Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by tdhoot on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:31PM
(#19715723)
Free speech is not only about articulation. It's also about the ability to share, disseminate, and influence others.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by code_sloth on Sunday April 21, 2019 @10:37PM
(#19715970)
Speech without thought isn't free speech. It's just people and sometimes mobs saying things.
Freedom of information flow isn't the same thing. Democracy works best with an informed electorate. Information flow without discourse is just indoctrination. And that's what Facebook (unintendedly) optimizes for.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by NeonVice on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:35PM
(#19716312)
Speech even without thought is still free speech. You would hope that the most thoughtful speech would be easily recognized and followed in place of its opposite. However, free speech does not exist in a world where only one group decides what is thoughtful speech.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by tus87 on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:52AM
(#19717046)
The only speech without thought is tourettes.
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by bencollier49 on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:48AM
(#19717234)
And glossolalia, and sleeptalking. Oh, and recitation from memory. Probably some other things.
Depending on your definition of "thought".
Re:Fearing More Violence, Sri Lanka Silences Social Media
by talmand on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:53AM
(#19719365)
>> Speech without thought isn't free speech.
That's a rather strong opening to limiting free speech. Who gets to decide that my speech was without thought? Is there an approval process? Can I repeal the decision? Do I have to document my thoughts before I speak to prove later that I did indeed think before I spoke out against the people that make those distinctions?
What Facebook enables and optimizes for can hardly be called free speech. Articulation is not encouraged, merely the spreading of thoughts (both good and bad). Engagement has been optimized for advertising purposes. It led to banal agreement in the form of likes and reshares. There is hardly any discourse, people get silo-ed in echo chambers, and the extreme ends of the spectrum get magnified. Confirmation bias rules, and bad ideas aren't defeated by good ideas because they hardly come into contact.
So no, Facebook isn't enabling free speech, as much as they'd like to claim they are. At best they are a communication tool, nothing more.