News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by burtonator on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:44PM (#19874613)
I didn't realize this about US law but if you've already been convicted of a crime OR they give you immunity you can be forced to testify.

They did this in Aaron Swartz's case and gave people immunity to force them to testify.

I was friends with Aaron and felt that he was mostly a hero in this situation though he was probably guilty of misdemeanor trespass.

It was troubling to see how upset it made my friends that they were going to be forced to testify against someone they loved or were friends with.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mehrdadn on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:54PM (#19874653)
> I didn't realize this about US law but if you've already been convicted of a crime OR they give you immunity you can be forced to testify.

Yeah, and it's not obvious why. The insight you're seeking here is that the right against self-incrimination was intended to be a solution to the problem of forced confessions (torture, etc.). It's not there because of some kind of belief that you really have some kind of fundamental human right to testify against yourself. In fact it's quite a bizarre thing to codify in a constitution otherwise.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mehrdadn on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:17AM (#19875762)
Here's some reading since it seems many were interested in the topic: https://apps.americanbar.org/abastore/products/books/abstrac...

> The Supreme Court traces the roots of our Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination to the protections the English courts and Parliament granted to those religious dissenters who were compelled to take oaths when called before the ecclesiastical courts, as well as the Court of High Commission and the Star Chamber. These courts used the “oath ex officio” to force heretics from the Church of England to swear before God to truthfully answer all questions, even before the heretics even knew the nature of the accusations against them. By use of the oath in conducting their investigations of religious heresy, these courts left witnesses with the “cruel trilemma” of (1) refusing to take the oath, which constituted contempt and subjected the person to torture; (2) taking the oath and telling the truth about their religious beliefs, which, if heretical, was punishable by death; or (3) taking the oath and lying, which was also punishable by death. In other words, this inquisitorial system countenanced methods of interrogating persons designed to lead only to confessions.

> [...] Parliament eventually abolished the Court of High Commission and the Star Chamber and, in 1662, passed a law providing that “no man shall administer to any person whatsoever the oath usually called ex officio or any other oath whereby such persons may be charged or compelled to confess to any criminal matter.” By the late eighteenth century, as the English common law courts began to recognize the presumption of innocence, trial judges in criminal cases began to afford defendants the right not to incriminate themselves, establishing the privilege against self-incrimination as a fundamental rule of evidence.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by lixtra on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:38AM (#19875865)
> In fact it's quite a bizarre thing to codify in a constitution otherwise.

I don’t know about the US but in many jurisdictions you cannot be forced to testify against close family (spouse, children).

It’s clearly about the state not creating a cruel situation.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mikro2nd on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:46AM (#19877191)
I'd suspect it's more about the state being pragmatic concerning the chances you or I would lie to protect a family member - assuming we have no axe to grind with said family member...
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by toomanybeersies on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:13AM (#19876020)
How does spousal privilege play into all this?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mehrdadn on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:50AM (#19876167)
I'm not sure I understand what you're asking exactly, but I guess you could say it doesn't. It's important to remember the "bill of rights" is really the "bill of government restrictions", not "bill of fundamental human rights". I guess that, unlike the right against self-incrimination, spousal privilege wasn't deemed fundamentally necessary for preventing the government from forcing testimony, so that's probably why it wasn't put there in the fifth amendment. I can only speculate as to the reasoning, but I imagine it might be as follows:

With self-incrimination, if the government decides to force testimony from you (which inevitably implies a guilty confession), you'll get punished one way or another regardless of what you say (which apparently historically meant choosing between torture and death). This means two things: (1) innocent people will get punished either way (which is obviously the opposite of what you want), and (2) guilty people won't have any incentive to tell the truth either (which is also not what you want either)—they'll instead have incentive to say whatever will minimize their punishment, which is determined by the government, not by the truth. So it's pretty much entirely a lose-lose situation, and not something that'll make a justice system (whom you're charging with the task of finding the truth) achieve its goal. Spousal testimony, on the other hand, is entirely different in that respect: as far as the relationship between you and the government is concerned (which is, recall, what the goal of the bill of rights was—again, it wasn't written as a manifesto on human rights), you actually have a huge incentive to tell the truth here, because you don't get punished by the government for providing guilty testimony against your spouse. Same exactly thing happens when you're provided immunity: you don't get punished, and therefore society gets to extract the truth out of you, with decent confidence that it'll get what it's looking for. Therefore, as far as the constitution being concerned, spousal privilege probably didn't need to be written in there, because the right against self-incrimination already sufficiently achieved its restriction and goal.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by maxlybbert on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:32AM (#19877498)
My understanding of spousal privilege is that it was originally justified on the idea that a married couple were legally one person. Today it has the same basis as other privileges, such as the privileges covering therapists and pastors: that it would be bad to interfere with confidentiality in certain relationships.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by tptacek on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:45PM (#19874618)
Of course you can be forced to testify. That goes all the way back to English common law. The public has a claim to every man's evidence.

A strict privilege against self-testimony is somewhat distinctive to our US system. Even countries that share it with us, like the UK, limit it; for instance, in the UK, your refusal to testify against yourself can be held against you.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by yeahforsureman on Friday May 10, 2019 @02:34AM (#19875545)
Privilege against self-incrimination is a generally recognised international standard and, for example, lies at the heart of the notion of a fair procedure under Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mehrdadn on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:08AM (#19875726)
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by austincheney on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:28AM (#19875823)
Juries are not frequently comprised of people with objectivity, intelligence, or education. Refusing to answer questions on the grounds of self-incrimination looks incredibly guilty even though guilt is clearly not established. A good prosecutor will use that in closing arguments or to influence other witnesses.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by Sharlin on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:00AM (#19876914)
Juries are most certainly not a universal part of the legal system. They are mostly found in the Anglosphere. Most European countries, for example, have a civil law system that typically does not feature a jury of peers.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by Pyxl101 on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:15AM (#19876481)
Are prosecutors allowed to imply in closing arguments that asserting one's fifth amendment right should be considered evidence that the person is guilty? I would hope that judges would instruct juries not to consider assertion of this right as evidence one way or another, and would not allow a prosecutor to say so either.

It seems that this is the case, based on Griffin v California: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/380/609.html

> Comment to the jury by a prosecutor in a state criminal trial upon a defendant's failure to testify as to matters which he can reasonably be expected to deny or explain because of facts within his knowledge or by the court that the defendant's silence under those circumstances evidences guilt violates the Self-Incrimination Clause of the Fifth Amendment of the Federal Constitution

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by bob_doggo on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:31AM (#19876552)
isn't the jury system an american thing?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by dredmorbius on Friday May 10, 2019 @07:11AM (#19876711)
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by Sharlin on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:00AM (#19876915)
But it is mostly an Anglosphere thing.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by saagarjha on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:12PM (#19874736)
In what way? Can they automatically assume the worst possible thing you could have said?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by dogma1138 on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:58AM (#19876193)
No, it’s called adverse inference basically the prosecution can say that because you didn’t cooperate you are guilty.

That said you cannot convict anyone on adverse inference alone.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by arethuza on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:04AM (#19875990)
Nitpick: I believe that is England and Wales, not the whole of the UK.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence_in_England_an...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence#Scotland

I think NI is also different.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by xxpor on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:46PM (#19874622)
That's right. The 5th amendment only protects you from self-incrimination. If theres no risk of you being charged with a crime you can't refuse to testify.

You could perhaps come up with a 1st amendment case but I think that wouldn't have much of a chance of going anywhere.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by peterkelly on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:56AM (#19875407)
You absolutely can refuse to testify. It just means you have to go to jail.

That's exactly what Manning did, and will likely do so again.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by xxpor on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:05PM (#19879091)
There's an implied "if you'd like to avoid jail or hefty fines" when talking about the legal system, yes.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by umanwizard on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:00PM (#19874680)
How can there be no risk of self-incrimination?

Even if they give you immunity for the specific thing you’re testifying about, what if your testimony reveals that you’re guilty of some completely different crime?

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:12PM (#19874741)
Generally immunity is qualified to include anything that comes out of asking you.... and you'd have your lawyer to give you a hand.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by waterhouse on Friday May 10, 2019 @02:34AM (#19875548)
Is there anything to protect against parallel construction? Bob mentions he was selling drugs to a guy near the scene of the crime. A police officer then finds out who the buyer was, and gets him to testify to bring drug charges against Bob. Or: During the following weeks, a police officer just happens to be in the same place at the same time of night every week, and eventually catches one of Bob's future transactions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witness_immunity seems to be the reference. Seems to cover the exact issue: "In the United States, the prosecution may grant immunity in one of two forms. Transactional immunity, colloquially known as "blanket" or "total" immunity, completely protects the witness from future prosecution for crimes related to his or her testimony. Use and derivative use immunity prevents the prosecution only from using the witness's own testimony or any evidence derived from the testimony against the witness. However, if the prosecutor acquires evidence substantiating the crime independently of the witness's testimony, the witness may then be prosecuted."

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by austincheney on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:35AM (#19875854)
There is specific immunity and blanket immunity. Specific immunity is protection from prosecution for a specified offense. Blanket immunity is protection from prosecution for any offense related to a given court case.

Immunity, like double jeopardy, is limited to a given court. For example a state prosecutor can grant immunity in exchange for testimony, but in the case of overlap with federal law the witness can still be prosecuted in a federal court.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by dgzl on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:11AM (#19875740)
I would guess what you're describing is actually an intended outcome.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by Pyxl101 on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:17AM (#19876491)
Could you have committed an unrelated murder, and by disclosing this murder in your testimony, become immune to conviction of it?

If that is not how immunity works, then how can the government force anyone to testify? The government does not know what (unrelated) crimes I may have to confess to in order to give truthful testimony on the matter in question.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by awinder on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:39AM (#19877138)
i'm not even sure what the answer to this is other than to say -- it's a completely contrived example and there's no way you would answer such a question let alone be asked about it. getting on the stand isn't some grand fishing expedition -- you're asked relevant questions and if they're not relevant then your lawyer / opposing lawyer is going to challenge relevance
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mokus on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:56AM (#19877714)
If you explicitly have immunity for all things you reveal in the course of the questioning (and that immunity applies to the crimes revealed, not just that particular testimony), then I don’t see why you wouldn’t reveal everything you can, whether asked or not. Any way you could possibly shoehorn “I murdered a guy in 2012” into an answer, you should, if that were how the immunity worked.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by 0x445442 on Friday May 10, 2019 @10:52AM (#19878307)
Does that include false testimony? If so, why couldn't Manning employ the Regan/Poindexter tactic... I don't recall? Or can the immunity be rescinded if the testimony doesn't produce the answers the prosecution wants?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by wespiser_2018 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:58PM (#19874928)
I would say that "forcing" testimony, can only be done under duress, in a situation like forcible coercion or torture. I'm not familiar with the Swartz's case and its parallel investigations, but in principle people aren't "given' immunity and "forced" to testify, but rather they choose a deal with the prosecution that included leniency for themselves and were no longer protected by the 5th amendment as a criminal defendant.

Manning exactly illustrates this point, no one is "forcing" her to do anything. She doesn't want to talk, so she won't! You always have a choice.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by xenadu02 on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:25AM (#19875044)
> in principle people aren't "given' immunity and "forced" to testify, but rather they choose a deal with the prosecution that included leniency for themselves and were no longer protected by the 5th amendment as a criminal defendant.

That's not exactly true. In the US you can generally be compelled to testify if you are not the one on trial unless you claim the 5th (the law generally recognizes that court proceedings are part of the record and testimony there could be used to bring charges against you later).

There can be a series of escalations and motions before the judge, eg where the judge asks you in closed court to give more details so he/she can rule on whether the 5th applies. In theory you could refuse to give any details by claiming even the tiniest detail would put you at risk of prosecution. Ultimately if the prosecutor offers you blanket immunity you can no longer claim the 5th because the threat of prosecution has been eliminated.

Similarly if you refuse to testify for fear of your own safety the government can offer to protect you, up to and including putting you into witness protection which eliminates the objection.

The general principle seems to be you have a series of objections you can raise. Each one imposes a higher and higher cost on the government, forcing them to decide just how important your testimony really is.

This is all separate from the material witness procedures, which have been abused somewhat in recent times. The theory there is there is an imminent thread to your life _or_ you are a serious flight risk. In those cases you get jailed until trial despite not even being accused. As you can imagine prosecutors have sometimes used the threat of losing your job, house, etc while jailed awaiting trial to coerce testimony.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by jrs235 on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:49AM (#19875129)
But what if testifying could/can/does open oneself to civil suits? Can a prosecutor offer civil immunity or only criminal immunity?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by xxs on Friday May 10, 2019 @02:57AM (#19875664)
I'd have thought that's a common knowledge (outside US) that "the 5th" applies only to criminal cases.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by droithomme on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:43AM (#19877592)
> no one is "forcing" her to do anything. She doesn't want to talk, so she won't! You always have a choice.

Pedantically true, yes. If I hold a gun to the witnesses head and demand they testify or I will pull the trigger, no one is "forcing" them to do anything. They have the choice to refuse to testify and suffer the consequences.

It's the same with Manning. She has the "choice" to be thrown in prison because she refuses. Usually doing something under threat of deprivation of live or liberty is legally considered being forced to do something.

I can rob a bank at gunpoint and then argue that the bank "chose" to give me the money, since they always had the option to refuse, just as you are arguing here that Manning has the "choice" to testify. When there is a threat of deprivation of life or liberty, that is not considered a free choice. It's coerced, under duress, also known as forced.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by wespiser_2018 on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:02PM (#19883746)
Testifying against a friend or community member is not coercion if people ascribe negative outcomes to not just their well-being, but to the well-being of their friends.

For instance, my testimony gets me out of jail, but it helps put my friend in jail: the degree my testimony impacts that sentence, and the sentence itself, have to be factors in the decision.

Thus, and without getting into Manning's thought process, I wouldn't be surprised if she believes the negative effects (real or perceived) of her testimony outweigh the stay in jail.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by nullc on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:09AM (#19874981)
They can't, however, force the testimony to be useful.

I don't fully understand why she didn't testify here. The events were so long ago and so stressful. If it were me I wouldn't be able to remember much with any confidence.

But I'm glad she has been released now and I hope it did some good.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by pacificmint on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:33AM (#19875066)
> But I'm glad she has been released now and I hope it did some good.

Well, she’s only been released because the term of the grand jury expired. She’ll be called to testify again, and if she refuses to testify again, she will most likely be locked up again.

So this is more a temporary development, rather than a resolution of the issue.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by StanislavPetrov on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:29AM (#19875300)
I think its pretty clear that she refused to testify out of principle. None of the war criminals exposed by Manning's leaks have been charged or tried for their crimes. The government's refusal to charge the war crimes, which are central to the entire case, completely undermine any pretense of "justice". As usual, the government is using its infinite power to punish those who exposed wrongdoing, while completely ignoring the actually wrongdoing that was exposed. I find it quite admirable that Manning refuses to be used as a tool to further this charade of injustice, at great personal expense. Being held in "contempt of court" is no vice when the court, and the prosecutors, have done everything possible to earn that contempt.

For those unfamiliar with the still unprosecuted war crimes exposed by Manning (and published by Assange):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rXPrfnU3G0

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by acqq on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:15AM (#19875753)
Even much more serious information is this one:

https://www.presstv.com/Detail/2015/09/10/428634/Syria-Assan...

"US had planned to topple the Syrian government long before 2011, the year that the brutal conflict broke out in the country."

"In his new book, Assange points to a cable pertaining to US Ambassador William Roebuck, who served as the Political Counselor at the U.S. Embassy in Damascus between 2004-2007, about plans for overthrowing the government of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad at the time."

The book based on the Wiklieaks files (Assange wrote an introduction):

https://www.amazon.com/WikiLeaks-Files-World-According-Empir...

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by megous on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:12AM (#19876472)
Might have saved millions of people from suffering. BTW, presstv is Iranian regime's news source, ally of Assad's regime, and the party (Iran) murdering civilians in Syria the last few years. So I wouldn't expect anything objective from them.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by acqq on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:38AM (#19876583)
Other media avoided to cover the book or what’s in the wikileaks material. I’ve tried to find and failed.

The book was not published by the writers of the article. They just wrote that the book exists and what is revealed.

I would also like a link to NYT or WaPo but they avoided to cover the book (and even more to analyse the materials leaked). At least you can still buy the book. The material itself is still reachable on the wikileaks site.

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by megous on Friday May 10, 2019 @05:13PM (#19882285)
Interesting. You're right NYT only mentioned the book in passing in one article. And I can't really find many references in any media I recognize, either.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by tssva on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:35AM (#19876570)
What has the court done? The court doesn't decide who is or isn't prosecuted and brought in front of them for trial.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by StanislavPetrov on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:15PM (#19881247)
The court ordered that Manning be jailed, which is entirely under its purview. The court could have dressed down the government prosecutors for being the jackboot thugs that they are and admonished them for not prosecuting the war criminals.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by Miner49er on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:32AM (#19877501)
Can anyone who knows law explain why the 1st amendment doesn't apply here? I understand the 5th doesn't apply, but it seems like the 1st should. Has this ever been decided in court?
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by mysterydip on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:10AM (#19876462)
Isn't that why they give people immunity? "We will let you get away with (whatever) in exchange for aiding us in frying this bigger fish"
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by grecy on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:45PM (#19874880)
> you can be forced to testify

What does forced mean?

What happens if you just say no? Contempt of court?

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by wespiser_2018 on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:06AM (#19874969)
Yes, you will be issued a Subpoena, and the presiding judge for the case can sentence you with Contempt of Court if you fail to testify. The idea is to keep you in jail under Contempt charges until you do whatever the judge wants.

The longest sentence for contempt of court is H. Beatty Chadwick (1994 - 2009), which was over a divorce settlement. Susan McDouglas went to jail over not answering questions about Bill Clinton in civil case, and was pardoned by him later. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_McDougal

Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by grecy on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:03PM (#19883447)
Oh wow, thanks. I didn't know that.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by redler on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:00AM (#19874937)
We may see this question explored publicly in great detail in the coming months.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by pnw_hazor on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:22AM (#19875786)
Barr is safe. It is unlawful for him to divulge grand jury testimony.
Re:Chelsea Manning released from jail with expiration of gra... by gdhbcc on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:21AM (#19875784)
You go to prison forever