News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:28AM (#19859733)
Heads up, a number of these effects don't appear to work correctly in Safari. For instance, the first, second, fourth, and fifth in the top row have a distracting flash in the middle of the animation.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by slivanes on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:50AM (#19860020)
I'm starting to get the feeling that Safari is going to be left behind and treated like ie6/8 in the near future.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by dspillett on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:23PM (#19861014)
That is already happening.

I know a number of people including myself who pretty much ignore Safari for small projects because they don't have iDevices to test on and Safari doesn't run anywhere else. In that instance you just stick to the standards and either hope Safari will cope or don't care if it doesn't.

Even on larger and/or professional projects I see it given second class support: people make sure their project works on Safari, so no show stopper or nasty UX bugs, but display glitches and non-major performance issues that are Safari specific get very low priority, if they are addressed at all.

Currently the differences seen are far less stark than those seen between IE6/8 and other browsers so this is a relatively minor issue, but it might not remain so.

In projects aimed for a wide audience though and for which mobile is a key platform, Safari support is forced much as old-IE support has been forced upon those of us writing software for large institutions who are slow to update, because nothing else runs on iOS. iDevice users can be pretty vocal and not quick to blame their own devices, and even ignoring the noise they can generate they tend to be people with disposable income so if your project/product is commercial you probably can't go too far down the road of ignoring Safari.

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by ricardobeat on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:56PM (#19861316)
That’s a terrible excuse since 1) there are plenty of remote/virtualisation tools that let you easily test any browser or platform 2) same logic applies to mobile 3) iPhone has up to 80% share in many locations, Macs up to 25% share in some demographics
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by dspillett on Thursday May 09, 2019 @01:34PM (#19870288)
> 1) there are plenty of remote/virtualisation tools

For small/personal projects they need to be free and, for some of us, available offline (I often tinker locally while travelling through low/no signal areas). Do you know of any that fit that bill?

Even with free and convenient tools some will resent needing to test on an extra platform at all just because Safari is slow to adopt new ideas or implements them partially/buggyly.

> 2) same logic applies to mobile

Incorrectly, but yes it does. Which is why you often see "doesn't work on mobile" or "works badly on mobile" in comments here and elsewhere. Mobile is a more general thing than supporting Safari though and a battle in its own right: it is more about accounting for small screens, no physical keyboards, touch-only, low power CPUs, etc.

> 3) iPhone has up to 80% share in many locations,

If a project is not optimised for (or not working at all on) mobile generally, then iDevices having x% share of mobile for particular populations becomes irrelevant. 80% seems rather high for any given population though, could you state any for which this is definitely true?

> Macs up to 25% share in some demographics

You are not potentially cutting these people off by not supporting Safari though, as they have the option of using other UAs unlike users of iOS based devices.

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by neurotrace on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:47PM (#19863299)
It may not be fair but it's true. Testing for Safari is such a hassle in my Windows and Android dominated world.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by TimTheTinker on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @08:04PM (#19864153)
That's a good argument for always supporting multiple platforms if you're a browser developer.

In related news, the new Edge will be released for macOS. I think Apple should follow suit with Safari on Windows again (shouldn't be too much work, since they already have the build and toolchain from a while back).

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by Wowfunhappy on Saturday May 11, 2019 @08:23PM (#19889292)
IIRC, Safari on Windows is a decade old or more. I'd bet mainline Safari has changed a lot in that time. Would probably be a significant amount of work.

And, uh, Apple's programs for Windows have a history of being really bad. Possibly done intentionally, but even so...

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by PetahNZ on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:43PM (#19863264)
Please share these tools for testing old safari, last time I checked I couldn't find any
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by ricardobeat on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:05AM (#19866269)
Browserstack, crossbrowsertesting.com, sauce labs.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @12:01PM (#19860133)
Given that we’re down to just three rendering engines of import, I really hope we don’t lose any more.

(Even if you consider Webkit and Blink largely the same, 2.5 engines is much better than 2.)

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by Epskampie on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:19PM (#19860976)
Not on iOS, since there is no alternative there.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:21PM (#19860998)
^ This is true, although in context, all the stuff that didn't work were hover animations, and those don't really matter on iOS.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by the_other on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:41AM (#19867262)
But it might suit your application to have an animation happen on tap, or on load, that looks like the hover ones. The trigger is probably the least important part of this demonstration site.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by osrec on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:54PM (#19863367)
Especially Safari on iOS. It infuriates me that we still don't have a push notifications API, nor a roadmap for when it may be included.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by caprese on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @07:45PM (#19864047)
I really don't live in that world

I use PWA, SPA, CSS, SVG, the works and don't have any issue with Safari and iOS rendering the way I expect it to alongside Chrome and Firefox

Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by chrischen on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @08:41PM (#19864319)
Odd thing to leave out since Safari runs on 100% of iOS devices.
Re:Show HN: CSSFX – Click-to-copy CSS effects by jolaleye on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @09:30PM (#19864571)
Thanks for the notice. I'm not quite sure what is causing some of these bugs but I'll be sure to continue working on it. The project is fully open source so feel free to make a PR if you're interested!