News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:32PM (#19810313)
“It's funny that 15 years back I was so anti MS and pro Google and now I think it's the other way!”

Stay skeptical of all of them. No need to be fan of one of the big techs. In the end they are all greedy organizations that want to dominate. None of them should be trusted.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by ticmasta on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:49PM (#19813316)
As a developer MS has treated me really well, IMO. They churn out as much short-lived tech as the next company but I think their windows-based culture of backwards compatibility carried over into the developer ecosystem, and the future of .Net Core running in Linux containers with docker and k8s, against SQL Server on Linux would make anyone who's been away from their tech for the past 5 years think they stepped out of a time machine.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by phkahler on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:10PM (#19813867)
On backwards compatibility. I recently learned that apple has deprecated OpenGL and soon will not support it at all. What a slap to developers... so yeah there is some value to Microsofts approach.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by megy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:23PM (#19813977)
There is an advantage and a disadvantage to backwards compatibility. Letting people keep using old technology that hampers progress. You have to devote resources to ensuring that it still works, and you have less people using the new stuff.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by SpikeDad on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:26PM (#19814004)
Apple isn't afraid of ditching tech when it becomes clear it's a dead end. In almost all cases they've been correct and the rest of the industry soon follows their leads.

Think how reliable Windows would be today if they hadn't left in all the cruft as far back as Windows 2000.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:19AM (#19815492)
> In almost all cases they've been correct and the rest of the industry soon follows their leads.

Counterpoint: 3.5mm jacks are perfectly fine and were never a "dead end".

OpenGL's indeed pretty crusty, but Vulkan is not. Apple would be better off participating in that ecosystem instead of letting NIH syndrome take hold.

> Think how reliable Windows would be today if they hadn't left in all the cruft as far back as Windows 2000.

Counterpoint: an x86 Linux executable statically compiled/linked any time after the a.out → ELF migration (so... predating Windows 2000) can be expected to run without issue on a bleeding-edge x86 kernel today (and if it's not able to do so, then that's a bug, and Linus will personally descend upon and eviscerate the one unfortunate enough to have introduced that bug).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bovermyer on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:44PM (#19810439)
I'm both wary of and hopeful about Microsoft and Google.

"Trust but verify" and all that.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:04PM (#19811427)
"Vertrauen ist gut, Kontrolle ist besser" for the Germans here :-)
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by sooper on Thursday May 02, 2019 @10:16PM (#19814921)
I think this is a better aphorism than "trust, but verify".

I work in the information security assurance field, I swear that 90% of the issues I see at companies with external service providers comes back to the fact that their contract does not have anywhere enough ability to hold the service provider to task...

Get everything you need in the contract / agreement, then hope you never have to use it.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by maxxxxx on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:16AM (#19818627)
From my experience it’s close to impossible to have a 100% bullet proof contract. If you try that you end up with the typical government contracting style where you spend a lot of time with specs and requirements upfront but it falls apart as soon as it touches reality.

In the end you need to pick suppliers you can work with productively no matter what the correct details are.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:52PM (#19810536)
I’ve always found this phrase an oxymoron.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by hathawsh on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:51PM (#19811239)
You're correct: an oxymoron is a phrase that is seemingly self-contradictory. While "trust but verify" is an oxymoron, it is not a contradiction or paradox.

A simpler oxymoron is "to make haste slowly". In that phrase, the "make haste" part describes velocity, while "slowly" describes acceleration. Anyone who has taken Calculus knows that velocity and acceleration can be independent variables. Thus "to make haste slowly" is an oxymoron but not self-contradictory.

Similarly, "trust but verify" describes two possibly independent variables: your attitude about the future and your behavior regarding the past. You can choose to trust people to make good decisions for the future, while simultaneously verifying they made good decisions in the past. Alternatives to "trust but verify" include "always trust", which has obvious bad consequences; "never trust", which has different but also bad consequences; "trust sometimes", which is ambiguous; and "verify always", which is unrealistic. The phrase "trust but verify" describes a healthy attitude and behavior.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:03PM (#19811406)
I wasn't 100% sure if I chose the correct term, thanks for the explanation!
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Isamu on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:12PM (#19812296)
It's a punchline from a joke that Reagan told repeatedly around the time of US-USSR weapons treaties. It's supposed to be funny.

Something along the lines of: "Q: Can we trust these guys to uphold their side of the deal? A: Sure, trust but verify."

Edit: here it is, it's actually a funny Russian proverb that Reagan was repeating.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust,_but_verify

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bovermyer on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:00PM (#19810606)
Where humans are involved, mistakes will happen. Trusting someone but verifying their work is a safe and sane pairing.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by apetresc on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:25PM (#19810941)
But the whole point of trusting is that you get to skip verifying. What's the difference between trusting and not trusting if you still have to put in the work of verification anyway?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by thaumasiotes on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:04PM (#19812168)
The difference is in when you begin cooperating. You can work much faster by immediately acting on agreements and later making sure the other party is attempting to hold up their end than you can by waiting until you can prove something about the other party and only then starting whatever it is you were supposed to do.

Consider these different hiring schemes:

1. Hire whoever applies, and keep them forever, no matter what. ("Trust, don't verify.")

2. Hire whoever applies, and fire them later if they don't seem to be working out. ("Trust, but verify.")

3. Full background check and extensive additional vetting before an offer is made. ("Don't trust, do verify.")

4. Never hire anyone. ("Don't trust, don't verify.")

Aside from the obvious pacing differences, note that what's verified (or not) in options 1/2 is different from what is verified in option 3. That's not a coincidence -- before you start working with someone, you can't assess whether they're doing a good job. You have to rely on more general (and therefore less reliable) markers of trustworthiness.

(You may think option 4 sounds ridiculous. It isn't -- that is the historical norm for cooperation outside of very well-defined groups like your family or your tribe.)

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by stupidcar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:27PM (#19810970)
How is verifying everything because you don't trust people not to make a mistake operationally different from verifying everything because you suspect bad faith? To the supposed trusted party, the result is the same: you not taking them at their word and instead checking whatever they do. Even if you're being honest about only verifying to avoid mistakes, you can never prove it.

This definition of "trust but verify" would be better reduced to "verify", since it essentially claims that trust is, if not impossible, not practically applicable in any situation.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rotrux on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:18PM (#19811579)
@stupidcar we've reached the depth-limit, so I'm responding here.

> In the case of "trust but verify", how does this trust manifest in a provable way?

Good point. "provable" is the problem here since we don't know eachother, and frankly I can't prove you're trustworthy initially; that's why the question this addresses (namely "trust-or-misstrust?") arises in the first place. Assuming we don't have dossiers on everyone we're going to meet and work with, we have to decide on an initial point on the trust-scale you mentioned with which to begin interaction.

"Trust but verify" is about having faith that people are generally good, and treating strangers that way while protecting yourself. It indicates balance between treating strangers like data-points and getting walked all over is important, and it provides a suggestion about how to approach the situation.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by thaumasiotes on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:01PM (#19812137)
> we've reached the depth-limit, so I'm responding here.

There isn't a depth limit.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rotrux on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:32PM (#19812547)
> There isn't a depth limit.

Well looks like you're right, but the nonetheless the reply button wasn't there.

Did I sufficiently address your question?

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by thaumasiotes on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:07PM (#19813849)
> Did I sufficiently address your question?

What question are you referring to?

Regardless, I suggest that it is better to reply to the comment you're replying to than to reply to some other comment, whether you see a reply link or not. You don't need the reply link to reply to a comment.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by e12e on Thursday May 02, 2019 @06:40PM (#19813665)
There's a soft rate limit.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rotrux on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:51PM (#19811234)
There are different kinds and levels of trust. "Trust but verify" doesn't mean you should give strangers your SSN.

I agree that this nuance is lost within the turn-of-phrase, but omitting the trust part doesn't seem to me like a good way to build a collaborative society. Companies are just people.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by stupidcar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:03PM (#19811405)
Yes, of course trust is a spectrum, and socially important, etc. But none of that answers my question: In the case of "trust but verify", how does this trust manifest in a provable way?

Consider it like this: For me, trust is feelings/thoughts. I might trust you a little, a lot, etc. But for you, my trust can only be demonstrated by my actions, because you can't peer inside my head and tell whether I'm genuinely trust you, or I'm only claiming to.

"Trust but verify" recommends adopting a mindset of trust but a pattern of behaviour externally indistinguishable from distrust. If I'm verifying everything you do, that does't signal trust, whatever the reasons I might give for it.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarejunba on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:41PM (#19811130)
The trust part is me trusting you to want to do the right thing. The verify part is me checking that nothing went wrong - either through a mistake on your part, a misunderstanding on mine, or just the signal loss from the fact that human communication is imperfect.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by stupidcar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:48PM (#19811203)
You've just restated the original post and ignored my question. Again: how does this definition of supposed trust differ from distrust in any verifiable way?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by fbarred on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:26PM (#19811676)
Trust but verify: I will trust you will do X, and will do Y in return, but I will verify that you are actually doing X. Example: mutual disarmament treaties with Soviet Union, Iran nuclear deal.

Don't trust: I will not even engage with you and will not do Y. Example: the belief by some that US should not engage in high-level diplomatic talks with North Korea on disarmament because North Korea has no incentive to follow through on its promises.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarejunba on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:58PM (#19811346)
It affects our interaction. Because I assume you'll act in good faith, I only add verification in the range of errors not in the range of malice.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by stupidcar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:23PM (#19811633)
It seems to me that the range of human error is rarely smaller than that of malice, so again I'm not sure there will be much apparent difference between an exhaustive verification of either sort.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarejunba on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:40PM (#19811870)
Is that true in your interactions with other people? I have not seen that be the case. The distribution is very different.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rocqua on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:06PM (#19812933)
If you suspect bad faith (i.e. don't trust someone) you don't even get in business. If you trust someone but verify their work, you get in business but still limit damage if they turn out to act in bad faith.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rurp on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:40PM (#19811112)
It is, but also carries a clear message; I think that dichotomy is why it's been such an enduring phrase.

The term became well known in the US during the cold war, in the context of arms treaties. The US and Russia were making agreements that relied on at least the appearance of, and some degree of actual, trust. Meanwhile they were undertaking extensive efforts to check if the other party was actually following their obligations.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:11PM (#19810778)
It's not. The trust is in the good intentions, the verification is that people do make mistakes. I trust myself, but I still verify my own work.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by CodeMage on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:44PM (#19811925)
What it means is "Trust the intentions, but verify the results."

It's just that "trust, but verify" is shorter and more memorable.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by levesque on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:00PM (#19810609)
Don't trust, verify.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by amelius on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:26PM (#19810958)
And how do you do that? E.g. how do you verify that Google deletes your data when you tell it to?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by levesque on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:46PM (#19811953)
No idea, was just messing around. If one really were to do this, the best way would probably be to trick them into employing you, and then verify from the inside (and even then, good luck!). I do believe it's going to be an issue in the future, if it isn't already one. Even as a government, how do you really make sure that company X erases the data?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by marmaduke on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:04PM (#19812905)
it's like preparing for the worst, while hoping for the best
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by make3 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:03PM (#19810652)
trust enough to use but keep your eyes open
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by redisman on Sunday May 05, 2019 @01:55PM (#19834004)
Tech giants are the biggest companies by market cap and run the world now. They're not the lovable runts from the 90's anymore.