News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by sigmar on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:31AM (#19765392)
>It's a bit anti competitive, yes, it limits what app makers can do, but it makes iOs secure. There's no other way to do it, and that's what many people don't understand.

Doesn't it seem weird to you how they only cared about "making iOS secure" once they had their own product?

If Google or Microsoft did this the reaction here on HN would be so different. Any anti-competitive practice could be rationalized by saying it makes the platform more secure.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by floatingatoll on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:49AM (#19765494)
If you’re building something and you lift up a rock and find a lot of weird solutions to a problem you’d never really thought through crawling under it, what would you do?

1) Ban them immediately, no matter how necessary to parents, as the risk of tracking/stalking of all iPhone users is unacceptable

2) Build a safer solution that can’t be harnessed for tracking/stalking, and then ban all solutions that can be used for tracking/stalking

Seems like they chose the latter. It’s easy to construct a case for why it is technically inappropriate to allow third-party apps in this space, that I personally boil down primarily to “a frequently-abused chance for corporate entities to monetize the user data of minors”.

Apple took years to implement content filtering, and did so in a way that prohibits applications from knowing whether their filters are ever exercised, as otherwise Facebook and other malicious entities would long ago have added a filter for ^(.*)$ to transmit every request to third-party servers. Is their refusal to permit otherwise anti-competitive, security-forward, or both?

Apple, if I understand correctly, prohibits third-party keyboards in certain password-type dialogs on iOS because keyboard apps are allowed to send network requests. (They are allowed to do so because e.g. GIF search.) Is this prohibition anti-competitive, security-forward, or both?

We as a community need to become a lot more careful with use of the phrase “anti-competitive”, as many industry-standard security practices that we would demand of any product we build and use are then labeled “anti-competitive” solely when they interfere with us doing anything we like, or when they’re done by an organization that doesn’t share its internal discussions with us when making decisions on our behalf.

Is it appropriate to stifle the competition for my personal data, even if that is, in a literalistic interpretation, anti-competitive?

I sure hope so.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by JadeNB on Saturday April 27, 2019 @06:55PM (#19768140)
> If you’re building something and you lift up a rock and find a lot of weird solutions to a problem you’d never really thought through crawling under it, what would you do?

> 1) Ban them immediately, no matter how necessary to parents, as the risk of tracking/stalking of all iPhone users is unacceptable

> 2) Build a safer solution that can’t be harnessed for tracking/stalking, and then ban all solutions that can be used for tracking/stalking

Surely the correct answer, if the solution is really so valuable that it cannot be done without in the time it would take to come up with a safe solution, is

3) tell the programmers of the potentially privacy-violating solutions that they'll be banned once you do (2), then do (2);

or arguably even

4) do (3), and, in the meantime, display a hard-to-ignore dialogue on installation that warns "this app may violate your privacy, and will be automatically uninstalled once Apple's safer solution is available. Do you wish to proceed?"

?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by floatingatoll on Saturday April 27, 2019 @07:22PM (#19768254)
ESR-type freedom fighters typically suggest that the priority should be on one’s freedom to shoot your own foot off with a footgun, as long as the footgun has clear warnings. This idealism commonly places absolute freedom as the number one priority, leaving no room for competing priorities such as the safety and welfare of those who are unable to make sensible judgement calls regarding footgun operation.

I have watched expert users infect themselves with malware faster than I can open my mouth to warn them that they’ve just unthinkingly clicked Next and blown their foot off, and then had to help them wipe their installation and start over.

I do not consider the current world we live in to be one where it is safe to prioritize absolute freedom over all other concerns. I accept that this puts me at odds with those that do, but as I watch them shoot their own feet off, I am grateful that I chose a more pragmatic path. I am grateful that a safer path is available for those who are unable to comprehend the severities of the risks they are defended against.

The solution you propose is no different than saying that the safety on a gun is sufficient to protect someone from accidentally shooting themselves with it. I do not agree with your assumptions, and I think the solution you describe is selfish and neglectful. You prioritize your ideals over the welfare of others unable to avoid paying the price you think yourself able to dodge. Your choice is abhorrent to me, and pushes me further away from the absolutist freedoms you espouse. Consider carefully in the future whether your argument as presented today helps or harms your cause.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by JadeNB on Saturday April 27, 2019 @07:55PM (#19768432)
> You prioritize your ideals over the welfare of others unable to avoid paying the price you think yourself able to dodge.

Wow, that's a lot of assumptions. Both my (3) and (4) include "then do (2)", which seemed to be the solution you were proposing; they just more clearly communicated to developers that (2) was coming, and more clearly communicated to users the consequences of implementing half-baked solutions before (2) was done. I can imagine a lot of practical problems with what I suggested, but it's hard for me to see how increasing the communication in either or both of the ways that I proposed, while also doing what (it seems) you're proposing (and what Apple did), constitutes adherence to a selfish ideal.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by lotsofpulp on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:41AM (#19765443)
All I know is I spent a considerable amount of time dealing with malware on Windows and bad video call quality on apps on android, as well as android’s problems with updating phone software, difficulty backing up and restoring data.

Ever since moving everyone in my extended family to Apple’s ecosystem, I no longer field any calls about uninstalling malware, computer running slow, video calls are crystal clear, and the devices work forever. And if there’s a problem, they can take it to the Apple store and get it fixed, and restore from iCloud backup and they’re up and running in no time.

If Google or Microsoft want to re-create that convenience, I’m all for it. I know I sound like a shill, but I think it’s well worth whatever extra it costs in terms of time I saved troubleshooting.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by miki123211 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:50AM (#19765496)
Friend of mine told me a story that he has set up a Windows computer for someone, and one week later that same person goes back and is like "oh, my computer is broken". The guy asks what happened, and the person explains that she was trying to get that new game for her daughter, but it's so expensive so she wanted a crack. The antivirus complained, like it always does, so she just turned it off and installed anyway. The guy immediately recommended to stay far away from Windows and get an iPad. She did and never came back.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by Volundr on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:19AM (#19765665)
While I'm not a Windows fan, I feel like Windows isn't the problem in this story.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by automatoney on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:31AM (#19765719)
It's clearly user error, but I think the point is that it's less of a headache to change the OS than the user.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by EpicEng on Saturday April 27, 2019 @08:34PM (#19768574)
I wonder if that game exists for MacOS? Probably not.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by briandear on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:12PM (#19766220)
Is essentially a gun control debate. Windows (the gun,) is benign on its own and millions of people can safely use it. However, in the wrong hands, it can enable dangerous behaviors and undesirable outcomes. MacOS simply has much stronger trigger locks.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by metildaa on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:20PM (#19766551)
Piracy is still a major threat to security on MacOS
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by w1nst0nsm1th on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:51PM (#19766730)
By definition, a gun is not begnin.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by josinalvo on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:32PM (#19767467)
I would wager most guns get fired a very small amount of times.

If you take those away, of the rest, I'd wager the overwhelming majority is used for sports and hunting.

So, not sure about that. You might have the right claim, but the "by definition" might be too much

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by mijamo on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:08PM (#19767646)
The same could be said of nuclear weapons.

A weapon is by definition madr to cause harm, so it is not benign.

Even hunting is not a benign act at all, which is why you need training and have a lot of regulation regarding how you can practice it.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by larrywright on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:50AM (#19766098)
I have helped friends with laptops, and laptops used by teens were the worst. They go to incredibly sketchy websites to watch free movies and TV shows, and install any software when prompted to by a popup. I haven't had to deal with it in a while and I don't miss it.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by babuskov on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:23AM (#19765678)
How did he get that pirated game to run on iPad? /s
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by xondono on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:58AM (#19770438)
He didn’t that’s the point.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by f137 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @03:39PM (#19767242)
Where did she get that game for ipad for free?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarejunba on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:00PM (#19767329)
Perhaps the point is "safe device + no game" > "device with user error likely + game", i.e. there is no longer a game but that's okay.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by miki123211 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:43AM (#19765454)
I've already explained it in the parent comment. Before screen time, there was no other way to achieve parental control, so they probably decided to go with those solutions, for the lack of a better option. Screen Time changed the situation and there's no reason to keep those privacy nightmares in the App Store any longer. You can achieve the goal of parental control via less privacy intrusive means, which you couldn't do before. Whether you actually should is an entirely different matter IMO.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:38AM (#19765428)
Anti competitive how? Apple doesn’t make money from their solution. On the other hand, they would make 30% on third party solutions. Wouldn’t it be in their financial interest to allow third party spyware?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by wayneftw on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:45AM (#19765466)
Microsoft didn't make money on their free Internet Explorer web browser but they lost an anti-trust case for giving it away free with Windows.

And before anyone says Apple isn't a monopoly...well they are in certain markets. For instance, among the younger generations they have like +80% market share and in the US they have close to 50%. There's also an anti-trust case pending against them in the Supreme Court right now.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:48AM (#19765484)
They didn’t “lose” because of bundling. They lost because they forced exclusive third party OEMs not to bundle Netscape. Do you notice that MS never stopped bundling IE?

Have any of the console makers or smart TV makers been told what they can and can’t put on their own devices? Has any physical store been fined for limiting what they sell in their own store?

And that’s not how monopolies are defined.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by wayneftw on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:25AM (#19765986)
Not allowing users to put competing third party apps on their own devices is exactly what Apple is doing. Should users have less rights on their devices than OEMs do e.g. in the Microsoft case?

And market percentage is too one major metric of how monopolies are defined.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by briandear on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:33PM (#19766326)
If those third party apps weren’t violating Apple’s policies, they’d be on the store. Should dangerous products be allowed on the App Store in the name of “competition?” That’s ridiculous. If Apple was trying to be uncompetitive, they would have removed all the third party calendar, reminders, notes and music apps. The only movie editing app would be iMovie. Yet they haven’t did that. They only removed screen time apps that violate user privacy in significant ways. App Store removals have never been because “Apple makes a competing product” — they are generally because of a privacy issue or some kind of content-based idea (such as removing InfoWars or not wanting yet another fart app.)

If you don’t like it by an Android and develop for Android. Literally every single person on the planet with access to iPhone could alternatively use Android. In fact, iPhone is more expensive than cheap Androids, so there is even less reason for people to stay with iPhone. Yet, for some weird reason, people keep buying the phones.

If I subscribe to the Disney channel, I suspect to not see porn. If I buy Apple, I expect that my privacy is being rigorously protected. For people who want porn or less secure devices, those things are readily available from other vendors. Just become Apple doesn’t sell “porn” doesn’t make them a monopoly. If your local movie theater doesn’t screen porn films, are they being anti-competitive? Are they considered a monopoly? Not allowing porn producers to screen their films at the local movie theater is analogous to Apple not allowing privacy dangerous apps on their store.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:54AM (#19766120)
So you want Apple to allow spyware on their phones? Should Smsrt TV makers be forced to allow any third party app? What about console makers? Should Nintendo be forced to allow adult oriented games on their platform?

What exactly is Apple’s business motivation for not allowing third party spyware but allowing third party music streaming, video streaming, office apps, book stores, etc? When they make money off of their own services in the other areas?

Next question. What if this app with the same capabilities - to record the apps and activity used on another phone - was marketed to husbands who suspected their wives were cheating. Would you be okay with that too? Should Apple allow it?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by will_brown on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:10PM (#19766208)
>Should Smsrt TV makers be forced to allow any third party app? What about console makers? Should Nintendo be forced to allow adult oriented games on their platform?

I think the argument is Apple has a little more market dominance (both smart phone hardware and OS) than a single smart tv maker or even Nintendo in the console market.

Keeping the market dominance point in mind, Apple isn’t just deciding what is and isn’t allowed...you had a number of developers with successful apps not just have to contend with a copy cat app created by Apple but because of their control over the marketplace Apple killed their developers apps and took the entire market (rightly or wrongly).

So yeah if you change your facts and the smart tv or Nintendo allowed apps/adult games, saw developers create a market and then the hardware maker launched their own software competitors and disallowed the initial apps/games...there would be blowback.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:15PM (#19766235)
You also had a number of developers who successfully were marketing fake “virus protection” including Kasperky that were kicked off the store. Should Apple have kept those on the store? Facebook bought a “successful” VPN product that it used to spy on users and figure out that WhatsApp was popular before it bought it. Should Apple have kept that?

Would you be okay if apps with the same capabilities were marketed as a way to catch cheating spouses?

If Apple decides they wanted to ban loot boxes in games, would you be opposed to that?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by Phlarp on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:17PM (#19766862)
>Would you be okay if apps with the same capabilities were marketed as a way to catch cheating spouses?

Aren't apps with these same capabilities (and more) being marketed as a way to track and spy on a spouse? (regardless of their fidelity)

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/13/world/middleeast/saudi-ar...

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:31PM (#19766919)
Of course I don’t agree with the app. But from what I can tell, at least on iOS, the app is just a front end for a website and a set of services. The app itself doesn’t intercept communications on the phone or use any special phone permissions. From another site, I saw the Absher service will notify the husband via SMS.

With NYT’s (usual) shallow technical reporting, I can’t tell what the app does. Just like the article for this post. The only reason we on HN suspect that the apps for this article must be using some combination of MDM API’s and a VPN is because we know how iOS works.

But I can always throw the question back at you. How can you on one hand say that it would be okay if this app did do something similar (which I can’t tell) and Apple banned it for privacy reasons but not okay to ban other software that is spyware?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by rndgermandude on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:06PM (#19767347)
>So you want Apple to allow spyware on their phones?

Yes.

>Should Smsrt TV makers be forced to allow any third party app?

Yes.

>What about console makers? Should Nintendo be forced to allow adult oriented games on their platform?

Yes. They do not have to endorse or even promote such games, but they shouldn't be allowed to prohibit such games either.

>Next question. What if this app with the same capabilities - to record the apps and activity used on another phone - was marketed to husbands who suspected their wives were cheating. Would you be okay with that too? Should Apple allow it?

Yes, Apple should allow the app's functionality. The law shouldn't allow such ads or spying on people without their knowledge.

In short, it shouldn't be Apple/Samsung/Nintendo's business what gets run on a device.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:09PM (#19767653)
Well, in that case you as a consumer are free to buy an Android for a phone or a gaming PC instead of a console.

You can then install all of the spyware and ransomware that your heart desires.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by FireBeyond on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:03PM (#19767622)
> So you want Apple to allow spyware on their phones?

Therein is the crux of the matter - it ceased to be Apple's phone the moment they sold it.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:06PM (#19767635)
In that case, should Nintendo be forced to allow Grand Theft Auto on their console?

Were you okay with them banning Facebook’s VPN app that spied on users?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by FireBeyond on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:18PM (#19767688)
And yet I said nothing about my agreement or disagreement with decisions like that, merely that a large part of the debate is when Apple's control ends. There is a non negligible portion of people who believe, act as if the device is Apple's, even after sale.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:49PM (#19767837)
Well. Since Apple’s retention rate is in the high 90s and that there are much cheaper Android alternatives available, maybe iOS users are okay with that....
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by theclaw on Saturday April 27, 2019 @08:30PM (#19768561)
No. It’s not the crux. It’s still Apple’s app store, GP should have asked “So you want Apple to sell spyware in their store?”
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by wayneftw on Sunday April 28, 2019 @08:20AM (#19770735)
> So you want Apple to allow spyware on their phones?

No, I want them to allow it on MY PHONE.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by briandear on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:17PM (#19766241)
Having a market share if 80% among a demographic doesn’t make a monopoly. Even 100% market share among a demographic isn’t a monopoly. I might suggest a review of the definition of the term “monopoly.”
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by addicted on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:51AM (#19765502)
MS did have to stop bundling IE in the EU.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:55AM (#19765529)
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:52AM (#19765507)
The argument is they want you to use less effective anti-addiction tools so you stay on your phone more.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:54AM (#19765521)
And since they aren’t an advertising supported business, what financial motivation do they have by keeping you on your phone more?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by saagarjha on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:00AM (#19765553)
Not that I agree with this argument, but Apple does have services that they could earn money off of.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:02AM (#19765569)
And Apple services that they earn money from are all subscription based. It would be better for Apple if people subscribed and used them less...
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by saagarjha on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:13AM (#19765631)
Not all of them. For example, you can still pay for apps and music.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:25AM (#19765691)
And you’ve been able to block iTunes and the App Store through parental controls forever.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:18PM (#19766253)
You honestly can’t imagine why a company would want you to use their product more and how increased use would have a direct financial benefit?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:22PM (#19766272)
So tell me how does Apple make more money they more time I spend on my phone?

I spend most of the time on my phone on the web, using subscription services that aren’t bought through the App Store, watching tutorial videos that I don’t buy through the App Store, and reading books I bought from the Amazon store.

I also listen to podcast using a third party player.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:09PM (#19766815)
Have you ever bought a new iPhone?

Have you ever dropped your phone and needed a repair?

The chance of both of those is correlated to how much time you spend on your device.

And of course, your particular use case isn’t driving apples decisions — it’s the aggregate behavior of all its users.

So while you may not buy more apps or services, it is certainly the case that increases in phone use correlate to increases in Apple Eco System generated revenue for Apple.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:34PM (#19766936)
Really? That’s the road you’re going down? Apple wants you to use your phone more to increase the likelihood that you will drop it?

And you still haven’t answered the other question. How are these third party apps better at controlling usage than Apple’s built in screen time and parental controls?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:25AM (#19769338)
Your question was how does increased usage increase revenue.

Repairs are a non-trivial source of revenue and increased usage certainly increases repairs.

But more important are the other examples I gave which you have ignored.

I don’t know how they are better personally, but the author of the article (did you read it?) certain pointed out some examples.

As far as I can tell, your argument is that user phone usage has zero impact on apples revenue, I’m making the opposite case. My sense is that phone usage is correlated with revenue.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:27AM (#19769685)
Yes I did read the entire article. Neither you nor the article (detail light) listed anyway that the third party apps were better than iOS built in features.

Until you do, I think it’s safe to say that your unsubstantiated opinions are just that. Again, can you cite any feature that the third party apps have that Apple didn’t either include recently in the screen time feature or the parental controls that have been there forever?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:00AM (#19769943)
Maybe you didn’t read the whole thing? Or maybe you are just trolling here? It’s unclear.

>> Unlike apps such as OurPact, Apple’s tools don’t allow parents to schedule different times throughout a day when an app is blocked — for school or family dinner. And Apple’s tool blocks adult content only on its Safari web browser and some apps, not on other browsers or many popular apps, like Twitter, YouTube and Instagram. <<

So, in case you missed it, here is what they are saying:

1) ability to set a schedule for blocking apps through out the day.

2) blocking content outside of Safari (in other apps / browsers / etc).

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:33PM (#19772801)
Well let’s see where to start...

If you set parental limits in settings. Those limits are supported by Chrome. But, if you are trying to limit what sites your kids can browse to, why would you allow them to install the third party browser in the first place? You can set up Family sharing to notify you and when your child tries to install an app and you can approve or reject the approval from your phone.

And if you are that concerned about your child’s well being, why would you install VPN software on their phone that allows a third party to track and record all of the internet activity from your child’s phone?

A VPN app cant block content on a level of granularity that blocks certain videos or twitter accounts.. But if you’re counting on software to block Youtube videos and Twitter, you’re doing it wrong.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:46PM (#19773254)
All I did was present evidence that your claim was false.

You said the article didn’t make any claims as to what features weren’t available so I provided them.

I’m not going to engage in a tangential analysis of those features, but you are welcome to it.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:47PM (#19775211)
So you’re not going to engage in an analysis when the article was demonstrable wrong and you have no experience personally?

How pray tell is a third party app going to filter only certain YouTube videos and certain Twitter posts? Didn’t you have at least the tiniest bit of suspicion about the article?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:55PM (#19775472)
No, I’m not.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:16PM (#19766238)
I’m confused why the downvotes, did I inaccurately represent the argument the original posted article is trying to make?

You might not agree with the original post, but downvoting me for merely stating what the argument is seems out of the spirit of HN.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:26PM (#19766297)
It’s unsubstatisted.

What is the financial motivation for Apple wanting you to be on your phone more?

How is Apple’s offering less effective?

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:05PM (#19766799)
Again, I simple stated what the OPs argument was. If you are downvoting me because you disagree with the original post, you aren’t clear on how to use HN.

As to your other questions, if I use the phone more I’m more likely to buy a new phone, buy more cloud storage, download and buy more apps, generate referral sales by other people seeing me use the product, drop the phone requiring Apple repairs, the list goes on.

Apple wants to develop a deep relationship with their users, so in Nearly every case using the products more is to their benefit.

The more you rely on the products the more free attention you spend in their eco-system, and the more likely you will spend money that they will get a % of.

I think some others have laid out the argument for how the Apple solution is less effective than others, so I’ll let that stand and not rehash it here.

Whether or not this is the actual motivation for Apple is unclear, but the incentives are clear that they’d want you to use your phone vs not using it.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by pvg on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:12PM (#19766835)
you aren’t clear on how to use HN.

There's a document about this stuff at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Take a look at the third item from the bottom.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by ada1981 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:02AM (#19769610)
Fair.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by scarface74 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @03:01PM (#19767067)
You haven’t stated from your own personal experience or showing a documented feature set how the third party apps are better.

Do you really think that people are going to purposefully install an app that keeps them from taking pictures that will cause them to use more cloud storage? Do the third party apps somehow prevent this better than Apples built in controls? You’ve posted twice without giving any details to back up your claims.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by morpheuskafka on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:26PM (#19766590)
Screen Time does not make Apple any additional money. They have no financial reason to care if customers used it or not, they get the same money as soon as you buy the device. In fact, paid parental control apps could earn them more money because of the 30% cut on app revenue.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by sokoloff on Saturday April 27, 2019 @03:11PM (#19767113)
Screentime makes Apple money if it's the deciding factor between someone buying an Apple device vs not. The inclusion of Screentime in iOS sold my family an additional two iPads for my kids to use.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by EpicEng on Saturday April 27, 2019 @08:41PM (#19768592)
Just like MS made no money from IE?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by dontbenebby on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:09PM (#19766498)
>Doesn't it seem weird to you how they only cared about "making iOS secure" once they had their own product?

Not really - there's a big difference between banning an insecure app when a secure solution has been added to the OS, and banning an app when no secure solution yet exists.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by briandear on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:08PM (#19766197)
They don’t sell ScreenTime or the parental control apps. They aren’t generating revenue from it. They do, however, make money from other people selling apps from the App Store. Also, if you have an iPhone, you already bought the phone, so what’s the incentive for banning outside screen time apps? How does Apple win? They win because their device and the apps on it are more secure. Calling that anti-competitive makes no sense unless Apple was selling competing ScreenTime apps. Not letting users unknowingly compromise their own privacy isn’t anti-competitive.

And in the case of Google, it would be different because Google’s business model is all about “targeting” you. Apple’s model is simply to sell you stuff.

Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by citrablue on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:26AM (#19765987)
Not all that strange -- the decision was more "we have a security issue, but banning these apps would create a screen time issue". Framed that way, it made perfect sense they waited until they had a long term solution finalized.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by busymom0 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:37AM (#19769722)
This whole thing started when Apple banned Facebook's enterprise certificated because they were using them for consumer directed apps + directing the user's data through their own VPN. This was clearly an abuse of the enterprise certificates and not what they are meant for. This happened around January - the same time when this article's developers were also notified that they will be removed because they were using MDM profiles for something they are not meant for. I don't think this has anything to do with their own product. Apple's product is also 100% free, I don't see how they have any incentive to ban others. Apple doesn't ban other podcast, music and other competitive apps.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by notSupplied on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:27PM (#19783971)
The conspiracy doesn't add up in this particular example given that Screen-Time does nothing for their bottom line. Don't get me wrong, I would definitely perk up my ears if there is a story about how Apple competes with Spotify as there is a lot to gain/lose on that front. But Screen Time? What is there to "win"?
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by tinus_hn on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:26PM (#19773479)
This kind of ban happens all the time. It just makes the news now because there’s a way to spin it into a conspiracy.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by z3t4 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:47PM (#19766703)
It's really thought to compete when you have to compete on your competitor's platform.
Re:Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and p... by rimliu on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:53AM (#19766113)
iOS only runs on Apple devices, same for macOS. This is not the case for Google and Microsoft.