fatal flaw - the inability of people to pay attention unless it's absolutely crucial.

> The way people use Tesla Autopilot shows that full autonomy is necessary, and will in fact be safer than any "assisted" system.

I think your example is uncharitable because you allow for a human to react to a false alarm in the second but don't account for a computer to react similarly in the first. Personally speaking, I have seen very few occasions of people exercising extreme braking wrongly. I feel computers would be less apt at discerning from a false positive than a human operator with even a little experience behind the wheel.

Given that autonomous cars can be misled by painting roadways certain ways [0], it's clear to me that the number of unknown unknowns that must be handled by a car are large in number, and I have less faith in the skillful handling of those events by a computer than a human.

[0]: https://nerdist.com/article/trap-a-self-driving-car/

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by melkiaur on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:07AM (#20203078)
> What exactly is the human bringing to the table?

He can see the big truck 200 yards in front of him, and recognize that it is indeed a truck, and not an overhead traffic sign. Apparently, Teslas don't bring that to the table.

Alternatively, the human could recognize that the truck is on fire and smoking, and that it would be a good idea to stay away from it.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by pjc50 on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:17AM (#20202584)
> The computer has an effective reaction time of 1/100 of a second.

.. to objects that it can identify as a hazard. We've already seen incidents where it fails to spot hazards such as cyclists and crash barriers, due to limitations such as having to filter out stationary objects from radar returns.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:19AM (#20202597)
".. to objects that it can identify as a hazard. We've already seen incidents where it fails to spot hazards such as cyclists and crash barriers, due to limitations such as having to filter out stationary objects from radar returns."

Really? I've seen no such reports with regard to assisted emergency braking systems. Please cite a reference.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by pjc50 on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:22AM (#20202624)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19932918

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19802284

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17257239 "These vehicles will run into stationary obstacles at full speed with no warning or emergency braking at all."

Anyway, the point was a general one - the computer hazard identification is very far from perfect at the moment, and benefits from a human spotting hazards that the automated system does not.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:22AM (#20203221)
Those reports were WRT full autonomous driving - not "assisted emergency braking".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_brake_assist

I see no mention of problems on the Wikipedia page. Do you know of any?

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by alistairSH on Monday June 17, 2019 @09:38AM (#20202776)
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:23AM (#20203226)
See above response.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by alistairSH on Monday June 17, 2019 @10:28AM (#20203291)
Emergency braking is part of autonomous driving, so ...?

Anyways, my VW has assisted emergency braking. I've had opposite issues - water splashes across sensor and the car brakes for no good reason. Generally going through a large shallow puddle and moderate speed. Happened 2 or 3 times and now I disable when driving near the beach after rain.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:24AM (#20203866)
"Emergency braking is part of autonomous driving, so ...?"

So, the Tesla issues involved not identifying objects in the field of regard correctly, and thus not steering appropriately. Brake systems weren't involved in either crash, IIRC.

Assisted emergency braking is much more narrowly focused than full autonomous driving. It doesn't care what the object is, if it's solid, in front of the vehicle, and in it's path, the system will brake. These days it potentially has vision, sonar, lidar and radar to provide sensory input. That's a whole lot more information than a human can access.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by alistairSH on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:02PM (#20204334)
I have no idea if the appropriate reaction in these cases would have been braking, steering, or some combination. Regardless, current autonomous vehicle systems (whether they claim to be full auto-pilot or just emergency braking assist or lane-keeping) have some pretty massive blind-spots.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:12AM (#20203741)
"Anyways, my VW has assisted emergency braking. I've had opposite issues - water splashes across sensor and the car brakes for no good reason. Generally going through a large shallow puddle and moderate speed. Happened 2 or 3 times and now I disable when driving near the beach after rain."

Your "issue" is essentially the system being extra safe - similar to slowing down when a bunch of water hits your windshield. Seems highly appropriate to me.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by alistairSH on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:00PM (#20204309)
Except it's a full-on emergency brake reaction and liable to get me rear-ended. Per the initial discussion, there are places (and this is one) where a human is still MUCH better at assessing the situation and acting appropriately.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Problem: Safer Human-Driven Ones by Recurecur on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @03:29AM (#20210444)
"Per the initial discussion, there are places (and this is one) where a human is still MUCH better at assessing the situation and acting appropriately."

You've done nothing to support that assertion. "MUCH better at assessing the situation and acting appropriately" doesn't compensate for 10x slower reaction time. Nor does it account for the high percentage of time that humans are paying attention to something besides driving. Machine systems don't get distracted, at least.

We'll agree to disagree, but anticipate fully autonomous cars sooner rather than later. ;-)