News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by forinti on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:40AM (#19818851)
The greeks had two institutions we could use: ostracism and lottery.

We should be able to vote on those we want out of politics and the most voted would have to seat it out.

And a small portion of representatives should be chosen by lottery. Maybe 5% or 10%. These representatives, obviously, would not have to answer to their sponsors.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:12AM (#19819117)
Actually, why not choose all representatives by lottery?

I don't think representatives need to have any particular competencies beyond being representative of the interests of the population. Hired staff can take care of things that require particular abilities.

I reckon that a wholly random set of representatives would act like a direct democracy where every voter is free to fully focus on the issues, is allowed an entire staff to help them, and can consult and coordinate effectively with other voters. I think that could work pretty well.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by superkarn on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:19PM (#19819711)
Would this have a similar outcome as the "lottery" for jury duty? What happens if somebody who really doesn't want to do it is chosen?
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:54PM (#19820067)
That's a very good point. I currently lean towards requiring every citizen to register for the lottery once every ten or so years (for one year of service). If they are picked, they have to go, except for serious unforeseen circumstances, but at least they would be able to plan for it to some extent. This might also require a cultural shift for people to accept it, but maybe not a radical one.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by stale2002 on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:40PM (#19821579)
> If they are picked, they have to go, except for serious unforeseen circumstances

If I was "forced" into a political position, then what I would do is purposefully sabotage the position I was in, out of spite.

What are you going to do? Arrest me because I voted a certain way? That doesn't sound easily enforceable.

Be careful what kind of slavery you force people into. Those slaves might just fight back (in this case, by voting for bad policies.).

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:59PM (#19822224)
I mean, if you want to be a sociopath about it, that's part of the risk in the system. As long as we can confidently establish that a supermajority of people would take the job seriously and would be happy with the compensation, we can afford a few bad apples.

Either way, I can imagine that if you were to pledge to purposefully vote against the population's interests in front of a judge, and the judge bought it, they may be allowed to disqualify you on these grounds (and probably slap you with a fine). I wouldn't want to make it impossible to get out of this duty, just difficult enough that most people wouldn't do it.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by stale2002 on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:20PM (#19822398)
> I mean, if you want to be a sociopath about it

Ehh, the sociopaths are the ones who want to force people into slavery, for "civic duty" or whatever.

The rest of us might fight back in ways that you don't like.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:52PM (#19822624)
Voting for policies that hurt people at large isn't "fighting back". What has the public done to you to deserve this? It's like working at a restaurant and spitting in customers' food because the restaurant owner is overworking you, and then saying no, the sociopath is the guy who's forcing me to come in on the weekend. Fuck that noise, you're both sociopaths.

If you're unhappy about being forced into duty, you can abstain from voting at all, or you can focus your energy on changing the system so that it works on a purely voluntary basis. That's perfectly fine. But let's not pretend that voting for bad policies, which will inevitably hurt people who have nothing to do with your predicament, is a proper way to fight back.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by stale2002 on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:59PM (#19822662)
> What has the public done to you to deserve this?

Well, what they did was force me into temporary slavery.

> It's like working at a restaurant and spitting in customers' food

If the customers were forcing me to work in a restaurant, I think I might do that.

> If you're unhappy about being forced into duty, you can abstain from voting at all

Why would I do that, when a much more effective method of screwing over the people who forced me into this, is by voting for bad policy?

The people who would force me into this want good policy. So I do the opposite of what they want.

This is why you don't do stuff like this. Because the people who you are forcing into slavery aren't going to play "nice" with your plan. They will instead take actions that you don't like, regardless of your complaints about it, or regardless how "immoral" you believe it to be.

I do not have to live by your code of ethics. I will instead live by mine, and screw over your plan in the way that hurts everyone the most.

You don't get to complain about "fairness" or the "right" way for me to protest, when you are forcing me into slavery.

I would engage in this behavior specially because it would very effectively sabotage this plan to force people into the work.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:46PM (#19822939)
What? The "public" didn't force you to do anything. The public is just people. You're part of the public, for Christ's sake. A representative who would act as you propose wouldn't be screwing some mysterious nefarious entity that likes to enslave people, they'd be screwing you.

> You don't get to complain about "fairness" or the "right" way for me to protest, when you are forcing me into slavery.

What about the part of the public who doesn't like this system, doesn't want to force you to do anything, and would like to change the way it works? If you're "sabotaging" the system by voting for "bad policies," you're screwing them over along with everyone else. Can they complain? Because I can guarantee you that they will.

Anyway. Let me put it this way: if 95% of the public supports this system, it doesn't matter how hard you try to sabotage it. It won't do dick. If a significant percentage hates the system, let's say 20%, then 20% of the "enslaved" representatives really want to change the system to work on a voluntary basis. Surely they can bloody negotiate with the remaining 80% to enact a reform, instead of lashing out against the public at large, who can't really do anything about the system because they weren't picked by the lottery.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by stale2002 on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:18PM (#19823402)
> it doesn't matter how hard you try to sabotage it. It won't do dick.

Sure it will. It will help cause more bad policies to happen, at the margin.

There would be lots of controversial laws, and 10% of people voting here to mess things up, would effect something.

That's my revenge on the 90% that forced me into this, because of their "support".

> Surely they can bloody negotiate

Why do that, when we can just sabotage things? You don't get to force me into this, and complain when I fight back.

People do not have to react the way that you want them to, or that you find fair. Burning everything to the ground, in whatever way I can, is a perfectly acceptable retaliation to slavery.

Sure, there would be collateral damage. But there is always collateral damage. No matter what political stance a person is fighting for.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:37PM (#19824004)
> Sure it will. It will help cause more bad policies to happen, at the margin.

Very unreliably. You will only be able to influence policies that are nearly 50/50, but if they are 50/50, that is because there is widespread disagreement over which option is better. This means there is a fairly high chance that your "sabotage" vote ironically results in better policy. Think about it: the issue is 50/50, and you have the decisive vote. Half of the voters are wrong. What do you think the odds are that you're in the half that knows what it's doing?

My analysis is that odds that the average saboteur would vote for a bad policy ought to be roughly proportional to the proportion of honest voters that pick the good policy. Unfortunately, these odds are a toss-up when the saboteur's influence is maximized.

> Why do that, when we can just sabotage things?

To get results. Your gripes are understandable enough not to be dismissed, and if you can make a credible threat of sabotage, you may be able to cause a reform and perhaps get your freedom back before the end of the term. Sabotage can be a valid tactic to get what you want, especially if you're in desperate straits, but I don't see how your stunts are supposed to achieve anything at all, let alone anything that cannot be achieved more efficiently through collaboration.

> You don't get to force me into this, and complain when I fight back.

Was I actually complaining, though? When I say your behavior in this situation would be sociopathic, I mean it as a statement of fact. Notice that I followed the remark with "that's part of the risk in the system," clearly indicating that I am willing to eat that loss. I'm not complaining. I'm accounting. (Also, I genuinely think you would be working against your own interests.)

> People do not have to react the way that you want them to, or that you find fair.

I know many people won't react the way I want them to. I know some people will act like sociopaths. This is a variable to quantify: if enough people would turn into madmen if they were forced to do this, well, that invalidates conscription, and it's back to the drawing board. Likewise, if a large number of people think my system is immoral, okay, sure, let's do something else.

I mean, I'm not married to the specifics: I think it is important to make sure that the sample is statistically unbiased, and conscription is the easiest way to do this, but if we can get close enough on a voluntary basis, hey, that's even better.

I do maintain that your reaction would be disproportionate and ultimately immoral. Again, though, I'm not complaining about it, because that would be pointless: you do you. But I'm taking note of it so that I can account for the seriousness of the threat.

Edit: And if the threat is serious enough, you win, really. I would oppose conscription and you wouldn't have to sabotage anything (well, if I had my way). Just want you to know I am listening, even if I disapprove of your behavior.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by stale2002 on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:25PM (#19824230)
> What do you think the odds are that you're in the half that knows what it's doing?

Well then it doesn't matter what I do, so I am not sure why you'd be so angry about it.

> hen I say your behavior in this situation would be sociopathic

It is not sociopathic to retaliate against people who want to force you into temporary slavery. It is instead called justice.

> would turn into madmen

There isn't nothing "mad" about fighting crazies like you who want to force people into slavery.

Instead, the madmen are the ones trying to take away our rights.

Honestly, my actions are fairly tame. I didn't even say that I would engage in violence or anything. I expect that other people might, and I wouldn't blame them.

Violence is a perfectly logical response attempts to force people into slavery. I wouldn't do it, though (because of the other alternatives at my disposal).

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Saturday May 04, 2019 @12:39AM (#19824493)
> Well then it doesn't matter what I do, so I am not sure why you'd be so angry about it.

I'm curious how you think you can evaluate someone's "anger" in written comments on the Internet. I'm not angry. I'm judging you and listing all the problems I see with what you say you would do, but there's frankly no need to be worked up to do any of that.

> It is not sociopathic to retaliate against people who want to force you into temporary slavery. It is instead called justice.

Okay, so my view is that equating this system to slavery is disingenuous, hysterical and ridiculous for too many reasons to count, and that your "retaliation" is unfocused, ineffective and reckless. Your view is that I'm a sociopathic tyrant.

Okay.

But you know what? Who cares.

I don't need your approval. You don't need mine. The only thing that matters is that I want an unbiased sample, but saboteurs, insofar that they purposefully act contrary to what they think is good, constitute an unwanted bias. In other words, you don't want to be conscripted, and I don't want to conscript you. We can probably work something out.

> Honestly, my actions are fairly tame. I didn't even say that I would engage in violence or anything. I expect that other people might, and I wouldn't blame them.

If by engaging in violence, you mean violent resistance to anyone who tries to force you to go to parliament, I consider this more acceptable than your idea of going and voting for bad policies, and I do not think of it as sociopathic (I also strongly oppose having such an enforcement policy).

If you mean random acts of terrorism, then this is insane and you've lost me completely.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by rolleiflex on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:07PM (#19820180)
For someone who doesn’t want to do it, a year is a very long time to come up with ‘serious unforeseen circumstances’.

There is no point in trying to force people to do things - the best way is to change the job in such a way that people will want to take it.

Pay them well, in other words, in money, in prestige, or otherwise.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by pdonis on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:45PM (#19821618)
> the best way is to change the job in such a way that people will want to take it

This isn't a change, it's what we have now. The problem is that the kind of people that want to take it are not the kind of people you actually want doing it.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:58PM (#19820674)
By serious unforeseen circumstances I mean things like getting cancer or being crippled in a freak car accident. Nobody's going to do either of these things just to get out of government duty.

Also, what's important is for the sample to be representative, so it's fine if a very motivated minority gets out of it, as long as it doesn't create a significative bias in the lottery.

But yes, they should be paid handsomely. And as I mentioned in another comment, their debts should be paid in full to make them less vulnerable to bribes.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by zorked on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:08PM (#19820183)
Being government for a year is a better deal than military service, and people don't complain too much about that.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by scythe on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:42PM (#19822078)
Use a tax incentive. It should be set high enough that most people will consider it worth their time, but low enough that anyone who really doesn't want to be in politics won't be financially harmed.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by bduerst on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:44PM (#19822919)
What happens if somebody doesn't really want to do jury duty?
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by vanderZwan on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:22AM (#19819208)
The Greeks who entered the lottery weren't chosen by a (meta) lottery. Greek democracy wasn't nearly as democratic as you may think.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:30AM (#19819282)
Oh, I'm aware. I'm arguing for universal lottery, and I think it would work.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by kevin_thibedeau on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:03PM (#19819580)
Bribery would be more rampant than it is now. With no career aspirations to keep them in line, unethical people would take the lobbyist money and run.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:41PM (#19819953)
What would keep people in line is that this would be illegal. A lottery-based system is also problematic for lobbyists because they have to bribe many more people and they can't help elect the people they have already bribed. If they try to bribe the wrong person, they are in big trouble, because they will get investigated, and even if they succeed, they will have to do it all over again the next year (assuming yearly terms). It's also worth pointing out that a lot of what we call "corruption" is the result of politicians, CEOs and lobbyists going to the same schools, working in the same offices, and just generally being friends. They don't even need to bribe each other. They like each other. Lottery eliminates this aspect almost entirely.

I would say the biggest vulnerability of lottery, with respect to bribery, is debt: if a representative owes a lot of money, they are particularly at risk. Which is why I think the state should pay off all debts owed by all representatives (conditional to not peddling their influence, of course). We can disqualify people who owe excessive amounts so that this doesn't cost too much.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by NeedMoreTea on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:13PM (#19819665)
Bribery doesn't seem rampant in jury service, where members are chosen by lottery. I'm sure we could find ways to keep bribery away.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by sokoloff on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:45PM (#19823755)
If you picked and announced the jurors 60-425 days before they had to serve, I bet you'd see bribery in jury duty emerge.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by NeedMoreTea on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:11PM (#19824155)
I'm in UK, I was informed of my upcoming jury duty about 4 months or more before the actual service.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by sokoloff on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:22PM (#19824217)
We have similar for jury pool service (I have one in my mail pile for about 10 weeks of notice), but is your case assigned and known to you and the parties to the case? I only know the date and court (we also call the evening before to see if we even need to show up and even if we do have to show up, there's no guarantee that you'll get a case as they have to have a slight surplus rather than slight deficit of potential jurors). I doubt any of the parties know my name before the jury is invited to the challenge phase.

Said differently, if I was a defendant, could I find out the exact jurors 2-4 months ahead of time so that I could arrange to bribe them?

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by NeedMoreTea on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:32AM (#19825212)
Ah, that's true. The selection of jurors for a particular trial was only on the day itself. The process sounds similar. We had to turn up at court for two weeks, and would get assigned a trial whenever you were free from the previous one, if it was a short one. The unlucky few who land a major trial have to sit it out to the end of course.

Maybe the sanctions that successfully keep jurors from telling the press about trials 99% of the time could work for this too. Maybe it would have to be cleverer somehow.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by kmonsen on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:31PM (#19819822)
Bribery is even more rampant now with career aspirations since reelection is costly. The job of politicians is to get reelected and they do it by being available to donors.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by koube on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:42PM (#19819962)
If we are able to reduce the question of no reelections to the question of whether we should have term limits, I believe we will find that no reelections will have the same drawbacks as term limits[0].

Lawmaking is a profession, and needs to be done by professionals. If it is not, studies show that power shifts towards other existing power structures, such as the head of state and to lobbyists[1], which would make a lottery based appointments counterproductive on the issue of corruption.

[0]: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2018/01/18/five-reason...

[1]: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/153244000100100...

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:59PM (#19820105)
You are absolutely right about lawmaking being a profession, but in a lottery system, I reckon these professional lawmakers would simply be hired by the representatives, and they could stay on for as long as they are deemed useful. The representatives would act more like full-time overseers on the executive and legislative branches, if that makes sense.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by koube on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:12PM (#19822327)
Junior lawmakers are also perfectly capable of hiring senior lawmakers yet the balance of power still shifts towards lobbyists, so I would assume that the same issue would exist for lottery-drawn representatives.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:02PM (#19823324)
Perhaps. I think there are generally three ways lobbyists can exert influence:

1. By nurturing personal relationships with politicians. I may be mistaken, but I feel like this is probably the most effective method. You want to exploit the natural tendency people have to want to help their friends, even decent people.

2. By helping politicians get what they want (e.g. reelection, but also first election, or election to a new position).

3. By providing compelling arguments and objections to various policies, grounded in special knowledge about their industry. These compelling arguments may be good (in which case the lobbyist's influence is actually a good thing), but they may also be bad (misdirection or lies).

I think lottery is less vulnerable to 1 and 2 (but not immune). It doesn't help against 3, although having seasoned lawmakers does, since they can see through the bullshit.

Either way, it's speculative, and it would need to be properly evaluated somehow.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by koube on Monday May 06, 2019 @04:18PM (#19843369)
Term limits have already been evaluated, as I posted in one of my previous comments.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by bduerst on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:46PM (#19822936)
Increase the penalties for bribes and make them severe enough that representatives won't risk it.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by dhimes on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:44PM (#19820528)
Would you volunteer for it, or would you be conscripted like jury duty?
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:02PM (#19820721)
As I said elsewhere, I'm leaning towards being required to register for the lottery exactly once every ten years or so. I think that'd be a reasonable compromise to ensure a representative sample of the population without inconveniencing people excessively.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by retzkek on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:10PM (#19821825)
The formal name of this system is Sortition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition

There's a good TED talk about it: https://www.ted.com/talks/brett_hennig_what_if_we_replaced_p...

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:06PM (#19820169)
> The greeks had two institutions we could use: ostracism and lottery

To expand on the former, if a majority of Athenians voted to hold an ostracism vote, two months later, the person with the most votes (potentially over a minimum) was banished from the city for 10 years [1].

One can imagine a gentler modern version. Every ballot must have an ostracism line. Every candidate on that ballot must appear on this line. If a simple majority of voters choose the same person, a second one-line election is held in 2 months. If a simple majority of voters, two months later, vote again to ostracize, the candidate is barred from appearing on that jurisdiction's ballots for 8 years.

So if a majority of New Yorkers say Richard Nixon is ostracized, he is simply unable to appear on New York ballots for 8 years. Given the ballot will contain all manner of candidates running for many different offices, this makes it sufficiently difficult to ostracism while providing an incentive against polarization.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostracism

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by bilbo0s on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:42AM (#19818870)
Those were always pretty interesting ideas to me, and I always used to wonder why the Founders did not replicate those facets of the Athenian Republic? It would solve a lot of our problems today.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by danielvf on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:28PM (#19819787)
In general, the founders thought Greek style democracy was a horrible system of government. Inevitably incompetent, bloody, unjust, rash, and would quickly self destruct. When the French Revolution happened - with chaos, purges, wars, and then an emperor taking over the country - the founders basically said “I told you so”.

Here’s an example.

https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Adams/99-02-02-6371

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by bilbo0s on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:14PM (#19820837)
But the French did not have the Athenian safeguards either.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by benmmurphy on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:09PM (#19820193)
Someone who has political aspirations is unlikely to push for a system where the political jobs are allocated by lottery.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by kmonsen on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:32PM (#19819831)
The founders wanted a republic governed by rich landowners. Preferably white and wasp.
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by yongjik on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:16PM (#19820248)
Imagine Google or Facebook hiring 5% of their developers by lottery. Take all applicants, no questions asked, pick randomly.

I can't fathom why people think "managing a country" requires less skills than managing servers. The consequences of hiring someone unqualified is certainly not less severe.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by duggan on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:32PM (#19820395)
I imagine in that scenario that Google and Facebook would get particularly good at resilience and security.

Once you've got enough people, 5% of them may as well have been hired by lottery, depending on what you're measuring. People get less productive, more productive, want to change the company, decide to steal things, etc.

I think it's interesting to think about.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by breuleux on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:51PM (#19820607)
Consider that the system would be rethought accordingly, though.

Representatives picked by lottery would not "manage" the country: they would hire qualified people to do so, and they would supervise their work according to their values. The point of the lottery, at least the way I see it, is to have an unbiased random sample of the population oversee the government, but not to actually run it.

Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by fmahaztra on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:37AM (#19819346)
Assuming I'm understanding it correctly, wouldn't the first one be a huge disincentive for the passing of politically/socially unpopular policies that are beneficial in the long-term?
Re:A New Way of Voting That Makes Zealotry Expensive by forinti on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:48AM (#19819452)
You wouldn't be able to vote everyone into ostracism. Only the most disliked politicians would be thrown out of the game.