News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by ttsda on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:53AM (#19999715)
At pressures a million times those experienced on earth. Still an advance, of course.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by Zanni on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:04AM (#20000013)
Nobody wants "high temperature" superconductors. They want superconductors at roughly standard temperature and pressure. This is only an advance by the extremely artificial metric of considering temperature only. Ceramic superconductors work at liquid nitrogen temperatures and standard pressure, which is much more accessible.

I'm not raging at ttsda. It is an advance. Of sorts. But not nearly as much as the headline suggests.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by gaze on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:27AM (#20000746)
You’re vastly underestimating what the significance of what this is part of. High Tc superconductivity was thought to be essentially dead. Extremely few significant new results for decades. Now this and magic angle twisted graphene and some other stuff. It’s really really cool. It’s like we’re watching an entire field thawing and lurching forward.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by galangalalgol on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:42AM (#20001327)
Is the graphene thing dead? One paper indicated graphene or even graphite soaked in a hydrocarbon would superconduct at room temperature. I was so excited I purhased some and tried that, it had a DC impedance similar to dry graphite...
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by TeMPOraL on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:47PM (#20006231)
Did you buy graphene or graphite? If the former, maybe what you got wasn't actually graphene? Apperently, the progress in this field is held back by most suppliers selling something they claim that's graphene but really isn't (or is of garbage quality) - https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2018/10/11/gr....
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by irq-1 on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:26AM (#20002529)
This is addressed in the second to last paragraph:

> The effort to manufacture synthetic diamond provided substantial motivation for the development of high-pressure methods. Today, however, synthetic diamonds are grown using a low-pressure technique called chemical-vapour deposition. Optimistically, it might eventually be possible to use similar low-pressure methods to produce metastable superconducting compounds that are initially discovered at high pressure.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by jeffwass on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:47AM (#20000516)
The headline is accurate.

In the scientific community, High-Tc superconductors typically refer to Type II superconductors, eg cuprates. And the “High-Tc” term means above temperatures relative to the usual elemental superconductor Tc’s, eg about 20K or so.

Materials that can superconduct above 77K are especially sought after since they can be cooled with only liquid nitrogen, much cheaper and abundant than liquid helium.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by marcosdumay on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:30PM (#20004615)
The maximum current and magnetic field you can apply to a supercondutor correlates very well with Tc, and it is likely that they are intrinsically linked so this correlation is unavoidable.

So, no, everybody cares about high temperature superconducors, because the higher the temperature, the strongest magnet you can build out of them.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by deelowe on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:14AM (#20001718)
What's wrong with high pressure superconductors? At least those don't require constant energy input, which would seem to be an improvement.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by sfasfsafd on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:43AM (#20002706)
at a 1E6 atm, it's beyond useless for any practical application (unlike "normal" superconductors that can be used with a bit of N2 plumbing). If you scroll through the paper, you'll see they talk about using a diamond anvil.

Even if we could compress anything other than a spec of this stuff, it would still require massive amounts of PV work to achieve the P required.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by hoseja on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:28AM (#20000390)
I thought "high temperature", when talking about superconductors, basically means any temperature above the boiling point of nitrogen...
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by chaboud on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:49PM (#20003312)
I think you may mean below.

Basically, low temperature superconductors (e.g. niobium titanium) are liquid helium cooled.

High temperature superconductors (e.g. YBCO, BSCCO) are everything else, but generally liquid nitrogen cooled.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by saagarjha on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:34AM (#19999904)
Also, the temperature (250 K, -23°C) is a bit chilly to be called “room temperature”. Still, this means you don’t need liquid nitrogen for cooling: a good but standard refrigeration system would be enough (and their insane diamond pressure apparatus, of course).
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by maxxxxx on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:19AM (#20001118)
Isn’t nitrogen cooling much easier to achieve than this level of pressure?
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by hackerpacker on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:42AM (#20001328)
well the pressure aspect wouldn't require constant energy input. And I assume it is a lot more economical to use a consumer refrigerator than liquid nitrogen.

But yah, you can bathe a much more complicated "circuit" in liquid nitrogen a lot easier than compressing it with diamond anvils. Though no commercial superconducting computers have emerged, cmos is just too cost effective currently, and the known examples are still in the 4K range.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by sfasfsafd on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:46AM (#20002733)
"well the pressure aspect wouldn't require constant energy input."

But you have to put energy in to compress it, energy that is lost (since you're compressing it isothermally). Since we're talking about 1E6 atm, any appreciable volume would require insane amounts of E to compress.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by maxxxxx on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:26PM (#20003597)
Wouldn't that also be pretty much a bomb if the pressure got relieved? I don't know how to do the math but 1E6 atm seems a lot of energy (is it potential energy?) that has to go somewhere.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by bzbarsky on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:08PM (#20004422)
TL;DR: It's pretty much like a bomb, yes.

How much energy it is depends on the volume change as you compress. If your material is completely incompressible, there is no volume change, no work done as the pressure rises, and therefore no energy stored.

In practice, for a material of bulk modulus K by definition you have

  -K dV/V = dP.
as the basic differential equation relating pressure and volume (if we assume that the bulk modulus is constant through our pressure range, which is quite an assumption in this case). Solving that, we get:

  V = V_0/exp(P/K)
where V_0 is the original volume and V is the volume after the pressure has been applied. Bulk modulus is commonly measured in GPa, so we're going to do that here. 1atm is about 1e5 Pa or 1e-4 GPa.

The work done while compressing is the integral of -PdV, which per that first differential equation we can rewrite as the integral of P * V/K * dP (we want to integrate dP because we know what the limits are: it's going from 1atm, or 1e-4 GPa, to 1e6 atm = 1e2 GPa).

Plugging in our expression for V we get the integral, from 1e-4 to 100, of P/K * V_0/exp(P/K) dP. The integral there is:

  K * V_0 * (-P/K - 1) * exp(-P/K)
For simplicity, I'm going to approximate that 1e-4 by 0, so we get:

  K * V_0 * ((-100/K - 1) * exp(-100/K) + 1)
when we evaluate at the two endpoints.

OK, so let's try an actual material and actual volume. Steel has a bulk modulus of 160 GPa according to <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulk_modulus#Selected_values>. So for steel we have:

  160 * V_0 * ((-100/160 - 1) * exp(-100/160) + 1) =
  160 * V_0 * 0.13 =
  21 * V_0
or so. If we assume we started with a 1 cm^3 volume of steel, that's an energy of:

  21e9 N/m^2 * 1e-6 m^3 = 2.1e4 J
or about equivalent to 5 grams of TNT per <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TNT_equivalent>. For comparison, 1 cm^3 of steel is about 7-8 grams of material, so we're right in the "about as much energy as the same weight of TNT" ballpark. Obviously if you start with a larger volume you end up with more stored energy: if we started with 1m^3 we end up equivalent to about 5 tons of TNT.

If your material is more compressible, the numbers are higher, as long as it's not too compressible (in which case it just collapses into a tiny volume quickly and not much more work gets done after that). If we take K = 50 (a typical number for glass from that table), you get:

  50 * V_0 * ((-100/50 - 1)*exp(-100/50) + 1) =
  50 * V_0 * 0.6 =
  30 * V_0
If your material is less compressible, you store less energy; for diamond with K = 443, you get something like 9.7*V_0.

Again, all this assumes pressure-invariant bulk modulus, which seems moderately unlikely when you are dealing with pressures that are on the order of the size of the bulk modulus or even larger, as here.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by smilliken on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:56PM (#20005233)
An upvote is not enough. Your comment is the reason I love HN.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by rohansingh on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:15PM (#20004498)
It would depend on what happens when the material is removed from the high-pressure environment.

As the article points out, diamonds naturally form in a high-pressure environment but are stable at standard atmosphere and temperature.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by contravariant on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:34PM (#20005891)
I'm not entirely sure but I think there are no theoretical obstructions to maintaining a ridiculously high pressure indefinitely.

Although I suppose there aren't any theoretical obstructions to indefinitely maintaining low temperatures either.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by imtringued on Saturday May 25, 2019 @06:40AM (#20008214)
Even blackholes lose their mass through radiation. Nothing can maintain a high pressure indefinitely.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by skunkworker on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:35AM (#19999911)
This.

lanthanum hydride @ 250K at > 1 million atm.

It's still very impressive though.

Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by taneq on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:45AM (#20001362)
Technically correct. The most annoying kind of correct.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by baq on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:07AM (#20000634)
this made me think, is the earth core a superconductor?
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by MichaelApproved on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:54AM (#20002168)
No. The core has pressure but it's way too hot to achieve super conductivity.
Re:Superconductivity near room temperature by effie on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:23AM (#20001150)
Interesting idea. It would help to explain persistence of Earth's magnetic field.