It is rock solid with 100's of tabs open
Thanks for mentioning this right off of the bat. Often you see folks complaining about how "version XYZ of software ABC" is "too slow" or "buggy" and then 27 comments later they make it clear that they have a very nonstandard use case.I want to be very, very clear: there is nothing "wrong" with having 100s of tabs open, and it certainly would be good if all browsers worked just as well with 500 tabs as a single tab. I'm on your side!
But, in general, people making sweeping statements about software in public have what I feel is a responsibility to be clear when they're using it in ways that are off the beaten path.
Like if I complained about "Windows being buggy", and it turned out I was using a copy of Windows 95 as a substitute for a proper realtime operating system for my spaceship's navigation computer, that's something I really ought to mention upfront.
(Not that having large numbers of tabs is that outlandish, or outlandish at all)
I've also got a Firefox 52 installation lying around and the new version is noticably faster.
I can confirm both that newer firefox is notably more responsive than old, and that I (or an extension, though I don't have many) managed to get a ff profile into a state where it had inexplicably bad performance, esp. unpredictable long freezes.
Something really unusual is happening then. I'd second trying with a new profile. You can get general troubleshooting advice at https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-takes-long-time...
(disclaimer: i work for mozilla, but not on the browser)
Bigger problem are the apps that consume too much CPU and memory. Unfortunately there is no nice way to avoid their killing the whole system (Linux here). But other browsers are no better. The browser makers should realize they are delivering a multiuser OS and protect the resources accordingly.
goto about:config and search for gfx.webrender.enabled and make sure it's set to false.
EDIT: More info on the rollout https://www.ghacks.net/2019/05/20/firefox-webrender-rollout-...
This is one reason why the software industry as a whole sucks, we just do not give a damn about the users.
I had to run waterFox to keep my old plugins working.
While I agree with you that the whole addon migration was a disaster and the wounds are healing just very slowly, I don't have the impression that recent Firefox versions had any performance issues (at least on my machines).
Meaning: I basically have a mindset which as a programmer would say: "shall I spend effort trying to optimize my app for users that have 200 tabs open? Naaaa, I don't see a usecase for that to happen."
I found the ScrapbookQ plugin, which also is able (with some work, admittedly) to import data from the old Scrapbook plugin:
Perhaps there should be a way to passivate tabs so that they don't take up memory when they are not used for a while.
The old version is so much more usable that I find myself using that computer much more frequently. It is rock solid with 100's of tabs open, all my extensions work and without silly restrictions on what they can and can not do and it uses a lot less memory. It's measurably faster too. I'm all for progress and improvements in software but after a long stretch of being a very ardent FF supporter I really do wonder if they have a future. If a competitor had a dream about what they could do to ruin Firefox they could not have done a better job.
Enhanced tracking protection is great but it doesn't matter if you push away your users.