News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:36PM (#19809710)
If people don't pay for software maintenance, e.g. Windows 10 updates, what do you do? Ads, harvest data...

Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl. services at a price point you can only dream of Apple hardware.

Facebook/Inst/Wapp and Google show that the majority of people go with 'Geiz ist geil' (cheap is cool), privacy be damned. Awareness doesn't necessarily lead to actions (read: payments).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by avtar on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:52PM (#19809887)
> Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee. You can buy a Windows computer incl.

IMO what I paid for my Windows Pro license is already that fee and then some.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cjarrett on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:03PM (#19809988)
Additionally, this was the biggest selling point of Windows Phone. It died, and so did the Security/privacy mindset.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bradford on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:16PM (#19810835)
If I'm interpreting you correctly, you're making two points, and neither of them are entirely correct:

1) Microsoft had telemetry in Windows Phone.

2) The security/privacy mindset hasn't died alongside Windows Phone. I think it's actually gotten stronger, GDPR has been the biggest forcing function.

[disclosure: MS employee, but my employer wants me to state that this is my opinion, not that of Microsoft]

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cjarrett on Thursday May 02, 2019 @08:29PM (#19814383)
certainly in Azure; I've also seen very big efforts towards privacy as the direct result of GDPR. Windows, I'm much less confident.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:54PM (#19812787)
I also paid for the Windows Pro license, but I meant the continued maintenance and free (bi)yearly updates. IIRC the license was around 50 € this cannot cover the full cost for the (let's say) 5+ years computer lifetime support.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:39PM (#19809757)
Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

This mindset is toxic and needs to die.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by bradford on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:42PM (#19810415)
[disclosure, MS employee]

With the absence of telemetry, how do you know Linux is doing just fine? (specifically in the desktop world, not server world).

Microsoft has an interest in knowing how well Windows is doing, and Windows has lived in a world both with and without telemetry. It was way, way harder to gauge success prior to telemetry, and it was also much more frustrating for the user to communicate their problems. I don't think Windows could have stayed in the pre-telemetry engineering world and maintained its position as a competitive desktop OS.

I ask this mostly out of ignorance, I've got experience using Linux, but I really don't know what the dev-loop is like for active engineers.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by user192837 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:57PM (#19812082)
Windows became the world's top desktop OS without telemetry. Please stop this "we harvest your data to make our product better for you" excuse because it is offensive for us customers. Don't put it on us users. We did not ask for that. Just say that it's because everyone is doing, or to better profit or whatever unethical reasons you have.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @09:27PM (#19814667)
What does telemetry have to do with the windows 10 start menu becoming a container for ads and not trivially removable partnered apps?

There's nothing wrong with transparent, privacy-respecting, and configurable telemetry, but what windows 10 does is none of those. Trying to describe it as something that's good for the users comes off a bit disingenuous.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:44PM (#19812673)
> I don't think Windows could have stayed in the pre-telemetry engineering world

You (Microsoft) shouldn't enforce people to send telemetry. Ask kindly and I suppose you'd get a better response. (VSC is a good example how it could/should be done)

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Nextgrid on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:51AM (#19816403)
> With the absence of telemetry, how do you know Linux is doing just fine?

I look at Linux-focused communities on Reddit, Hacker News, etc (there’s always a good rant about Linux’s shortcomings).

But that would, you know, mean you actually need to pay competent people that can understand the discourse and engage with the community, something you guys clearly don’t give a shit about (have you ever seen the Microsoft Support forums? It’s a disaster).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by lostmsu on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:46PM (#19810459)
> Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

Ugh. I am quite proficient with tech stuff, but last month trying Ubuntu 18.04 LTS on my desktop left me pretty disappointed. A hard no-no for anyone non-technical: the graphical login did not work until I manually switched to the text terminal and installed the latest NVidia driver (Titan V).

And even now one of my screens does not wake up until I toggle it on/off.

And no freeform per-screen DPI.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by cosmodisk on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:54PM (#19812794)
100% agree. Linux is great for developers or server admins but when it comes to an average Joe from the office,it is 20 years behind windows. It may look similar,it may feel a little similar but it is not.Most of the apps are complete shit, it is difficult to do things unless you an admin or technical user and etc. My job is split in half- one side is technical and I'd be happy with Linux, the other is a business user and this side will never switch to Linux,or not until all the MS products are ported to Linux.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by 1024core on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:07PM (#19810723)
> until I manually switched to the text terminal and installed the latest NVidia driver

As an nVidia card owner, I feel your pain. It's a case of both sides (nVidia and Linux) digging their heels and refusing to cooperate.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chappi42 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:36PM (#19812606)
> This mindset is toxic and needs to die

A bit a more friendly reply would be appreciated.. What is toxic exactly?

Linux (the Ubuntu desktop which I use) might do fine, but it needs to be financed also, developers need a salary. (Some) people donate, there seem to be 'some arrangements with e.g. Amazon' and - I suppose - the main funds currently come from Canonical using server edition income.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:45PM (#19809816)
Fine among our crowd but how many non technical people are using Linux?
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:25PM (#19815270)
Virtually everyone who owns a cell phone that's not an iPhone. Android apps tend to be ad-supported, though, so not sure if that really helps the point.

There's also the TVs, set top boxes, refrigerators, and cars (among many other consumer-facing devices) that run Linux (which completely displaced Windows CE).

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by Nextgrid on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:53AM (#19816407)
We’re talking about using a Linux operating system to replace Windows. I don’t think bringing up where the Linux kernel is used alone is relevant.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:21PM (#19821415)
Linux is the kernel, though (and debatably also the application API/ABI). That's all it is. At the risk of sounding like some Richard Stallman wannabe, your complaints should be directed at GNU (or perhaps GNOME or KDE).

Trying to argue "well those don't count because they're not real Linux" is 1) blatantly false and 2) a textbook case of a No True Scotsman fallacy. Linux is Linux, regardless of which userland happens to be running on it.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:15AM (#19831894)
I wasn't being crisp in my definitions, I'm using Linux to refer to the OS on desktop. My bad for any confusion.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:21PM (#19842792)
No worries. It's worth clarifying specifically because of how many user-facing software stacks are indeed built on top of Linux.

Still, I feel like the only reason the Year of the Linux Desktop hasn't "arrived" is because we keep moving the goalposts on what "Linux Desktop" means (and/or maintain an unnecessarily strict definition of it), probably because we do mean "GNU Desktop" or "GNOME Desktop" or "KDE Desktop" or "X11 Desktop" or something along those lines when we say "Linux Desktop".

Would you count ChromeOS as a desktop Linux? If not, why?

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @02:59AM (#19847200)
It hadn't crossed my mind when I wrote the post because I was in a thread about Windows (so in my mind it was desktop Windows vs a "linux distro" like Ubuntu, Cent, Debian, etc).

But I suppose ChromeOS should count too since it runs on laptops and desktop computers.

Of course Linux (the kernel) is much more dominant on mobile because of Android. But then again Android is indirectly supported by Google ad revenue and so would contradict the original claim in the thread I'm responding to:

> Linux seems to be doing just fine keeping software maintained without ads or harvesting data.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by kuzehanka on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:51PM (#19809870)
Uhh. The entire world? The internet doesn't run on IIS.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by belltaco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:54PM (#19809909)
There are no ads in IIS or Windows Server.

By your logic every developer is a Windows user, since they use Stack Overflow that runs on Windows, IIS and SQL Server.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by chillacy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:13PM (#19812306)
> non-technical people

And you bring up internet infrastructure?

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by belltaco on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:53PM (#19809890)
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AsyncAwait on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:32PM (#19810316)
Canonical does not maintain most of the software that comes with Ubuntu, at least not exclusively.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by yellowapple on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:29PM (#19815291)
That article is about spyware Canonical themselves developed and baked into the desktop environment they developed specifically for Ubuntu.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by AsyncAwait on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:11AM (#19817007)
I know, my point is that the most complex pieces of software within Ubuntu are not primarily developed by Canonical and thus it's possible to maintain complex Linux software without having ads and tracking.

The fact that Canonical had developed spyware has nothing to do with the Linux kernel, glibc, bash, GNOME, systemd, PulseAudio, all of which prove that you don't need ads and tracking to maintain Linux software.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by quantummkv on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:02AM (#19815931)
The difference here is that most Linux users are capable of filing detailed bug reports and work on solving them. And many do so.

By contrast most Windows users consider bugs to be something that requires an anti-bug spray.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by MagicPropmaker on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:44PM (#19809801)
Oh yes! They're taking the desktop by storm!
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by saghm on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:51PM (#19809863)
I think it's a lot more plausible that Microsoft could still do fine with Windows if they took out ads than that Linux would be doing much better in the desktop market if they started bundling in ads.
Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by MagicPropmaker on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:19PM (#19810167)
I run Windows 10 as my primary operating system. We do Erlang, and C++/CUDA programming here.

Are there ads? I've never seen anything other than a very occasional promotional tile for a Microsoft product. Apple cross-promotes, too.

Re:Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having... by tabtab on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:42PM (#19809783)
Re: Windows (likely) always could offer better privacy for a fee.

This could fuel class complaints that the poor will be snooped on more than the rich.