News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by jopsen on Sunday April 21, 2019 @05:17PM (#19714638)
Wow, are we know so scared of mob mentality that we don't condemn brazen free speech interference?

I know social media platforms can create mobs, but since when are we all scared that:

> That digital rights and press freedom advocates might now sympathize, if not agree, with Sri Lanka’s action.

This seems questionable to me, and problematic for people trying to find each other.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by mikeash on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:16PM (#19715162)
I’m a firm believer in free speech and think this is a bad move.

However, there’s a vast difference between targeted censorship of forbidden topics and a temporary blanket ban on certain forms of communication. This isn’t good, but it’s pretty mild. Temporary limits on fundamental freedoms during an emergency are pretty common, even in the good old USA.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by code_sloth on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:16PM (#19715647)
Free speech is about the right to __articulate__ opinions and ideas. To articulate ideas and opinions, you have to think and formulate your thoughts.

What Facebook enables and optimizes for can hardly be called free speech. Articulation is not encouraged, merely the spreading of thoughts (both good and bad). Engagement has been optimized for advertising purposes. It led to banal agreement in the form of likes and reshares. There is hardly any discourse, people get silo-ed in echo chambers, and the extreme ends of the spectrum get magnified. Confirmation bias rules, and bad ideas aren't defeated by good ideas because they hardly come into contact.

So no, Facebook isn't enabling free speech, as much as they'd like to claim they are. At best they are a communication tool, nothing more.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by tdhoot on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:31PM (#19715723)
Free speech is not only about articulation. It's also about the ability to share, disseminate, and influence others.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by code_sloth on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:37PM (#19715970)
Speech without thought isn't free speech. It's just people and sometimes mobs saying things.

Freedom of information flow isn't the same thing. Democracy works best with an informed electorate. Information flow without discourse is just indoctrination. And that's what Facebook (unintendedly) optimizes for.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by NeonVice on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:35PM (#19716312)
Speech even without thought is still free speech. You would hope that the most thoughtful speech would be easily recognized and followed in place of its opposite. However, free speech does not exist in a world where only one group decides what is thoughtful speech.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by tus87 on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:52AM (#19717046)
The only speech without thought is tourettes.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by bencollier49 on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:48AM (#19717234)
And glossolalia, and sleeptalking. Oh, and recitation from memory. Probably some other things.

Depending on your definition of "thought".

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by talmand on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:53AM (#19719365)
>> Speech without thought isn't free speech.

That's a rather strong opening to limiting free speech. Who gets to decide that my speech was without thought? Is there an approval process? Can I repeal the decision? Do I have to document my thoughts before I speak to prove later that I did indeed think before I spoke out against the people that make those distinctions?

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by hliyan on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:31AM (#19717384)
Sri Lankan here. I have to agree with this. I'm absolutely against censorship and suppression of free speech, but in this particular instance, it's more like a government grounding all flights because it's a vector for a spreading pandemic. Social media right now is such a vector. I'm certain we prevented a lot of retaliatory bloodshed with the social media blackout and the curfew.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by zzzcpan on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:22PM (#19715434)
It's not that mild. Still an attempt to stop information government doesn't like from spreading. Still targeted, more broadly, but targeted. Still requires internet censorship infrastructure to even be able to order ISPs to block websites and power, so much power to get there, pretty much dictatorship level power. China, the anti freedom villain, does this kind of thing regularly.

I get why people are making excuses though. Pretty much no political systems in the world can actually exist with truly free speech, because they all rely on controlling free speech to function. And now that actual free speech got out of their control it threatens them and makes them push against it, promoting restrictions to free speech.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by lambdasquirrel on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:46AM (#19716815)
There's also the contrarian viewpoint that Facebook is a danger to civilization, and not only ideas that are valued by democracy. The whole thing was built by hijacking the limbic system. And aren't ads much the same? So you can say then, that it was monetized by likewise hijacking the limbic system. Anyway, this is not a good recipe for discourse.

Now they can finagle around with it as much as they like, try to machine-learning this, machine-learning that, but it isn't going to get around that it fundamentally operates by hijacking people's limbic system. And people are ultimately more clever and dastardly than whatever machine-learning they are going to throw at it to try to sanitize the discourse.

It's probably easier to teach yoga/tai chi/meditation/whatever to all of Facebook's users than to fix Facebook.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by username223 on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:39AM (#19718803)
> Temporary limits on fundamental freedoms during an emergency are pretty common, even in the good old USA.

Exactly. If people are rioting, for example because their football team won the Super Bowl (http://fortune.com/2018/02/05/eagles-win-super-bowl-riot-psy...), the city may impose a curfew to give everyone a chance to cool off. This just sounds like the digital equivalent to me, and while it's unfortunate, it seems like the best solution to the problem.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by lambdasquirrel on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:09PM (#19715137)
I'm sure this isn't going to be a popular opinion here, but for most of the people in the world, "free speech" isn't as important as the safety of their loved ones. If most people in the world wanted "democracy" as it is in the United States, they would have chosen it. Or as the Chinese put it, people are much less likely to choose "freedom" if you instead frame it as a responsibility. Are we speaking responsibly?
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by andrepd on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:43PM (#19716002)
>If most people in the world wanted "democracy" they would have chosen it.

What the heck is this supposed to mean? What, I suppose that if people in China wanted democracy they could just go and get it? Oh wait, not really, they get silenced, arrested, and massacred... Is there even a place on Earth where a democratic transition was achieved not by force against the holders of power?

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by tsbinz on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:37AM (#19716994)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athenian_democracy ? The initial implementation doesn't seem to have been very forceful ...
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by everdev on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:09PM (#19715375)
> If most people in the world wanted "democracy" as it is in the United States, they would have chosen it.

Taking power from a non-democratic leadership is incredibly difficult, risky and almost always violent. And non-democratic leadership very rarely self-democratize. Unfortunately, we don't know if much of the world wants democracy as it's aggressively stamped out in many places and illegal to pursue it.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by lambdasquirrel on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:21AM (#19716501)
Democracy happened in South Korea and Taiwan, and across all of Western Europe over the course of the 19th century. There are also places that have implemented democratic systems, but the people hardly seem to have benefited. Do you then blame the people for not contributing more to their democracy?

While I agree with you, that it’s difficult, sometimes bloody, and elites almost never give up power voluntarily (isn’t that true even in democracies though?), one can see that it can be done.

Even in “speech,” there is a matter of quality — quality that has been taken for granted in much of the “free” world. It is this quality that is the responsibility of speech.

Now, on topic, another comment on this thread points out quite well that some of our social media platforms are not designed for quality. They were designed to be viral.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by spinach on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:53AM (#19716836)
Democracy didn't just happen in Korea though, the people didn't choose it, it was done in part with America's interference/help after the end of the war. I agree that democracy isn't going to work everywhere in the world but I don't think it has to do with what people want (whatever that means, the majority?, since everyone has a different opinion...).

I agree with you on the short-comings of social media though, with their algorithms designed to push up the things that make people out-raged (those that go viral the fastest) and enable people to deepen and solidify their beliefs with very narrow curated feeds. These have led to hate crimes all over the world. There is definitely a dangerous element to them that people who harp on about 'free-speech' seem to want to sneer at.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by watwut on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:24AM (#19717357)
Democracy did not just happened in Europe. It does not happen by itself, without power struggle and fights and right conditions. The ideas that lead to democracy also dont just emerge automatically like something in born.

The fact is, those countries where people "just don't care" happen to be countries that violently suppress opposition. The opposition does not necessary want fairness and freedom, but they want participation on power.

There is always mechanism for fighting out power and ideas - prison or election.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by soulofmischief on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:57AM (#19719396)
> If most people in the world wanted "democracy" as it is in the United States, they would have chosen it.

And if most poor people didn't want to be poor, they would have chosen to be rich. And if most homeless people wanted to live in homes, they would have chosen it.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by qbaqbaqba on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:11AM (#19717101)
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by ww520 on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:12PM (#19716172)
I might be wrong but I believe U.S. is the only country has the right to free speech enshrined in the laws. Most countries, including European's, don't have free speech. I'm a firm believer in free speech but it's hard to talk to other countries about it when no one else values it as much as us.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by Throwway32 on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:38AM (#19717207)
I’ve made this point before: the US government has killed at least one citizen in a drone strike because he was making terrorist propaganda. Free speech, even within the loose limits set in US law is not as clearly guaranteed as you may believe it to be.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by Tomte on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:26AM (#19716745)
Most European countries (would have said "all", but am not sure how to categorize the Vatican and Belorussia) have Free Speech. Just not the extremist version that America favors.

Germany tempers it with the legal doctrine of "practical concordance", where a global maximum over all Basic Rights is sought, not just a local maximum for Free Speech, and all other rights lose.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by jopsen on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:48AM (#19717030)
The Danish constitution (or foundational law) has it.

It's also in the Human Rights convention.

In Europe a few counties has minor limitations on a few sensitive subjects. Don't confuse that for censorship, or free speech restrictions.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by johnisgood on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:34AM (#19718385)
> Don't confuse that for censorship, or free speech restrictions.

Why do not those "minor" limitations fall under censorship or free speech restriction?

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by vishnugupta on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:46AM (#19717437)
Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India guarantees to all its citizens the right to freedom of speech and expression. The law states that, “all citizens shall have the right to freedom of speech and expression”.

(Copy pasted from web)

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by buyx on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:41AM (#19717215)
South Africa’s constitution guarantees freedom of expression, and that right has generally been interpreted very liberally.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by screye on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:29PM (#19715209)
A big part of why social media websites/apps (FB and WhatsApp) are banned is because they are the central means of communication and agglomeration.

Forcing people to slow down in their ability to react to a massive amount of information/emotion, by letting them sit on for a while may not be a bad idea.

All too often a flurry of incomplete information leads only to a large degree of noise that organically sorts itself out inside of a couple of days.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by DenseComet on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:46PM (#19715523)
See: 9/11 Trading Halt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_effects_of_the_Septem...

Giving people time to think and force them to slow down is a proven method to prevent all out chaos.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by mirimir on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:25PM (#19715444)
I don't know about "we", but the Sri Lankan government clearly are. I certainly sympathize.

What would happen if a US president were assassinated now? Several cities burned after Martin Luther King was killed. Lots of LA burned after officers who beat Rodney King were acquitted. And now, with social media? It'd be total chaos.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by jopsen on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:51AM (#19717042)
Not really, social media was there during many of the BLM demonstrations.

People have become less violent over the years and with social media responsible organizers have a better shot at preventing violence.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by danharaj on Sunday April 21, 2019 @05:26PM (#19714677)
"I disagree with what you say, but I'll defend to the death (of other people) your right to say it."
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by manfredo on Sunday April 21, 2019 @05:42PM (#19714738)
There's a reason why we set the bar for prioritizing safety over speech at credible, immediate threat rather than an abstract threat. Effectively every movement or political group has committed acts of violence. Whether its Islamists blowing up marathons or shooting up nightclubs, or right wingers shooting up churches and mosques, or liberals trying to assassinate congressmen at a baseball game. If you look hard enough you can point to deaths or criminality caused by most political speech, and use that as justification for bans.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by weaksauce on Sunday April 21, 2019 @06:23PM (#19714958)
> liberals trying to assasinate congressmen at a baseball game.

One deranged man not liberals in general. There have been numerous right wingers shooting up churches and mosques and planned parenthood buildings.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by meowface on Sunday April 21, 2019 @06:31PM (#19715000)
You know full well that their post was discussing a more abstract point. Violent extremists exist among all ideologies and groups, and always will.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by weaksauce on Sunday April 21, 2019 @06:51PM (#19715074)
it just is way out of place compared to the frequency of the other acts of terrorism to the point of being silly to include. it's how people "both sides" things and it's dangerous to the focus of where we should be worrying.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by DuskStar on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:11PM (#19715143)
> it's how people "both sides" things and it's dangerous to the focus of where we should be worrying.

I'd say it's the people going "But not MY side!" that we really need to be worrying about here.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by siosonel on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:06PM (#19715360)
I agree both or all sides engage in self-serving agenda and bad policies. Nobody is perfect.

But it is hard not to see that extreme ideology drives the agenda of one or a few sides, while most sides are willing to compromise with reasonable, evidence-based solutions that the ideologists reject outright. It is irresponsible to say in that case that both sides are being unreasonable - that false equivalence promotes an unhealthy stalemate and gives cover to those who blindly delay progress.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by rhizome on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:55PM (#19716405)
There are two ways to take it: the "everybody has been bad" GP used, and "the probability of any one event being X is lower than the rest." For the former, it would make sense to look at how guns are promoted as problem-solvers, and for the latter is worth discussing how group values make a person more likely to inflict firearm injuries. Utility vs. incitement, I suppose.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by anigbrowl on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:22PM (#19715686)
Even when available date supports such a claim?
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by DuskStar on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:57PM (#19716082)
Well, the example here was "my side only does this a little, so Not MY Side!"... In other words, the data did not support such a claim.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by anigbrowl on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:27AM (#19716751)
It's hard to take such a disregard of proportionality seriously.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by pmorici on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:01PM (#19715114)
I think his point stands broadly regardless of the specific example you take issue with. The heyday of radical left wing terrorism in the US was the 60's and 70's

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-wing_terrorism

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by shoes_for_thee on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:06PM (#19715361)
Please see SDS and the Weather Underground, in that case.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by weaksauce on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:55PM (#19715801)
perfect. thanks for proving my point. if all you have are some radicals from the 60s and 70s you can't say that liberals are an issue nowadays on the scale that is radical right wing terrorism.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by braythwayt on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:35PM (#19715963)
Speaking as someone old enough to remember the Weather Underground, I would not conflate “anti-authoritarianism” with “Liberalism.”

Liberalism in today’s society is stuff like taxing people to pay for health care, or living wages, or supporting the right of workers to unionize.

The Weathermen’s stated political goal was to overthrow U.S. imperialism. That is not something I would lump in the same basket as liberalism.

So I would say that this isn’t an example of liberal thinking at all, whether from the 60s or any other decade. Just because it isn’t “conservative” doesn’t make it liberal, and trying to lump everyone into a false dichotomy is rather Fox News, in my opinion.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by mirimir on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:36PM (#19716322)
I used to love the "US out of North America NOW!" graffiti.

But maybe that was AIM, not Weather Underground.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by wisty on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:21PM (#19715896)
I'm very pro free speech, but having the ability to discuss ideas on a public platform being temporarily curtailed is only worrying if it's overused.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by johnisgood on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:41AM (#19718423)
Does it mean that you are OK with censorship for an arbitrary length of time, as long as it does not reach whatever your definition of "overused" is? It seems like you are OK with censorship as long as it is done at the right time, with the right length. Right being arbitrary and whatever you personally prefer, i.e. it is censorship in my favor, therefore it is good. Please correct me if I am wrong, but to me it reads as: "as long as it is in my favor".
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by hliyan on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:37AM (#19717403)
> This seems questionable to me, and problematic for people trying to find each other.

People here are finding each other through traditional point-to-point comms -- SMS and phone calls. The social media blackout probably saved lives today and prevented a lot of retaliatory bloodshed.

Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by arc19 on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:20AM (#19716711)
The most commonly used social platform is whatsapp in Sri Lanka, they have only blocked media, It is possible to exchange messages but not download photos or videos without a VPN.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by biql on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:06PM (#19720587)
This seems more like a failure of those platforms to be honest. If they could actually moderate the content and not allow incitement, which is illegal in some jurisdictions, I don't think there would be any problems. After all, they do moderate it to some extent since there is no CP, drug markets, etc.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media by chriselles on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:20PM (#19715420)
Agreed that a social media ban makes contacting people more difficult, but not impossible(voice,txt,email,forums).

Recent amplification of fake news and violence(30+ deaths attributed) on social media in India probably plays a big factor, as does last year’s anti-Muslim riots in Sri Lanka.