I guess that’s why I think it’s great.
If it was a smaller token amount, it would feel sad.
If it was more, it would feel exploitative (like a number of people in this thread already said).
Then there's also the social aspect of it all. If you're working with a team of 10 people and 8 of them are contributing to projects that help the company because you're all on the same mission of "rainbows and unicorns are amazing, our company is the best" then there's a tremendous amount of social pressure to keep up with everyone else because otherwise everyone thinks you're not on the same page and you get outcast. Once that happens for a while, that's when you get burnt out and resent everyone you work with.
I think it's less about a different thought process, but about a set of potential legal implications or ramifications.
Formidable does pay folks their full engineering salaries to make targeted contributions to open source during work hours. We can't afford to do a ton of this, so it mostly happens when folks are between projects. The extra $20/hour is extra. It's meant to be fun and encouraging. It's basically the "buy me a beer" license, but Formidable actually buys us a beer.
Now: $20/hour.
If that's devaluing something, I would like to devalue my worth by several orders of magnitude please. :)
Before: This costs nothing but I’m avoiding paying for the engineering time that is $$$.
After: $20 an hour is the going rate for developing this sort of software.
If I'm furnishing my new empty home and don't have a couch, I'm going to shell out approx. $2,000 for a couch because I need one.
If my house is completely furnished and someone shows up at the door with a couch, I'd either turn them away completely or possibly offer them a small amount after evaluating whether I can even accept it.
IMO claiming that rewarding people for doing any random OSS work they'd do anyway devalues software development in general is concern-trolling.
Since this is done on the employees' own time (after hours), isn't this basically saying, "hey, go help make our app's dependencies better in an overtime scenario but we're going to pay you $20 / hour instead of 1x to 2x your usual salary"?
I know at the bottom it clears that up but I dunno, it just feels weird to me. It seems like a concealed way to mainly benefit the company and potentially exploit the good will of its employees.