News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:26PM (#19950551)
If you’re dead, what do you care what happens to your remains?

I see no problem with exhuming a corpse to solve a murder case as long as there’s probable cause and a warrant, which there was here.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by maxerickson on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:42PM (#19950615)
I agree with you about not caring, but I wonder if you've really not noticed that lots of people do care about how remains are handled?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:47PM (#19950646)
I have, but I’m still going to question it when someone bases a comment on it.

In any case, the second half of my comment should apply just as well for such folks. We allow much worse things with a warrant, even from that perspective.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mindcrime on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:14AM (#19951582)
I have, but I’m still going to question it when someone bases a comment on it.

And what do you hope to accomplish by doing so?

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by veidr on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:54AM (#19951857)
Furthering the cause of logic and reasonability? Advocating for evidence-based forensic science winning out over superstition and other lesser concerns?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mindcrime on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:04AM (#19951882)
Furthering the cause of logic and reasonability? Advocating for evidence-based forensic science winning out over superstition and other lesser concerns?

Calling somebody out over something incredibly subjective, on an HN comment, seems like a terribly weak effort towards that end.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:06AM (#19953637)
Oh no, a weak effort, how terrible.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mindcrime on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:15PM (#19954605)
More like "pathetic".
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:20PM (#19954635)
Your comments are so much better!
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by NeedMoreTea on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:03AM (#19952107)
It's not like it's a new development either - police and justice systems around the world have long had the possibility, and right, to ask to exhume a body to further an investigation. It has most often been the victim historically.

So I don't see why this would be viewed as any different.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mehrdadn on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:05AM (#19951555)
> If you’re dead, what do you care what happens to your remains?

Not speaking for this case in particular, but regarding the general question, maybe it's something you don't want your loved ones to have to think about/go through?

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by travmatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:19PM (#19956498)
Not positing this as your position, but we can’t base the rightness of such an action in a vacuum that only considers the interests of one party and ignore the interests of everyone else. In weighing the relative rights of individuals and society, the relative rights of the deceased’s relatives are less important than the victims relatives in knowing the truth about their loss, and societies interests in identifying murderers, whether alive or dead.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mirimir on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:33AM (#19951803)
Cremation would have made little difference in this case. They would still have identified his relatives, and obtained DNA from them. It would have just prevented confirmation.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by scarface74 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:21AM (#19952960)
Well. I’ve told my wife to get rid of my body as cheaply as possible if I die first. I don’t care what happens to my body.

I also don’t really like the idea of traditional funerals. Even though it’s too much to ask, I would much rather for people to have a cookout or something more joyous to celebrate my life than a funeral with everyone in suits.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:32AM (#19953438)
No organ donation?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by scarface74 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:35AM (#19953462)
Sure. I signed up for organ donation.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:25AM (#19953728)
I think signing up for organ donation means you do care about what happens to your body. You care that someone gets something out of it!
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:46AM (#19953844)
I think it means you care about what happens to other people. Your body is just a means to an end.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by kurthr on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:32AM (#19953197)
If you were innocent, wouldn't you want your body exhumed so that people didn't assume you were guilty and the victim's family could have closure?

I guess if one was guilty and dead with other living accomplices...

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:39AM (#19953222)
If you were innocent and japanese, and the state would like to round up all japanese people in an internment camp, wouldn't you like the state to not be able to use your dna to find all your descendants and family?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by dd36 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @11:15PM (#19951216)
Well, could they sue your estate or assets that were inherited by your family?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:05AM (#19951556)
"When I'm dead, just throw me in the trash"

-Diogenes of Sinope

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by vixen99 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:52AM (#19951696)
This was the wish also of Hugh Everett, proponent of the many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory. He wanted his body to be thrown out with the garbage. Following his death and cremation this is apparently what happened when his wife decided to honor his request.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by ekianjo on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:12AM (#19952146)
> If you’re dead, what do you care what happens to your remains?

Consider how your family members might feel about it? It's not just about dead you.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by qwsxyh on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:13AM (#19952151)
It is only about dead me. It's my body.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by evgen on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:11AM (#19952701)
Once you are dead it is no longer your body. The dead have no rights. None whatsoever.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:33AM (#19953447)
Might be a technicality thing, but with that logic as soon as you are dead all your estate is up for grabs by anyone.

If your body is your posession like your house or your car, then you have the right to do what you want with it.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by evgen on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:33PM (#19954103)
It is up for grabs. Die as the victim of a violent crime and guess how much power your estate has to prevent an autopsy. Die of a virulent communicable disease and guess how much power your estate has to prevent your body from being cremated and the pathogens within rendered as inert as possible.

Your body is your possession like your house or your car, and I am sure you can image how often a clear legal directive like a will is placed before a state body like a court and judgement passed.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by balt_s on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:51AM (#19953561)
This is a faith statement not based in objective fact. Materialism has this to say about the dead; other religions express their beliefs differently.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by evgen on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:38PM (#19954121)
This is not a statement of faith, it is a statement of law. Once you are dead you have no rights and any possessions, claims, and liabilities pass to that legal fiction we call your estate. Perhaps there is some non-Western culture that handles things differently, but other than the estate being more of a familial construct rather than a legal one in some instances I am not aware of any deviations from this of any significance and look forward to being shown a counter-example.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:46AM (#19953848)
Objective fact has provided a ton of evidence for materialism and very little for any alternative.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by bpchaps on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:21AM (#19952175)
Do you seriously think that you're the only person who cares about what happens to your body after you die? Would you be perfectly okay if somebody dug up your mother's body and did $AWFUL_THING with it?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by nosianu on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:35AM (#19952392)
How about we stick to the topic at hand or at least in its vicinity instead of building "insert some very imaginative and awful story that is meant to appeal to emotion but has no basis in the topic being discussed" straw man?
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by scarface74 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:22AM (#19952962)
I can’t say I would care, it’s just a body.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by qwsxyh on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:24AM (#19952968)
Yeah, I wouldn't give a shit. She would be dead.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by vkou on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:33AM (#19951445)
> If you’re dead, what do you care what happens to your remains?

Because our society believes in body autonomy, to the point that it won't use your body's organs to save other human beings, without your express consent.

Your body is your property, and it takes a damn good reason for someone else to access your property, contrary to your will.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by jacquesm on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:52AM (#19951850)
> it won't use your body's organs to save other human beings, without your express consent

No longer true here in NL:

https://edition.cnn.com/2018/02/14/health/new-dutch-law-orga...

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:36AM (#19953470)
I blame the Predictably Irrational guy for making opt out so popular world-wide.

I personally find it abhorrent. I used to be an organ donor before they made it opt-out in argentina: after that in protest I took myself out.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by licebmi__at__ on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:34AM (#19953776)
Can you elaborate about this? I can't really see reasons for outside of superstition and clinging to false hopes to be against it being opt out; and even on an opt out system, I find that doctors still "request" the permissions to the family because no one wants to deal with unnecessary legal trouble.

Even following the anti authoritarian reasoning, which I'm kind of fond, I find it silly to worry about this, with all the stuff the state decides over your life.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:35PM (#19954110)
It reverts the burden of proof. It is now on you and your family to prove otherwise.

> I find that doctors still "request" the permissions to the family because no one wants to deal with unnecessary legal trouble.

Until they don't need to. In argentina for example, the legal requirement of getting consent from family members was lifted with the introduction of the opt-out. Funny thing about the opt-out, its an online registration!

I've seen opt-out described as a "libertarian paternalism" proposal to say that you have the liberty to choose anything but that there is an opinionated default. I find such reasoning to always lead to a death by a thousand cuts: if every single policy was implemented opt-out, you would definitely be able to manipulate the population into something.

> with all the stuff the state decides over your life.

I worry about any of them. And I don't find it comforting at all to argue that because individual liberties are breached many times, whats does one more stripe do to the tiger.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:40PM (#19954417)
There’s always an opinionated default about everything. Having the default be no organ donation is as much a decision of the state as having the default be the opposite.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:38PM (#19955679)
I think I understand the general point, but in this particular case the default is obviously you can't mess with a dead body.

You can't go to a cemetery and dig up corpses because "they didn't opt-out of grave-robbery". I would say that the body naturally falls under the concept of private property, which is why it is heinous to desecrate bodies and their belongings when people die.

What's crazy to me is that this problem looks so easy to resolve: if you want organ donors, pay for them. A form of reverse insurance: that will get you people in.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:58PM (#19955784)
What makes it obvious? Just because it has usually been done that way in the past?

Paying for organ donors comes with a host of problems. It’s far from easy.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:34PM (#19956859)
Because you wouldn't take things from a corpse in any other situation, as it is considered unsacred (disrespectful to the body) and robbery (say, take the shoes & wallet of a recently diseased person).

> Paying for organ donors comes with a host of problems. It’s far from easy.

Nobel prizes have been awarded on one solution to this problem alone!

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by icebraining on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:26AM (#19952370)
Yeah, opt-out is quite common nowadays - Spain, Portugal, Croatia, Belgium, Austria, Colombia, Chile, etc. I think in some cases the family must still be consulted.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by Doubl on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:29AM (#19952990)
People in persistent vegetative states or even comas are likely to become rarer in such countries, I'd suspect.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by icebraining on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:44AM (#19953243)
Well, it's been 25 years since the system was implemented in Portugal, and they've only increased.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:49AM (#19953867)
Is that supposed to be a bad thing? If I were in such a state with no hope of recovery, I’d want to die ASAP.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by Fnoord on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:48AM (#19952630)
> Because our society believes in body autonomy, to the point that it won't use your body's organs to save other human beings, without your express consent.

> Your body is your property, and it takes a damn good reason for someone else to access your property, contrary to your will.

The way I see it, we're a guest on the planet, and after we are done for, there's a few things we leave behind: our direct ancestors (family), our indirect ancestors (mankind) and our planet as a whole (Earth with its inhabitants) many of whom are important for the planet's ecosystem. We should ensure that after we are done for, these living organisms survive and lead a happy and healthy life.

Now, I'm of the opinion that our justice system is relevant for society. It allows Earth's inhabitants to lead a happy and healthy life. This is particularly true for crimes such as murder/killing which have a deep impact on society. So if this heavy crime can be solved using the help of a deceased one, I'm all for that. Even if it involves force or naysayers.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:38AM (#19953488)
If the host is the planet, what is the claim on the other guests to your body.

There is a great danger in the state being able to use dna this way: it is against privacy, and privacy is a tool against attacks on liberty. It is also a tool for crime.

You can't live free without crime. Once the state has this information, it can only be used against you, not in your favor.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by glennpratt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:49PM (#19954769)
> You can't live free without crime. Once the state has this information, it can only be used against you, not in your favor.

I understand there is risk, all things have potential extremes, but the idea that data on me can only be used against me is false on it's face.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by evgen on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:14AM (#19952715)
Your body is your property up until the point when you die. Once you are dead you no longer have rights and your body becomes the property of your estate, a much weaker claim than body autonomy and one that the state can trump for a variety of reasons.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:48AM (#19953858)
Our society also believes that probable cause and a warrant qualify as “a damn good reason.”
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by Doubl on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:23AM (#19952964)
I wish that were really true for all humans
[dead]
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by seniorivn on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:53AM (#19951700)
Or if you refuse to get medical treatment like vaccination
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by scarface74 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:24AM (#19952967)
Well as long as you stay in your house by yourself and don’t infect other people, you can do whatever you want. Also, don’t send your kids to school.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by firstplacelast on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:05AM (#19951723)
I love that this is downvoted. LOL. I'm all for vaccination, but you are 100% correct.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by thaumasiotes on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:09AM (#19951899)
https://reason.com/2019/05/10/broader-implications-of-my-bod...

The list is pretty extensive. Women aren't exactly being singled out for special treatment overall, though they certainly are in multiple specifics.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by stephenr on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:30AM (#19951793)
Show me a child who can make an informed decision about vaccinations.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by hrktb on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:32AM (#19952578)
It’s just moving the issue to the family. Cremating a body basically became a privacy/security best practice I guess.
[dead]
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by seniorivn on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:55AM (#19951703)
It does because those are two different crimes in a row, but for the people it doesn't really matter.