Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by viach on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:53AM
(#19831986)
Isn't splitting Olympic Games by 2 (or more?) dimensions is in general a sort of propaganda of gender inequality?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by Jabbles on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:01AM
(#19832010)
It isn't propaganda to acknowledge that elite male athletes are better than elite female athletes, for any reasonable definition of better.
Therefore, if we want any women participation in the Olympics, we have to have more than one category.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by pdkl95 on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:49AM
(#19832160)
The solution is to define the categories by the specific physical traits that are beneficial to the competition (sort of like the weight classes used in boxing). Gender is an indirect indicator. Instead of dividing in to [men, women, ...(other?)...], divide by e.g, size, weight, allele, etc.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by rwmj on Sunday May 05, 2019 @07:14AM
(#19832223)
It's an interesting idea, but what criteria would you use to group people for running?
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by berbec on Sunday May 05, 2019 @07:41AM
(#19832315)
Personal best time at competing distance.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by ordinaryperson on Sunday May 05, 2019 @07:58AM
(#19832357)
How would this work? Some Olympic distances are:
-Sprints (100m, 200m, 400m),
-Middle distance (800m, 1500m)
-Long distance (3000m Steeplechase, 5000m, 10,000m)
-Hurdles (110/100m, 400m)
-Relays (4x100m, 4x400m)
Men would dominate every distance, you'd have no women competing.
More cynically I'd point out that all high-level athletics are really television shows and the audience (deservedly) wants women's sports.
To me the solution is a new intersex category.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by rwmj on Sunday May 05, 2019 @07:45AM
(#19832327)
That would be extremely easy to game. It has to be something that's near-impossible to cheat, such as height, length of leg, or a particular genetic marker.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by viach on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:07AM
(#19832037)
Where this boundary where we can acknowledge that one category of people is _better_ in something and needs to participate only in _protected_ type of some events?
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by garmaine on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:48AM
(#19832158)
Or we can apply weighting factors to calibrate everyone onto a single scale. You could even weight age, tested T levels, height, weight, etc...
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by polote on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:58AM
(#19832000)
> So going back to the premise that women’s sport is the PROTECTED category, and that this protection must exist because of the insurmountable and powerful effects of testosterone, my opinion on this is that it is fair and correct to set an upper limit for that testosterone
They use the "protected category" expression in the article
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by adminu on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:01AM
(#19832013)
Well, in a performance point of view it is a fact that women perform 10-12% worse then men (from the article) in certain disciplines. The genders are quite measurable not equal in this metric.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by stefan_ on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:02AM
(#19832015)
Of course, it's discrimination. That is the whole point.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by Arbalest on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:55AM
(#19831993)
That's like saying that, your child gets to go to a public school, just like a rich child. The rich child just happens to be able to afford a private school.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by viach on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:03AM
(#19832018)
Rich/Poor are not genetic qualities. It's more like saying girls and boys go to different schools, because they have different abilities to learn.
Which is obviously not true in learning and, as it turns out, in sport.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by Arbalest on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:10AM
(#19832047)
They're not genetic but they still follow parental lineage. I'm making the point that advantages that people start out with are already not equal, that equality can't be simplified so much that you can just say, they have the same opportunities and that's enough.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by SubiculumCode on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:03AM
(#19832022)
Well it certainly does invite the question of why the olympics does not further divide the games to make it fairer for other groups, say a basketball division for shorter people...they do for boxing already re feather and heavy weights). Perhaps it is better to just let people compete all together no matter their sex, and let the best succeed. I do not doubt there are a number of sports that female athletes would dominate. ---Seems better than asking a woman to change her body because it doesnt fit a feminine archetype for testosterone levels.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by qazpot on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:20AM
(#19832079)
Then people like you would cry about How nobody watches the Short People Basketball League or How Weightlifting league for weak people did not generated any revenue.
Sport are meant to celebrate the best of Humans in fields of physical endeavor.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by adolph on Sunday May 05, 2019 @08:32AM
(#19832470)
Boxing has different weight classes and although the big ones seem the most popular, the lighter ones seem popular among those who enjoy boxing, right?
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by SubiculumCode on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:18AM
(#19833213)
I am not sure why my parent comment has been judged so harshly, as my reasoning was both feminist and humanist. Sure sex has the x y genetic component, but as soon as you throw in expression and developmental processes, sex is a spectrum, ignoring even gender distinctions. Rules that restrict eligibility by the natural expression of your sex because they deviate from some prototype are deeply wrong, and also ignores/discriminates against large swaths of naturally expressed sexualities within the inter sex range.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by Jabbles on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:21AM
(#19832082)
I do not doubt there are a number of sports that female athletes would dominate.
Such as?
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by keanzu on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:35AM
(#19832117)
Ultra-distance swimming is the only one I am aware of.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by earthling77 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:25PM
(#19873043)
Based on?
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by reaktivo on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:39AM
(#19832130)
Gymnastics of the top of my head
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by earthling77 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:15PM
(#19872969)
Maybe the balance beam, but only for obvious choice reasons.
Re:What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY...
by tigershark on Sunday May 05, 2019 @06:39AM
(#19832131)
Curling