News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by ComputerGuru on Monday December 06, 2010 @04:52PM (#1976968)
The rest will simply laugh at the Herman Melville reference.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by aikinai on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:55PM (#1977167)
Just to confirm with empirical evidence, I didn't know about the "fail whale" meme until after seeing this, but I still thought Google's page was humorous and made sense.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by hugh3 on Monday December 06, 2010 @07:06PM (#1977399)
The worst case scenario is that it makes no less sense than the original Twitter fail whale.

That was a completely out-of-context picture which made no sense, but nobody complained about it. Likewise, anyone confronted with a google books fail whale (which, incidentally, should happen a lot less often than the twitter fail whale, because google's infrastructure doesn't suck) without the preceding context of the twitter fail whale will understand what the page means just as much as they'd understand "404 not found".

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by StavrosK on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:11PM (#1977029)
Fail Whale fail, "Whale Fail" fail.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by alanh on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:14PM (#1977044)
No, it doesn’t make sense, even if you are familiar with Moby Dick. How is the whale failing? How is there any “fail” associated with the whale? The wording only makes sense if you are already familiar with the Fail Whale meme.

Edit: Thanks for pointing out the color of the whale. That does make more sense. But still, I object to the unprofessional and derivative wording. Having any sort of whale on an error page is homage enough, without beating anyone over the head with it or confusing people. “We’re having trouble locating that <del>whale</del> <ins>book</ins>” would make more sense, IMO.

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by hugh3 on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:16PM (#1977054)
Note the colour of the whale and the dejected expression on Ahab's shoulders.

"Not another fricking black whale", he's saying. "Whale fail!"

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by catshirt on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:45PM (#1977335)
fwiw, even the term "fail" alone is still pretty subcultural. i don't entirely agree with alanh, but they are definitely right that many of those who understand the reference are letting their understanding blind them.

this type of blindness is rabidly (albeit understandably) common among technology companies in general. given that that Google reaches all types of users and an error page is meant to inform, i'm not sure the reference is worth the risk.

that all said, i personally find the reference obvious, thus boring. but that's just my opinion. :)

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by hugh3 on Monday December 06, 2010 @07:08PM (#1977406)
fwiw, even the term "fail" alone is still pretty subcultural. i don't entirely agree with alanh, but they are definitely right that many of those who understand the reference are letting their understanding blind them.

Sure, but it's not necessary to fully understand the page in order to get the message. An error occurred. Why is there a whale involved? Who cares?

The only people I can imagine who might get confused are people who encounter this while trying to read Moby Dick.

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by catshirt on Monday December 06, 2010 @08:07PM (#1977575)
i never suggested the reference was detrimental to the page, but it is a risk. proven even just by the fact that it's debatable. it is an error page; the person likely got here because they are confused in the first place. this is especially notable given the huge spectrum of Google's audience.

i don't feel strongly either way on the execution. however, i do feel strongly that it would be negligent for the deciding party to not at least recognize that it is a risk.

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by Aleul on Monday December 06, 2010 @07:33PM (#1977479)
Just curious, what age groups to do associate with? Being 20, so around teens and what not 'fail' is said an obnoxious amount. I don't think it's as subcultural as you think. (Some of these people ask how to use Twitter...)

Yes, it's an error page, and it says it is "having trouble finding the page". I don't get the confusion that could cause.

If an obvious reference is boring, why did you complain about the use of fail which is subcultural as you put it?

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by catshirt on Monday December 06, 2010 @08:18PM (#1977598)
i'm 22. it's not a generation gap and i'm aware of the virality of "fail" in general. i never suggested in what capacity it existed, just that i would consider it subcultural. even if you assume the extremity that everyone under 22 has heard "fail" to some extent- i'm quite sure they are not Google's primary audience for this product.

i do realize this is not an acute analogy, but allow me to close with a sobering reminder of the truth. google asks: "what is a browser?" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4MwTvtyrUQ

Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by orangecat on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:18PM (#1977062)
The whale isn't failing, Ahab is failing at whaling.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page by hammock on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:27PM (#1977271)
All this failing and whaling has got me wailing.