Most developed nations have a public health system. Akin to how the US has public schools and emergency services.
The revolution could be the government bitting the bullet, and spending a fortune on bootstrapping a public health system that undermines insurance and private health.
Yes, it will hurt that sector a lot, it won't happen overnight, it will cause huge deficits, and it will inevitably cause higher taxation. But it's ultimately what needs to be done. We just need to give up on the sunk cost fallacy and go with proven models.
We already have a public healthcare system, it is called medicare. We can expand medicare so that private insurance takes up a smaller segment of the total market. I believe that approach will provide incremental improvement and give policy makers leverage for further incremental improvement, but it is not a revolution.
While many of our politicians are talking about revolution, what they are all proposing is incrementalism. The reason for that is very simple; revolution is a bad idea and incrementalism has a proven track record of working.
As an aside, medicare-for-all is still a long way away from a public healthcare system; it makes one area of the healthcare system public.
Is there any empirical evidence to back this up? There are enough successful examples of revolution and incrementalism from around the world, but I can't find stats.
No we can't. Medicare pays below cost of care, and hospitals make it up from private payers. You can't just switch everyone to Medicare, you would have to reduce expenses somehow (which means firing people).
The regular pricing also builds in an assumption that some patients can't or won't pay. If they can more easily get Medicare, less padding is necessary.
It's probably actually at least a month of waiting time.
The "provider" is not a single person. So to reduce the income of the organization, you have to fire people or reduce their salary.
I think you are thinking you can reduce their profits, but you can't. Instead if you feel they are charging to much, that directly translates into lost jobs or lower pay.
It might be necessary, but just as long as you know what you are advocating.
Can you imagine a politician running on a platform of firing healthcare workers?
From https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-industry... it seems insurance companies add about 20% to the cost of healthcare.
https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/sep... says 12%.
The same article says Medicare is 2% with the assistance of industry groups, but would cost more without them.
So, abolishing insurance companies would save maybe 5%. That's not zero, but it's not exactly a lot, and would not come close to what's needed.
Or, uh, "Medicare for all", since medicare is an existing, functional single payer system (not actual "public health system" but still, there, works already for a significant fraction of the population, is an existing proposal.
We just need to give up on the sunk cost fallacy and go with proven models.
This, definitely. It's worth saying "sunk cost" arguments often go more with entrenched interests than any actual benefit. Unfortunately, this doesn't make them easier to counter.
I think we could start by expanding military medical benefits. For example, give lifetime benefits to all honorably discharged service members, not just those who made it to retirement. We already have a government funded and run system. It has some excellent assets, such as Walter Reed, a research facility. We could just start quietly expanding that in a way that people could get on board with.
(Changed "honorably discharged veterans" to "honorably discharged service members" for clarity.)
Then we continued to underfund the VA.
It’s only logical that it’s where it is.
Some of us foretold this from before the wars.
I agree that certain jobs do not have to be done by the government and in that way, doing them via government gives rise to all sorts of bad incentives and inefficiencies, but I would not want to paint anything run by government employees as cost inefficient (especially if it's a core government competency) compared to the private sector alternative without some clear evidence.
The comment was directed at the VA, there's no reason it needs to be run by government personnel for the most part. A few could be on hand to handle classified matters if necessary. People hired by the government are not necessarily the best subject matter experts, as the rigid pay structure doesn't allow offering to pay what they're worth - and more often, to pay less, as many job classifications are simply salaried too high. Maybe strictly in matters of government policy could an expert find their niche, and I'd agree be a core government competency. Most other government agencies I can think of would be better off contracted out to enact the laws set by the President and Congress, with the flexibilty of private employment pracitices.
If you're speaking from personal experience I'm interested what happened.
My point is not that interacting with folks at the VA is bad (generally folks try to do their best) but that at a certain point if a single organization runs a specific function incentives get turned around to the point where you lose the ball somehow, and there's no pressure to improve. This seems to have happened to a certain extent at the VA and I see the pattern happen a lot across large institutions, generally. ESPECIALLY if they are not in a competitive environment.
Usually you’ll see a couple of regional banks, the local big bank outpost, and insurance companies. That’s lots of money and lots of jobs, lots of votes.
Unlike banking, the arcane processes actually created more middle class jobs while banks nuked jobs over the last 30 years. If Clinton couldn’t push universal care in the 90s, nobody is going to do it in the foreseeable future.
There is a lot of profit in medicine yet almost no competition around prices.
The simplest fastest solution, for now, is to pass a law requiring transparent prices!
If a majority of the poor in America are not educated enough to understand how public healthcare will benefit them and the country, or are educated enough to understand but not educated enough to realise media outlets have a politcal agenda and might not be reporting accurately, then public healthcare is still not going to happen.
(and they might not want socialism, but it seems like they dont understand that democracy has problems too. and healthcare is the living example. but again, it circles back around to being educated enough to understand that democracy is good, but it isnt perfect, and no system is)
Isn't the contrast between capitalism and socialism? It seems like I could have democracy with either.
Of course it doesn't help the conversation that Americans use term socialism differently than Europeans or Marx himself did.
Frankly both sides of the argument are understandable. No one wants a child to suffer but no parent wants to give up on their baby. It's a tragic case.
It's also an exception. Using it as the basis of how you decide 99.999% of other medical cases is idiotic, and using Alfie's memory as a tool to promote a particular system of healthcare payment is obscene and shameful.
Just remember this - for every case like Alfie's where there genuinely are two sides to consider there are millions more where the doctors are simply right. Setting a precedent that parents wishes automatically overrule the doctors would cause so many children to suffer. This is why we let doctors and courts make decisions - to save children from stupid parents.
Just to clarify, the state didn't kill him. He died of GABA-transaminase deficiency, which was only diagnosed after he died. The treatment that his parents wanted to try was a shot in the dark. No one knew what was wrong with Alfie.
You are arguing that taking a child from hospital, causing him more pain and suffering, putting him through a frightening and scary procedure, that has no basis in medicinal science (as there's no way to know if it'll cure an undiagnosed problem) is better than letting him die peacefully, safely and surrounded with love.
You can take a "life at any cost" point of view but the UK Court didn't. It took the view that a pain free and caring death was better than an agonising and highly unlikely long shot.
They removed his life support, against the wishes of his parents and then prevented them from accepting help. He survived ~5 days without it.
While it's a sad story I agree, it's not the point. Giving the state the power to decide who lives and dies without a trial and conviction for a crime is something many of us had hoped was settled long ago.
(Besides, we can probably find a lot more cases of dead children in the US where they were simply denied or unable to afford coverage ...)
But in the US there would have been the additional funding step: the parents would have had to get insurance companies to pay for futile treatment, and no compnay would do so, or the parents would have had to crowd-fund this treatment.
Here, for anyone interested, are some of the legal documents (in date order) around the Alfie Evans case. They clearly show that parents have a right to a family life and to care for their child as they see fit, but that this right isn't total because the child is also human and has his own human rights. The paramountcy principle mean that the rights of the child come before the rights of the parents.
Please note that because of the involvement of the Christian Legal Centre in some of the court cases there's been a lot of misinformation spread about the case.
I know that there's nothing I can say to change your mind: you have an ideological viewpoint, and that's okay. But I think you should at least acknowledge that your opinion is not based on fact.
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWCA...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/eu/cases/ECHR...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWCA...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/eu/cases/ECHR...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC...
https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWCA...
https://www.supremecourt.uk/docs/in-the-matter-of-alfie-evan...
The details make me uncomfortable (with the court decision), he had an offer from a qualified intuition for help.
Thank you.
Opposition from incumbents ensures that any change will be a difficult process, and a "new normal" will not come easily. Any long-term planning efforts will be sabotaged and subverted toward capture of profits. The best we can hope for is a series of smaller disruptive shifts (each followed by a resettling) that eventually improves the situation.
Something needs to happen. Increasingly it looks like dissatisfaction with the current system will boil over and force a major shift, but other events (wars, for instance) could pop up and distract the public for a time.
Key thing I've noted about was it was designed to get people covered and to stay that way. That's the opposite of neoliberal ACA which is designed to be annoying and has traps designed to rat fuck people.
The ACA was a stalling tactic, and it has been rather successful in that role. People are starting to see through the ruse though.
That's been my opinion, more or less the ACA was just to set the take by the Insurance/Health care parasites to 17% GDP no more no less.
Healthy SF was really about access and outcomes.
Tens of thousands.
But my lord there is no such force.
> looks at US uninsured death rate and medical bankruptcy rate.
> horn blows.
A new power is rising. Its victory is at hand.
Not to be callous but if they're poor, is that enough?
Because 64,000 Americans died of drug overdose in 2016, and 72,000 in 2017 (200/day). (2018 stats not yet out.) 2/3rds of those are linked to the opioid epidemic, but those numbers haven't been enough to engage with the same sort of cultural change in other areas of the American psyche, as socialized healthcare would be. (NOT proffering an opinion on that here, just pointing out the body count may not be enough. Sadly.
Then, once the revolution comes, how many people are you willing to let die while you iron out the operational bugs in your new system.
Fixing the US healthcare system is going to be like changing an engine mid flight. It will require long term planning and consist of a lot of bandaids and ducktape while we work on it. Unfortunately, our political system is by-polar, so plans need to be designed not by what will work best, but by what cannot be dismantled when leadership changes.