News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by dang on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:46AM (#19989147)
Taking HN threads into nationalistic and racial and ideological flamewar is not allowed on HN, and we ban accounts that do it. If you have something thoughtful and substantive to say, that's a different story, but please keep the cheap battle rhetoric someplace else.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by jlawson on Thursday May 23, 2019 @11:43PM (#19998285)
I said absolutely nothing about race. I resent the implication that my opinion is somehow racially-based.

Nor have I done anything related to a "flame war". I insulted no individuals and I attacked no groups.

Nor has a "flame war" arisen from my comment. There have been many responses and there's no "flame war", just reasonable disagreement.

I simply expressed a sense of loss at the potential dissolution of a culture. My concerns are central to the whole topic; they are shared by most Japanese people. This is not some fringe view, it is at the center of the entire issue and is entirely mainstream.

Your accusations don't connect. This rebuke makes it seem like you're using biased enforcement of facially-neutral rules to advantage one side of the discussion, and suppress mainstream views on the other side. What you're doing here is harmful to the health of the HN community, and wider discourse. Please reconsider how you've approached this issue, and be more circumspect before making such accusations. Ask yourself - How would someone with the opposite mainstream view, or a Japanese person, consider the comment? How would I moderate this if I agreed with the underlying worldview and values?

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by jdietrich on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:59PM (#19988309)
All cultures are blended. Most of the things you think of as uniquely Japanese are in fact imports, or the hybrid cultural offspring of imports. Kanji was stolen wholesale from Chinese Hanzi, sushi evolved from fermented fish dishes from the Mekong, pagodas are a Chinese import, Buddhism is an import from India via China, the kimono came from China, manga is based on ukiyo-e which is based on Chinese woodblock printing techniques, kare raisu came from India via the British Royal Navy. I could go on ad nauseum.

Anyone who espouses cultural purity is simply ignorant of culture. If you perceive your cultural environment as homogenized, it's your own damned fault for being a passive consumer rather than an active participant.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by GoblinSlayer on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:03AM (#19991866)
Aside from inheritance there are mutations that are not based on previous work and are unique.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by fromthestart on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:39AM (#19988536)
>Anyone who espouses cultural purity is simply ignorant of culture.

There's a difference between gradual assimilation of cultural elements over hundreds of years, and flooding a country with change on the scale of a generation. It's perfectly reasonable to want to preserve what amounts to a cultural identity by limiting cultural influx.

>Anyone who espouses cultural purity is simply ignorant of culture

Nonsense. The fact that a given culture contains elements from others does not mean that it is not itself pure. Culture is simply information - in the form of practices, foods, clothing, ideals - and while there may be a great deal of overlap among the basis vectors that could be combined to represent the world's cultures, purity could be approximately gauged by a principle component analysis, which would most certainly show distinct, tight groupings for more homogenous, isolated cultures like that of Japan, and a more diffuse, homogenized cluster among westernized cultures.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:00AM (#19988645)
The ancestral post of this thread is bemoaning supposed cultural deracination in Japan because of changes to immigration policy. It is hysterical to presume that the Japanese are about to flood their country "with change on the scale of a generation".

> does not mean that it is not itself pure

By what metric is a culture pure? How can information be pure? How far back in the timeline do you want to gauge purity? And at what point is it relevant to policy?

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by wallace_f on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:30AM (#19989057)
Japan is an extroardinarily unique place. Even Australia, NZ, the UK and America have not just lot in common when you compare them to Japan, but a surprisingly lot. Japan really does have its own culture and identity.

The Japanese have always wanted to protect their culture, identity, and economy, going back to where n Perry shot off a cannon to get them to open up the West's plans.

As a foreigner who loves Japan, I think there is a stretch between letting particularly interested individuals enjoy to the country--which is already possible--and opening itself up economic migration--which is what Western countries now experience.

Look at Singapore. It's such a god damn hell compared to Japan even though on paper they should be doing better.

There is really no other place like Japan on earth, it will be sad to see it homogenize with the rest of it.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:34AM (#19989079)
Again, it seems highly dubious that opening up to economic migration means the same set of policies used everywhere, and the same results everywhere.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by wallace_f on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:08AM (#19990560)
I know you keep wanting to broadcast that opinion, but it is obviously not clear to be true. For reasons you can see in my comment, and also see this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19988198
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:30PM (#19993198)
So either Japanese culture is "extraordinarily unique" and has a strong sense of identity, allowing its people to pursue immigration policies with different results from other nations, or its culture is already no better or worse or different than those aforementioned nations- and immigration will lead to the same conclusions. So which is it?
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Nadya on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:16AM (#19991994)
We've seen the same results in every country that has attempted it, so why would one more country be any different? How many repeating occurrences of something occurring do you need before you can look at the data and go "There's a strong correlation there." without being called or implied to be a racist?
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:25PM (#19993140)
Because if cultures are real, then it stands to reason that an immigration policy set by Japanese people would be different from one set by Western Europeans.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Nadya on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:03PM (#19993564)
There are only so many ways to make cheese and most of the process is going to remain the same. Being a different or unique culture doesn't fundamentally change how cheese is manufactured.

I fail to see your point. There are only so many ways to do set immigration policy and currently Japanese policy is different from ones used by Western countries. Much to the chagrin of the Western countries criticizing it as their own policies are breaking down and giving rise to nationalism and increasing social and racial tensions.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:14PM (#19993677)
But we're not talking about different cheeses, but perhaps different dairy products. Yogurt is not a cheese.

While not free of problems, Canada's immigration situation seems to not have attracted the same amount of problems as seen in other Western nations. Strange that Japan isn't adopting a similar points-based system. But it seems like the sort of Japanese innovation that could arise. One would presume a Japanese immigration policy and pathway of citizenship would mandate learning the language and other ways to facilitate assimilation, different from the policies of most Western nations.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Nadya on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:31PM (#19994505)
>Strange that Japan isn't adopting a similar points-based system

They do use a points-based system for highly-skilled workers: http://www.immi-moj.go.jp/newimmiact_3/en/evaluate/index.htm...

>One would presume a Japanese immigration policy and pathway of citizenship would mandate learning the language and other ways to facilitate assimilation

It strongly does and is incredibly difficult otherwise. When applying for citizenship if you struggle at all when asked questions in Japanese you will likely, if not certainly, be rejected. There are countless anecdotal stories out there confirming the difficulties in attaining citizenship from people who already have permanent resident status.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:15PM (#19994994)
So given how historically stringent the Japanese government has been in doling out citizenship, it stands to reason even an "open" policy would be more measured and less laissez-faire than those in, say, Nordic countries, no?
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by fromthestart on Thursday May 23, 2019 @11:14AM (#19992498)
>By what metric is a culture pure?

By the degree to which it has uniquely evolved in relative isolation.

>How can information be pure?

By the degree to which the combination of information that defines a particular culture is unique. Again, if we model culture as a linear combination of cultural traits, purity may be measured as, for example, euclidean distance between clusters, reflecting unique developments that occur as a function of isolation. As an extreme case, compare an undiscovered tribe in the Amazon, or the Amish, to a cosmopolitan population like residents of New York City.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:25PM (#19988122)
Why assume that Japanese culture is neither venerable nor attractive enough to withstand the phenomenon you’re describing?
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by blfr on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:41PM (#19988201)
Because culture is not an abstract set of ideas separate from its people. You can only adopt a culture you weren't brought up in to a certain degree, and usually very shallowly.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:47PM (#19988242)
There have been non-ethnically Yamato people in Japan for at least centuries. However Japanese society or law might have treated them, are you saying the Zainichi are culturally less Japanese than ethnic Japanese?

Seems like a lack of faith in societies to properly integrate new arrivals.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by duality on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:50PM (#19988262)
This will likely prove to be a false equivalence.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by blfr on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:51PM (#19988263)
Seems like a lack of faith in societies to properly integrate new arrivals.

Yes, exactly. I have little faith in that, because it rarely happens.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:53PM (#19988278)
Why assume modern day East Asian countries will integrate new arrivals the same way as European and North American nations do?

And are you aware that international migration has been happening for millennia? All nations have people who have assimilated and integrated, to different degrees.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by mantas on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:10AM (#19988946)
And lots of unique cultures were lost along the way.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:12AM (#19988954)
Most unique cultures are likely to have disappeared by force via conquest and colonization, not through voluntary migration. And in most cases, it is the migrants themselves' cultures that get lost in favor of the host nation's culture.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by duality on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:48PM (#19988249)
Mass migration seems to be for economic benefits. A handful of people may immigrate out of appreciation of their new host culture, but millions or tens of millions doing so? Seems unlikely to me. They'll go to earn more money.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:57PM (#19988301)
It sounds like Japan, with its own unique culture and governance distinct from Western nations, is not pursuing a course of mass migration but something more regulated and careful.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by lmm on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:29AM (#19991550)
They were, for a while. Isn't the point of this article that they're moving to a much more Western-style policy? Japan was a unique culture, but already feels a lot less so than it used to be.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:34PM (#19993239)
Perhaps it will be a more open migration policy with Japanese characteristics.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by GoblinSlayer on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:23AM (#19992061)
It's not unthinkable their ability to withstand influence is based on monoculturalism. Immigration can dilute that ability. In any way change inherently conflicts with status quo.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by themagician on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:33PM (#19988161)
What is the alternative?

All of the “developed” nations need immigration to prevent the social systems from completely falling apart. Our entire financial system is based on increasing population growth and the young paying to support the old. There aren’t enough young people. Without immigration, pensions, healthcare, social safety nets, property values… it all implodes. We go back to 1930 where old people just die in the street.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by blfr on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:40PM (#19988196)
What is the alternative?

Having kids. Having a sustainable culture rather than some weird human shredder reliant on constant stream of new souls from abroad.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by themagician on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:11AM (#19988374)
People can’t afford to have kids. Maybe if young people didn’t have to spend a huge portion of their paycheck supporting old people they could afford kids.

The older generation doesn’t want immigrants. The older generation votes against tax increases. The older generation does everything they can to keep home prices high. Then they demand no one cut their entitlements. All take, no give. It’s not surprising people aren’t having as many kids.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by cthalupa on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:47AM (#19988569)
With Japan, it's not solely (or perhaps even primarily) a matter of not being able to afford kids. Even in Tokyo the fantastic public transport means you can live in one of the more inexpensive wards and still commute basically anywhere in a reasonable amount of time.

People aren't even dating in Japan, though. Marriage rates are way down, people aren't having sex, etc. Even the non-sexual aspects of relationships have been commoditized, with host/hostess bars where you pay to have conversations with people like you would while out on a date, cuddle bars where you pay just to cuddle, etc. Dating video games are huge.

Women being able to more readily progress into senior positions in white collar jobs is a relatively recent occurrence, and getting married/having kids is a good way to end your career, so they're less likely to want to date seriously.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by chr1 on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:50PM (#20003784)
Perhaps they should invest more into developing artificial womb https://metro.co.uk/2019/05/14/human-babies-born-using-an-ar...
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by duality on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:45PM (#19988226)
It is weird to hear: 1) stop having so many kids, it's bad for the Earth, and 2) we're not having enough kids, let's substitute with immigrants.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by Apocryphon on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:52PM (#19988272)
Perhaps some of those kids will become rocket scientists and help us get off this Earth and continue our relentless expansion and consumption off-world.

Also, isn’t immigration a negation of 1)? The kids are already born, they’re just not in the same country.

Sarcasm aside, there are two systemic problems at play. 1) is ecological, and 2) is economic. The second may be physically easier to solve- but it still requires us to figure out a way to move beyond our capitalist system that a) prioritizes relentless growth and consumption, and b) has countries with large welfare programs that requires new workers and taxpayers to keep the elderly and the ill off the streets.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by TheChaplain on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:10AM (#19988371)
Kids.

The primary reason as I understand it for the lack of kids is simply because it's a trap for women as it is now.

Maternity- and child care leave are too short. There are extreme shortage of daycare for infants and pre-school children, forcing women to stay home and even give up on their career until the child is old enough to go to/from school themselves.

And having 2-3 children pretty much kills any career.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by barry-cotter on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:26AM (#19989995)
> Maternity- and child care leave are too short. There are extreme shortage of daycare for infants and pre-school children, forcing women to stay home and even give up on their career until the child is old enough to go to/from school themselves.

This is not the case in Sweden and it has not had any great effects on fertility, which is within spitting distance of its neighbours. If you can’t afford childcare in Sweden the state will pay. Childcare is heavily subsidised and available 24/7 if you have shift work. Tiny effects on fertility.

> Cohort Fertility Patterns in the Nordic Countries

> Country differences in fertility outcome are generally rather low. Childlessness is highest in Finland and lowest in Norway, and the educational differentials are largest in Norway. Despite such differences, the cohort analyses in many ways support the notion of a common Nordic fertility regime.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/23525308_Cohort_Fer...

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by mantas on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:14AM (#19988963)
Yet what I see around is men being against having kids. While women do somewhat support the idea.

It's definitely not a one-sided issue.

But yes, infrastructure is definitely a massive issue. I wonder what would happen if resources that Western europe countries pour into migration would be put for fixing birth rate. Push propaganda on all fronts, put shit ton of money into infrastructure, install new cultural norms...

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by chr1 on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:05PM (#20003912)
Propaganda usually doesn't work or has the opposite effect.

It may be better to pass a law that would link pension of old people to tax paid by young people who have chosen them. This will make having many successful children profitable again. And will restore the role of a family, which is artificially lowered by social services.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by ericd on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:15AM (#19988397)
They don't all implode, the paper value might implode, and the expectations probably have to change. That's pretty different. And honestly, imploding property prices would be quite helpful in solving the sub-replacement rate birth rate, as well as a host of other social problems.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by nitwit005 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:35AM (#19989083)
Ultimately the global population is going to level off for one reason or another. Immigration is a temporary fix.

Alternatively, you can keep going with exponential growth, if you can find a few more planets to put people on.

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by PorterDuff on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:18AM (#19988419)
So what happens when you have perpetual growth?
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by themagician on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:25AM (#19988460)
I don’t know. Logan’s Run, maybe.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by GoblinSlayer on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:41AM (#19992192)
Childbirth can be encouraged, it's just not done.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by maximus1983 on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:53PM (#19988279)
And then the immigrants stay and get old and there is increased strain on the strained social systems. Most immigration systems in Europe assumed that the immigrants would go home once they have made some money.

At some point it is going to implode anyway. The UK in the last 25 years has completely changed due to immigration and our health system is basically about to fall over, there are massive cultural tensions between natives and immigrant populations that are on the verge of exploding in poorer areas (North of England) on almost a daily basis. None of this gets covered in the news but there are plenty of videos on Facebook, Youtube etc of clashes.

I suggest you read the "Strange Death of Europe".

Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by themagician on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:15AM (#19988398)
Healthcare requires young, relatively healthy, people. It’s another system where the young pay for the old. The immigrants aren’t the immediate problem, they are the immediate solution. They may crowd the system, but they are also the ones funding it. Kick all young, relatively healthy, immigrants out and see how quickly healthcare collapses as the older people on fixed income try to find a way to balance the healthcare budget.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by lmm on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:20AM (#19989951)
Importing a bunch of young people works for one generation. But those young people grow old (and assimilate into a culture with a low birth rate), and what do you do then - import ever more young people to take care of the previous generation of immigrants? That doesn't seem sustainable.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by maximus1983 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @12:35AM (#19988513)
You miss the point. The system is going to collapse anyway and long term thinking is needed
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by vkou on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:03AM (#19989832)
Immigration allows you to slowly deflate the demographic bubble over the next thirty years, instead of pop it, with much suffering over the next ten.
Re:Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration by duxup on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @11:46PM (#19988237)
Exciting, a new culture gets to develop.