News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by prmph on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:51AM (#20103822)
I have never understood is why there is no security around the pickup of bags on arrival. What prevents someone from simply picking up my bag from the carousel, knowing that it's not theirs, and walking off?

Or are airplane passengers invariably saints, so that this never happens?

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by hjk05 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:33AM (#20104140)
Most the time the fact that you are stranding there right next to the belt waiting. It’s a extreme high risk crime with little reward and no way for the criminal to make sure what they’ll get. They’d have a more profitable time trying to pick wallets from people waiting for their baggage.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by toper-centage on Thursday June 06, 2019 @09:17AM (#20114236)
Pick any discreet bag up, and if the owner comes after you, say oops my bad. Not that hard.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by Plyphon_ on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:01AM (#20103900)
Because overwhelmingly bags are full of clothes and cosmetics. The majority of which will be already used in some capacity.

Even the most opportunist thief probably doesn't want someone elses old clothes and half empty tins of hair product.

Even worse if it's a return flight - that means the clothes are dirty!

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by andyjohnson0 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:27AM (#20104087)
I've wondered this too. Maybe because almost all the people who have access to the carousel area are passengers with luggage. So any potential thief could also be the potential victim of theft - and in some game-theoretic way it is therefore most advantageous for everyone to be honest. Analogous to a Nash equilibrium?

Same reason why theft from tents on campsites is not (in my experience) so prevalent. Tents are vulnerable to burglary but most of the potential burglars are other campers and are therefore also vulnerable.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by mhb on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:01AM (#20103897)
It seems like the answer to this would be the same as the answer to the other question.

The laissez faire baggage claim is refreshingly delightful in contrast to the hell that every other aspect of air travel has become though.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by kijeda on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:09AM (#20103953)
Baggage claim in most airports around the world is behind some kind of one way exit point so you need to have been a traveller on a flight to get access to the baggage carousel.

It is also not uncommon in places where petty theft is high for you to have to show your baggage receipt matches the baggage tag before you can take it from the baggage handling area.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by dajohnson89 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:18PM (#20109717)
I had to this at SDQ (Santo Domingo). I was pleasantly surprised.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by enjo on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:20AM (#20104021)
This isn’t true of any airport I can think of... and I travel (across the world) quite frequently.

The exception is baggage claims for international flights which are usually in a secure area due to the need to pass through customs.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by hjk05 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:34AM (#20104147)
This is true of literally every single airport i’ve ever traveled through. I guess experiences vary greatly.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by arkades on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:13PM (#20108644)
This would be a more useful discussion if both of you just named the relevant airports.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by gambiting on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:45PM (#20109498)
Where were those airports out of curiosity? I've flown hundreds of times in my life, airports across Europe, and I have never ever seen this.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by matchbok on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:16PM (#20108669)
Every airport in the US I've been to...
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by wahern on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:22PM (#20110094)
I've been to almost every major airport, and several regional ones, in the continental United States and I can't remember a single baggage claim area for domestic flights that wasn't open to the public. Just this past weekend: Boston and San Francisco, both open to the public.

My favorite airport was Long Beach; it's been ~9 years, but last time I flew in the baggage claim conveyor belt was literally outside at the curb. (And this is why that place rocked. The expansion has likely since ruined all the little conveniences of LGB.)

Once upon a time some baggage areas had security which would spot-check claim tickets before you could leave the baggage area. That was mostly pre-9/11, though, when checking in your bags could be easier than leaving with them. Some major airports have [now] uselessly annoying barriers to baggage claim areas for that purpose.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by sliken on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:28PM (#20110756)
PIT is open as well. Generally wherever I fly is someone is meeting me they meet me at the luggage claim.

Not sure how it could be any other way. After all you can pack weapons in checked bags, so once you are at checked baggage you are already beyond the security perimeter.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by ramblerman on Thursday June 06, 2019 @03:48AM (#20112417)
> not sure how it could be any other way.

Use one way doors like pretty much any airport in Europe. Once you go to baggage you can’t go back to the main airport. But you are still not in a public area.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by sliken on Thursday June 06, 2019 @04:15AM (#20112541)
Sure, that's common here as well. But with 1000s of people an hour leaving it's easy to walk in an out door.

Are they enforced with guards blocking people from coming in the exits?

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by tjohns on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:40PM (#20107017)
Sometimes there is. I've had security check my claim tag before exiting the carousel area at LAX before. But that's certainly not the norm, even at LAX.

I suspect it's risk based. If they have reason to suspect there's ongoing theft, then they add additional layers of security.

Outside of that... theft would be extremely risky. There's a good chance the owner is already at the carousel somewhere watching their bag come out, and there's cameras everywhere.

Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by showdead on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:37PM (#20108870)
Nothing. It made the news in 2009 in Phoenix: http://bobarno.com/thiefhunters/airport-luggage-theft/
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by snarf21 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:20AM (#20104020)
In some airports they do. I was in Atlanta last month, and a representative was checking bags against ID as everyone picked up their bag. I'm sure it is a function of the frequency of things getting stolen.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by madcaptenor on Thursday June 06, 2019 @03:58PM (#20118457)
I've never seen this on maybe a few dozen flights into Atlanta.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by nkrisc on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:59AM (#20103882)
Perhaps there very little to gain. Airport security can ask you at any time to see the corresponding stub for your baggage tag. So you want to steal a bag, what are you risking it for? Some clothes?
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by dmitriid on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:57AM (#20103862)
It happens on such a small scale that security isn’t needed
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by Tor3 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:23AM (#20104043)
There is, however, a non-zero risk for losing your handluggage or purse while waiting for your checked-in luggage. I know one fairly large (for European standards) airport where, for some reason, pickpockets (or what to call them) are able to get into the (closed) baggage area, and you have to keep an eye on your belongings at all times.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by gowld on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:25AM (#20105355)
Why doesn't the TSA apply that theory to flight security?
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by wahern on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:41PM (#20110190)
Because like nuclear power people (writ large) have an especially irrational fear of flying; they demand crippling levels of security theatre. Terrorists understand this, too.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by jon-wood on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:52PM (#20108443)
Many people have pointed out that to get there you need to have flown in (probably losing money on the deal). Another, probably much smaller factor, is that there’s a non-zero chance that you grabbed the bag of someone bringing contraband in - at which point you’re going through airport security with a choice of saying the bag is yours and being arrested, or saying you stole it and being arrested. There are just much easier ways for a thief to make a living.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by stronglikedan on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:16PM (#20108675)
I cannot recall ever arriving at an airport where any local couldn't have walked in the arrival exit, grabbed a bag off the belt, and walked out without passing any type of security whatsoever. Aren't the belts usually right by the exits? I mean, perhaps security is watching for that type of activity via cameras, but I've never seen a checkpoint to get out after getting my bags.
Re:Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year? by sithadmin on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:28PM (#20108783)
In the US, if you're arriving from an international flight, then baggage claim will be before you clear a final CBP and customs checkpoint.

For domestic flights in the US, yes, generally anybody can just waltz up and take a bag if they wished.