News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by est31 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @12:43PM (#19911114)
It's very popular to criticize the Energiewende as a failure because it apparently failed to reduce CO2 emmissions of the whole country. And of course, it's true that Germany could have had greater reductions if nuclear was kept alive instead of coal. But the Energiewende actually changed Germany. Suddenly everywhere you go you have solar panel farms and many houses have them on their roofs and there are wind turbines. It was a cool time to live in germany to see these projects realized everywhere. They were done in an era where the price of renewables was very high compared to other technologies. The big contribution that Germany has done to the world with the Energiewende is:

* demonstrating that an industrialized nation actually can start a gradual transition towards renewables and most importantly

* by buying renewables at high prices, helping the manufacturers to get the price of renewables down. I think it's partially thanks to Germany that renewables have become the cheapest form of elecricity generation this fast, with impact observable around the globe!

From that second point alone I think the Energiewende should be considered a success. Could it have been better? Sure. Is it perfect? No. Do I like the high energy prices now? No. But I'm definitely glad we had it.

Also consider that we here Germany in fact do have a nuclear catastrophy right below our feet in the form of Asse 2.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by realusername on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:01PM (#19911258)
> But the Energiewende actually changed Germany. Suddenly everywhere you go you have solar panel farms and many houses have them on their roofs and there are wind turbines. It was a cool time to live in germany to see these projects realized everywhere

Does it really matter to see all those solar panel farms if the end result is they were not much helpful? The money which went into this is absolutely massive and could have been used in a better way to fight climate change.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:06PM (#19911306)
At least you can say that Germany kickstarted mass manufacturing of PV modules. So even if Germany itself didn't benefit, everybody else did. Including Chinese manufacturers. So I'd argue that the money was well invested.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sisu2019 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:22PM (#19911482)
and how are these PV users going to cover their baseload?
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:33PM (#19911631)
Long term? Some kind of storage solution in combination with hydro power and, my preference, natural gas as it burns much cleaner than coal.

Short to mid term? Same as above, only that storage will have to be replaced with something else. Since coal is clearly favoured by the system in Germany coal has to replaced by itself. Coal is just the worst alternative. Unfortunately nuclear is no option in Germany, until storage tech is sufficient it could nicely close the gap.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by vkou on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:17PM (#19912234)
Natural gas is not a sustainable long-term solution. World emissions need to be brought to zero, in the next five years, in order for us to avoid a climate castrophe.

If we are still positive at the five-year mark, that means zero at, say, the ten-year mark, and negative emissions for many decades.

Natural gas has no place in this long-term.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by imtringued on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @08:57PM (#19915405)
It's actually very sustainable. Renewable energy production follows a normal distribution. The natural gas plants won't have to produce more than 60% of the electricy during the 10 worst days of the entire year. Therefore a 90%+ reduction in emissions is possible without any storage system at all. Add power2gas technology which will be available over the next decade and it suddenly we are not only carbon neutral, we can also capture it. How are you going to store energy without using gas? Oh and did I mention that 10GW worth of natural gas plants costs less than a 1 GW nuclear power plant? Therefore not running natural gas plants most of the year is cost effective.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:41PM (#19913138)
Well, it has a place in the energy mix because modern gas power plants are incredibly fast to ramp up. So they are perfect to quickly stabilize the grid. As a base supplier not so much.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:37PM (#19913085)
"Natural gas has no place in this long-term."

Carbon sequestration is possibly a viable solution. There seem to be solutions in trial (there are numerous questions around it), and even with added costs of capture, it's considerably cheaper and more reliable than other form of energy - moreover, we have it in abundance.

Natural Gas is as viable for the horizon of our future we're able to predict.

In 100 years, every dimension of our tech will have changed so much it's hard to predict. Maybe we solve the nuclear wast problem. Maybe we get fusion. Maybe we have uber cheap solar. Maybe we have dirty easy sequestration. Maybe we have alternatives.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by ccffph on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:11PM (#19913405)
We have already solved the nuclear waste problem. The issue is that nobody wants to bury it in their backyard, so to speak. Waste containers are incredibly safe and secure, and modern fuel waste is much safer than gen 1 fuel waste. People like feel-good shiny solar panels and wind turbines over concrete near-zero emission solutions.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:35PM (#19913630)
We haven't solved the 'waste problem'.

1) Long term storage has some existential risks. Over very long time horizons, these risks become real.

2) Transportation, processing and storage: all of this operational stuff is totally ripe for accidents.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by wbl on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @08:23PM (#19915211)
It doesn't. The impact of radiation is a rise in cancer rates which even if they substantially shorten lifetimes aren't X risk.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @11:15PM (#19916104)
Your answer is basically 'radiation causes rise in cancer which can substantially reduce lifetimes is not a risk'.

I don't see how that's reasonable, I suggest you might have typed something incorrectly.

There are still quite a number of risks inherent in the Nuclear process that require only a few operational failures for disaster.

If very smart countries and operationally efficient countries like Japan screw up the risks, then anyone can. And that there were mitigating circumstances does not change the fact that Japan still had great governance and scientists and persisted with either risky models or a failure to measure the risk.

Basically, we'd need to suck the risk out of every part of the process in order for it to work well.

I think it's possible.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by adrianN on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:26AM (#19917399)
What's the existential risk? The absolute worst case that I can imagine is that all the waste somehow ends up in the ground water. That would be extremely bad, but localized to the area where the waste is stored.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sonnyblarney on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:05PM (#19922615)
Existential is as you mentioned: ground water pollution of the entire NE seaboard. Terrorist dirty bomb in NYC that affects 30 million people as the weather carries particles etc.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by ccffph on Friday May 17, 2019 @01:43PM (#19941844)
inverse square law and lack of any volume of any highly active source makes dirty bombs a nonissue. they are scarier than they are effective.

Again, waste storage is incredibly secure and safe. It wouldn't leech into the water. Nuclear subs have sank into the ocean, and, surprise, there wasn't a global disaster.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by jhayward on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:22PM (#19913511)
The concept of `baseload' is entirely a creation of the system of extremely large thermal plants that are essentially a path-dependent outcome of the electric grid's development. There is no intrinsic usefulness in the concept.

In other words it would be good to stop acting as though the only possible grid is one that looks exactly like the one that was developed in the early 1900's. There are many other arrangements of generation resources and economic structures to pay for them than the existing grid. That is what renewables are moving toward.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sisu2019 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:39PM (#19913655)
well we certaintly aren't moving towards that in Germany so I wonder where they actually are and what that looks like in reality. If everyone else is also just going to burn more coal than ever before all of this is nothing but a very expensive step backwards.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by jhayward on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:54PM (#19914228)
What makes you say that? Take a look at the summary in another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19913933

That looks like progress to me. Why do you say "everyone else is just going to burn more coal?"

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by rasz on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:34AM (#19919772)
They will power the infrastructure of the new Nord Stream 2 pipeline build against EU interests, obviously. That and strip mined Hambach forest.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by netsharc on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:39PM (#19911730)
I'm pretty sure if the survival of human race is at stake, money is no object. If someone in a foreign country invented a machine that everyone can buy to make themselves carbon-positive, the logical move for any government would be subsidize the purchase, even if that means great debt: but as the planet continues surviving, the country will go on collecting tax revenue from productive citizens/businesses and will be able to pay its debt back.

Being afraid of government debt if you're a stable country is illogical: it's also why Germany can borrow money at negative interest rates, meaning people would actually rather lend money to Germany and get less back in a few years, rather than park it at a bank. Unlike a business or an individual, the lender has very little risk that the stable country will go bust/get hit by a car and can't earn money to repay the bank.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hackeraccount on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:52PM (#19911919)
The point is that while you can spend a lot of money you can't spend infinite money. There's a finite pile of euros. Every euro you spend on something stupid is one less euro you can spend on something smart.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by cygx on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:16PM (#19912219)
Money is a tool of social organization that lacks instrinsic value. Any time we as a society refuse to do something worthwhile for the sole reason that it would cost too much, that's a capitulation to human stupidity and/or greed.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by ehaliewicz2 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:35PM (#19912453)
It's not so much about money, the implication is that making solar panels costs some amount of resources that according to the parent, could possibly be spent in better ways. The money just represents, indirectly, the amount of resources.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by cygx on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:16PM (#19912891)
The question is, what's the limiting factor: Availability of manpower, natural resources, etc, or 'merely' the money to pay for them? The latter is an artificial constraint.

Take nuclear fusion as an example: Supposedly, this is a case where the projected investments necessary to go from theory to practice just haven't been made. With return of investment only anticipated in the far-off future, it was decided that the money could be spent in better ways.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by ehaliewicz2 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:11PM (#19925018)
Obviously money again is only representing some value or resource. You have to compensate workers or else they won't do any work (unless you plan on enslaving them, or have the government provide for all their needs).
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:32PM (#19913044)
The value of money is not artificial, it's valued through a measurement of it's availability vis-a-vis other resources and opportunities.

Surely countries can invest more if those projects are 'more value creating than other investments' and if it's rational, but the notion that countries shouldn't be afraid of debt either is pragmatically no helpful.

All of us are just a few irresponsible financial decisions away from being Greece, Venezuela, Weimar etc.. Stable fiat currencies are a precarious thing, which why we are so cold and 'small c' conservative about it.

As for Germany's problems, it has to do with how we measure value, institutional legacy, and obviously unwillingness to consider Nuclear.

Merkel was never really a pragmatist in the sense we would understand it - she was a political pragmatist, meaning really just 'populist' but more of the centrist type: I believe her Nuclear decision was mostly political.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by cygx on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:21PM (#19913500)
Of course it's artificial. However, that doesn't mean it's arbitrary, or useless, or can be ignored at will given the current system of socio-economic organization. You're absolutely right that in the world we live in, policy makers have to be careful about financial decisions, or suffer the consequences.

But I believe people should be reminded from time to time that our world is pretty far from the best possible one: There's no particularly good reason that a child has to die from undernutrition every couple of minutes, that fusion research stagnated due to lack of funding, that people go bankrupt to pay for healthcare, etc. As a species, we're just too stupid and greedy to do any better...

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by EastLondonCoder on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:58PM (#19912716)
The only "currency" I know with a finite money supply is bitcoin. I may be misunderstanding you but there certainly isn't a fixed pile of Euro notes sitting in a vault under the European Central Bank. Money creation is essential to any macroeconomy, just look at the countries in Southern Europe. They have to deal with atrocious unemployment because they cant devalue. Germany and France certainly can. Sure runaway inflation is harmful, but in the choice of inflation in the high single digit contra 20-30% unemployment, my choice would be to lower unemployment.

If your case is that economic output is fixed I would flat out disagree. It's been shown over and over again that investment increases economic output. Which was very much the idea with Germany's Energiewende

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by adventured on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:40PM (#19913126)
There's a strictly finite value base - assets, economic output, etc - to all fiat money supply. It's the underlying value, things priced and transacted in the fiat currency, that make it valuable. You can easily spook the confidence in fiat by doing stupid things to an economy.

Otherwise Venezuela would be the richest country in world history right about now, given their inflation rate.

It works identical to mathematical halving in concept. Yes you can keep going, and no you'll never reach zero. However every time you debase the currency to pay for something beyond your budget, you destroy some of the value underpinning it. You make the assets and transactions in that currency less valuable. You can infinitely subdivide the currency, and each time you do it, you destroy more of the value base. Eventually you're splitting pennies, so to speak. This is especially true in cases where you're printing to pay for something you can't afford (almost always the reason for such printing), so what you're really doing is eating the nation's asset base through the currency debasement.

Just ask Japan, they sliced more than 1/3 off their standard of living by debasing the Yen over the past decade. They had no choice due to their debt situation (they needed to stealth default), however it reduces the value of the assets that are held in Yen, making it easier to eg use dollars (or gold) to buy those assets (whether businesses or real-estate and so on).

So sure, in theory can you infinitely print currency. In practical application, you destroy the value of the things that underpin the currency and the whole scheme self-destructs given enough time and 'printing.' That puts a more realistic cap on actual potential money supply. The fact is, it inherently must be finite. Eventually your money is not worth anything, as you destroy the assets under it. As that happens, people stop accepting the worthless currency, it becomes too expensive to 'print' it and support it, and it becomes a self correcting system, in all cases and without exception.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by anoncake on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:01AM (#19918954)
> I'm pretty sure if the survival of human race is at stake, money is no object.

It shouldn't be, but unfortunately, it very much is.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by est31 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:03PM (#19912054)
> Does it really matter to see all those solar panel farms if the end result is they were not much helpful?

Sure, putting them further into the dry south would certainly have improved yields, e.g. putting them into Spain or even further south like DESERTEC envisioned. And still, they produce a non-trivial chunk of German electricity now. Not sure what you are suggesting, compared to stuff like fusion, we actually know that solar works. Also, there is a political component of having them on own soil: energy independence. A lesson learned in the oil crisis.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by jwr on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:03PM (#19912055)
I also get a warm fuzzy feeling from solar panels and wind farms. But we are losing our planet to climate change, and warm fuzzy feelings do not help. Lowering CO2 emissions does.

Germany could have had zero CO2 emissions by now, if money were invested into nuclear instead of the current efforts. The declaration to move away from nuclear power was misguided and will be regarded as a huge error in the future.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:35PM (#19912447)
I like to say that the environmental NGOs, politicians etc. have been given the choice between pneumonia (nuclear power) and cancer (CO2 emissions), and they answer "oh no, my grandma died of pneumonia when she was young, so I'll have the cancer".
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by imtringued on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @09:11PM (#19915477)
The renewable subsidies don't cover the cost of a modern nuclear power plant. The 25 billion € per year spent on renewables is just barely enough to construct a single nuclear plant. Other than warm fuzzy feelings that nuclear is superior it wouldn't actually solve the problems Germany is currently facing. Merkel doesn't want to threaten the jobs of coal workers and their communities. Therefore coal plants don't get turned off.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by est31 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @06:09PM (#19914326)
Feelings and impressions are more important than you think. Stock markets for example are not perfect but instead also reflect human perception: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/reflexivity.asp

This deal requires investment at the start but will pay off in the end by lower costs caused by climate change. So what is holding people back? Their perception. They feel like they will die before the impacts will happen. They feel like nobody is doing anything about it so why should they be the first? Humans are built in a way that joining an existing movement is easy but starting one is hard. Germany helped getting the start of the s-curve going.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by ars on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:57PM (#19913830)
And this is why environmentalism is a failure. It values appearance over results.

So basically it looks good to have lots of Solar and Wind, never mind if it actually does anything useful?

It's called Greenwashing, and if people don't stop doing it this planet is going to get worse and worse.

You realize you've basically said that they only success of this project was reducing the price of PV Panels? If that was your goal there are WAY WAY better methods to do that.

> demonstrating that an industrialized nation actually can start a gradual transition towards renewables

That's not what it demonstrated though. It demonstrated than even a highly motivated industrialized nation failed in transitioning to clean energy sources.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by y0ghur7_xxx on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @12:56PM (#19911221)
I agree with you. Germany did not accomplish it's goal of CO2 emissions reduction, but in the process of trying it did a whole lot of other great things. And I hope we will all learn from the experience Germany made and it will contribute to all of our next efforts.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by wbl on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @08:21PM (#19915201)
What matters for climate change: CO2 emissions. What doesn't matter: solar panels on roofs.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @12:59PM (#19911244)
The biggest issue, unintended I assume, is that CO2 certificates are not rare enough (or expensive enough). The result is that coal is actually cheaper than the most modern gas plants. That is based on variable costs, so. In that regard the renewables are basically "free". Which means that renewables are fed in first followed by coal. Which leaves not enough demand for the cleaner and more flexible gas plants. Obviously CO2 emissions go through the roof.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by atupis on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:36PM (#19911672)
Also I don't get why German does have very limited transfer capacity between Norway,Denmark and Sweden. Those countries have lot cheap renewable energy.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:45PM (#19911803)
I believe I remember from my masters that there are plans (underway? to be? already in place?) to actually connect the countries. Would be great if that worked out.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sgift on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:24PM (#19912313)
You probably think of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NORD.LINK ? Building is in progress.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by nielsole on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:59PM (#19914272)
IIRC one issue of NorGer(a similar cable) was that German energy law prefers domestic plants over imported electricity. This of course is a huge risk to investors of submarine cables and was an obstacle in getting it built.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:42PM (#19913146)
Yep, that one!
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:27PM (#19912351)
While there are some pretty huge electrical links in place already, there is a large political and public resistance towards expanding this.

For the public, they know that the endgame is more expensive electricity. No good. For local industry, it basically amounts to taking the increasingly large competitive advantage they have of cheap, low emission electricity and just giving it away to Europe.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by petre on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:53PM (#19913794)
The generation capacity will idle otherwise. It's probably better to sell the electricity for cheap than let the capacity idle to the point where it rusts and becomes useless.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:57PM (#19914248)
Oh, it won't idle, no worries. They're running as hard as they can. We use the 'leccy to produce the world's cleanest aluminium, nickel, silicon etc. These industries are what drove construction of the hydroelectric plants in the first place.

People are talking maybe we'll build the next gigafactory for batteries here. There is no shortage of electrochemical industries hungry for that power, and that green image.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by 99_00 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:45PM (#19911806)
The goal is reducing CO2. Renewables are technology that may help achieve that. Adopting renewables isn't the goal.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by atemerev on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:49PM (#19912612)
Germany famously counts biodiesel among renewables (technically correct), which certainly doesn't help in reducing CO2.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sisu2019 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:21PM (#19911470)
billions and billions down the drain for symbolism. Mostly private individuals like me payed that via crass energy taxes. It's nice that you get enjoyment out of seeing solar and wind farms but in the end they'll do nothing but serve as testament of the hubris and stupididty of politians.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:43PM (#19911778)
The initial pre-Fukushima plan to exit nuclear was solid. What ruined it was the blind actionism post-Fukushima.

Also, despite all the fear mongering that renewables will collapse the grid it proofed to be pretty stable and robust. Even high energy industries like the chemical and processing industry adapted pretty well. Some even actively participate in the energy market now. And in case processes can be slowed down or stopped they buffer energy generation peaks practically serving as some kind of storage.

So, Germany has the opportunity to learn a lot about smart grids in highly industrialized environments. It's just that Germany's track record in these kind of things is, well, bad.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by sgift on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @02:40PM (#19912504)
> The initial pre-Fukushima plan to exit nuclear was solid. What ruined it was the blind actionism post-Fukushima.

I have a feeling even with the pre-Fukushima plan we would have the same situation now. The thing was that the CDU never committed themselves to the plan. And the energy industry always hoped that one day there will be a CDU-led government that just kills the plan.

So, since the government didn't force them to, they never prepared for the case of the nuclear shutdown actually happening. And when the CDU-led government killed the exit plan it seemed for a short time that their calculations were right. And then Fukushima happened and for the most part we were back to where we were before.

Yes, there was some blind action, but despite stories about all the changes the post-Fukushima plan didn't diverge markedly from the pre-Fukushima plan. Only difference was that the energy companies couldn't hope that a new government will save them since all parties agreed that the exit should happen.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by hef19898 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:39PM (#19913109)
That's true. Maybe the sharp turn the CDU took after Fukushima took them by surprise. I had the impression that back then nobody had a plan or even vague idea if what they were doing. Besides getting voter support.
Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by Gondolin on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:18PM (#19913991)
I agree that Energiewende is important and that reducing the cost of renewable was sorely needed, but at the same time the decision to close the nuclear plants (rather than coal) was a gigantic mistake.

1) Because it costs a lot of lives. Coal + Lignite in Germany cost 8000 lives per year (funnily everybody also seems to forget that coal release more radiation in the air than nuclear plants). https://www.thelancet.com/article/S0140-6736(07)61253-7/abst...

By contrast Chernobyl was 4000 deaths https://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2005/pr38/en/

By not closing 10GW of nuclear production, Germany could have prevented 2000 deaths by year, so in total 20000 deaths over ten years.

2) Because it gave the impression that a carbon free electricity could be achieved by wind and solar alone. This is not the case: first Germany will only close coal in 2038 (in 20 years!!), and plan to use gas to replace coal at least up to 2050. Gas is way better than goal for air health, but it still release a lot of CO2. 2050 is way too late to be carbon free.

The problem with wind and solar is the intermittence: if you look at the data from https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-c... you will see that on average wind is at 20% capacity and solar at 10% capacity. So even with batteries to smooth things out (which don't exist at the huge scale we are speaking with), Germany would need a lot more solar and wind that it does. For a peak consumption of around 70GW, this mean it would need 350GW of renewable energy. It is so far only at around 100GW, having added 50GW the last ten years. So at this speed it would still need around 50 years. This is without counting the fact that: - the energy stockage problem is at least as hard to solve - solar panel and wind turbines have a lifetime of 20 years, so this does not take into account replacing existing ones - it is getting harder and harder to find place to put them. In 2018 the rate of installation of new renewables slowed down a lot because of this problem.

3) By contrast nuclear cost less, when taking into account this intermittence problem and the cost of interconnection (which is not counted by the figures usually given); it is a lot easier to interconnect a huge centrale than a lot of small ones. But cost is not an argument anyway when we are talking about climate change (if there was a proper carbon tax at least Germany would have closed coal before nuclear).

It is friendlier to the environment (wind turbine kills a lot of birds, and solar panel take a lot of room from wildlife).

It is as safe as solar and wind, and way safer than hydroelectric and coal. Banqiao Dam collapse was 230000 deaths. Yet nobody is calling for stopping hydroelectricity.

Again, Chernobyl was "only" 4000 deaths (high range estimate using a linear model rather than a threshold model are at 10000-20000 deaths), Fukushima was 0 deaths (but 1500 due to the evacuation, including zones where the radiation was the same order of magnitude of the natural one). Chernobyl cannot happen with modern reactors; a Fukushima style incident could, but the nuclear operators increased the security of the points of failures that Fukushima revealed. Again, living near a dam is probably less secure than living near a nuclear plant. And building and installing solar panels and wind turbines cost lives too (as do building dam and nuclear plants, and so on); on average as much as nuclear killed. Yet there is a lot of hysteria about nuclear plants, because an accident is so much more spectacular and visible.

And yes an accident would leave an exclusion zone, but it would actually be smaller than this stretch of no man land (a coal mine in Germany): https://twitter.com/LejeuneXa/status/1124749045996634118

4) I am not saying nuclear fission is a miracle energy (fusion would be). It is as safe as it is in developed countries because of all the regulations, this model would not be applicable in developing countries. For these countries, wind and solar is the way to go, and in this respect Energiewende which paved the way is a success.

There is the problem of nuclear waste, but this frankly this is a (small) problem at the scale of 100s of years, this should not at all be our priority given the very small time frame we have to reduce climate change (the ship has unfortunately sailed for preventing it from being too impactful [aka more than a few million deaths], the real question is whether we limit it to be really impactful or a total catastrophe). This is like worrying about a leak in the sink when the whole house is on fire: bad priorities!

5) But, by making the illusion that 100% carbon free electricity could be achievable without nuclear, Germany set a dangerous precedent. It is not currently possible (as proved by Germany not really reducing its CO2 emissions), it may be possible in 30 years (current prevision is only a cut of 65% in 30 years, the 95% cut is from a very optimistic plan by Greenpeace) but this is way too late.

By refusing to use nuclear for purely ideological# reasons, Germany is depriving itself from a vital tool against global warming. And by vindicating some green movements to call for the closing of nuclear plants along the development of renewable (whereas the sane thing to do would be developing nuclear along renewable: solar panel in sunny places like desert, offshore wind turbines and nuclear plants), it may indeed have done a whole lot of harm. And when we are speaking about the future of human civilisation, this may prove to have been indeed a very costly mistake indeed.

[#] And yes, when you take into account that coal each year kill more in Germany than Chernobyl did globally (and way more than Fukushima); and that even if there was a Chernobyl every 10 years (which cannot happen with the nuclear reactors we have) anyway it would still be a drop of water compared to what climate change is going to bring us, closing nuclear plants can only be ideological.

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by imtringued on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @09:19PM (#19915507)
>It is friendlier to the environment (wind turbine kills a lot of birds, and solar panel take a lot of room from wildlife).

If you think nuclear power plants don't kill millions of animals per year then you must be living in some kind of fantasy land. Where do you think does the coolant for them come from and where does the waste heat get dumped to?

Re:Progress has been limited on Germany's shift from nuclear... by Gondolin on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:32AM (#19917724)
Some plants have a closed cooling system. And the million figure count fish eggs, which is somewhat cheating. And if you take into account the reduced wildlife area due to solar panel and wind farm needing more space than nuclear plants, I stand by my statement that nuclear is more environmentally friendly per GWh (but I do concede that solar panels in desert and offshore wind turbines are even better than nuclear for the wildlife).

But in all this we should remember that environmental impact of fossil based electricity is an order of magnitude worse anyway.