As an example you offer an online document cleaner, the user uploads his document and you do the magic on it, but if you encrypt the document then the backend can't read it. The document needs to be decrypted somewhere.
It’s a genuine question for which I’ve done a small amount of google/Wikipedia reading, but I suspect the answer is “no, of course not”, but I’ve been surprised before by tech/crypto solutions that I didn’t know the details of.
Sure, but it's how business in the real world works as well. You can't enter a shop without being observed or even recorded, either by cameras or the shop personal / owner in smaller ones. Your behavior during a conversation is analyzed in realtime and reacted to, that's the basics of selling. There is no invisible commerce in the real world.
That's a fundamental reality that you can't just omit, doing so would be irrational treating the web as something purely abstract, which it isn't. It's an abstraction / extension of the real world, because it's part of it.
What the web needs is obvious boundaries and private spaces that are basically extensions of your own home and those of your friends, make it clear that you can't do x or y (going in public) without being observed and analyzed. Right now the only real indicator is the tracker count of adblock plugins.
But there are plenty of situations where the analogy shows how invasive surveillance can be. Imagine if your car mechanic kept a log of everywhere you drove. Imagine if the mattress maker knew everything that took place in your bed (for product improvement, naturally).
I'm alright with necessary data collection, like the banks and brokers recording what I ask them to do. But that's because there's no other way of doing those things except for services or becoming a professional myself. If the software can work as not a service, then I'm less okay with the data collection when it's only offered as a service.
So the best thing would be to fight for better information, education and clarity about these things, instead of treating only the symptoms with regulations and laws that only excludes people from participating in the market.
Why not have mandatory indicators about different privacy levels and a driver license for tech that gives people the necessary foundations? This could solve the privacy problem from the ground up.
I try to do my part. I do not buy access to games on Steam, movies and TV series on Netflix, books on Amazon, I do not use Google, I do not use Facebook nor am I in contact with anyone who does, and so on.
I am open to discussion. Why is it specifically capitalism's fault? What other economic systems would be favored, and why?
> If you do not like a service, you can opt out by not using it
This is a simplistic objection, that doesn't stand to cursory scrutiny. These systems invade everything, and give you no real way of consenting. When you visit some random site, you will be informed upon to dozens of services, with no way of even knowing which. You might not use Google, but can you avoid sending an email to anyone using Gmail - particularly those who use it with their own domain?
And this is getting impossible to escape even in real life, with companies employing many mechanisms to surveil you on the public street, without you even entering their private property. How do you opt out of that? Stay at home 24/7? No, that doesn't work either.
> If you have an issue with something used by millions of people, then you should consider the possibility that it actually may be the people who keep the service alive.
People are driven by incentives. We can criticize a system, government or company for incentivizing behavior we consider harmful.
> I try to do my part. I do not buy access to games on Steam, movies and TV series on Netflix, books on Amazon, I do not use Google, I do not use Facebook nor am I in contact with anyone who does, and so on.
And yet, the last site you submitted to HN loads stuff from Facebook's servers. Even if you have enough know-how to block them, you've helped them surveil other people.
> Why is it specifically capitalism's fault?
It's capitalism's fault insofar as it promotes these business models.
> What other economic systems would be favored, and why?
Criticizing a system doesn't mean one advocates its replacement.
These systems invade everything, and give you no real way of consenting
This is a simplistic objection, that doesn't stand to cursory scrutiny When you visit some random site, you will be informed upon to dozens of services, with no way of even knowing which
You decide the browser and extensions you are using, and your computer is actually making the connection to the others websites.. ! You might not use Google, but can you avoid sending an email to anyone using Gmail - particularly those who use it with their own domain?
When you send a regular snail mail you don't control either the postal box used -- a company could be scanning the document. Don't send the mail, or encrypt it. with companies employing many mechanisms to surveil you on the public street
The issues lies in the fact that the streets are public and not private placesConsent requires intent. Just because my browser happened to connect to some website, does not mean I give consent to have my accesses recorded and used for other purposes.
You may say it's legitimate to log and track without consent, but you can't invent my consent.
And the fact that it's often considered legitimate to log and track without consent is what enables most surveillance capitalism (though some consensual business models exist as well).
> When you send a regular snail mail you don't control either the postal box used -- a company could be scanning the document.
And that would be part of surveillance capitalism as well.
> The issues lies in the fact that the streets are public and not private places
Maybe so; analyzing such questions is part of the studies on surveillance capitalism.
Service as a Software Substitute (SaaSS)[1] is also inherently spyware, an increasingly popular feature as surveillance capitalism[2] infects our economy.
[1] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-s...
[2] http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/02/shoshana-zuboff-q-and...