If we were in a fantasy land where Tether wasn’t fraudulent then the price variance of Tether on exchanges would be so minuscule that there would be no arbitrage opportunity for anyone to take advantage of. Your hypothetical profit opportunity only exists because Tether is (ultimately) fraudulent.
Remember that Tether was pitched as a 1:1 USD backed cryptocurrency that could be exchanged 1:1 at any time (in both directions). The mess that it is now (only liquid on exchanges at a variable rate) is not what Tether was marketed as.
Tether (as promised) is the equivalent of you accepting $100 USD from your friend and giving them $100 of Monopoly money and promising them that at any time they can trade their monopoly dollars for your real dollars... and you won’t ever use the USD for anything, it’ll be locked away untouchable by you. How do you profit from that? You can’t lend it, you can’t invest it, you can’t use it as collateral, it has to be unencumbered at all times and you have to incur the costs of managing it.
Read the original whitepaper and try and identify a profit opportunity. This is all before considering that Tether is a fundamentally flawed concept: if Tether could operate a reliable banking relationship, so could others, and Tether would be pointless.
Of cause there would. Even if the tokens are backed 1:1 by dollars it still has an exchange rate. So tether could issue at above 1 rates and buy at below 1 rates. That provides a very simple profit making scheme.
For users, they would often like to “cash out to tether” quickly, which means they’d undercut the exchange rate thus providing tether with a profit in exchange for swift processing.
> If we were in a fantasy land where Tether wasn’t fraudulent then the price variance of Tether on exchanges would be so minuscule that there would be no arbitrage opportunity for anyone to take advantage of.
I’m reminded of the joke where two wallstreet stock brokers are walking down the street, one says to the other “look a 50$ bill on the ground!” The other without looking down replies: “that’s impossible, if there was a 50$ bill on the ground someone would have picked it up.”
If USDT is credibly backed by dollars this spread is tiny, not least because other holders of Tether can play the same game. And if USDT is backed by dollars held in cash in customer accounts as originally claimed, there's an enormous opportunity cost of not investing those dollars.
I agree the spread might be tiny though. Though if Tether puts itself in a bad light every now and again it could force the spread a bit wider.
You only need and should keep enough liquid cash needed to handle day to day withdrawals. Everything else is fair game up invest.
See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking
“[...] each tetherUSD in circulation represents one US dollar held in our reserves (i.e. a onetoone ratio) which means the system is fully reserved when the sum of all tethers in existence (at any point in time) is exactly equal to the balance of USD held in our reserve.”
That said they don't state anything about what their reserve is. Wealthfront has a 2.3% savings account for us normal people. If I created a stable coin like tether is and had a billion dollars of investment; I could make 23 million dollars a year and tell people that I have a 1:1 backing without lying.
If I went to a bank with a billion dollars I could likely negotiate an even higher rate for such a savings account.
I don't think that's how it works. As others have mentioned, FDIC insurance only covers 250k per depositor per bank. Typically when entities have that amount of cash (think Apple, Google, etc.), they put them into US government bonds, which are effectively equivalent to deposit accounts.
Edit: this is an interesting point, though. Ignoring the insurance issue, what would a bank do if you asked to open a deposit account with a billion dollars (paying, say 2%/year)? My uninformed layman's speculation would be that they would reject you because they wouldn't know what to do with that much money: they have to somehow lend out enough of it to at least break even on the 20 million/year that they're paying you for interest, but at the same time they have to be able to give you back your 1 billion at any time you ask for it.
Large banks deal with deposits in total orders of magnitude greater than that (the top banks have over $1 trillion each in deposits.) $1bn in a single demand deposit account is stupid for the depositor, but it doesn't move the needle on a major banks total of deposit accounts, and they can deal with it just fine.
Lastly, putting that money in bonds, index funds, and other such things scales well. The wealthfront example I used took on a billion in deposits in a short timeframe: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/23/wealthfronts-new-high-yield-...
To your first point, if you have another entity do that type of investments for you and present it as a bank account with a variable interest rate; then you can claim you have a 1:1 cash backing truthfully, even if the reality is different. If you just stored the money in a normal bank, the reality would stay the same.
Can you point me in their direction?
It’s what every insurance company and bank does.
Or if you don’t want to do that, put it in treasuries or something and take your 1,2,3% of whatever it may be.
Tether could have replicated either strategy, but seems to not have.
They could also have profited from those that lost their keys (it happens).
In addition you have to keep in mind that it is also about absolute numbers. No one invested these billions with them, no one is charging them some kind of relative rent. Every dollar is profit. If you could make 0.001% off storing 5 billion, that would still be an attractive business model.
“[...] each tetherUSD in circulation represents one US dollar held in our reserves (i.e. a onetoone ratio) which means the system is fully reserved when the sum of all tethers in existence (at any point in time) is exactly equal to the balance of USD held in our reserve.”
Where does the 5% come from?
If all their customers decide to withdraw their money, this is a "run on the bank" and generally dooms the bank.
Presumably Tether planned to do the same: a percentage of the money they held would be invested, based on the assumption that not everyone who held Tether would want USD at any one point in time.
Of course, this stretches the meaning of "reserve", and utterly fails if they mismanaged the investment bit and lost the money they invested
Everyone gave multiple good profit opportunity already, but what about having a transaction fees? They still have a cost related to operating this business, you put that cost toward a transaction fee and you put a small profit on top.
That's how credit card works, though their fees apply much more often than it would for a stablecoin, where most transations aren't from the coin to fiat money.
> you accepting $100 USD from your friend and giving them $100 of Monopoly money
That's pretty much the definition of a bank. Banks does it for free ALL the time and has actual physical locations on top of that and has to operate locally too.
> Tether is a fundamentally a risk free money making concept
To me it sounds like you don't really understand the risks of tethers business. It is light-years away from being risk free, because you are on the mercy of the banks where you store the fiat. The banks can freeze your money any time, as they now did (AFAIK).
If you are operating a business with unclear regulation at this level, you can't really rely on banks like normal businesses can. The banks will cause problems with pretty high probability.
Though.. I can imagine there's a lot safer options than some small polish bank.
Maybe they could become a bank themselves to contain some of the external risks.
No, it actually works like fractional reserve banking, which for some reason, nobody has a problem with.
Could be, and now I'm just spitballing here, but it could be the use of government backed currencies, the heavy degree of government oversight and regulation, and the federally insured deposits.
Barring that you should look at Lawler's article on tether: https://kevinlawler.com/stablecoins
He offers forward contracts if you think he's wrong. He's good for it.
There have been ~two historical exceptions. From April 20 - May 20, 2017, they could have absolutely cleaned up by buying their own tethers back. Hundreds of millions of dollars of tethers were traded at an average price of 95 cents or so.
Perhaps a better comparison would be to banks (as the credit they create is essentially new money), but again, they are subject to restrictions (i.e capital requirements so they can absorb a reasonable level of defaults without ever touching deposits, etc.), operate within a legal framework, and have to stay solvent.
So at best you could say Tether is probably an illegal shadow bank that probably isn’t solvent.
If Tether was a bank, its 73% reserve rate would be considered spectacularly high. The crypto world is basically re-inventing fractional reserve banking now.
> The only thing Tether has to do is buy back Tether at any price lower than they sold it for and they make profit.
How would Tether be able to sell Tether at a higher price than market price but then simultaneously buy Tether at a lower price than market price? Tether would have to wait for its price to drop and then rise again, just like any other trader. Curiously, Tether could spread FUD about Tether and then refute it.
Now consider Tethers case. You give Tether a dollar. ???. Tether has $0.70 and you’re not even allowed to get it back.
You give the bank $1. The bank then goes ahead and loans $0.90 to Bob, who then uses it to invest in a business or a home. That $1 still exists, just most of its backed by the debt that Bob has to the bank. I don’t believe bob would take that $0.9 that the bank loaned him and put it back into the same bank.
I'm just pointing out the parallels, which are far more striking than the differences. People here point out that fractional reserves is backed by loans and securities of (supposedly) equal value, or that it's all regulated and insured, but it wasn't always like that, it's not a strict requirement for the system to work.
Insurance and regulation is good for you as a consumer, and yeah that is new.
But assets have always been backed by loans of (greater than or) equal value. That’s the point of banks.
Tether is not a bank. You have no guarantee of being allowed to exchange tether for dollars. It’s just... a weird service that doesn’t make sense. Tether doesn’t “work” because tether doesn’t do anything
Greater or equal face value, not actual value. Tether is basically making the same claim.
> Tether is not a bank.
I never said that Tether was a bank.
> You have no guarantee of being allowed to exchange tether for dollars.
To be pedantic, no such guarantee exists for bank deposits either.
> It’s just... a weird service that doesn’t make sense. Tether doesn’t “work” because tether doesn’t do anything.
Tether obviously does work, it's probably the most stable cryptocurrency out there, despite being run by sketchy people. You can exchange it for other cryptocurrencies and you can exchange cryptocurrencies for ordinary currencies. Absent proper access to ordinary banking, Tether has been a tool for exchanges to perform settlements in the hundreds of millions of dollars. The view that Tether "does nothing" is just uninformed.
It also feels like you’re jumping on a worn out bridge and telling me it hasn’t broke yet. Look! It only lost 30% of my money so far!
However, as far as a cryptocurrency goes, Tether obviously works even when it's only backed by fractional reserves. Remember, most cryptocurrencies are backed by nothing.
> It only lost 30% of my money so far!
If I held any Tether, I could exchange them right now for dollars almost one to one. That's been true for most of the time of Tether's existence. The peg worked even when it wasn't clear whether Tether had any money whatsoever.
If we look at the peg carefully, Tether has often traded above one dollar. That's because of Tether's utility as a cryptocurrency. Actual dollars are far harder to move around than Tether. Other cryptocurrencies are backed by nothing and often far more volatile.
The market is certainly pricing in the risk of the fractional reserve, but it priced it so low that it's almost imperceptible. In lieu of any catastrophic events, the peg will probably hold, because it held for the longest time, when it was unclear if there was any backing whatsoever.
Like I said, I'm being pedantic. The FDIC doesn't give you a guarantee that you can withdraw any money from a bank account. It offers you insurance on the amount - up to 250,000$ - in the event of bank failure.
> Tethers terms of service specifically state you’re buying funbucks / chuck-e-cheese tokens and they have no redemption value. A unit of value in your bank account represents a claim you have against the assets held in the bank backed by the weight of the US government.
While I think the characterization of Tether as "Chuck-E-Cheese tokens" is fair, a claim beyond 250,000$ against a bankrupt bank may well be worth 0$, despite the (considerable!) "weight of the US government". In that event, I would probably prefer to have the Chuck-E-Cheese tokens instead.
> A Tether is worth whatever you can get the next guy to buy your bags for representing no obligations on anyone.
While there may be no legal obligation for Tether to exchange its tokens for actual dollars, there still is a reputational obligation to do so, if we're assuming that Tether is intended to run as a legitimate business (which is admittedly a big assumption). In that sense it's somewhat comparable to PayPal.
But for illustrative purposes it’s probably best to assume that the 90 cents is eventually put into the same bank, so people can follow why the bank is allowed to do this.
There are now 1.90$ credited to both me and Bob, where before there was only 1$ credited to me. The 90 extra cents are now part of the money supply. They appeared out of thin air.
Perhaps it's unfair to say the bank "invented" the money, but it did create it.
> They’re owed 90 cents from Bob, and they will collect interest on the loan to profit. If no loans are made, the bank will eventually have more than $1.90 in reserves.
If Bob eventually pays back and the bank doesn't make any further loans, the bank will have 1$ (my dollar) and a couple of cents of interest.
> You give Tether a dollar. ???. Tether has $0.70 and you’re not even allowed to get it back.
If I give Tether a dollar Tether has another dollar. I get a Tether token which I can exchange on the open market for whatever the market price is. It supposedly is possible (though inconvenient) to get Tether itself to exchange their tokens for actual dollars (of which they hold only 70%) but (just like a bank) Tether relies on that not happening "at scale".
Bob can spend 90 cents because he has 90 cents, though he is obligated to pay it back later.
The bank can loan out (in this example) 81 cents of the 90 cent deposit from bob.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_creation#Fractional_rese...
This is wrong. The bank will have $1.90 + interest. You have to pay back your entire loan. Yes, bob might default, but averaged out, the risk calculations set the interest rate high enough to cover that profitably. The fractional reserve part of the banking system is a temporary choice that happens continuously. But if stopped, the bank would eventually have all of its cash because it has all of its reserves covered in debt.
> If I give Tether a dollar Tether has another dollar. I get a Tether token which I can exchange on the open market for whatever the market price is. It supposedly is possible (though inconvenient) to get Tether itself to exchange their tokens for actual dollars (of which they hold only 70%) but (just like a bank) Tether relies on that not happening "at scale".
The difference is tether has no title to the missing 30%, and probably even more of it if we are going to be honest. The likelihood of repayment and the fullness of reserves are two separate concept. And banks win on both counts.
Dude, check your damn math! The bank owes me a dollar. At the time of the loan, it has 10 cents and Bob has 90 cents plus an obligation to pay it back with interest. At the end of the loan, the bank has the 90 cents back plus some amount of interest nowhere near enough to make the total add up to $1.90 (unless Bob takes up a ridiculously high APR and term just to loan a dollar).
> But if stopped, the bank would eventually have all of its cash because it has all of its reserves covered in debt.
This ignores that Bob has deposited his money at another bank which has used it as a reserve to make even more loans. The system can't stop, it would collapse.
Assume that “the bank” in question represents all banks. And so depositing in any bank counts as depositing in “the bank” because this is illustrative.
You give a dollar. The bank loans out 90 cents to bob. Bob buys something (I skipped over this) from Joe. Joe puts 90 cents in the bank. Bob pays back 90 cents he earned using the purchase from Joe. The bank now has $1.90.
You’re right that the system would collapse if it stopped. But so would, say, the entirety of the national economy stop if we decided to just stop making loans. We like loans because loans enable growth. So you can, idk, buy better GPUs to mine poopcoins
"The bank" can't simultaneously be "all banks". Sure, if we consider "all banks" then $1 paid into the system can "magically" turn into $1.90 (and far more) without even considering interest. That's my original point! Money is being created by fractional reserve banking.
But it’s important to get that money is not blindly created. It’s done because value is created at a faster rate than physical dollars. You can view banks as a service that invests your dollars. You give them money to loan out and receive some of the interest in compensation. You yourself can create “new money” by making a loan yourself. The new money is just the result of value creation.
[citation desperately needed]
I think you're just letting your imagination run wild on how things work and why that makes sense.
> You yourself can create “new money” by making a loan yourself.
No I can't. If I make a loan to myself, there is no new money to circulate. If a bank makes a loan on fractional reserves it is new money than can circulate and that can itself be the basis for new money creation.
> The new money is just the result of value creation.
The new money is the result of fractional reserve lending, period. Whether "value" is created along the way is absolutely not a given.
If value were not being created fast enough, then people wouldn’t be able to payoff the loans. The loans are made either to enable value creation (business loans) or to fund a purchase and the loan taker agrees to funnel their value creation (salary) back into it.
> No I can't. If I make a loan to myself, there is no new money to circulate. If a bank makes a loan on fractional reserves it is new money than can circulate and that can itself be the basis for new money creation.
Obviously I meant to someone else. Though perhaps this one is too hand wavey to be useful
If that was true, that every loan by a bank was multiplying assets by 10, because they're required to hold 10% in reserves, then we would instantly have runaway unimaginably huge inflation and everything would collapse. So even if you don't understand why it's not true, common sense should make you pause and look for that understanding.
It is true. Assuming that banks are exerting their full capacity for lending, banks would be multiplying the money supply by 10.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking#Mon...
> ... then we would instantly have runaway unimaginably huge inflation and everything would collapse.
That isn't true. If you get loan to buy something, that isn't free money. You're going to have to not buy other things to pay back the loan.
Look, how do you know you're not the equivalent of a flat-earther? Is there any doubt in your mind about whether you have correctly understood the situation? When did you become convinced of your views?
I never said anything like that. I'm saying the bank is creating new money that is becoming part of the money supply. I gave you a Wikipedia link so that you can convince yourself.
> Look, how do you know you're not the equivalent of a flat-earther?
Wikipedia says what I am saying.
> Is there any doubt in your mind about whether you have correctly understood the situation?
That is a question that you really have to ask yourself.
Note that it does not work this way currently since normal people cannot buy/sell directly with the Tether treasury at all.
Unless Tether can buy Tethers cheaper than anyone else (through some unspecified mechanism) then they can't profit from arbitrage any more than anyone else.
Of course Tether can charge a fee to mint new Tethers, or to exchange Tethers for actual dollars. That's exactly what they do.
Let me start by saying I don't hold Tether nor have I ever, nor do I think it's a good idea.
Tether is a fundamentally a risk free money making concept, it works just like gift certificates. The only thing Tether has to do is buy back Tether at any price lower than they sold it for and they make profit.
And being able to buy Tether at a lower price is a fundamental market property because of knowledge imbalance. They literally can not fail at making money, the only thing they had to do was not lose their liquidity.
They print free money without it even being a scam, even better they are providing a public service, and still they messed it up...