News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:35PM (#19954110)
It reverts the burden of proof. It is now on you and your family to prove otherwise.

> I find that doctors still "request" the permissions to the family because no one wants to deal with unnecessary legal trouble.

Until they don't need to. In argentina for example, the legal requirement of getting consent from family members was lifted with the introduction of the opt-out. Funny thing about the opt-out, its an online registration!

I've seen opt-out described as a "libertarian paternalism" proposal to say that you have the liberty to choose anything but that there is an opinionated default. I find such reasoning to always lead to a death by a thousand cuts: if every single policy was implemented opt-out, you would definitely be able to manipulate the population into something.

> with all the stuff the state decides over your life.

I worry about any of them. And I don't find it comforting at all to argue that because individual liberties are breached many times, whats does one more stripe do to the tiger.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:40PM (#19954417)
There’s always an opinionated default about everything. Having the default be no organ donation is as much a decision of the state as having the default be the opposite.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:38PM (#19955679)
I think I understand the general point, but in this particular case the default is obviously you can't mess with a dead body.

You can't go to a cemetery and dig up corpses because "they didn't opt-out of grave-robbery". I would say that the body naturally falls under the concept of private property, which is why it is heinous to desecrate bodies and their belongings when people die.

What's crazy to me is that this problem looks so easy to resolve: if you want organ donors, pay for them. A form of reverse insurance: that will get you people in.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by mikeash on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:58PM (#19955784)
What makes it obvious? Just because it has usually been done that way in the past?

Paying for organ donors comes with a host of problems. It’s far from easy.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:34PM (#19956859)
Because you wouldn't take things from a corpse in any other situation, as it is considered unsacred (disrespectful to the body) and robbery (say, take the shoes & wallet of a recently diseased person).

> Paying for organ donors comes with a host of problems. It’s far from easy.

Nobel prizes have been awarded on one solution to this problem alone!