News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by dd36 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:34PM (#19950097)
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by whyenot on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:47PM (#19950144)
Your link is to what is represented as the authentic text of the memo. If genuine, to me, this seem like the most important bit:

"It is important to bear in mind that we lost $700 million in the first quarter this year, which is over $200 million per month. Investors nonetheless were supportive of our efforts and agreed to give us $2.4 billion (our net proceeds) to show that we can be financially sustainable.

That is a lot of money, but actually only gives us approximately ten months at the first-quarter burn rate to achieve breakeven. It’s vital that we respect the faith investors have shown in Tesla, but it will require great effort to do so."

With relatively low gas prices at the moment, decreasing federal subsidies for electric cars, and more players entering the market, it seems like Tesla is in a pretty tough spot.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by mikeash on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:34PM (#19950585)
Seems like gas prices are currently around the ten year average: https://www.gasbuddy.com/Charts

I’m not sure that gas prices matter all that much to Tesla though. Even with the low-end Model 3, it’s tough to save money over an efficient gas car. Tesla’s appeal is based more on their cars being fun, quick, quiet, clean, practical, and technologically sophisticated.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by charlesdm on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:52PM (#19950170)
> With relatively low gas prices at the moment, decreasing federal subsidies for electric cars, and more players entering the market, it seems like Tesla is in a pretty tough spot.

Nothing you couldn't see coming 5 years ago, however.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by melling on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:39PM (#19950354)
6 months ago Musk said they would profitable going forward.

The trade war might be part of the problem. They need to get the Shanghai factory online.

https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/tesla-hurt-by-trade-war/

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by Shivetya on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:45PM (#19950388)
If they would focus on building cars they might have been there but they are betting the farm on FSD and its that short term push that might end up hurting the most.

Plus as an owner, their priorities are just whack. Next update we get a Sentry icon on the main display and, wait for it, animation of rain on the car if its raining. I guess that is better than video games.

A Toyota Camry, scratch that, Corolla, can respond to more voice commands than my TM3 and best yet, you can select through blue tooth or USB the music play list you want to play, and more, all without having to use your phone which is illegal in most states.

So love the car but I have my doubts about Tesla's ability to focus on what is required instead of pissing away resources on Easter Eggs like fart noises; I wish I were kidding

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by dd36 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:05AM (#19951371)
I think you’re overestimating FSD current vs. sunk costs. They’re not betting the farm unless you mean the model 3 lease return but that can always change.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by asaph on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:10PM (#19950234)
To be fair, the current competition is largely a reaction to Tesla's accomplishments.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by rayiner on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:24PM (#19950291)
I question that CW. If that were true, the competitors would be making sporty sedans like Tesla. But almost none are. The competitors—the Bolt, Kona, etc., are all totally different form factors.

The alternative, potentially better, theory is that everyone is reacting to the same incentives and market structures. Governments are pushing electric vehicles through subsidies and mandates. Meanwhile, exploding use of portable electronics has led to massive improvements lithium ion battery technology. Tesla has targeted a flashy niche market, expensive sports sedans, but has largely avoided trying to compete in the markets where the sales really are: crossovers and SUVs. (Every year, Toyota sells as many RAV4s as all the vehicles Tesla has ever sold.)

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:06PM (#19950477)
The Model 3 and even the X can barely be considered expensive sport sedans. The first is a low end lux compact, the second is an expensive SUV or crossover. Only the model S is in that category.

In Beijing, I saw a lot of Model S’s on the road in the year before I left. These people would have been driving Audi A5+ or an S-class if it wasn’t for Beijing’s plate lottery (you can get a car quicker if it’s an EV). As far as that goes, the Model S is a good strategy outside of the USA where people aren’t so SUV crazed.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by Retric on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:33PM (#19950331)
Their are plenty of cars like Aston Martin Rapid E, Mercedes-Benz EQC, Audi E-Tron, and Jaguar I-Pace aiming up market.

Tesla is maintaining a brand halo by keeping a reasonable minimum range, but the base Model 3 is relatively inexpensive compared to many competitors.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by trimbo on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:43PM (#19950377)
> Governments are pushing electric vehicles through subsidies and mandates

Specifically, isn't this because of CAFE[1]? Gas mileage compliance is calculated per manufacturer. So BMW can keep selling 17mpg M3s as long as they're selling enough of those i3s[2]

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_econom

[2] - Which sell for $50K but are like $15K used!

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by yboris on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:01PM (#19950928)
Thanks for sharing the i3 used cost tidbit! Can confirm -- just found a 2015 one with only 40,000 miles for about $15,000 https://www.carfax.com/vehicle/WBY1Z4C58FV502306

Any comment on whether it's a car that would last to 150,000 miles? I see a warranty of "guaranteed at least 70% capacity for 8 years or 100,000 miles".

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by eropple on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:40PM (#19950609)
You can find an i3 for $15K used? Where? Carfax has like $24K at minimum for a 2017.

Edit: NM, had to widen my search params. I dunno if I'd want to trust a 2015 electric car, though. ;)

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by trimbo on Saturday May 18, 2019 @11:20PM (#19951236)
FWIW there were at least 2 <$20K at my local dealer when I checked it out in the winter or fall. Maybe people have caught onto the cheap i3 thing.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by windexh8er on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:48PM (#19950407)
This is my foundational fear of losing Tesla. Love them or hate them if they were to sink I feel the large drive to compete with them goes away and we go back to business as usual burning dead dinosaurs. While Tesla isn't perfect by any stretch I do think they continue to be very important to the overall market progression and higher expectations of auto manufacturers.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by jjeaff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:46PM (#19950644)
Is there really a large drive to compete with them? So far they have proven that unit profitability is difficult if not impossible with current tech.

And meanwhile, Ford is selling a quarter million F-150 trucks every quarter compared to Teslas total units per quarter around 40k. I don't think the big automakers are worried yet.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by windexh8er on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:20PM (#19951017)
There is. Buyers of an F150 are not buyers of any Tesla product. Ford just invested heavily in Rivian [0]. That's Tesla's backyard for sure and is a departure from those buyers of the F150.

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/24/business/ford-rivian-inve...

While maybe not "worried" Ford sees a risk.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by Barrin92 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:05PM (#19950471)
Self driving and electric cars have been in development for a long time. Mercedes Benz in the 1980s was testing automated driving on empty streets in Munich.

The difference between Tesla and others isn't that Tesla somehow was the first to come up with these ideas, they were the first to attempt to run a car company like a startup and marketing themselves as a disruptor.

Which in a sense is true because it brought the products to the forefront, but there's a reason that hadn't happened before, because a car manufacturer actually needs to make money on the existing markets. No use in pushing a good idea before the time is right.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by MaupitiBlue on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:05PM (#19953962)
>To be fair, the current competition is largely a reaction to Tesla's accomplishments.

Does it really matter?

Tesla is doomed. It’s run out of early adopters and its cool factor is diminishing. The last quarter’s results indicate that demand is down. Supply issues can be spun as a positive, but if demand is weakening...

Combine that with increased competition from a half dozen well established players and the writing is on the wall.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by soup10 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:44PM (#19950385)
The domestic oil boom and the fact that we are now a net exporter of oil makes the transition to electric cars less urgent.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by atq2119 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:57PM (#19950447)
This ignores the fact that EVs are currently the only viable path towards road-based transport that is compatible with the continued existence of our species.

The transition isn't urgent due to oil prices. It's urgent due to greenhouse gases making the planet inhospitable for humans.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:08PM (#19950485)
Maybe less urgent now? And let’s not forget many other countries with 2030 commitments to going pure EV.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by barney54 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:33PM (#19950582)
There are also fuel cell vehicles such as the Honda Clarity, Toyota Mirai, and Hyundai Nexo.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by moneytide1 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @11:15PM (#19951221)
Musk has said that hydrogen is foolish. I can understand that angle, because the concussive blast from compressed hydrogen ignition would be more dangerous than a lithium fire.

But a hydrogen economy feels like it could work when scaled up. Somehow it feels practical as the most abundant element in the universe, with high energy density. Lithium/cobalt reserves are limited, though recycling measures might could solve that problem.

Platinum-group element coated electrodes powered by ~25 year life spans of cadmium/tellurium solar cells (or Perovskite, and many others I'm sure, but Cd/Te is the one I've deployed en masse personally) would allow for low maintenance hydrogen generation and a shift away from natural gas sourcing.

Nafion is necessary for the fuel cells themselves but I'm not sure about the production process behind that.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by soup10 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:41AM (#19953233)
"less urgent" doesn't mean its not important at all. When we were constantly at the brink of war and supporting all kinds of terrible governments to secure stable access to oil and keep the petrodollar intact.. There was more pressure to quickly develop alternatives to oil.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by MaupitiBlue on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:11PM (#19953999)
Hasn’t the sky is falling meme lost most of its traction over the last few years?
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by cosmodisk on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:40PM (#19950610)
Oh,is that so? Try to guess where's the electricity coming and the inpact it has on environment.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by jjeaff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:54PM (#19950670)
Depends on where you live. If Vermont, more than 90% of their grid is powered by renewables and other non carbon sources like nuclear.

Not to mention that the equivalent mpg for a Tesla is 100mpg.

Add to that the fact that mass produced grid electricity is massively more efficient and clean than everyone generating energy themselves. (ala internal combustion engine).

It would be like saying that everyone having their own gas generator at home is just as bad as having a single gas power plant that powers the grid.

Sure, there are other sources of pollution like the batteries but "all in", electric cars are still significantly better for the environment.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by ummonk on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:24PM (#19950543)
You seem to have a very low opinion of human adaptability to varying climates.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by newnewpdro on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:44PM (#19950629)
If a bulk of the species living on the planet collapse from climate change, humans will not be having a good time.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by csours on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:11PM (#19950237)
Gas prices are highly volatile
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by m0zg on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:32PM (#19950572)
5 years ago "gas will be $5 a gallon" would seem like a very safe bet.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by _-david-_ on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:48AM (#19953860)
It is not that far off. Gas is over $4 a gallon in Southern California. I paid $4.15 last time I filled up.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by jjeaff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:56PM (#19950685)
Not to anyone who understands economics and/or has followed the historical rise and fall of gas prices.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by hef19898 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:41AM (#19952022)
Shit, that would mean, if read it correctly, that the 2.4 billion gave Tesla a runway of 10 months. Starting now. But that would mean that Tesla was almost bankrupt when the money was raised? Or do I interpret that completely wrong?
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by Matt3o12_ on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:26PM (#19950302)
A bit later in the thread the poster also states a pretty good explanation:

> A lot of FUD from the media said Elon stated they will only have 10 months left before cash balance is zero. No where in this letter stated such a thing and Elon just used an arbitrary number(in this case the newly raised capital) to express the point that 2.4 billion may seem like a lot of money, but we shouldn't take it for granted. In fact their cash balance is most likely over 4 billion.

> This letter to me shows the maturity of a company. Elon is telling his team that just because I can raise 2.4 billion whenever I want doesn't mean money is falling from the sky. Everyone must continue to be vigilant about cost cutting, and we must prove to our investors that we will take cost cutting seriously.

> From Q1 conference call, Elon alluded that the reason why he is against raising capital all the time is because he wants to focus on cost cutting as the primary objective. So his letter does not seem anything out of the ordinary. > So no, the sky is not falling.

> https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/bq50s8/elons_a...

So it sounds to me that Elon musk does not want Tesla to burn money like Uber. He says they most certainly could, but he would rather focus on cost cutting. This seems to be a very mature reaction, something every mature company does. This makes Tesla less and less like a startup and more like a mature company. Granted, they are not there yet but I believe they could be there very soon.

Elon Musk also always makes things “hardcore”, or more extreme then a normal company would do. Instead of cost cutting over years, he wants it done fast but might underestimate the time it actually takes to achieve his goal. We have seen that move from him many times, when a released the model 3, he gave a very very optimistic release timeline. While he missed it, it was still a lot faster then his original plan to release it in 2020 and still faster then a lot people estimated. While this doesn’t always work out (like his autopilot goals), by setting such hard goals and deadlines, things move much faster then they normally would. Only time can tell if his cost cutting plan actually works but he has shown that such extreme actions can often lead to much better results because everyone wakes up and doesn’t just put it on goals for the next 3 to 5 years list.

That being said, I am not really worried about Tesla. They have shown that they are able to get a lot more money if necessary and their demand is still going strong. The competition doesn’t look very promising (the audi E-Tron is often compared to the 2013 model S, and while it is most certainly superior in some aspects, I believe Tesla is still a few years ahead from the competition).

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by fullshark on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:52PM (#19950428)
> their demand is still going strong.

This is what's not clear, and a major risk factor for them. I think Musk views 35k as the inflection point where quantity demanded sky rockets and he's not been able to get there. Seems like a lot of decisions were made based on assuming that would happen by 2019.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by ksherlock on Saturday May 18, 2019 @08:27PM (#19950554)
The $35k model 3 does exist (well, $35.4k after last week's price bump). But it's a software limited version of the $40k SR+ model and it's not listed on the website and you have to talk to person to order it who will probably try to upsell you as if their job depended on it.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by sjg007 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:49PM (#19950891)
What are the limits?
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by hawaiianbrah on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:55PM (#19951151)
The range is software limited.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by confiscate on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:48PM (#19950886)
Agree. Do you think price is the limiting factor for lackluster demand? Maybe if they can make model 3 cheaper than 35k demand will rise
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by fullshark on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:50AM (#19951508)
I"m not sure, but i think there was a lot of pent up demand for a high end electrical car, they're in the process of serving that demand globally, and then what? Do deliveries plateau or even drop? There's stories about it dropping already, at least for the models S and X.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by philipodonnell on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:48AM (#19953546)
> A lot of FUD from the media said Elon stated they will only have 10 months left before cash balance is zero. No where in this letter stated such a thing and Elon just used an arbitrary number(in this case the newly raised capital) to express the point that 2.4 billion may seem like a lot of money, but we shouldn't take it for granted. In fact their cash balance is most likely over 4 billion.

10 months is a weird number and frequency for someone to pull out of a hat arbitrarily, especially the CEO of a public company. Something that lined up with a quarter or a year, ok, but 10 months? Why not 3 quarters, or less than a year?

You get to 10 months when you have a monthly burn rate in mind and you divide that by your available cash and it says 10.

Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by JohnJamesRambo on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:40PM (#19950119)
Yikes. It’s bizarre that they just now realize this and implement it. Reminds me of something a teenager would do at the last possible minute before something bad happens.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by davej on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:55PM (#19950184)
I didn’t read it like that. I read it more like... yes, we just got some money from investors but the drive for profitability is still a huge priority.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by TAForObvReasons on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:06PM (#19950223)
This type of belt tightening message also usually predates a mass layoff
[dead]
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by TAForObvReasons on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:00PM (#19950205)
Irrespective of the technical merits, a significant portion of the HN user base likely invested in $TSLA years ago and are financially incentivized to support all of Musk's claims, even if they wouldn't support the outlandish claims normally.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by goatherders on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:14PM (#19950250)
There is no evidence at all for the assertion that "a significant portion of the HN user" base is invested in anything.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by jjeaff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:49PM (#19950415)
Considering that a large portion of HN readers are technical and data driven, I would think/hope that they are not invested in individual stocks with any significant amount of their net worth and are instead taking the approach that the data bears out which is to invest in low fee index funds.
Re:Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cuttin... by unityByFreedom on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:55PM (#19950438)
I suspect those invested one way or another will be more vocal.