News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:07PM (#19809405)
It’s unfortunate to see Microsoft (along with Adobe, etc) expanding into Ads. If nothing else, they could really differentiate and join forces with Apple from privacy standpoint to oppose Google, Amazon and Facebook.

Instead, “Intellisense with AI now available on VS Code” is Microsoft’s nice way of saying “We harvest the shit out of your data”. Ah, like a true Ad company. Don’t get me started on Windows 10 telemetry.

I really believe that Apple’s bet on privacy will pay off well in the long term. They’re different companies (Apple is selling hardware) but boy they could have gone into Ads with a MASSIVE user base but they chose to limit Ads in the App Store. It would have been huge expansion opportunity but they didn’t pursue it. And it will pay off as privacy awareness spreads and Microsoft could join them as operating system providers.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by johnday on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:28PM (#19809635)
> “Intellisense with AI now available on VS Code” is Microsoft’s nice way of saying “We harvest the shit out of your data”.

What? The IntelliCode description says that "Contextual recommendations are based on practices developed in thousands of high quality, open-source projects on GitHub each with high star ratings.". I'm not clear on how you think Microsoft will harvest data from doing this - much less how it is related to ads.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:31PM (#19809664)
There is telemetry built into VS Code that you can turn off, but it is turned on by default. There is no way to know how they're using that data. Microsoft also collects data on Office365 platform and even local Office 2019 installs.

I was trying was to make a tongue in cheek point, rather than specifically digging into exact methods of how they collect data. You may be right but it is besides the core issue we are discussing here.

At the end, it is irrelevant how they're collecting data - all you need to know is this: https://about.ads.microsoft.com/en-us

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:31PM (#19810306)
We don't do any training on your data. Telemetry is largely for feature use tracking (eg we should really do better around this component, everyone is using it). There is absolutely no ads overlap at all. Literally none.

Disclosure: I work at Azure but not on VS Code

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by rurp on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:56PM (#19811319)
A big tech company harvesting extensive user data by default and saying it's ok because "Trust us, we don't do anything bad with it" is not a compelling argument these days. Even if it's true (and that's a big if), that says nothing about what Microsoft will do with the data tomorrow, or the next day.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:36PM (#19811818)
It's on by default, but literally the first thing we ask you, actively, is about giving us feedback and let you turn it off right then. It's not remotely hidden.

I totally understand, though about trust. We've been asking users for feedback for 20+ years, I hope we've shown ourselves to be good actors!

Disclosure: I work at Azure on machine learning

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:05PM (#19815172)
> We've been asking users for feedback for 20+ years, I hope we've shown ourselves to be good actors!

Not sure about the Azure team (since my experience with Azure is limited to a one-off project that required a SQL Server instance to test compatibility with some client's legacy DB, plus some very recent dabbling in VS Code and Azure Data Studio), but whichever team runs Windows nowadays, for example, hasn't exactly "shown [them]selves to be good actors". Or is preinstalling Candy Crush even on "Professional" versions of Windows 10 considered being a "good actor" by today's standards?

(Sure, even the first versions of Windows had games preinstalled, but those were first-party instead of third-party, they ostensibly existed to help users learn how to use a mouse, and they didn't plaster themselves front-and-center on my Start menu like seedy massage parlors in a Bangkok red light district)

Needless to say, "we've been siphoning your data for multiple decades, so you can trust us to keep doing so even though we're actively betraying that trust at this very moment" is cold comfort at best. I would hope that the New™ and Improved™ Microsoft™ would at least have some self-awareness about that.

I'm sure your intentions are good and pure. I hope they stay that way. I have no way of knowing whether or not they will, and historical precedent says they probably won't. It shouldn't be surprising that I and plenty of other tech-savvy users would take such claims of trustworthiness with a baseball-sized grain of salt.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:10PM (#19823617)
I should have said - "be good actors in relation to how we handle your data."

According to the Windows GDPR statement (https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy/gdpr-it-gui...), we only collect Windows functional data and Windows diagnostic data, and only if you allow us.

If we did more than that, we'd be liable for huge fines/jail! We have never "siphoned your data for multiple decades" - we only collect WHEN and ONLY WHEN you let us.

The way that our intentions haven't changes is because we are legally required to tell you if they do!

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:25PM (#19842832)
I know a lot of people like to claim that the US is like the EU, but this is the first time I've heard someone claim that the US is literally in the EU.

Less sarcastically: the GDPR is not applicable in the US, so hiding behind that does me no good. If your only defense is "but the GDPR doesn't let us do that!", then that's deeply concerning and only proves my point.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by tekknik on Saturday May 04, 2019 @10:30AM (#19826660)
You keep saying trust the GDPR, but what about us on the other side of the pond? GDPR gives us zero recourse if you do run afoul.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by pm90 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @08:59PM (#19814543)
@ThIronYuppie Let me say first of all that I really appreciate your sincerity and belief in the Goodness of the company that you work for. The issue is not insincerity, but:

* a lack of trust in corporations in today's economic and political climate and

* the skyrocketing growth of the online advertising business, which has made user data quite literally the gold mines of the digital age

The incentives today are very very well aligned for a corporation to sell user data. Even if a company may mostly be made of good people, without explicitly written contracts or declarations of any kind, a Company can change internal policies rather quickly. Maybe there will be a manager who sees the selling of that data as a way to boost profit and rise within the company. Maybe the company sells that division along with their data.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by ionised on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:07AM (#19816990)
You say the issue is not insincerity but I beg to differ. Microsoft has never been particularly sincere about the reasons it does the things it does.

It has been a deceitful bully of a company for a long time.

Indeed, one of the main reasons why there is so little trust in corporations is because they are so insincere, anti-consumer and lacking in any kind of social conscience.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:02PM (#19823586)
I get it - I do. I'm a recent returnee to MSFT, after many years working not at MSFT, and I remember what it was like.

We can't rewind and fix the past, but we absolutely can be better working forward, and we will.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:00PM (#19823581)
I totally get it. We're a big company, and you're right to question EVERYTHING. All I can say is we'll try and earn your trust every day and laws like GDPR make sure that we're on the hook to do so. Put another way - we CANNOT change this without EXPLICITLY notifying you.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kohtatsu on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:13AM (#19815764)
s/gold/oil/
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by ionised on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:03AM (#19816972)
> I totally understand, though about trust. We've been asking users for feedback for 20+ years, I hope we've shown ourselves to be good actors!

I don't believe you have, sorry (Microsoft I mean, not you specifically). I get the impression Microsoft is the same company it always was, only now it's better at convincing the gullible that it is on their side.

That Windows 10 update prompt for previous Windows versions were obnoxious and downright deceitful, making the 20+ years old traditional 'close window' X in the corner of the window actually download the update instead of doing what users expect it to do.

That's before we even get onto the subject of Windows 10's draconian privacy policies and use of dark patterns all over the OS designed to get people to disable their privacy settings.

Of course, even if they don't fall for tricks like coloring the 'privacy customisation options' link during installation a slightly different colour of blue than the background of the window to make it deliberately hard to read, they will still likely have all their privacy options reset and have previously removed crapware like Candy Crush added all over again in a forced update.

I'm on a Pro version of Windows 10 and I can't even disable the telemetry and constant phoning home every time I launch an application and or encounter a problem (that I absolutely do not need help with) with something I'm running.

I could understand this crap with the Home version. Not on Pro which I fully expected to have a degree of control over like I did with Win7 pro.

As a result of all this, Microsoft finally made my shit list after decades of shady behaviour and anti-competitive business practices and I won't be buying or using anything by them going forward.

Hell I even started PC gaming on Linux, that's how much I dislike the things Microsoft does.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Silhouette on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:33AM (#19819305)
I'm a little late to this party, but I couldn't agree more (except that I'm in the fortunate position of making decisions about my businesses, so we can decide not to use Windows 10 at all for much the same reasons).

We also don't use VS Code at all, for one simple reason: we tried to determine what the privacy policy actually was, and we couldn't. In particular, there appeared to be wording among the various indirectly linked documents that implied Microsoft might at some point upload our source code without our knowledge or consent, with no guarantees and nothing to indicate how it would or might then be used.

Combine that with an organisation that has a recent deliberate strategy of pushing updates whether wanted or not, collecting data whether volunteered or not, and attempting to coerce or deceive users into accepting those things whether it's in their interest to do so or not, and unfortunately while certain people who work for Microsoft and comment here may have no ill intent, it simply isn't safe to trust the company as a whole with the same benefit of the doubt.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:13PM (#19823639)
Good news! The privacy policy is specifically listed in our FAQ on our website - https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/supporting/FAQ

We _only_ collect telemetry data. NEVER user data. And you can opt out! (it's right there during set up - or you can go here - https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/supporting/faq#_how-to-di...).

Again, to reiterate, we would never collect data if you didn't consent. It's the law!

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Silhouette on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:33PM (#19823978)
Good news! The privacy policy is specifically listed in our FAQ on our website

Unfortunately, if you go down that rabbit hole (which we did before) it follows various redirect links and ends up at https://privacy.microsoft.com/en-us/privacystatement, which is a generic document that changes frequently and includes by reference ambiguous additional product-specific documents that may or may not exist.

What you need here is an absolutely clear, unambiguous statement to the effect that you will never under any circumstances upload our source code or other proprietary data to any external system without our explicit opt-in. It's really that simple. Otherwise, I'm afraid those of us working under commercial confidentiality agreements or other legal controls are just going to run away.

Again, to reiterate, we would never collect data if you didn't consent. It's the law!

Perhaps you could explain to me how to turn off the telemetry in Windows 10 then? Or for that matter how consent was obtained for the telemetry that was silently added to earlier Windows versions after release by anyone who installed Microsoft's recommended updates?

I appreciate that your personal intentions may be honest and good here, but the simple fact is that your organisation has a very clear, very bad track record at this in recent years, and its senior leadership has not only been entirely unretentant about that policy despite widespread criticism but actively doubled down on it. Anything Microsoft does will naturally be contaminated by that history now, unless as a minimum it makes a clear, legally actionable statement and/or imposes verifiable technical measures to guarantee different behaviour.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:21AM (#19833225)
From the linked FAQ:

VS Code collects usage data and sends it to Microsoft to help improve our products and services. Read our privacy statement to learn more.

If you don't wish to send usage data to Microsoft, you can set the telemetry.enableTelemetry setting to false.

From File > Preferences > Settings (macOS: Code > Preferences > Settings), search for telemetry.enableTelemetry and uncheck the setting. This will silence all telemetry events from VS Code going forward. Telemetry information may have been collected and sent up until the point when you disable the setting.

That's ALL telemetry. So, the second you don't actively opt-in, we collect no telemetry data in VS Code AT ALL.

You'll also want to disable crash reporting:

VS Code collects data about any crashes that occur and sends it to Microsoft to help improve our products and services. Read our privacy statement to learn more.

If you don't wish to send crash data to Microsoft, you can set the telemetry.enableCrashReporter setting to false.

It's that simple. Absolutely nothing - and CERTAINLY no user code (which we never collected in the first place.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Silhouette on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:14AM (#19840163)
Thank you for the further response. I'm not sure whether this is your area at work or you're just trying to help here, but as further feedback in return, that reads like an opt-out scheme to me. I'm also immediately struck that this relies on a setting (which Microsoft products have a history of changing when installing later updates) and that we still haven't resolved whether VS Code has its own separate privacy policy (which is mentioned as a possibility in the generic Microsoft privacy statement we were discussing before, without any specific indication of how to determine the answer definitively or where it would be found if it exists).

So again, while I appreciate that individuals involved may have honest intentions and be trying to help here, this is still a very long way from the kind of clear, unambiguous official statement that would make me trust any Microsoft product enough to use it in the current data-harvesting, forced-updates climate. I have specific legal obligations to clients when dealing with their source code and the proprietary knowledge implicit within it, and there's no way I can take this sort of documentation to my lawyer and say "Can I use this?".

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by mwilsonthomas on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:00PM (#19812864)
You can read more about exactly how the IntelliCode feature uses telemetry and data here:

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/intellicode/in... - No user-defined code is sent to Microsoft, but we do collect information about your use of the IntelliCode results.

For base model suggestions, which are open source or .NET types and members, we capture whether you selected an IntelliCode suggestion and log the name of the suggestion. Microsoft uses the data to monitor the quality of the base model. For custom models, we capture whether you selected an IntelliCode suggestion but do not log the names of your user-defined types or methods.

Thanks Mark Wilson-Thomas Program Manager Visual Studio IntelliCode

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:41PM (#19810391)
Thank you for the insight. Would you know if this is written somewhere on the VS Code homepage or privacy policy? I think it should be highlighted!
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:36PM (#19811827)
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by komali2 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:53PM (#19810549)
Is there a way we can see what data specifically is being sent to your servers from our local VSCode installations?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AdamTReineke on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:14PM (#19810818)
(Disclaimer, work at Microsoft. Not on VS Code.) I expect you should be able to run Fiddler or Wireshark or similar traffic sniffers to see the requests.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:12PM (#19815196)
At least in theory, it shouldn't be necessary to go to such an extreme, considering that VS Code is ostensibly FOSS and thus readily auditable for this sort of thing: https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode

This assumes, of course, that y'all aren't doing any weird code-injecting funny business when packaging it up for installation :)

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:07PM (#19811468)
I presume these requests are encrypted? So, it is hard to know what exactly is being sent.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by CodeCube on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:31PM (#19811734)
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AJ007 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:09PM (#19810763)
What people want to hear is there is none, and there never will be. Even that isn’t enough, but at least there is some legal recourse.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by icxa on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:38PM (#19811095)
We need to stop relying on the assertions Big Tech make about themselves, and work towards regulation.

What most viewers saw during the Facebook congressional hearing was woefully out of touch, forgive me for using this phrase “old white guys” questioning Mark with many facepalm-able moments. But the house hearing, which includes 40 representatives from the Millennial generation, who grew up on tech, asked much better questions. It just got swallowed up by the news cycle because the Manafort Raid was happening at the same time as hearing about the Cambridge Analytica scandal was occuring.

All of this is still new. Banking, Finance, Real Estate, those are all well regulated at this point and arguably much more sophisticated or complex. The situation we have now with the Googles, Amazons, Microsoft, Facebooks of the world packaging up our metadata, combining it with other third party data, training AI, etc is all new, and those who are knowledgeable about it are just now making it into congress, so I am optimistic we will start to see real regulation on these shameful business practices soon.

Roger McNamee had an excellent conversation on the Sam Harris podcast recently about all of this. It was a very good conversation and one I highly recommend listening to.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:43PM (#19811914)
Can you say more? Like there is none what?

If there are any changes to this doc - https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/compliance/gd... - you would be able to check that immediately, and we would never change our data collection policy without changing that document... It's the law!

Disclosure: I work at Azure on machine learning but not VS Code

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AJ007 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @08:34AM (#19858197)
"We specifically make the UE4 EULA apply perpetually so that when you obtain a version under a given EULA, you can stay on that version and operate under that EULA forever if you choose." https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/108340919447950541...
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by ionised on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:09AM (#19817000)
He means no telemetry. None whatsoever. At the very least a default opt-out.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:14PM (#19823642)
You got it! https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/supporting/faq#_how-to-di...

(we ask both during install, and you can disable at any time)

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by thereare5lights on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:28PM (#19810991)
Is there any way we can verify this?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scrollaway on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:34PM (#19811047)
If you can't trust Microsoft employees saying it, then it's most likely you won't be able to trust anything short of running Wireshark to verify the outgoing data, no?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by TheIronYuppie on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:40PM (#19811872)
For better or worse, here - https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/compliance/gd...

However, if you don't trust us (and I get it!) Your best bet is just to opt out which you can do at any time, including during install.

Disclosure: I work at AZure on machine learning but not VS Code

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by e12e on Thursday May 02, 2019 @06:52PM (#19813730)
If in the EU you could ask for all collected data under the GDPR. [ed: all personal data - so there might be some set of aggregated, non-identifable data that they might not be required by gdpr to allow insight to - that is however a pretty high bar to clear (and intertwines with being allowed to sample / collect that data in the first place, informed concent, defaulting to not collecting data (opt-in) etc]
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by mhermher on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:00PM (#19810617)
Whew! For a second I thought MS might be selling information on what type of variable names I use to advertisers.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bitL on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:40PM (#19811109)
Nah, it's more like automating you away once significant part of your coding process is replicated by AI in the future and then selling your replacement/virtual clone to your employer at a lower cost :-P I guess at some point there will be a replacement/clone store and any company could add 'mhermher'-style coding to their own projects by purchasing clone there. Internally ranked and price exponentially rising the more capable replacement is (e.g. ACM ICPC winning replacements will cost millions).
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by graycat on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:13PM (#19813894)
I'm a Windows desktop user, XP, 7, and 10. That's what I want, a DESKTOP. I don't have a smart phone. I may soon buy a $20 mobile flip phone. I have nothing from Apple.

For my own general purpose computing, I want Windows desktop especially with its backwards compatibility.

For business, I'm doing a startup which for the users is a Web site, and I wrote the code on XP and will run it on 7 as my server until I switch over to Windows Server.

I've done nothing with Unix or Linux.

In the past 10 years, I've typed in about 400,000 lines of text as software, with about 100,000 program language statements. For the compiled code, it's essentially all Visual Basic .NET with ASP.NET for Web pages and ADO.NET for getting to SQL Server database. I like VB.NET. I did my startup Web pages with ASP.NET -- seems fine to me although they are my first Web pages and I;m no Web page expert. E.g., I wrote no JavaScript although ASP.NET writes a little for me which is optional.

For a cloud, for now I'd be concerned about cost, startup time, and security. Later I'll be concerned about security.

I tried Visual Studio for a few minutes and gave up on it. I've used no integrated development environment and have no desire to.

My two most important tools are my favorite text editor KEdit and my favorite scripting language Rexx. I type my code into KEdit and have a lot of KEdit macros to help me with the code. The code for my Web site is about 100,000 lines of typing and about 24,000 programming language statements -- I had no trouble debugging and never wanted anything like Visual Studio.

I wouldn't use Visual Studio for free -- too much botheration for too little need.

When I looked at Visual Studio, I could find no reasonable, usable, competent documentation, and no way do I want to take out months to figure out like a puzzle and document Visual Studio for my own use. E.g., Microsoft keeps talking about "intelisense" as if I should already know what that meant and would like it. Of course, I can't look up intellisense in a dictionary, and absolutely, positively, with feet locked four feet down in reinforced concrete will Microsoft refuse to document, describe, and explain what they mean by intellisense. It is as if their gibberish not in any dictionary has self-evident meaning and value -- it has neither. Grotesque, outrageous, inarticulate, incompetent, sick-o communications.

It turns out, ASP.NET is super easy to debug -- just give the .ASPX file to a Web browser and let ASP code do its things.

For Office and e-mail, I use my legal copy of Office 2003 with Outlook. Now that I have good, extensive notes on how to adjust the settings and options on Outlook, I can do the setups in an hour instead of the several days as before; it's fine. There are some improvements I could think of, but I doubt that Microsoft would be interested. It might be that I could program the improvements with the old VBA which might be able to read and parse an Outlook PST file, but so far I've never tried VBA and when I did want to try it didn't have a copy. For Excel, I use it to draw simple graphs and otherwise regard it as worthless -- I'd much rather write code in Rexx, VB.NET, Fortran, PL/I, etc. and then use Excel to draw the plots. My understanding is that now there is much better graph drawing software, likely with API's, or better API's, than Excel.

For high quality word whacking, I use D. Knuth's original TeX and love it. I hate Word -- used it some, got okay with it, but hate it.

Lessons: To me, for my personal computing and for business, I want the full power of a good desktop computer. I place high value on backward compatibility, e.g., back to Office 2003, an old Watcom Fortran, an old IBM OSL (Optimization Subroutine Library) to be called from Watcom Fortran, KEdit, Open Object Rexx, etc. For business and software development, VB.NET is fine.

Far and away my greatest gripe with computing, the computer industry, and Microsoft is documentation -- on average, the quality of the documentation is awful. To me, the biggest problem in my startup, by far, is poor documentation. Broadly the poor documentation has commonly taken me 100-200 hours to do things I should have been able to do in one hour. So, I DO write my own notes and then AM able to do the stuff in one hour. The bad documentation is close to killing my startup. Long since I should have been sending six figures a year to Microsoft for licenses on their software, and the main reason I'm not is their documentation. E.g., it took me two weeks of full time mud wrestling JUST to find a connection string that worked with SQL Server -- should have taken 10 minutes. Recently I spent 80 hours full time getting simple file sharing, as a first time user, between my 7 and 10 systems. I wrote up notes for myself that will solve the problem for any first time user in less than an hour. I posted the notes on TechNet. Responses from others were awful, e.g., kept talking about Workgroups and Homegroups and some Windows password tool, ALL of which are just irrelevant down to next to useless. Apparently nearly no one still actually knows how to use the simple, well designed, command line NET commands to set up first time user file sharing. The old NET documentation is also awful, gets a grade of flat F in just simple Bachus-Nauer syntax notation 101 and totally omits anything about semantics, meaning, usage, understanding, security, consequences, timeouts, etc. I had so much trouble with even simple things with SQL Server that eventually I got help, really simple answers, from some high up SQL Server executive.

To me, the most serious problem blocking information technology, computing, Microsoft, and my work is BAD DOCUMENTATION.

When Microsoft learns how to describe their work, then I'll start to consider if they are a competent, functioning company with a bright future.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by baybal2 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:44PM (#19809799)
Fuzzy logic, hamming scoring, and markov chains suddenly became "AI" now...

They don't need your telemetry for that

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by falcor84 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:47PM (#19810474)
I'm pretty sure these approaches were considered AI from the very start. If anything, algorithms stop being referred to as intelligent over time, as our expectations of what is possible grow.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by jlarocco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:09PM (#19810053)
Yawn. "AI" has always, and probably always will be, a marketing term to sell other algorithms.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by jlarocco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:05PM (#19810009)
> "Contextual recommendations are based on practices developed in thousands of high quality, open-source projects on GitHub each with high star ratings."

Wait, what? Is there a way to opt out of that in GitHub? I don't want their AI to scan my code.

Realistically, since most of my GH code is Common Lisp with few stars, I doubt it's looking anyway, but I'd like to make sure.

I'm sure it's covered in their TOS, but as a (still) paying GitHub customer I don't want them to do that with my repos.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by hirsin on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:37PM (#19810362)
Should have nothing to do with github and everything to do with you putting your code on the internet with a permissive license. Google or Eclipse could do this too (and I expect they do, since it's the best corpus of code available).
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by phillipcarter on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:57PM (#19810586)
Google does, in a way, with the GitHub data set in BigQuery -> https://cloud.google.com/bigquery/public-data/#sample_tables
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by lightbyte on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:29PM (#19810279)
Don't make your repos public if you don't want people reading them
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by wanderer2323 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:53PM (#19810542)
I disagree with the paren't sentiment but I think they raise an interesting point: is/should there be a license that says: you can read/use/modify {this} but you cannot use it as a training data for the AI.

{this} can be code or text or an image or any other content.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by axefrog on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:33PM (#19811043)
Genuine curiosity... why have you put an apostrophe in "parent"?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by wanderer2323 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:38PM (#19814082)
attempting to write "parent's" before coffee
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by lozenge on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:22PM (#19810204)
Just change the license file until GitHub doesn't recognise the license any more.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by soulofmischief on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:46PM (#19810461)
Is it publicly hosted on Github with a permissive license?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by newsoul2019 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:26PM (#19809610)
>> If nothing else, they could really differentiate >> and join forces with Apple from privacy standpoint >> to oppose Google, Amazon and Facebook.

I didn't realize I wanted this, but now I do.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by oneplane on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:30PM (#19809648)
Same here. But we should keep in mind that there is no guarantee that their stance stays the same, and they pretty much only answer to money and nothing/nobody else.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:35PM (#19809704)
The thing with privacy stance is that it is primarily based on trust. If Microsoft now goes into privacy centric company, nothing makes me trust them as much as I trust them going back into selling ads after 5 years.

It is a sensitive branding issue.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by exelius on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:50PM (#19809855)
That’s why I think whatever trust solution we come up with will have a heavy audit component to it. I know everyone here hates SOX compliance, but the entire goal of SOX was to increase investors’ trust in financial reporting in the wake of the Enron accounting scandal. And it worked.

SaaS companies already make ridiculous margins. Applying a sensible regulatory framework around privacy and data usage auditing would add overhead to be sure, but I’m also sure software margins will cover it.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by exelius on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:39PM (#19809754)
Yeah, Apple had the foresight to see the next big thing in tech was going to be privacy. But I think it’s reflective of a larger societal problem: we don’t know who to trust anymore. It seems like every company is trying to scam its users, so Apple is betting that there is a valuable segment of the market willing to pay a premium to do business with a brand that has no ulterior motives past selling you a device at a high markup, and maybe some value-add services.

To be fair, this has always been a problem — I think the recent failings of the historical trust model are due to better information rather than any increase in exploitative behavior. But prior to the smartphone era, trust was a fuzzy, emotional problem where a customer’s trust in a brand could be influenced by marketing alone. Today it is an explicit, quantifiable problem where users are willing to vote with their feet.

What companies are we bestowing authority upon? Do those companies’ business models truly have our best interests at heart? What guarantees do users have that their trust won’t be violated? I firmly believe that whoever can solve these questions to the market’s satisfaction will own the future.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarface74 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:10PM (#19810771)
Apple being big into privacy is just a benefit of their business model - they don’t need to make money off a data as a hardware company.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:19PM (#19811586)
Correct, it is also important to recognize that they could have exploited their user base (500 million iPhones sold) to serve ads or collect data and sell it - that is a real business expansion idea. "They don't need to make money as a hardware company" sidesteps the investor-company relationship: Public companies are obligated to expand under investor pressure, but the strategy is always in the hands of the executives. Apple didn't succumb under the pressure.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by exelius on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:48PM (#19813309)
I wouldn’t say it’s “just” a benefit of their business model; it’s the entire point. I don’t see Samsung making any of these moves.

Any good product organization (and Apple is one of the best) focuses on their customer. We all know that. But Apple goes further and takes their customers’ side — the iTunes Music Store was an absolute disaster for the recording industry but a huge boon for the consumer (and, of course, iPod sales).

Apple is only in a position to do this effectively because they have such a large and loyal customer base. They have a large and loyal customer base because they have consistently driven innovation in personal computing while making high-quality devices that people are willing to pay a premium for. Why would they betray that loyalty?

Apple’s business model is simple and easy to understand. I look at their balance sheet and see where the money comes from: hardware sales to consumers. You can do the same with Amazon and Google too — which shows you why their definition of “customer focus” is so different from Apple’s.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by spectramax on Thursday May 02, 2019 @09:49PM (#19814798)
I agree 100%. Everything from hardware level encryption, localized machine learning, face-id(and Touch ID), T2 Chip, Secure Enclave, afps, secure vault, etc are all not needed for “normal business” but are focusing specifically on privacy as a differentiating factor.

Out of many large corporations the only company I trust is Apple. I’m happy to pay more. I’m happy to sit through their repair bullshit. I trust their motives.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by nacs on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:14PM (#19811541)
It's also a conscious decision in the way they build their products. If they wanted to, they could also continue being a hardware company and add data-mining/ads on top of that -- but they choose not to.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by max76 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:35PM (#19809701)
From the cloud perspective Azure has a better privacy pitch than AWS has.

Amazon is currently expanding into markets at such a rate everyone is afraid their market will be next. Microsoft currently is staying in their lane. If someone is going to be invading my privacy I'd rather it not be a direct competitor.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarface74 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:09PM (#19810753)
What does expanding its product portfolio have to do with privacy?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by max76 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:53PM (#19812046)
I don't want my data in the hands of my competitors. Amazon is either competing with or threatening to compete with a wide range of organizations.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarface74 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:01PM (#19812135)
Whether you are using Azure or AWS, if you’re concerned about your data, you should be encrypting it with customer managed keys.

Netflix is AWS’s largest customer, even though it competes with Amazon Prime Video.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by jacques_chester on Thursday May 02, 2019 @09:35PM (#19814711)
Netflix's video streams are delivered from devices installed at ISPs.

Their most valuable data: what is being watched, where, by whom, is hidden from Amazon.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by scarface74 on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:05AM (#19818520)
Not always. The devices at the ISPs are basically a local cache. They don’t have devices at every ISP and all of their content isn’t on every device.

But that’s really neither here nor there. I doubt very seriously that even if Amazon (AWS not the retail side) was snooping on customer data - which I believe they would be fool to do so - they couldn’t inspect the video stream to know what was playing where.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by max76 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @07:28PM (#19814018)
Encryption doesn't hide everything. For example, Amazon could estimate the geographical location of everyone watching Netflix and use that information to determine optimal billboard advertisement locations for it's advertisement campaign.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:15PM (#19810831)
> but boy they could have gone into Ads with a MASSIVE user base but they chose to limit Ads in the App Store

But they still with with Ads. And they've tried Ads in the past, with iAds. That they failed doesn't mean they didn't try, and doesn't mean they won't try again. Apple is all about advertising. Now, we can discuss how they handle privacy related to ads, but let's not pretend Apple is in no way a contributor to ad ecosystem.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:36PM (#19809710)
If people don't pay for software maintenance, e.g. Windows 10 updates, what do you do? Ads, harvest data...

Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl. services at a price point you can only dream of Apple hardware.

Facebook/Inst/Wapp and Google show that the majority of people go with 'Geiz ist geil' (cheap is cool), privacy be damned. Awareness doesn't necessarily lead to actions (read: payments).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by avtar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:52PM (#19809887)
> Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl.

IMO what I paid for my Windows Pro license is already that fee and then some.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cjarrett on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:03PM (#19809988)
Additionally, this was the biggest selling point of Windows Phone. It died, and so did the Security/privacy mindset.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bradford on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:16PM (#19810835)
If I'm interpreting you correctly, you're making two points, and neither of them are entirely correct:

1) Microsoft had telemetry in Windows Phone.

2) The security/privacy mindset hasn't died alongside Windows Phone. I think it's actually gotten stronger, GDPR has been the biggest forcing function.

[disclosure: MS employee, but my employer wants me to state that this is my opinion, not that of Microsoft]

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cjarrett on Thursday May 02, 2019 @08:29PM (#19814383)
certainly in Azure; I've also seen very big efforts towards privacy as the direct result of GDPR. Windows, I'm much less confident.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:54PM (#19812787)
I also paid for the Windows Pro license, but I meant the continued maintenance and free (bi)yearly updates. IIRC the license was around 50 € this cannot cover the full cost for the (let's say) 5+ years computer lifetime support.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:39PM (#19809757)
Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

This mindset is toxic and needs to die.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bradford on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:42PM (#19810415)
[disclosure, MS employee]

With the absence of telemetry, how do you know Linux is doing just fine? (specifically in the desktop world, not server world).

Microsoft has an interest in knowing how well Windows is doing, and Windows has lived in a world both with and without telemetry. It was way, way harder to gauge success prior to telemetry, and it was also much more frustrating for the user to communicate their problems. I don't think Windows could have stayed in the pre-telemetry engineering world and maintained its position as a competitive desktop OS.

I ask this mostly out of ignorance, I've got experience using Linux, but I really don't know what the dev-loop is like for active engineers.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by user192837 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:57PM (#19812082)
Windows became the world's top desktop OS without telemetry. Please stop this "we harvest your data to make our product better for you" excuse because it is offensive for us customers. Don't put it on us users. We did not ask for that. Just say that it's because everyone is doing, or to better profit or whatever unethical reasons you have.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @09:27PM (#19814667)
What does telemetry have to do with the windows 10 start menu becoming a container for ads and not trivially removable partnered apps?

There's nothing wrong with transparent, privacy-respecting, and configurable telemetry, but what windows 10 does is none of those. Trying to describe it as something that's good for the users comes off a bit disingenuous.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:44PM (#19812673)
> I don't think Windows could have stayed in the pre-telemetry engineering world

You (Microsoft) shouldn't enforce people to send telemetry. Ask kindly and I suppose you'd get a better response. (VSC is a good example how it could/should be done)

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Nextgrid on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:51AM (#19816403)
> With the absence of telemetry, how do you know Linux is doing just fine?

I look at Linux-focused communities on Reddit, Hacker News, etc (there’s always a good rant about Linux’s shortcomings).

But that would, you know, mean you actually need to pay competent people that can understand the discourse and engage with the community, something you guys clearly don’t give a shit about (have you ever seen the Microsoft Support forums? It’s a disaster).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by lostmsu on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:46PM (#19810459)
> Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

Ugh. I am quite proficient with tech stuff, but last month trying Ubuntu 18.04 LTS on my desktop left me pretty disappointed. A hard no-no for anyone non-technical: the graphical login did not work until I manually switched to the text terminal and installed the latest NVidia driver (Titan V).

And even now one of my screens does not wake up until I toggle it on/off.

And no freeform per-screen DPI.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cosmodisk on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:54PM (#19812794)
100% agree. Linux is great for developers or server admins but when it comes to an average Joe from the office,it is 20 years behind windows. It may look similar,it may feel a little similar but it is not.Most of the apps are complete shit, it is difficult to do things unless you an admin or technical user and etc. My job is split in half- one side is technical and I'd be happy with Linux, the other is a business user and this side will never switch to Linux,or not until all the MS products are ported to Linux.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by 1024core on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:07PM (#19810723)
> until I manually switched to the text terminal and installed the latest NVidia driver

As an nVidia card owner, I feel your pain. It's a case of both sides (nVidia and Linux) digging their heels and refusing to cooperate.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:36PM (#19812606)
> This mindset is toxic and needs to die

A bit a more friendly reply would be appreciated.. What is toxic exactly?

Linux (the Ubuntu desktop which I use) might do fine, but it needs to be financed also, developers need a salary. (Some) people donate, there seem to be 'some arrangements with e.g. Amazon' and - I suppose - the main funds currently come from Canonical using server edition income.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:45PM (#19809816)
Fine among our crowd but how many non technical people are using Linux?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:25PM (#19815270)
Virtually everyone who owns a cell phone that's not an iPhone. Android apps tend to be ad-supported, though, so not sure if that really helps the point.

There's also the TVs, set top boxes, refrigerators, and cars (among many other consumer-facing devices) that run Linux (which completely displaced Windows CE).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Nextgrid on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:53AM (#19816407)
We’re talking about using a Linux operating system to replace Windows. I don’t think bringing up where the Linux kernel is used alone is relevant.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:21PM (#19821415)
Linux is the kernel, though (and debatably also the application API/ABI). That's all it is. At the risk of sounding like some Richard Stallman wannabe, your complaints should be directed at GNU (or perhaps GNOME or KDE).

Trying to argue "well those don't count because they're not real Linux" is 1) blatantly false and 2) a textbook case of a No True Scotsman fallacy. Linux is Linux, regardless of which userland happens to be running on it.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:15AM (#19831894)
I wasn't being crisp in my definitions, I'm using Linux to refer to the OS on desktop. My bad for any confusion.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:21PM (#19842792)
No worries. It's worth clarifying specifically because of how many user-facing software stacks are indeed built on top of Linux.

Still, I feel like the only reason the Year of the Linux Desktop hasn't "arrived" is because we keep moving the goalposts on what "Linux Desktop" means (and/or maintain an unnecessarily strict definition of it), probably because we do mean "GNU Desktop" or "GNOME Desktop" or "KDE Desktop" or "X11 Desktop" or something along those lines when we say "Linux Desktop".

Would you count ChromeOS as a desktop Linux? If not, why?

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @02:59AM (#19847200)
It hadn't crossed my mind when I wrote the post because I was in a thread about Windows (so in my mind it was desktop Windows vs a "linux distro" like Ubuntu, Cent, Debian, etc).

But I suppose ChromeOS should count too since it runs on laptops and desktop computers.

Of course Linux (the kernel) is much more dominant on mobile because of Android. But then again Android is indirectly supported by Google ad revenue and so would contradict the original claim in the thread I'm responding to:

> Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:51PM (#19809870)
Uhh. The entire world? The internet doesn't run on IIS.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by belltaco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:54PM (#19809909)
There are no ads in IIS or Windows Server.

By your logic every developer is a Windows user, since they use Stack Overflow that runs on Windows, IIS and SQL Server.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:13PM (#19812306)
> non-technical people

And you bring up internet infrastructure?

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by belltaco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:53PM (#19809890)
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AsyncAwait on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:32PM (#19810316)
Canonical does not maintain most of the software that comes with Ubuntu, at least not exclusively.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:29PM (#19815291)
That article is about spyware Canonical themselves developed and baked into the desktop environment they developed specifically for Ubuntu.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AsyncAwait on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:11AM (#19817007)
I know, my point is that the most complex pieces of software within Ubuntu are not primarily developed by Canonical and thus it's possible to maintain complex Linux software without having ads and tracking.

The fact that Canonical had developed spyware has nothing to do with the Linux kernel, glibc, bash, GNOME, systemd, PulseAudio, all of which prove that you don't need ads and tracking to maintain Linux software.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by quantummkv on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:02AM (#19815931)
The difference here is that most Linux users are capable of filing detailed bug reports and work on solving them. And many do so.

By contrast most Windows users consider bugs to be something that requires an anti-bug spray.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by MagicPropmaker on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:44PM (#19809801)
Oh yes! They're taking the desktop by storm!
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by saghm on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:51PM (#19809863)
I think it's a lot more plausible that Microsoft could still do fine with Windows if they took out ads than that Linux would be doing much better in the desktop market if they started bundling in ads.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by MagicPropmaker on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:19PM (#19810167)
I run Windows 10 as my primary operating system. We do Erlang, and C++/CUDA programming here.

Are there ads? I've never seen anything other than a very occasional promotional tile for a Microsoft product. Apple cross-promotes, too.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by tabtab on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:42PM (#19809783)
Re: Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee.

This could fuel class complaints that the poor will be snooped on more than the rich.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cutenewt on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:38PM (#19810375)
I feel like Microsoft has a bigger ads opportunity now, after the LinkedIn acquisition.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:48PM (#19809840)
Remember MS was first to jump on the NSA PRISM slide.

While they’ve made some better decisions recently, this one has shown no signs of change. It’s why I still relegate anything MS to VMs.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cutenewt on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:37PM (#19810361)
I think Satya would be pretty open joining forces w/ Apple.

But Tim Cook, I would bet, would be averse to it.