Firefox's solution is a good one - don't ban autoplaying video, ban autoplaying video that includes sound, unless it is specifically allowed for that site.
Even on Firefox with media.autoplay.default set to 1, noscript, and UBO some sites still play video without my interaction. News sites are the worst about it; I'm considering switching some of my web usage to a text-only browser.
[edit] After perusing the comments of the article, I took the advice of "ryanja" and also set the following to false in about:config, and it seems to have been effective.
media.autoplay.allow-extension-background-pages
media.autoplay.enabled.user-gestures-needed
media.block-autoplay-until-in-foreground
Chrome has that, too, but you need to right-click->mute to mute. Mentioned my extension since it should make it easier to find the noisy tab because of the centralization, but haven't ported it to Firefox.