If I teach history and have a finale exam with one question, “who was the first president of the United States?” then the students will all get A’s, but nobody would consider that a college level history test, and even if you made an A, there is no way to know that you mastered the subject.
That’s a simplification, but in essence the issue at stake here.
Good for folks who are good at trivia, not so sure it is the best route.
But yeah I agree grades should reflect how well the student grocks the topic.
I think there is very much a thing there that could help change the way education works and maybe augment existing education (a boot camp before starting down the CS path might be a good booster / filter out folks who "hey I don't want to do this, I'll do something else").
On the other hand my experience also says that boot camps are heavily profit driven and generally do a poor job of selecting students and push through students who IMO have no business touching code. About half my class was IMO, unemployable. In that way I'm a bit aligned with the article ;)
If that is not the case the world will automatically try to get the next best certification possible. In the world of old just being able to read was seen as a mark of excellence; once that was the norm it became having finished basic schooling. After WW2 having any kind of university degree was synonymous with intelligence, today lots of jobs start requiring a PhD in order to filter out high-level candidates.
This could go on and on forever but the only thing we are achieving is making everybody lose more and more time in school trying to get a piece of paper. This is extremely wasteful and can be simply corrected by making schools actually hard. Then the qualifications will go back to being a premium which most companies will not actually need (rather than bartenders needing a bachelor's degree).
There's also an additional disadvantage of having the bar low: you help discredit actual science by having hordes of barely-passable "experts" which say whatever they want to say. In my parent's time when somebody was a doctor or engineer people would listen very carefully; today nobody even believes global warming or vaccines because so many qualified "scientists" keep barfing random opinions out. This is a serious problem because it undermines the public's trust towards serious issues, and while there's no easy solution raising the bar in universities would certainly help.
What might actually help here is to move to a two-tiered method of grading. One is the actual grade, which is solely for the student as a personal evaluation and never made available to anyone outside the school, and the other is a pass/fail for the course.
Then if you have a D for the first half of the semester, you know you need to work harder because there is a significant risk that you don't pass the course. And mediocre students actually fail courses and either have to repeat them until they genuinely master the subject matter or have a "fail" show up on their transcript.
But the school doesn't disadvantage their students by giving out a B as the most common grade when other schools give As, and thereby doesn't deprive their students of honest performance feedback or make it impossible to fail bad students because when the 40th percentile students have an A the "bad" students have a B- when they deserve an F.
You are speaking like this is a fact, when there are solid arguments that the whole IQ->Job performance theory is pure nonsense
See https://medium.com/incerto/iq-is-largely-a-pseudoscientific-...
https://www.businessinsider.com/why-your-iq-strongly-influen...
High IQ, ideally with a bit of psychopathy, is really a killer combo.
I'm sympathetic to some extent. I'm a product of a boot camp (granted I had a technical background before that) and I've worked with CS grads who I'm a bit astounded by their inability to just debug something on a basic level (form a theory, test it, make a logical next decision). On the other hand I wonder if that is a case where they should have been filtered out, or if the issue is they weren't taught / tested on the right things?
>The old academic criteria, imperfect as they were, were in fact doing a reasonable job of selecting individuals able and willing to handle the rigors of traditional college. The blunt fact is that the majority of people who scored below a 1200 on the verbal and math sections of the SAT would have found it difficult or impossible to handle a curriculum like that required to earn a state-school engineering degree or comparable certification. Today, thanks to grade inflation, such students can and do pass through top schools with top honors, especially in the liberal arts.
Do we really want to just go by the "old academic criteria"?
Are the people who just scrape by all just bad?
Would it be better if those people just be pushed out the door?
So let's say we make it "harder", is that harder testing? More work? What then?
I feel like as far as learning about how people learn that it is pretty clear that some people work well in what has become the traditional education systems, and others less so, and I"m not sure that filter really determines who will be productive or if that's all we want from education... to filter folks based on how the education system works now?
Personally I'm inclined to lean towards more / better education, less focus on making everything "harder".