News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:29PM (#19616362)
A little bit like the US maybe?

I was already in a technical field, was laid off after a company buyout, I changed careers and took a coding bootcamp.

A few like minded classmates and I would compare notes after we did interviews.

The other two older guys and I got a lot of "culture" related questions. One dude was actually told by the recruiter that they were worried he was too old, he was surprised they'd actually say it to him so he asked ... and the recruiter repeated herself happily.

Meanwhile the younger classmates reported hearing nothing about "company culture" in any of their interviews...

The description of culture was often pretty benign ("we like to have fun" and so forth) but I couldn't help but wonder if it wasn't just a placeholder for some bias. On one occasion I got a description of "we're a young office".

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by mr_overalls on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:57PM (#19616669)
I'm mid-40s and probably sound like it on the phone.

I've been subtly persuaded by a recruiter from applying to a company via persistent "culture fit" questions. The recruiter _kept_ reiterating how awesome the office's on-tap beers, foosball tables, and casual culture made it a fun place to work.

I'd steer the question back to benefits, remote work, policies, etc. Only to have the recruiter hammer again on the "fun" stuff, talk about how the co-workers enjoy getting a beer together after work. Eventually I got the hint.

Later I found out that the company has a reputation locally for constantly hiring new college grads and burning them out via overwork, shifting project requirements, and random changes of software infrastructure. Guess I dodged a bullet. But it's interesting that probably many of their problems could be solved just from hiring a few experienced devs, data engineers, and project managers.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by vkou on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:27PM (#19617011)
> Eventually I got the hint.

The hint wasn't that you're a bad culture fit, the hint was that there are no benefits.

You don't have to be over 40 to need benefits.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @02:11PM (#19617450)
No, but the younger workers often lack the wisdom to see that they need benefits.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by mr_overalls on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:04PM (#19617911)
The benefits were okay, but not great. It's hard to convey the gist of the conversation, but it really did give the impression of hammering home: "You know these are young people, right? This is how they work."
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by x0x0 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @05:38PM (#19619208)
Some people want to work for a frat house. Telling you early on that is what the company is should be viewed as a favor.

I worked at a similar place, and it was a fucking disaster. They would be in the office for 12 hours a day and maybe do 5 hours of work. Meanwhile, there were endless gokart races, pingpong tournaments, and general nonsense. People wouldn't just waste their own time but also made it nearly impossible to focus on your work.

I made it nine months because I was too foolish to quit faster.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @02:12PM (#19617457)
You certainly don't have to. But a lot of younger workers I work for are less likely to be concerned with them.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @05:33PM (#19619155)
On the flip side, the recruiter for the place I now work at mentioned couple of times that the company preferred "seasoned" employees and there was subtle hint of "make sure you're OK with that."

It definitely skewed older at the time I joined, although we've hired quite a few people in their 20's/early 30's since then.

It's a difficult situation for a good recruiter. On one hand, you don't want to discriminate illegally, but on the other hand, you want the company you're working for (and the candidate) to be happy with your results.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by Asooka on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @02:07PM (#19617418)
You could fire back with "Well of course, that [foosball, beer] is a given, that's how my last workplace was. Can we talk about what unique perks your company offers?"
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by coldtea on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:08PM (#19617969)
As if the problem was the other guy haven't heard him ask that repeatedly already?
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by codesushi42 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:49PM (#19616593)
In a weird way, it may have been for the best. It is incredibly frustrating to work with arrogant 20 somethings who don't know squat. Youth doesn't just mean inexperience, it can also come with a lot of ego with nothing to back it up.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by agentultra on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:53PM (#19616625)
I can confirm this. I was 20-something once. I have the blog posts to prove how arrogant I was.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by munchbunny on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:55PM (#19617305)
I'm months away from leaving the 20-something club, and looking back at what I wrote to myself in my journal, it's amazing how much my own views and temperament have changed in even five years. Looking at fresh college grads now, I have moments of realizing "this is how I looked to the senior members of my team."

It's humbling. It's also encouraging to extrapolate that into how much more room there is to grow.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by neilv on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @02:05PM (#19617396)
Don't be humbled. 20yos interpret humility as weakness. :)
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by nostrademons on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:03PM (#19617902)
It's somewhat rational to do this, because when you're a 20-something fresh out of college your biggest challenge is differentiating yourself from all the other 20-somethings fresh out of college and showing that you might actually have some technical skills worth hiring you for. One way to do this is brash confidence bordering on arrogance; as annoying as it is, it seems to be more effective than meekly sending out job applications and hoping some company bites. Another way is to latch onto the things you do know and play them up for attention.

When you've got a few years of experience your career progression speaks for itself (hopefully). You're differentiated because of the sequence of jobs you've held, and you can prove you can ship things because you have shipped things. 20-somethings usually don't have those luxuries.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:58PM (#19616673)
I hear ya there.

At least one place never shipped a product and closed down... but god damn they had a lot of toys in their office and everyone was having a great time playing with them. ;)

Meanwhile I got a job at a place along side a younger guy who straight up was a way better programmer than me, but he really struggled with stuff like working independently without being told exactly what to do, and just understanding customer business logic / what questions to ask and so forth. Good kid but just needed more experience working. He moved on to a better place for him where he could get more structure.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by njepa on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:35PM (#19617097)
At least from my perspective the environment changed a lot over the last 10 years. Companies (and societies) that invested in people used to be a lot more common. You had at least a chance to get a semi-private office, experienced colleagues and a longer development cycle so you could learn things. Today if you don't adopt a self-serving attitude you aren't going to have a good time commuting to your open office were management just sent you four e-mails trying to disguise their next opportunistic move. I think the reason we often complain about the young is because they are more clairvoyant about what reality is being served. A reality which often reflects badly on us.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by onion2k on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:09PM (#19616798)
In my experience you get arrogant developers who are horrible to work with at all ages and experience levels.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by doctorpangloss on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:41PM (#19617146)
Part of the competitive advantage of the technology industry may be that young people can be management. It could be, indeed, the exact opposite of what you're saying.

In literally everything else, hierarchy is by age.

Consider that a bad computer program business can still make a bajillion dollars. Maybe the fact that its CEO is young enough to understand the problem matters. Or maybe it's as simple as, young people who are more skilled than older people, and now can be in charge. Most of the value may be tied up in something else, but most of the competitive advantage may be tied up in the age.

My feeling is, the ability for young people to be in charge is similar to (but not as impactful as) other historic opening-of-opportunities for people in the workforce.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by jerf on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:56PM (#19617316)
"In literally everything else, hierarchy is by age."

Hierarchy is by age because ability to lead and make good decisions is heavily correlated with age, because that's heavily correlated with experience, one of the most relevant metrics. It is so heavily correlated with age that many companies and/or unions have in various ways institutionalized that connection and reified it beyond what is justified by the facts.

There are young people who can lead. I suspect in the vast bulk of those cases a lot of that leadership is the wisdom to listen to more experienced people, and adapt it to their local circumstances. There is nothing wrong with that; it legitimately would put them ahead of their peers and bring great value to both them and whoever hires them. I suspect the number of cases of a brilliant young leader who is truly just doing it on their own is so small as to be not something worth worrying yourself about. Probably a lot of young would-be leaders have been hurt by the idea that it is some Platonic aspect of their youth they should be pursing and the fogies should just be ignored if not actively contradicted; that's very rarely a way to get ahead. The cases I can think of where some young founder "showed them" are not cases where they tore up the old rule book and did everything in a fresh new way, but more cases where they identified a particular inefficiency in the old ways and exploited that, because you really can't make progress by simply doing the opposite of whatever worked in the past.

"My feeling is, the ability for young people to be in charge is similar to (but not as impactful as) other historic opening-of-opportunities for people in the workforce."

No, I wouldn't think so. Those other "historic" opportunities all revolve around things that are attributes of people that are immutable. Your age is not such an attribute. Indeed, many wish it were immutable. But it's not. Certainly we want to make sure that young people have a path forward into leadership and management, because society's ongoing existence requires it, but they don't need any sort of special management affirmative action program or anything. Time will take care of your youth, in all senses of the term, whether you like it or not.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by doctorpangloss on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @06:05PM (#19619444)
> Hierarchy is by age because... heavily correlated with...

Listen, the same exact things were said about women, or Jews, any number of groups of people who were excluded, by whatever means, coercive or not, from opportunities of employment, in various societies in the industrial world.

I'm not saying we should throw out applications of people over 30. I'm saying that management is now open to young people, and it turns out businesses make tons of money despite being full of young people, so all your god-damned correlations are really just a bunch of fucking folk wisdom that doesn't add up to anything.

It's basically the best time, ever, in the history of the world, to achieve prestige or power as an 18-21 year old, ever, a benefit that is available to everyone's kids, including yours, and you're never going to want to change that, even if it personally sometimes results in less prestige or power for older people.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by jerf on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:55AM (#19624628)
"Listen, the same exact things were said about women, or Jews, any number of groups of people who were excluded, by whatever means, coercive or not, from opportunities of employment, in various societies in the industrial world."

And the reason why that was a bad thing isn't that it is just always wrong to say that skill is correlated with various attributes. Those things are wrong because skill isn't correlated with those things.

Leadership skill is correlated with age. The alternative is, as I said in another post, to say that as a young person, you are currently as skilled as you will ever be. You will never learn anything more. You will never get any better. You will never deserve a raise because you're bringing more value to the business. You are almost certainly not going to agree to this about yourself. Even if you do, I'm going to tell you right now that I think you're saying it just to be argumentative on the internet, and that you don't really believe it. Particularly the raise bit.

If everyone's getting better with experience, age can't help but be correlated with skill. It's a bit weaker mathematically, but in practice, it'll happen the other way too.

The reason we can even entertain the idea that experience doesn't matter is that there was a relatively recent event in which the environment changed so completely and quickly that a great deal of practical experience was rendered irrelevant. However, by "relatively recently", I mean, the mid-to-late 1990s, when we went from mainframes and "big iron" terminals to commodity computers and the web. Since then, there has been no similar sea change.

"you're never going to want to change that"

What I "want" is utterly irrelevant. I certainly do not want a world in which people celebrate failure to learn from experience. But that want is also irrelevant to what actually happens, seeing as there are still a lot of people working very hard to produce a cultural environment in which we studiously fail to learn from the past. (That's not a crack at you; I'm more taking a crack at modern academia there, which to my eye is to a large degree devoted to precisely that.)

I would advise you to lose the chip off your shoulder, try to learn from people who have already learned the hard way, and stop thinking you've got it all figured out, because ironically, if you do in fact want to displace the older fogies, it is precisely thinking that you've got it all figured out and that you don't need to listen nobody, nohow that will prevent you from doing that. The correct path is to A: listen to the people with experience B: think about it a lot C: think about it in your local context and then D: tweak it as appropriate for your local environment.

I would also advise you to carefully distinguish between people like me, who include step D, and those who don't. That D is all the difference. By no means would I expect advice from those who have gone before to apply 100% in a changing world. However, the world does not generally change discontinuously, nor does it change as much as the tech industry sometimes fancies itself changing. It's still going to apply 98%. That 2% can still be a big deal; it's the difference between Uber/Lyft and a conventional taxi company. But it's a lot easier to get there with the procedure I outlined in the previous paragraph than to try to reconstruct the entire knowledge base from scratch.

If, on the other hand, you want to start a business where you don't focus on customers because that's what your old fogie advisors told you to do, and you don't worry too much about revenue because that's what your old fogie advisors told you to do, and you don't worry about how you're going to get repeat customers because that's what your old fogie advisors told you to do, and you don't worry about complying with the local laws because "move fast and break things" is more important than listening to your old fogie advisors, and you don't ask anyone for advice on how to hire properly because it'll just be old fogie advice, etc. etc.... well... I did my part here. It's on you. One less "young person" to worry about upstaging me in the future, I guess.

Ironically to me personally, even as I write this, my wife and I are watching a relatively young person basically throw their financial future away, against the advice of all of their family and friends. In this case not because of an active rebellion against the old fogies, just someone not used to taking advice, and who takes the advice not to do something as a personal criticism, rather than an attempt to help them. It's not an HN-type of situation either. A tech startup may be a lottery ticket, but there is a chance of winning, and as long as you don't hang on to a failing business too hard, the worst case scenario isn't really all that bad; you made a living, you got a heck of a lot of great experience, and you can walk into any number of jobs or even perhaps another startup if you still impressed your investors even so. In this case, the best case scenario is that after 20 or so years of exceedingly hard work, they'll catch up to where they could have been if they just got a normal (non-tech) job, and both the average and worst case scenarios are substantially worse. Failing to learn from other's experience isn't just an academic problem. It's a real problem.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by tomc1985 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:45PM (#19617199)
Hardly a good thing, though. The last thing we need are inexperienced leaders
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by whateveracct on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:55PM (#19617300)
The sniff of ego, arrogance, exceptionalism, etc is a turnoff for me when job hunting. Sadly you don't always see that stuff until you join. And it also feels a bit inevitable - feels like every VPE I encounter does a lot of spouting answers instead of asking questions.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by jdietrich on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:13PM (#19616851)
Older workers expect higher wages and are less willing to tolerate unpaid overtime. They're harder to bullshit with cheap "perks" like foosball tables and beer on Friday. An experienced developer might be better, but who cares when you can get two junior devs for the same price and they'll work 14 hour days during your quarterly "crunch"?

Bad managers operate on the assumption that writing software is like making widgets - it's just a matter of man-hours. They don't believe in the 10x developer, they don't even believe in the 1.1x developer; their employees are just meat in a seat.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by liquid153 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:49PM (#19617252)
"meat in a seat" lol, gonna have to steal that from you
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:52PM (#19617278)
Reminds me of the old movie phrase about a given movie:

"But does it have legs? Will it put butts in seats?"

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by prolepunk on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:56PM (#19617315)
The other opposite is where companies only believe in '10x' developers at the expense of everyone else.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by sf_rob on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:37PM (#19616448)
Wow, I've received frighteningly little interviewer training, but the "things to not say/consider" talking point has been reiterated strongly. That said, I can't say I'm surprised.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by sevensor on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:50PM (#19616603)
I once sat next to an HR manager as he asked a room full of entry-level candidates who they thought should win the next presidential election. The woman from HR who was sitting on his other side turned and gave him a horrified look. A minute later when he tried to ask about their religion, she shut him down.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @12:54PM (#19616640)
At a big company a while back I sent an email asking about parental leave. I got an email back from very young HR girl who seemed perfectly nice... but clearly didn't understand the policy as she mixed up a lot of terms and concepts in her response.

But that wasn't really a big deal, I was used to HR reps at that company not understanding anything about benefits.

The kicker was that her profile picture in the email was her in the company bathroom, taking one of those "hold the camera up in the air to accentuate cleavage" type photos.

I didn't even want to keep her her email open too long...

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by kyllo on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:05PM (#19616747)
It's a bad question, but not an illegal one (in the US). You can be no-hired or fired legally because of your political views or support for a political candidate.

Religion is off-limits in the US.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by javagram on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:08PM (#19616782)
Some US states including California consider political affiliation a protected class too.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:52PM (#19617275)
When I was working in China, I would be copied on emails asking intern employees to verify that they were hepatitis free. This was and is very illegal in China, but the vendor company did it anyways.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by neilv on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:02PM (#19616712)
A little bit like the US: http://anewdomain.net/dont-hire-anyone-30-ageism-silicon-val...

You can also look at HN. Ageism topic posts usually have comments that a proper HR person could sense from across the building, fast enough to slam the emergency power cutoff button, mid-sentence.

It seems like there's often also an upvoted comment by a claimed middle-aged person, saying how they're so dumb now (which we who make a living with our brains should find alarming).

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by T-hawk on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:05AM (#19622270)
HN has those comments and HR doesn't explode because: Ageism is legal in the US except for specific prohibitions.

The Age Discrimination In Employment Act only prohibits discrimination against workers age 40 and older. There is no federal restriction against disfavoring workers at age 39 for being too old, nor against favoring workers over 40 at the expense of younger ones.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by neilv on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:47AM (#19624051)
Thank you, I didn't know that. We really should be looking at protections for all ages. 20yos aren't on the undesirable end of age discrimination right now, but I suspect most have little idea how quickly 30 arrives, when you're busy working (and possibly also having a family life), and that's way too young for screeners to be silently shredding their job applications.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by dictum on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:15PM (#19616866)
> A little bit like the US maybe?

One way humans learn to be less awful is when they observe the same bad behaviors they've been engaging in on their rivals or frenemies.

The opposite seems to be true in corporations and nation-states: any bad behavior by a competitor is an excuse to adopt the same practice and lobby for lax laws when regulations prevent that; competitiveness trumping societal sustainability.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by ramraj07 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:02PM (#19616711)
Hardly generalizable though. Went through a data science / engineering fellowship for phds and the first people to get placed were the ones who did a PhD decades ago and were doing something else for a longtime and now wanted to get back into tech. There are definitely places in the US that value experience and wisdom and others that don't.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:03PM (#19616724)
No question there are places that value that kind of thing.

I really don't know what any of the places I interviewed at are REALLY thinking too. Just suspicions.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by gvand on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:15PM (#19616870)
That recruiter should have been praised for his honesty... I would have interpreted that as a warning for a company full of twenty-something imbeciles.

No one wants to be an unpaid part-time kindergarten teacher in addition to the normal job.

Culture fit is a problem with younger colleges only when "culture" implies "juvenile behaviour".

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by usgroup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:01PM (#19616705)
Think of it this way, if this thing is real (and I doubt it is) then smart companies will make themselves the exception and buy hard into the 30+ market, and have much better employees as a result.

30+ women/men are the staple of science, and if they are not the staple of software engineering then you’re making a big mistake.

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by jerrycruncher on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:13PM (#19616843)
If your friend has proof of the "you're too old" response and is at all litigious, that's a slam dunk age discrimination lawsuit. Like, instant settlment.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by T-hawk on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:10AM (#19622277)
Nope, if he's in the US and not over 40. The Age Discrimination In Employment Act only prohibits discrimination against workers age 40 and up. Disfavoring workers of age 39 or under is perfectly legal federally.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_Discrimination_in_Employme...

Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by tyingq on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:42PM (#19617157)
It may have been an independent recruiter just offering up their experience with that particular company. In that case, I'd welcome the insight.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:23PM (#19616961)
We talked about that fact, but being in a position changing careers ... not sure what the long term outcome might be.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by true_religion on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:22PM (#19616956)
Is that a west coast thing? On the east as a young dev you hear about company culture all the time, and ther are some firms which tilt to hiring mostly older folk.
Re:Chinese tech firms are throwing out applicants over the a... by duxup on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:43PM (#19617168)
I suspect it is a company to company thing at the very least.