News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by gnode on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:06AM (#20102858)
> bill-payers will give price support to the Hinkley Point C nuclear station at a cost of £92.50 per megawatt hour, compared with £55 for offshore wind.

Something ignored here, is that electricity generation is not fungible. Wind power is not reliable, but nuclear is. Nuclear power is really the only practical solution for the UK to eliminate fossil fuel use from electricity generation, around the clock; we don't have the geography for adequate hydro.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by pjc50 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:12AM (#20102882)
People keep arguing this, but it is now really too late. Nuclear power is too slow to build, has trouble with suitable sites (need to be away from populated areas but near water). If we started planning a new power station now it wouldn't be online until about 2030. The intermediate strategy of "overprovision wind and fill the remaining need with CCGT" is actually working pretty well. Hopefully people can start talking about battery storage, or some other modular deployable solution.

(Cost is another issue, but it seems the parties are happy enough to spend $100bn on a nuclear weapons system that we hope never to use)

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by dabeeeenster on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:24AM (#20102935)
Tend to agree. The window for nuclear is closing now. We should be doing a fuckton of R+D into energy storage solutions, and overprovisioning offshore wind.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:55AM (#20103078)
To substitute a single 4GWe nuclear plant, one would need ~96 GWh storage, which there is no technology for, plus ~48GW wind farm, while UK has ~22GW installed total now..

And you talk of overprovisioning. Crazy.

If anything, we must invest into making nuclear cheaper.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by pjc50 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:12AM (#20103165)
The UK 's largest current nuclear plants are 1.3GW, which makes the 4GW number look unrealistic. I'm not sure where you got the worst case capacity factor numbers from either.

> invest into making nuclear cheaper

People have been talking about this since the 1950s. How much will it cost and how long will it take?

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:43PM (#20109875)
4GWe is a stock design for a PWR nuclear power station, 4 reactors of 1GWe each, sharing the infrastructure.

UK lagged behind the times, yes. Doesn't mean it shouldn't catch up skipping ye olde misdesigns.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by imtringued on Thursday June 06, 2019 @03:47AM (#20112408)
I don't understand this "which there is no technology for" argument. There is no shortage of energy storage technologies. We have battery storage, we have hydro storage, we have thermal storage, we have hydrogen storage, we have hydraulic hydro storage. We have enough options from the MWh range to the TWh range. Some technologies have pretty crazy scalability. Hydraulic hdyro storage capacity grows faster than the radius^4 but the costs only go up by r^2.

I also don't get where you have youe numbers from. Wind power generally has a 60% capacity factor therefore replacing a 4GW nuclear plant requires 6.6GW of wind power.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by cygx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:17AM (#20103200)
Given these numbers, how was it possible for Germany to cut nuclear energy production from 156TWh in 2002 to 72TWh in 2018? (source: https://www.energy-charts.de/energy.htm?source=all-sources&p...)
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by XorNot on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:27AM (#20103285)
They buy their baseload from France, which at this point has one of the most vibrant nuclear industries in the world (and no surprise, fought hard to make sure ITER was on French territory).
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:15PM (#20106699)
" The French government just announced a plan to power 95 percent of the country with solar and wind energy by 2060. And by doing so, the government would spend about $44.5 billion (39 billion euros) less than it would if it maintained its current energy infrastructure.

To get there, the government would need to cancel plans to construct 15 new nuclear power plants, and instead replace its aging nuclear reactors with renewable infrastructure over the next several decades, according to a new report published Monday by the French environmental agency."

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:16PM (#20110065)
That'll result in humanitarian aid being sent to France.

I hope it's just political bullshit.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by cygx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:40AM (#20103346)
In 2018, Germany imported 10TWh of electricity from France, while it produced 545TWh. That's not even 2% - how are you supposed to cover baseload with that?
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by pjc50 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:13AM (#20103563)
A lot of people seem to be saying "baseload" when they mean "peak". That's the benefit of the international links - countries not having their peak consumption at the same time of day can average it out between each other.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:18PM (#20110077)
Can't send power over thousands of kilometers without losing half of it, sorry. Not to mention oceans.

It is just not happening.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by macspoofing on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:36AM (#20104169)
That's the problem with solar and wind. During peak times you get very good generation capacity and nothing or too little off-peak.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by imtringued on Thursday June 06, 2019 @03:33AM (#20112342)
You must be pretty naive if you think an industrial giant like Germany can just import energy from another country. The answer is that Germany has 24GW of load following gas plants that sit idle 90% of the time.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by macspoofing on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:35AM (#20104159)
Did you not notice that Germany signed multi-decade/multi-billion dollar deals with Russia for their natural gas.

As Germany scaled up their solar and wind infrastructure they NECESSARILY also scaled up their use of natural gas and also supplemented high demand with imported coal and nuclear power from their neighbours. There is no such thing as a solar/wind deployment without natural gas. Natural gas providers are now one of the biggest lobby group for solar and wind.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by cygx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:09AM (#20104496)
Germany did scale up its natural gas usage - from 40TWh in 2002 to 44 TWh in 2018. That's a rounding error. In 2016, gas consumption in Germany was about industrial (38%) and domestic homes usage (31%), not electricity production (15%).

It may very well be that gas is going to play a major role in replacing coal, but that has yet to happen - while nuclear energy has already been cut back significantly.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:47AM (#20103387)
Germany decided to focus on cutting nuclear instead of cutting coal.

This is not an example to follow, really.

In the current situation, getting rid of coal and fossil fuels should have higher priority than getting rid of nuclear purely for ideological reasons...

Your argument is also misleading: Of course use of nuclear power can be reduced by increasing use of renewables. But the important point is that renewables cannot replace nuclear.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by cygx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:05AM (#20103507)
Doesn't matter for the argument under discussion. If you look at the numbers, you'll see that Germany did reduce coal energy by 48TWh, which was essentially offset by increased biomass capabilities and some natural gas. So focussing on nuclear, you're left with a decrease by 84TWh offset by an increase of Wind energy by 95TWh and Solar by 46 TWh.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by macspoofing on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:51AM (#20104296)
>by increased biomass capabilities and some natural gas.

Some natural gas? Some? You think those pipelines from Russia are there to only provide 'SOME' natural gas?? Nord Stream has an annual capacity of 55 billion cubic meters. Nord Stream 2 will double that to 110 billion cubic meters. Those are huge, politically sensitive, projects. And those aren't the only planned natural gas pipelines.

Second, biomass really sucks as the fuel of the future. It is environmentally destructive due to the land-use requirements. It's also expensive. It may be carbon neutral (depends if you burn dedicated crops or if you burn waste). Regardless, it's crazy that people would be pushing this as a fuel of the future just so they can get nuclear power off the table.

There is only one answer to cutting C02 emissions, and that's nuclear. We've already lost 50 years because we haven't internalized that fact, and we'll continue to lose time until we do.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by cygx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:21AM (#20104629)
Yes, 'some'. Specifically, 4.44TWh.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by detritus on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:09AM (#20103150)
Hi, do you have any sources for your calculations - I'm not challenging you, I'm simply interested to know more about the realities of trying to go non-carbon (especially when we're looking to electrify our transport network down the line..).

Thanks for any pointers!

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:57PM (#20109959)
I'm afraid you'd have to research this youself, if you wish to really understand.

Current designs of PWR reactors are about 1000-1200 MWe, constant, and not really throttable. This makes them the best baseline supply one can wish for, for a comparably meager investment once the idiotic regulation premium is subtracted.

If we had bulk energy storage it would have been so much cheaper to just pump it with electricity from nukes than that from wind or solar.

Since we don't have the storage tech, the question is moot.

Wind or solar is useless for the grid, period.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ncmncm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:14PM (#20110691)
> Wind or solar is useless for the grid, period.

That must come as an awful shock to everyone already driving their grid with increasing fractions of wind and solar.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Thursday June 06, 2019 @07:49AM (#20113575)
And it does come as such.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ncmncm on Friday June 07, 2019 @12:57AM (#20121762)
Very gradually, evidently.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Friday June 07, 2019 @08:33PM (#20129802)
A comfy, nice, slowly creeping death of a grid might be preferrable to some.

Problem is, when the grid fails it's not like you can throttle down the load. Too late for that. It just goes out.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ncmncm on Sunday June 09, 2019 @08:36PM (#20142893)
Curiously, with all the grids taking wind and solar power, this has not happened. It's almost as if the operators of power grids have engineers on staff who have figured out how to keep them up, and do.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @06:57PM (#20170204)
Yeah, well. Engineering keeps figuring out how to keep reliance on solar/wind low enough so as for the blackouts to not happen.

It's engineering, you know. Keeping politics from breaking things. Keeps getting harder to do though.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by Retric on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:07AM (#20103144)
Wind is variable but it never has zero output days. Further in many cases you can select peak output periods based on specific sites local conditions.

On top of this you can massively over provision and still be cheaper than nuclear.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lstodd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:47PM (#20109897)
It has zero output days. If only because storms can blow off the blades if you don't feather them.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by Retric on Thursday June 06, 2019 @05:52AM (#20112992)
England does not get 24 hour wind speeds of 55mph (a common wind turbine cut out speed).

Specific locations can get close to that, but as a system some areas are getting lower wind speeds and generating lots of power.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ncmncm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:44PM (#20110521)
Certain places have zero days. But not the same day as all the neighbors.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by gnode on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:16AM (#20103196)
> We should be doing a fuckton of R+D into energy storage solutions

I agree that we should research energy storage, but there's no guarantee such research would be very fruitful. I don't think it's sensible to double down on the CCGT stopgap, and put our faith in technological breakthroughs. Nuclear fission is a technology which exists now, and we should invest in before the window closes.

That said, I can't see it happening in the UK because our politics are a dumpster fire.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ncmncm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:58PM (#20110593)
Storage is just an engineering problem. It doesn't need breakthroughs, just development. And every system invented can be used at the same time, somewhere. The most cost-effective ones will spread.

Underground air pressurization is low tech, and can drive existing gas turbines, with or without added methane.

Catalytic production of ammonia from water and air is advancing by leaps and bounds, mostly enabling increasingly smaller synthesis systems. Ammonia is directly useful as industrial feedstock, liquid fuel, and fertilizer, once power storage reserve is met. Again, compatible with gas turbines. (A practical use for the waste oxygen would be helpful.)

Ammonia is excellent because it is directly useful at the sites of wind turbines at remote farms, avoiding need for connection to an electric grid. It can be injected directly into the soil for fertilizer, and used to power existing machinery -- trucks, tractors. Intermittent production, there, is no handicap. Excess can be sold to neighbors.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by jonatron on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:01AM (#20103118)
Instead, diesel generator sites have sprung up eg: http://www.plutuspowergen.com/current-operations/gallery/ This proves that if grid scale energy storage was cost effective, it'd be built. There's also the demand side of the equation, maybe storage heaters will make a come back if they're activated on live pricing rather than a night timer.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by pjc50 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:06AM (#20104468)
That's an interesting read. http://www.plutuspowergen.com/about/sustainability/

> "Plutus PowerGen’s facilities are anticipated to run for no more than 150 hours per year in 60 minute blocks of time during peak demand and may not exceed 300 hours as a result of the commitments made in the planning permission process. Despite providing valuable generating capacity, each facility is expected to be switched off for more than 97% of the time, ensuring that their annualised emissions are minimal. The Company’s facilities will conform to all UK and EU air quality standards The generators will be fired with either green fuel from HVO (hydrogenated vegetable oil) or gas."

A set of "backup" generators run for 3% of the year on vegetable oil is hardly a big carbon emitter. It's an expensive problem - no matter what the grid setup is, someone's got to be the generator of last resort which gets hardly ever used.

This is exactly the kind of market that a Tesla battery got deployed into in Australia.

http://www.plutuspowergen.com/current-operations/business-mo... is an interesting read too.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by nickik on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:20AM (#20103221)
Its insane to say nuclear window is closed. In 100 years people will for sure use nuclear and not wind and solar. It would be insane not to. The efficency fuel and land usage is so much more efficent, its an engeneering and regulatory problem right now, not a fundamental problem.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by gnode on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:38AM (#20103733)
I don't think it can be sensibly argued that nuclear is more fuel efficient than wind and solar, which have no fuel as such). Although future nuclear technology (breeder reactors, seawater uranium extraction, fusion) makes fuel hugely abundant, and essentially a non-issue, comparable with renewables.

Engineering and regulatory costs won't necessarily come down over time. As use of nuclear power wanes, costs will likely go up, the positive feedback reinforcing the trend.

In 100 years time, fusion may be developed, but we may have seen peak fission already.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by nickik on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:24AM (#20104673)
Wind and solar don't have fuel, but the conversion is bad and the resources is distributed and hard to capture.

> Engineering and regulatory costs won't necessarily come down over time. As use of nuclear power wanes, costs will likely go up, the positive feedback reinforcing the trend.

Why would they not come down? In most technology we use it does come down. Nuclear is really the exeption where normal development has not happened.

Regulatory costs are comming down right now already. The US has started a wide range of reforms to address this problem. The US is going from essentially impossible to regulate a new reactor to only very expensive. Interestingly nuclear went from both parties being against, to both parties being for and 3-4 nuclear reform bills have gone threw congress with little issue. Its suprising to say the least. Its still baby steps but at least its not continued political deadlock.

Canada is doing much better and there is actually now feasable to go threw the regulatory process again. This has lead many US and British companies to move to Canada.

This should allow now reactor types comming to market in the next 10 years and those be much smaller in scale then PWRs and thus have very much smaller capital costs, thus building them should be cheaper.

None no of that is a certainty but its also not crazy either.

> In 100 years time, fusion may be developed, but we may have seen peak fission already.

Fission is 10^12 more dense then chemical energy, Fusion is about 10^15. The difference there is not all that relevant specially not as a society already ignore the 10^12 difference.

Most Fusion don't really add much, other then maybe being better at nuclear proliferation but that is not really a hugly practical problem with fission specially in the western world.

Solar and wind have to replaced fairly often, and once first generation installations must get replaced, and cheap nuclear is available, the situation might reverse itself.

That said, in certain places it will be hard to beat these but there many places where they are not optimal and there is still the intermitency question. Many GenIV nuclear plants can be perfectly perfectly load following or can be connected to utility scale heat storages.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by AmericanChopper on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:26AM (#20103273)
What’s wrong with new nuclear power coming into service on 10 years? Is it because we’re 10 years away from climate disaster? Because people have been saying that since the 70s. If that’s the only obstacle to some long term thinking then I can’t see what the problem is.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by Grue3 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:07AM (#20103934)
>need to be away from populated areas but near water

There should be no problems with such sites in the UK. There are a lot of sparcely populated coastal areas in the north or even in Wales.

>If we started planning a new power station now it wouldn't be online until about 2030.

What's with this desire for instant gratification? The world won't end in 2030. Even if you get a single plant running by then, it would be a great help. Not starting now is just an excuse.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by nickik on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:17AM (#20103203)
You can get pretty cheap nuclear plants from South Korea or even advanced pebble reactors from China. Those don't take as long to build, the west is just to proud to do this.

You can also plan to use modern reactors for the next 30, mutlibe companies, including British Company are already in the regulatory process in Canada (and they went their because British nuclear regulation were so backwards).

Both options would be cheaper then building some costum plant based on old tech.

That said, if they are willing to build modern gas plants with wind, that's actually one of the better options.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by daniel-cussen on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:13PM (#20109212)
I remember Leo Szilard complaining the first nuclear power plant took 18 months and later they took 12 years, as if that was an improvement.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by macspoofing on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:55AM (#20103081)
>but it is now really too late.

Then the only alternative is natural gas supplemented by solar. No battery technology is forthcoming.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by douglasfshearer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:36AM (#20102993)
CCGT - Combined Cycle Gas Turbine

FYI

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:28AM (#20102952)
There are/were several new nuclear power stations planned.

The issue is that government policy is that they should be funded by the private sector (and that the UK is no longer able to build a nuclear power station by itself).

No-one in the private sector can do that, as we've seen.

For Hinkley C, EDF could not (and the French government did not want to finance). For another power station Toshiba recently gave up and took a serious financial hit because it was just too much [0].

The only ones willing to throw money at this to build those nuclear plants are the Chinese, which EDF already called in to partly finance Hinkley C, but then everyone goes ballistic about "handing over our electricity supply to the Chinese Communist Party".

Considering that the UK developed and built the first civilian nuclear plant this is (yet another) monumental lack of strategic vision and huge waste.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/nov/08/toshiba-...

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by wongarsu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:37AM (#20103330)
Even if you have the money and are not concerned about the time to break even, nuclear seems like a terrible investment.

Let's ignore subsidies for a moment. Also lets assume I can have the plant operational in 10 years (very optimistic unless I'm about to be ready to start construction).

Onshore wind is already much cheaper than than nuclear. The wind turbines being built when I start construction will reach their end of life, be replaced by even more profitable wind turbines that will themselves reach end of life before I will start thinking about decommissioning my nuclear plant. So I'm not just competing about the current generation that already is significantly cheaper, I'm also competing against another few decades of cost reductions for wind.

So how long until wind plus storage is cheaper than my nuclear plant? Will it be in 10 years with economies of scale from EV battery demand, or 30 years until something more ambitious like storing molten salts or molten aluminium becomes serious competition? Or am I willing to bet it takes 50 years, giving my reactor 40 years of profitable operation?

It seems like a terrible bet to make. I would need a lot of subsidies to make it look like a good idea.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:39AM (#20104187)
> Onshore wind is already much cheaper than than nuclear.

Except that it cannot possibly produce enough to replace nuclear or meet demand.

And nuclear is not more expensive than _offshore_ wind, which will also struggle to produce enough.

As discussed in this thread, people keep ignoring that raw cost per kWh is just one of the parameters. Another key parameter is that production must be able to meet demand.

At the moment it is simply not possible to operate only on wind and solar. This becomes is more true when you account for the boom in electricity needs that is coming because electric cars.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by wongarsu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:20AM (#20104624)
In the UK offshore wind seems only 10% more expensive than nuclear right now [1]. I think it's fair to assume that over the majority of the operating time of a nuclear plant that starts construction today offshore wind will be cheaper than that nuclear plant.

As a private plant operator that isn't also the grid operator I don't really care though about meeting demand. I care about a slightly different metric: can I sell my electricity at a higher price than it takes me to produce it? Of course if nobody can meet demand, prices tend towards infinity and I'm happy. Maybe that happens often enough that I can still make a profit despite all the times I make a loss when wind is too strong and electricity prices are too low. Growing demand is a good point that might help.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#...

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ChrisSD on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:50AM (#20103062)
I think this just goes to show how ridiculously expensive Nuclear is to build in the first place, even before the ongoing costs, waste disposal, decommissioning, etc.

The deal took over a decade and not only includes upfront costs but also British bill payers giving a "generous" subsidy to French energy for 35 years.

Providing 7% of the UK's energy needs is far from nothing but it comes at a very high cost. Bringing all the costs in-house might lessen the bill in the long run (if the UK were to be building a lot) but would require a lot of investment in relearning how to build the plants.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:05AM (#20103131)
Nuclear is not more expensive that, say, offshore wind. [0]

> The deal took over a decade and not only includes upfront costs but also British bill payers giving a "generous" subsidy to French energy for 35 years.

Not so. The deal is only to guarantee the price of electricity sold, which had to be done to remove financial uncertainty over decades in order for EDF/Chinese partner to agree to finance it.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#...

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by boyband6666 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:28AM (#20103289)
Except the strike price used is far above the current market rate, with no real indication that it would reach that level naturally. Describing it as a generous subsidy might not be strictly accurate, but isn't far from the truth.

If the strike price used were the current market rate (or maybe a bit lower), that would seem reasonable to allow a company to have the required long term security knowing the bottom won't fall out from under them, but an implicit subsidy does not seem like a good strategy.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:39AM (#20103342)
As said, it was about removing risk and ensuring a return that made the investment worthwhile.

That's just a direct consequence of the government policy of not financing the construction and operation with public money.

The alternative was to directly spend public money, which makes the complaint about this guaranteed price being a public subsidy rather moot.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by boyband6666 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:25PM (#20108757)
... or to accept that the plans were not economically viable as they stand. I'm an economist not a nuclear physicist, but the signal the market is sending is that these plans are not what is needed. Find a way to make the electricity cheaper, or accept the demand isn't there.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by mrpopo on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:11AM (#20103159)
> I think this just goes to show how ridiculously expensive Nuclear is to build in the first place, even before the ongoing costs, waste disposal, decommissioning, etc.

All proponents of renewables bringing the topic of nuclear price fail to make the point that they are comparing apples and oranges. One is reliable, the other is not. To make a fair comparison, you have to include either

- the price of added storage, for which the latest estimates I've seen show would put the price at 5-30x the original price per kWh, including manufacturing, power losses, renewal, etc.

or

- the price of making the electricity less reliable for the industry. It's possible, and seriously considered in 100% renewables scenarios, to switch the electricity consumption for industries at specific times (e.g. the factories run at peak solar or peak wind only). And give incentives for individuals (variable kWh price) to try to pilot their consumption around the production. Problem: this might ruin the competitivity of the industry. The costs associated are much harder to estimate.

TL;DR even if it comes at a very high costs, nuclear would still be cheaper than renewables + adequate storage.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by jabl on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:36AM (#20102991)
As an aside, Hinkley Point C is so expensive because they really botched the financing. Nuclear cost is all about minimizing the cost of capital. What they did pretty much guaranteed the opposite.

Here's an alternative model being proposed for future UK nuclear energy projects: http://www.dieterhelm.co.uk/energy/energy/the-nuclear-rab-mo...

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ptah on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:59AM (#20103109)
UK has no expertise to build nuclear power plants and have to rely on companies owned by French and Chinese governments. the security aspect should also be taken into account
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by nl on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:08AM (#20103146)
Nuclear power is really the only practical solution for the UK to eliminate fossil fuel use from electricity generation, around the clock; we don't have the geography for adequate hydro.

People who make this claim aren't looking at the trends. Local storage is rapidly dropping in price, pump hydro works as a large scale and cheap energy storage solution and the build costs for nuclear is huge.