News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by Shivetya on Friday May 17, 2019 @05:24AM (#19937778)
As an owner and autonomous driving fan I keep asking the same question. Will autonomous cars be legislated to always obey the law or will that still be a judgment left to the driver if the car can be driven either way.

I am surprised there are not laws to have cars alert you to the fact your speeding for the systems that can read speed limit signs in addition to have current maps.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by gambiting on Friday May 17, 2019 @05:52AM (#19937937)
>>I am surprised there are not laws to have cars alert you to the fact your speeding for the systems that can read speed limit signs in addition to have current maps.

Well, there are systems that do this. Many new cars have speed limit sign recognition built in and they will display the current limit on the dashboard(and sometimes show you an icon indicating that the vehicle thinks you are speeding).

The reason why this is not more aggressive is because it's only seemingly a simple problem - in reality it's far far from it. In my experience of driving around the EU - I had a Mercedes CLS(brand new 2019 model) with adaptive cruise control and speed limit signs recognition, and while amazing when it worked, it worked maybe 50% of the time. Issues I noticed:

1) it kept detecting speed limit signs on roads parallel to the one I was on [0]

2) it kept detecting speed limit signs on side roads - leading to actual dangerous situations, because I was on a 50mph road, going past a 20mph side street and the car would suddenly hit the brakes because it detected a 20mph speed limit. That's 10000% unnacceptable in a production vehicle. [1]

3) it kept reading speed limit signs on the slip roads leaving the motorway - so you're doing 70mph on the motorway, and it suddenly reads the 50mph speed limit that's for the motorway exit. Same problem as with point 2.

4) In situations where there are no speed limit signs, it would use the map data - and even though this was a brand new, March 2019 vehicle, it had no idea that a stretch of motorway next to my house is not limited to 50mph anymore, and hasn't been for the last 2 years.

In practice, I had to keep overriding the speed limit chosen by the car constantly, and after few days I switched it fully off as it led to me nearly shitting my pants as the car hit the brakes for seemingly no reason whatsoever few times.

And then I have concerns about countries where the speed limit is only valid to the nearest intersection - and the definition of an intersection varies. There are paved roads merging with the main road which are not intersections because the side road leads to private property, and then there are dirt tracks which are intersections because technically it's a public road open to motor traffic. There are no signs to indicate either - the driver is just "supposed to know". It's idiotic, I know. And in some countries(Poland) the speed limit can change as often as 4-5 times in a span of a single kilometre. What's even worse is that there are situations when the speed limit can actually increase(!!!!) the speed limit set in a certain zone(built-up zones have a 50km/h speed limit, but this can be increased by a regular speed limit sign - and then yes, it goes back down(!!!) to 50km/h after an intersection). All of this stuff would be incredibly hard to code into a system like this, and it's one of the reasons why I suspect the proposal made by EU to have automatic speed limiters built into cars will either fail, or people will just keep disabling it altogether, making the whole idea pointless.

[0] Here it would think the side road has a speed limit of 50mph, because it would read the wrong sign:

https://www.google.pl/maps/@54.9929676,-1.5788994,3a,75y,78....

[1] Here for example the 20mph sign is placed at an angle to the road, so the car would read it going past it - and set the adaptive cruise control to 20mph which is incorrect for this street:

https://www.google.pl/maps/@55.0074774,-1.615172,3a,41.3y,90...

Same here:

https://www.google.pl/maps/@55.0071611,-1.6214135,3a,75y,240...

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by tomp on Friday May 17, 2019 @06:51AM (#19938263)
Not to mention that "speed limit recognition" is a huge waste of resources in the era of GPS. If countries want that, they should just keep an up-to-date database of roads with their speed limits, and update that appropriately. Alternatively, companies could drive cars around (like Google does for its Maps), run speed limit recognition, do manual adjustments, and upload that to their online maps.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by gambiting on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:12AM (#19938384)
Well.....I wouldn't trust that either.

My sister has an insurance policy with a tracker(because she's quite young and there was no other option for her) and one day we noticed that her insurance score has fallen down through the floor, hugely negative points for....speeding. Of course the website doesn't tell you where or when, just that you're being penalized for being naughty. Ok, so we call them up, and they say they will send us the exact coordinates where the "offence" happened. Ok, cool - and turns out that they thought she was driving 70mph on a road going next to the motorway - which had a 20mph speed limit. Which was literally physically impossible, as previous GPS points were showing her on the motorway and there was no direct exit to that smaller 20mph road. So the GPS was off by maybe 10-20 metres at most, but the insurance has automatically penalized her massively for speeding. What's stopping the same system from failing when used for automatic speed limit adjustment? Especially in some extremely dense cities where you literally have roads of varying speed limits overlapping each other.

The insurer did correct that score penalty manually after I complained. But it's still a joke that it could make that mistake in the first place, especially since they can literally cancel your insurance due to speeding.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by neffy on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:39AM (#19938541)
Unfortunately, you really can't solve these kinds of questions with the full on deterministic approach. The world is big, speed limits change, databases have to be updated.

Google maps was (dangerously in the winter) directing people to an old road, into mountains after a new one had been built. It took national news, and several months of attempts to get them to update it.

The just build a big very accurate database approach is the one I would absolutely guarantee will never work.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by rayiner on Friday May 17, 2019 @09:00AM (#19939095)
Google also for a long time didn’t properly account for Rock Creek Parkway in DC going from one-way south, to bidirectional, to one-way north depending on the time of day. Also, it still doesn’t realize that the street I live on is a pedestrian street with car barriers at every other intersection. (You have to drive down the correct subdivision road from the main road, instead of just getting into the subdivision and expecting to be able to drive down the pedestrian road to the right house.) So Uber drivers will constantly call me saying they are stuck and can’t figure out how to get to me house. (The road was turned into a pedestrian road maybe 5-7 years ago now.)
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by londons_explore on Friday May 17, 2019 @09:36AM (#19939445)
Roads which have restrictions changing on a hourly/daily basis google doesn't understand, but there will be a warning in the directions ('this route contains private or restricted roads').

If there is something out of date, hit the report button and it's typically acknowledged immediately, confirmed in a few hours, and public within a few days.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by rayiner on Friday May 17, 2019 @10:01AM (#19939671)
Google recognizes it now, but it took years. (For a major thoroughfare in the nation’s capital.) Just reinforcing OP’s point that you can’t rely on the map being up to date.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by DFHippie on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:10AM (#19938374)
You still need to deal with temporary speed limits in construction zones.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by maccard on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:13AM (#19938391)
And smart motorways
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by kwhitefoot on Friday May 17, 2019 @12:06PM (#19940871)
And AP1 does that perfectly.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by cesarb on Friday May 17, 2019 @11:11AM (#19940322)
> and it's one of the reasons why I suspect the proposal made by EU to have automatic speed limiters built into cars will either fail, or people will just keep disabling it altogether, making the whole idea pointless.

If it's a proposal by the government, they could do better: they could mandate not only automatic speed limiters, but also something embedded in the roads like balises (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balise) to reliably indicate to the car the correct speed limit.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by kwhitefoot on Friday May 17, 2019 @12:05PM (#19940860)
My 2015 S 70D is much better at recognizing speed limits than your Mercedes. Gets it wrong rarely and in fact notices signs that I miss. There is one parallel road where it persistently incorrectly recognizes the speed limit as belong to the road I am on bt that's just one out of many of thousands of km of road that I have driven in the car over the last 18 months.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by tjtrapp on Friday May 17, 2019 @08:53AM (#19939032)
> Many new cars have speed limit sign recognition built in and they will display the current limit on the dashboard

Tesla Model 3 has this feature and, while autopilot is engaged, will decrease the speed of the car when the speed limit decreases.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by gambiting on Friday May 17, 2019 @08:55AM (#19939044)
So, just like that Mercedes CLS I was talking about. It will keep itself in its lane and slow down for any speed limit that it detects. My point of that entire wall of text was that this detection of limits is unreliable, because in real life the signs are sometimes placed in such a way that the cameras detect them as applying for the road you are currently on while in reality they do not.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by plttn on Friday May 17, 2019 @11:15AM (#19940373)
Eh not quite. Only HW1 Model S did the sign recognition based on camera, HW2+ currently just uses GPS database.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by kristopolous on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:18AM (#19938421)
I'm only half joking when I call for a bloodlust dial with a murder level on it.

The core idea is to continue to grant enough agency to the operator that they are held responsible as long as the vehicle faithfully executed the intent.

The tongue and cheek bloodsport throttle in the real world would instead be a proactive user choice of how much human guidance and interaction is required (solving the handoff problem, for example, 1 minute automatic, 1 minute manual or an automatic system that you'll need to irritatingly press a button every few minutes to stay engaged).

If a user options for "zero engagement" (let's pretend they're drunk or just got out of surgery), then there has to be a visceral experience of the underlying risks; a constant beeping and flashing, some real sense of urgency and warning.

I know it's a luxury product but cars are machines of carnage where death is never more than a mistake and mere seconds away. That reality should supercede.

This may be eventually removed, but a system like this would honestly solve all the current issues

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by noxToken on Friday May 17, 2019 @09:01AM (#19939100)
>an automatic system that you'll need to irritatingly press a button every few minutes to stay engaged

Just like trains! There is an alarm system just as you describe. After a certain amount of time, there are audio and visual warnings for the engineer. The engineer must engage the switch to "snooze" the alarm, and in the event that the engineer does not engage, the train automatically cuts power to throttle to brake.

I'm not sure flashing lights and a klaxon are what we would want in a car, but maybe beeping akin to lane assist that quickly increases in volume + a light on the dash would be a good start.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by Domenic_S on Friday May 17, 2019 @11:41AM (#19940648)
It works that way in a Tesla. If the system doesn't detect your hands on the wheel (using rotational force on the steering wheel as a proxy), first a message appears on the screen, then seconds later the screen flashes blue, then a few seconds later the volume on the radio is lowered and the car beeps at you urgently. If you still don't touch the wheel, a few seconds later the hazard lights come on and the car slows to a stop.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by londons_explore on Friday May 17, 2019 @09:32AM (#19939408)
> I am surprised there are not laws to have cars alert you to the fact you['re] speeding

Europe is mandating this (combined with limiting) for new cars soon. It will be possible to override 'temporarily'.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by CydeWeys on Friday May 17, 2019 @05:46AM (#19937911)
It seems inevitable that autonomous vehicles will be required to obey speed limits in the future. The question in my mind is will it be the same speed limits as for humans?
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by gambiting on Friday May 17, 2019 @06:04AM (#19938004)
Yes, because:

1) I don't believe we'll go "autonomous cars only" for predictable future. I can see that happening on limited set of streets(say, strict city centres), but not overall. Mostly because I think requiring everyone to buy an autonomous car is ridiculous, and then there are cars made even right now that I can totally see people driving in 20/30/50 years from now. We'll always allow manual cars on the road, just like we still allow horses - it just became so rare that in practice it's not an issue to have an animal with no safety features on the road next to modern motor vehicles.

2) there will always be users of the road that cannot be made automous - motorcycles. Unless you believe that motorcycles will be banned, but I don't think that will happen.

So yes, I think any speed limits of the future will be set for humans first and foremost. I do look forward to those speed limits to be revised up though - cars are far safer and more efficient at higher speeds than they were few decades ago, and yet speed limits have never been revised to reflect that. US is particularly bad at this, with empty stretches of straight road having a speed limit of 50mph for instance. That should have been fixed years ago.

Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by tastroder on Friday May 17, 2019 @06:01AM (#19937990)
I don't see how that is even a question without 100% autonomy and proven above-human performance, human drivers on the same roads still have to react so different speed limits don't seem to make much sense.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by nightski on Friday May 17, 2019 @08:37AM (#19938897)
Well seeing as you can get a ticket for going at or under the speed limit in some major cities because it is a hazard that might be interesting.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by perl4ever on Friday May 17, 2019 @08:28PM (#19944819)
I believe the law in NY state uses the phrase "impeding traffic" and doesn't reference the speed limit. So (although I am not a lawyer) I imagine you could violate it whether you were going under, at, or over, the limit.
Re:Third fatal Tesla Autopilot crash renews questions about ... by cesarb on Friday May 17, 2019 @11:18AM (#19940402)
We already have different speed limits for different users in some highways (for instance, one major highway near where I live has a limit in some places of 110 km/h for cars and 90 km/h for trucks and buses), so there's precedent. But I believe that, at least initially, speed limits for self-driving vehicles will be lower.