Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page
by catshirt on Monday December 06, 2010 @08:07PM
(#1977575)
i never suggested the reference was detrimental to the page, but it is a risk. proven even just by the fact that it's debatable. it is an error page; the person likely got here because they are confused in the first place. this is especially notable given the huge spectrum of Google's audience.
i don't feel strongly either way on the execution. however, i do feel strongly that it would be negligent for the deciding party to not at least recognize that it is a risk.
Sure, but it's not necessary to fully understand the page in order to get the message. An error occurred. Why is there a whale involved? Who cares?
The only people I can imagine who might get confused are people who encounter this while trying to read Moby Dick.