News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by jason_zig on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:12AM (#19961153)
Does anyone else feel helpless when reading stuff like this? Is there anything I can do to make things better in these scenarios?
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by duxup on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:47AM (#19961618)
I think this event sounds far worse than it is. The site is contaminated already worse than any leak would cause.

That's not good, but it's not some sort of catastrophic event here.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by acct1771 on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:18AM (#19961239)
Tell people around you to stop implicitly trusting centralized power.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by irrational on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:32PM (#19962135)
But whom has the power to clean something like this up except for centralized power?
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by justin66 on Monday May 20, 2019 @02:30PM (#19963511)
"The market."

Just kidding.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by onemoresoop on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @10:52AM (#19970665)
The market is irresponsible.

Not kidding.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by onemoresoop on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @10:51AM (#19970655)
I see the point, without centralized power you wouldn't have messes at this scale, there would be local messes that local power would be incentivised to clean up because it's in their backyard and it stinks.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by acct1771 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @08:54AM (#19969658)
The people that created it.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by anoncake on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @02:56AM (#19978522)
This mess was created by the US government.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by NotSammyHagar on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:33AM (#19961441)
How about it's never too late to work to rectify the mistakes of the past. We at least have to do our best as human beings. I can't do anything about something 1000 years ago, but I can help that person I saw on the street maybe, or I can add my voice to those who decry some terrible behavior of the government. I can vote. I can go to city councils and speak out.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by addicted on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:31PM (#19962124)
Who goes around implicitly trusting central power. In any aspect of their lives.

I can literally think of no one I know who wouldn’t respond to me telling them “hey you should stop implicitly trusting central power” by asking what drugs I’m on if I think they implicitly trust central power.

I guess this straw man is necessary to create so some can beat it down, but as far as I can tell such people don’t actually exist.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by ben509 on Monday May 20, 2019 @01:07PM (#19962525)
> Who goes around implicitly trusting central power. In any aspect of their lives.

It's required for the government to provide a "social safety net" and more broadly for the Progressive vision of society. That includes Progressive-era reforms in education and retirement, as well as Progressive inspired reforms in healthcare and welfare, esp. the Great Society.

These reforms are predicated on the notion of a government agency collecting statistical data and reviewing comments from the public to determine policy that provides baseline services and acts as a buffer to economic variance.

Note also "implicit" trust. Trust is transitive: you might trust in some service the government provides without necessarily understanding that the service relies on some centralized power. Thus you might not explicitly trust a central authority, but because you rely on the services it provides you may be implicitly trusting it.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by AnthonyMouse on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:40PM (#19964261)
None of that stuff really requires any great level of centralization at all. Many components, like social security, are effectively mandatory requirement savings and could be replicated at the level of an individual if they didn't exist, simply by using the money not paid in social security tax to buy an annuity.

The primary thing you would require any government for at all would be redistributive programs, but that still doesn't require uniformity of centralization. We don't even have it as it is -- the Saudis are some of the richest people in the world, they make most of their money from the US and Europe, yet they pay no income tax to either region.

Meanwhile you could implement redistributive programs even at the level of a city. There is nothing stopping New York City from imposing a land value tax and using the money to fund a UBI, if that's what they want to do.

Centralized government actually interferes with this significantly, because San Francisco or the state of California can't implement its own healthcare policies when they have the US government overriding them, and hoovering up the state's money and sending it to other states, using it for military spending or sending it back with strings attached that require it to be spent on less efficient or less appropriate programs than the state would choose to fund for itself.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by ben509 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @05:23PM (#19975205)
To be clear, I wasn't arguing whether policy should be one way or the other or what anyone should do, just whether or not people do commonly trust central authority.

You bring up a fair objection: the Progressives' big pushes for central planning were around 100 years ago, and there's no reason the same goals couldn't be met with a distributivist approach, and many novel programs rely far less on central planning.

All true, and you're going to find hundreds of people on HN who could go into far greater detail.

Outside this techno-libertarian bubble, most people have no notion of distributed anything. If you ask most people, "how can we do a major program," their conception will be a big government agency planning it out.

And they'll have reasonable arguments for why, such as economies of scale and standardization.

> Meanwhile you could implement redistributive programs even at the level of a city.

I think this hits at a problem with the original concept of "trusting a central authority" as you bring up what is a smaller central authority, but nevertheless somewhat central.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gubbrora on Monday May 20, 2019 @02:17PM (#19963355)
People trust centralized power because there is no viable alternative to trusting the centralized power and hoping for the best.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gooseus on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:39AM (#19961528)
Yes.

Plenty of people will offer things you can do, but really they're only things that will treat your feeling of helplessness and not things that have any significant chance of improving these scenarios.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by _bxg1 on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:33AM (#19961430)
Vote. As futile as it feels, that's all any of us can do.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gnode on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:27PM (#19962082)
Voting is a blunt instrument; it's effective, but it's a poor signal. It says only one thing: I want this entity to wield power. If you want to sue someone, you don't become a judge, you bring a lawsuit.

If you want to cause political change, you need to bring something into the public discourse; make it known to the politicians and the electorate. People do this by writing their politicians, getting media attention, organising or joining political action groups, backing candidates, or even going into politics themselves.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by _bxg1 on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:36PM (#19962169)
Sure; I meant "vote" more as "participate in your democracy".
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by tenpies on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:12PM (#19961916)
It is futile because you think that the only country with this issue is the US.

I can guarantee that China and Russia have similar if not worst storage problem - the difference is that the US allows this information to exist in the public. Even if those governments allowed the information to be public, what are you going to do, not for the Party/Putin? That sounds like a great way to win a free trip to Siberia or the re-education camp.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by Bendingo on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:35PM (#19967179)
> guarantee that China and Russia > for the Party/Putin

This thread has nothing to do with China/Russia/Putin etc. And yet, still somehow every discussion of US always requires criticism of Russia.

> trip to Siberia or the re-education

Please remember that USSR no longer exists.

[dead]
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by dang on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:37AM (#19967797)
Please don't do this here.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by _bxg1 on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:48AM (#19961625)
And replace elections with what?

Democracy is the only system that has ever served any kind of majority of the population. Ours may be in rough shape right now, but burning it all down instead of fixing it helps no one.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gnode on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:54PM (#19962361)
> Democracy is the only system that has ever served any kind of majority of the population.

I disagree. Sortition / demarchy, which is the selection of officials randomly from the population (much like a grand jury), has been used throughout history, and is a strong contender. It's exponents tend to state diversity of representation, anti-corruption, and the minimisation of factionalism as advantages.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by ben509 on Monday May 20, 2019 @01:24PM (#19962720)
So that's what it's called. An appointed Senate and demarchist House would be ideal. An interesting advantage is courts can readily convene a committee to clarify the meaning of legislation, which is largely impossible with a fixed number of reps in the House. This removes the specter of a handful of justices legislating from the bench.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by sethhochberg on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:10PM (#19961900)
Plus, surely we'd need some kind of way to decide which of our current leaders get the guillotine... maybe by asking everyone to write down their opinion, and counting up the results...
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by ben509 on Monday May 20, 2019 @01:29PM (#19962772)
Once the mob gets blood lust, any kind of system or thought goes out the window and everyone will be desperate to put the brakes on.
[dead]
[dead]
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by dang on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:34AM (#19967781)
Could you please not post like this here?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html