News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by wongarsu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:37AM (#20103330)
Even if you have the money and are not concerned about the time to break even, nuclear seems like a terrible investment.

Let's ignore subsidies for a moment. Also lets assume I can have the plant operational in 10 years (very optimistic unless I'm about to be ready to start construction).

Onshore wind is already much cheaper than than nuclear. The wind turbines being built when I start construction will reach their end of life, be replaced by even more profitable wind turbines that will themselves reach end of life before I will start thinking about decommissioning my nuclear plant. So I'm not just competing about the current generation that already is significantly cheaper, I'm also competing against another few decades of cost reductions for wind.

So how long until wind plus storage is cheaper than my nuclear plant? Will it be in 10 years with economies of scale from EV battery demand, or 30 years until something more ambitious like storing molten salts or molten aluminium becomes serious competition? Or am I willing to bet it takes 50 years, giving my reactor 40 years of profitable operation?

It seems like a terrible bet to make. I would need a lot of subsidies to make it look like a good idea.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:39AM (#20104187)
> Onshore wind is already much cheaper than than nuclear.

Except that it cannot possibly produce enough to replace nuclear or meet demand.

And nuclear is not more expensive than _offshore_ wind, which will also struggle to produce enough.

As discussed in this thread, people keep ignoring that raw cost per kWh is just one of the parameters. Another key parameter is that production must be able to meet demand.

At the moment it is simply not possible to operate only on wind and solar. This becomes is more true when you account for the boom in electricity needs that is coming because electric cars.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by wongarsu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @10:20AM (#20104624)
In the UK offshore wind seems only 10% more expensive than nuclear right now [1]. I think it's fair to assume that over the majority of the operating time of a nuclear plant that starts construction today offshore wind will be cheaper than that nuclear plant.

As a private plant operator that isn't also the grid operator I don't really care though about meeting demand. I care about a slightly different metric: can I sell my electricity at a higher price than it takes me to produce it? Of course if nobody can meet demand, prices tend towards infinity and I'm happy. Maybe that happens often enough that I can still make a profit despite all the times I make a loss when wind is too strong and electricity prices are too low. Growing demand is a good point that might help.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#...