News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dang on Saturday June 01, 2019 @01:49AM (#20067487)
Please don't take HN threads further into flamewar. You created a doozy here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by bachmeier on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:50PM (#20063262)
1. Human beings will always make bad choices. There is nothing wrong with helping them when they do.

2. You can't blame children for mistakes made by their parents.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by leetcrew on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:00PM (#20063367)
regarding 1), there is something wrong with helping people when they make poor choices, especially when "helping" is providing material assistance. you are basically subsidizing the unwanted behavior. at the margins, this causes more people to make the bad choice in the first place. this doesn't mean the government shouldn't help people who make mistakes at all, but it does mean the help has to be structured very carefully to minimize the perverse incentives.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by hnaccy on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:05PM (#20063411)
>Human beings will always make bad choices. There is nothing wrong with helping them when they do.

You're forcing others to help them by threat of force.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by wedn3sday on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:20PM (#20063558)
Forcing the wealthy to help the poor is how we avoid a surge in the guillotine construction industry.

Governments use the threat of force all the time to make people perform pro-social actions, if I park in a handicap zone I get a ticket. What is that ticket besides the threat of force if I dont pay it? What is any contract between any two parties besides a threat of force? On a fundamental level the government exists to threaten force against rich people in order to help poor people, which allows those poor people to go on living and not take up arms to take what they need from the wealthy.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by cliffy on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:54PM (#20063294)
This is a really bizarre position.

If reproduction is not a right, then you shouldn't have a problem with the government coming to sterilize you for some arbitrary reason, right? Maybe your skin is not the 'right' color?

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by algaeontoast on Friday May 31, 2019 @03:46PM (#20064291)
I don't. I actually support recent calls for developing a means to give vasectomies (high percentage of which are reversible) to all newborn males. Therefore, having a child is the choice of both the male and female counterparts of a couple. I'd be stunned if more women didn't support this measure...
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by mach5 on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:46PM (#20063224)
so only the rich should reproduce? absolutely disgusting mindset. nobody chooses a life of poverty, and the overwhelming inequality of our current society both perpetuates and exacerbates it.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by algaeontoast on Friday May 31, 2019 @03:43PM (#20064274)
I disagree. It's not fair to create a human when you're on the edge of being able to properly educate, raise and care for said human.

Having sex is a choice, there are risks involved, one of them is pregnancy.

Many people who aren't considered "rich" can raise children and be economically comfortable.

I'd encourage you to ask someone who grew up in poverty or with uneducated parents (who accidentally had children or decided to have four children knowing they couldn't afford it) if they'd willingly put a child through what they went through growing up and I think my point would be crystal clear.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by CuriouslyC on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:01PM (#20063371)
If you can't care for your child, you shouldn't have one. The natural order is that children from unfit parents die. There are too many humans on this planet as it is.

If you're impoverished in your thirties, it is probably the result of a long history of poor life choices. You can get dealt a horrible hand with lots of tragedy and disadvantages and still be able to make it on your own in your thirties, as long as you're moderately intelligent and hardworking.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by mitchty on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:13PM (#20063492)
> If you can't care for your child, you shouldn't have one. The natural order is that children from unfit parents die. There are too many humans on this planet as it is.

So... wow, thats one hell of a logic leap. Ignoring how close this is to progressive attitudes in the early 20th century, what about "happy accidents". This is a rather to be blunt disgusting attitude to our fellow humans.

> If you're impoverished in your thirties, it is probably the result of a long history of poor life choices. You can get dealt a horrible hand with lots of tragedy and disadvantages and still be able to make it on your own in your thirties, as long as you're moderately intelligent and hardworking.

I get the distinct impression you have no clue what you're talking about and have never worked paycheck to paycheck in your life. One bill can cascade into exactly what your saying is "a long history of poor life choices".

The attitudes such as this are exactly why populist messages are winning a lot of disaffected people. If you're telling them: improve or die, or just die if you're not useful to companies, is it any wonder they're rejecting the worldview wholesale?

I hate politics but the attitudes espoused in the parent post do nothing but blame people for the lives they tend to have been born with irrespective of ability or life choices. As someone that barely escaped things only by dumb luck at picking computer nonsense as a profession, the lack of empathy and understanding by people that have never seen what life is like in survival mode is both astounding and saddening.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by CuriouslyC on Friday May 31, 2019 @08:12PM (#20066221)
If you can't afford it, a happy accident should become a happy abortion.

I came from about as broken a home as you can imagine. I dropped out of high school. I lived on the streets. I went back to college to try and escape my situation. I spent 8 hours a day in the computer lab, working on my skills. I slept in tents and on couches so I could focus on my education and get ahead. Don't talk to me about privilege.

People have the ability to be strong. Coddling and enabling keep them weak. We should help people when they are hit by random, extreme circumstances. We should mostly let them struggle when they're dealing with basic life shit.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dsfyu404ed on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:09PM (#20063454)
Define "care"

I assure you kids can and do grow up just fine without an upper middle class amount of resources thrown at them.

I agree with your second paragraph though.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by ryanmercer on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:15PM (#20063510)
>Define "care"

If you can't put a roof over their head, and feed them, you probably shouldn't have had them.

Multiple people I went to high school with have children they outright can not afford, they couldn't afford the first, or the second, one has 5 children and has been receiving government assistance (and regular handouts as food distribution from her Church) since the first was born. This sort of thing is not uncommon, people with 1 or more children that they have never been able to afford on their own.

Look, I like sex but the primary function of sex is reproduction, if you can't afford the gamble that even 1 in 100,000 times you have sex a child will result then you simply shouldn't be having sex and if you have one unplanned child, and can't afford it, you absolutely should not be doing anything that could create more until a time that have improved your means and can afford to have more.

That's not eugenics, that's not mean, that's not classism, that's not racism, that's common sense.

When couples want to adopt, they are almost always (if not always) required to meet with someone that they have to provide financial statements/pay stubs/w2s etc to as to show that they are able to adequately provide for a child, no one has a problem with this...

Edit: and for those downvoting this, that appear to think I "am the rich" I make 34k USD per year, my father died 12 days before my 13th birthday and my mother did her best to provide for us after that, I personally have a bankruptcy from trying to live foolishly above my means in my early 20's. I drive a used car. I eat black beans and rice 5 days a week for more than half of my kcal requirements so that I CAN afford luxuries like internet, a current gen phone with a data plan, a playstation plus subscription and my two gym memberships as a strength athlete. I do not have children, if I had a sexual partner I would exercise all caution as to not have children as I know it would be a financial burden that would tax my income. I am not elitist, I am not rich, I am lower middle class. I AM responsible, I DO exercise common sense, I DO put thought into my actions that may impact me financially.

Not all people living in poverty are responsible for being there, in fact most probably aren't, however many do directly worsen their situation considerably by taking up vices like alcohol & tobacco and by making financially reckless decisions like having children. These actions make it far harder to dig themselves out of poverty and they should be expected to take responsibility for their own actions instead of expecting those with more means to swoop in and rescue them from their poor choices.

The grocery figure in the original article is insane, simply switching to beans and rice for half of their kcals (which will also meet healthy fiber and protein levels) would shave hundreds off that. Adding potatoes, canned vegetables, no-frills whole grain bread, would also bring down costs and probably markedly improve overall nutrition. Instead, a good chunk of these families, are likely buying overly processed box foods/soda/junk food/fast food for way too large of a portion of their dietary intake. Again, this is a poor choice many of those families are making. I've yet to find a grocery store that doesn't have shelves laden with beans, rice, lentils, potatoes and bread.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by mach5 on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:38PM (#20063750)
> That's not eugenics, that's not mean, that's not classism, that's not racism, that's common sense.

it is the material conditions of classism, racism, and hate that causes the poverty in the first place, with the intentional outcome of making the lower class suffer, so the rich can have more. this IS eugenics. you say it isn't, but in the preceeding paragraph, straight up say that poor people have no business having kids. unbelievable.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dsfyu404ed on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:48PM (#20063839)
Never ascribe to malice what can be explained by ignorance.

There's far more indication that the wealthy just don't know/care about the plight of the poor. Sure a few billionaires might promote what can be seen as anti-poor policy but it seems as though most of them think it's actually good policy.

Your comment is equally bizarre and extreme as the one you're replying to, but extreme in a different direction.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by mach5 on Friday May 31, 2019 @03:01PM (#20063964)
yes, we all know what hanlons razor is, thanks. that indication does not matter in the least, nor is it in any way provable. the rich completely ignoring their domination over the poor does not make them less culpable. it's almost worse, in a way.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by psynautic on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:42PM (#20063792)
you love to see it.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dsfyu404ed on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:39PM (#20063763)
I generally agree with your sentiment but I think you're going a little too far when you say poor people shouldn't have kids. Yes, a disturbing amount of the time it just results in them leaching off society but most of them turn out fine. Nobody is ever "financially prepared" to have kids anyway. They suck up all your money if you let them.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by RhysU on Friday May 31, 2019 @06:03PM (#20065420)
I was financially prepared to have kids. Letting one's kids "suck up all" one's money is my definition of not being prepared, medical emergencies aside.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by mach5 on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:20PM (#20063559)
complete conjecture, there is a giant cohort of people older than 30, crushed by debt and medical bills, stuck in menial jobs because their parents couldn't afford college. you're telling me that the janitor that cleans your office isn't hard working? or the factory-worker that makes your clothes? are they all just lazy morons that don't deserve to reproduce?

please, just go mask-off, be true to yourself, and admit you just want eugenics. you're already A-OK with the death and suffering of children.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by CuriouslyC on Friday May 31, 2019 @08:20PM (#20066248)
Bankruptcy is a good way to deal with crushing medical debt.

You can go to a community college for next to nothing, while sharing a room with several other people, and eating ramen and microwave burritos, then cover a good portion of the costs with a Pell grant, food stamps and some needs based scholarships. After a few years, you can transfer to a 4 year university for a profitable major, take out student loans and complete your degree (this should be doable for 16-24 grand). You might have to work part time to pull this off but not more than 1-2 days a week.

I don't think there are many valid excuses for being unsuccessful beyond your early 30s.

I am ok with the death and suffering of children if it avoids more death and suffering later.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by hnaccy on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:07PM (#20063437)
There's a gap between only the rich reproduce and habitually unemployed/low-wage workers shouldn't have multiple kids at a young age.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by wedn3sday on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:24PM (#20063613)
For that gap to exist, people need access to comprehensive reproductive health services so they can make the choice of when to have kids. In the long run its much, much cheaper for the state to pay for condoms and pregnancy tests then it is to pay for day care, incarceration, and funeral services.
[dead]
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by solean on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:54PM (#20063297)
what are condoms?
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by psynautic on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:29PM (#20063663)
not free like they should be.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by sorryforthethro on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:42PM (#20063180)
[Deleted]
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dsr_ on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:53PM (#20063285)
It's very clear that the Republican Party is not supportive of funding a sexual healthcare provider unless it only teaches abstinence.

I'm glad you're in favor of artifical wombs, but until that happens, please note that the live ones are attached to people who deserve the same degree of bodily autonomy you have.

Simplest possible case: there is no situation in which the current law will force you to donate your organs in order to save someone else's life. Even if you're already dead, you get to control your body through a pre-registration, an affirmative choice. The anti-abortion laws require women to potentially sacrifice their lives to save others.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by sorryforthethro on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:54PM (#20063300)
I wrote that I am against the current legal retaliations for exactly the reason you describe.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by behringer on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:44PM (#20063202)
> Sorry but it's weird the core of your political argument is tied around funding a private NGO.

Not OP but I'm all for the government helping people learn about and schedule abortions.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by vernie on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:52PM (#20063283)
Do the downvotes cause you pain? Just leave your original comment.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by vernie on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:56PM (#20063315)
Ouch! Who's downvoting me? Stop it!
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by sorryforthethro on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:53PM (#20063286)
Yes they do. I don't know why but I really should just stop using these forums.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by vernie on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:56PM (#20063313)
In response to your original comment, I believe there's also a desire to punish people for having premarital sex, as evidenced by right-wingers' strong opposition to emergency contraceptives.
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by happytoexplain on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:07PM (#20063432)
I've never had a conversation with a person who was broadly anti-abortion and anti-subsidized-birth-control that didn't end with the explicit impression that they feel disgust for people who have sex before marriage or for reasons other than reproduction, and that the primary notion upsetting them is the idea of their taxes going toward those people in any form. It's clearly a notion born out of the popular and too-eagerly-applied idea of "bad" people who "deserve" consequences.
[dead]
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by anarchy8 on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:44PM (#20063198)
What kind of deranged argument is that?
Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by tastygreenapple on Friday May 31, 2019 @03:11PM (#20064036)
It seems like the natural next-step of the blithering "you have a right to pleasure".

"You have the right to healthcare" == single payer healthcare

"you have the right to pleasure" == single payer prostitution

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by wedn3sday on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:11PM (#20063474)
In many places in the US having kids is actually not a choice but an obligation forced on women by lack of funding for reproductive service clinics by ignorant politicians and repeated attacks on the right to an abortion by right wing extremists. This is a very loaded conversation at the moment, but there are politicians who've said things like, if a woman is raped and becomes pregnant she should accept the gift that god gave her.

The ability to have kids or not is one thing, the right to make the choice is another, and it's constantly being attacked by religious extremists.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by hnaccy on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:21PM (#20063566)
If you can't afford condoms don't have sex.

23% of those 18-30 aren't having sex and they're not dying.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/03/29/share-ame...

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by taborj on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:18PM (#20063537)
> This is a very loaded conversation at the moment

And your choice of words to describe the situation certainly aren't helping. In fact, they're causing more harm than good, as you present one side as good and kind, and the other side as evil incarnate.

In other words, this is a complex situation, and you're part of the problem.

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by dang on Saturday June 01, 2019 @01:51AM (#20067497)
> you're part of the problem

A personal attack like this makes a hellish thread worse still. We ban accounts that post like that. Would you mind reviewing the site guidelines and following them?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Almost half of US families can't afford basics like rent ... by wedn3sday on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:33PM (#20063699)
That might be because one side is good and kind, and the other is evil. Sure, there's two sides of every argument, but we can sit here all day an no matter what you tell me the sky will still be blue.

The comment I responded to was saying, "having kids is a choice," to which I say, "many people are being forced to have kids they dont want." Forcing unwanted births is a specific policy objective pursued by a group of people pushing they're religious views on others.