News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by monkeynotes on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:33AM (#19583523)
AI is like a mountain. No matter what humanity does, someone will summit just because it's there. We can control businesses to an extent, but a curious person in the basement, no one has control over that.

And good luck holding the military back.

One way or another humanity is on its way to the inevitable, and it's our evolutionary destiny because we are basically hard-wired to pursue the curiosity that is AI.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by auber on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:25PM (#19587185)
You are wrong. At least when it comes to AGI, which is the only kind of AI that really needs to be prevented from existing. Your conclusions are based on fuzzy thinking and extrapolating old and irrelevant data.

We can control businesses. And as for someone in their basement, it isn’t clear at all that one could develop AGI in their basement. AGIs discovery will probably require massive, massive amounts of compute. More than could fit in a basement or be powered by domestic grid connections without drawing attention.

Good luck holding the military back? You are talking about the US right? The military and every other government entity answers to the people either directly or indirectly. If enough ordinary people wanted it, the constitution of the United States itself could be amended into the ITunes terms of service. And since AGI is to the detriment of literally every human being on the planet, I think some basic legislation might be able to be passed.

Don’t succumb to these notions of hopelessness. They are wrong. And you even spread them around which just makes solving the problem even harder.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by rmwaite on Sunday April 07, 2019 @02:31PM (#19598862)
This is so wrong. “AI” could consist of super sophisticated flying drones with powerful lasers and the ability to self replicate and a mission to kill all detected life. If these were the only things it were capable of it would destroy most of us. Are we anywhere near that? Not now - but we are way closer to that reality than that reality would be to “AGI.”
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by gnulinux on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:35PM (#19586758)
You talk as if AI is something a person can "make" in their garage. I don't buy this for a minute. You can argue the exact same thing about, say, nuclear weapons. But people making nukes in their garage is not a real problem because such a complex project with a lot of niche resources is not attainable in a garage. Curiosity doesn't mean anything if you need decades of mathematics, CS, statistics and neuroscience research as well as thousands of human hours of programming to achieve something.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by skybrian on Friday April 05, 2019 @06:36PM (#19587671)
I think a better analogy might be to computer security. Script kiddies exist. You don't necessarily need to do a lot of research if you can learn to use open source tools. It won't be state of the art, but that's not necessary to do damage.

These days there are a lot of high school kids messing around with machine learning. They might not have the theoretical understanding, but I don't think it will require a graduate degree to get there.

I'm not sure why there aren't more hacker tools that apply machine learning? Maybe we're not quite there yet.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by newen on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:59PM (#19588465)
Script kiddies do things that anyone doing research or work in computer security can do if they spend time on it. They are not doing new things. AGI is a completely different beast and has still not been achieved after research done by very smart and experienced people with millions of dollars in funding. It's almost ridiculous to compare these things.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by MRD85 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:17AM (#19589541)
It's ridiculous to compare by today's standards but what about a script kiddie in the year 2100? 2200? If it is truly beyond a single individual then what about a small rogue nation like North Korea?
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by jononor on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:41PM (#19584355)
The amount of resources and thus damage that an individual in a basement can do is rather limited.

We got treaties on nuclear and chemical weapons. It could happen for autonomous weapons and weaponized intelligent agents also. But it might require a serious case of abuse before we get there, as it did for chemical and nuclear...

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by ZhuanXia on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:03PM (#19585356)
>The amount of resources and thus damage that an individual in a basement can do is rather limited.

It is for now. We will get to a point where a negative utilitarian with accesses to genome synthesis technology will be able to kill tens of millions. And this seems like it could become pretty feasible, even from a basement.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by a1369209993 on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:01PM (#19585905)
You can do that in a basement without AI. And I think, given the topic, that's all I'm going to say on the matter.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by bitforger on Friday April 05, 2019 @01:27PM (#19584939)
Right. Currently in order to do state-of-the-art AI, you need a lot of _computers_ and a lot of _data_. Neither of these is easy to obtain by an individual in a basement.

We would need to consider, however, access to finished products (like trained models). In some cases in the future, having access to the appropriate model might be as dangerous as handing someone a nuke.

How hard would it be for someone to assemble a indiscriminate "killer drone," given the appropriate image recognition and flight control models?

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by jononor on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:03PM (#19585916)
Image recognition and flight control makes a drone, but probably not a killer drone, as that would presumably require some sort of munitions - like a gun or explosives. So it might be efficient enough to just limit access to those parts?
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by MRD85 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:56AM (#19589641)
People with low education levels can show you how to build all sorts of things that go bang. Someone with an engineering background could vastly improve on a lot of designs. If you could make a small, lightweight projectile weapon that can be 3d printed then you have what you need.

My background is an engineering role in the military and my current path is CS. I don't think it's unfeasible that an individual could build a crude drone that would kill a single person. Building an entire swarm of death robots is a different story.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by MaulingMonkey on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:07PM (#19585385)
AWS makes it pretty easy to get a lot of computers, at least.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by pixl97 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:33PM (#19591899)
It is really easy to detect nuclear abuse. It's somewhat harder to detect chemical abuse. I have no idea how you're going to detect AI abuse without pretty much spying on everyone.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by samcday on Friday April 05, 2019 @01:20PM (#19584835)
I guess once we have T-1000s coming back to kill people we'll know that it's time to start putting the brakes on AI.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by everdev on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:58AM (#19583789)
I think there was once a yogi or guru-type that criticized the denuclearization effort saying why get rid of nukes if we still have the mindset that can justify using them?

I can't help but think the same is true of AI or any technology that could be used for good or bad.

We spend a lot of time trying to control the tools, but less time trying to improve culture and ethics of the operator.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by heavenlyblue on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:18PM (#19586041)
>> there was once a yogi or guru-type that criticized the denuclearization effort saying why get rid of nukes if we still have the mindset that can justify using them

Probably because politicians are more aware of the realities of _current_ human nature rather than some future hypothetical that may never happen at all.

Also there's an important point to be made that the powers that actually owned the majority of nuclear arsenal on the planet had enough missiles to destroy most of the human civilization.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by canjobear on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:08PM (#19583894)
We don’t know how to improve people’s ethics.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by BucketSort on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:23PM (#19584064)
Yes we do. You change the social goals. A materialist society will always bring us to the brink of destruction. Also, having poverty and fear loom over people is a terrible idea for the basis of a civil society.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by heavenlyblue on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:20PM (#19586060)
>> You change the social goals.

How do you make the majority of the society believe in the same social goals without resorting to tales a-la Christianity during the fall of Roman Empire?

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by carapace on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:36PM (#19587286)
> How do you make the majority of the society believe in the same social goals without resorting to tales a-la Christianity during the fall of Roman Empire?

In my opinion this is the key question.: How do we get everybody on board with e.g. UN Sustainable Development Goals[1] or something like them?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goals

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by true_religion on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:55PM (#19586947)
If we can’t do without it, I see no reason to not resort to “tales”.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by heavenlyblue on Friday April 05, 2019 @07:52PM (#19588161)
I have to admit that there might not even be a way to do that otherwise.

You'll either need to make the whole of the humanity live in the sorts of Star Trek universe, where everyone is equally educated and is equally capable to critical thinking.

Or you end up with the same system where the majority of people are obliged to give their absolute trust to the minority.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by BucketSort on Friday April 05, 2019 @10:22PM (#19588766)
Well, you change the culture. Sometimes that takes the form of a religious revolution, sometimes more social revolutions.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by macawfish on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:56PM (#19584519)
Wonderful perspective, thank you!
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by andrewla on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:05PM (#19585363)
The article fails to support this level of alarmism. Yes, it can be abused, but it's just a statistical modeling technique. Even linear correlation can be abused as well, vis a vis the replication crisis in the social sciences.

The danger of AI abuse is that existing large, powerful entities will put too much faith in statistical models without understanding their limitations, and will make bad decisions that harm people. Fortunately we have a filtering function -- entities that use these techniques with more nuance will slowly replace the failing ones because they are making better decisions. There will be a long transition as governments desperately try to save the dinosaurs from the consequences of their poor decision making, but if they can't make the transition, they're going to cease being relevant.

AI abuse is just statistical abuse. If a bank has a model based on ten years of real estate data that says, "hey, real estate increases in value, we should leverage into that", then come 2008 they'll find that things that their neat statistical model stated don't work any more. That's all the "dangers of abuse" are.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by AlexCoventry on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:06PM (#19585937)
> The article fails to support this level of alarmism

Maybe you missed the section where he said "Killer drones are a big concern." and "A lot of what is most concerning is not happening in broad daylight. It’s happening in military labs, in security organizations, in private companies providing services to governments or the police."

> it's just a statistical modeling technique

...and gunpowder is just a chemical.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by tehsauce on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:10PM (#19585976)
This is a spot on analysis. The danger is not that the system itself is too powerful, it's that powerful entities are putting so much faith in these systems that when they fail it's catastrophic
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by WalterSear on Friday April 05, 2019 @06:03PM (#19587465)
Some of those 'statistical models' can already play DOTA better than some of the best players in the world.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by 0x8BADF00D on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:44PM (#19585744)
> You have expressed concern that corporations have ‘stolen’ talent from academia.

Nobody is stealing anything. What they don’t realize is that the free market will incentivize AI researchers to go to the private sector. It’s just simple economics.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by webmaven on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:42PM (#19586824)
If private industry are using inflated (in the short term) valuations and low tax rates to fund a talent war, but publicly funded educational institutions can't compete by increasing funding (through governments raising taxes or printing money), then the playing field isn't exactly level, is it?
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by GuiA on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:21PM (#19588313)
Publicly funded educational institutions can compete by reassigning some of their budget dedicated to sports and administrative roles to their researchers, for starters.

For instance, the public US university I attended for grad school has an endowment of about $1B, and spent ~$150M on athletics in the past year. A post doc salary there is about $40k a year.

Why would anyone take this over $200k a year (with lots of sweet perks) at eg Google? Because they are passionate about academic research (and potentially teaching), something that the university is very aware of and has no problem using to their advantage.

Talking about level playing fields here seems disingenuous.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by webmaven on Monday April 08, 2019 @09:10AM (#19604815)
> Publicly funded educational institutions can compete by reassigning some of their budget dedicated to sports

Athletics programs are a huge driver of both alumni donations and student enrollment. Unfortunately. Not to mention licensing revenue from apparel and the like.

> Because they are passionate about academic research (and potentially teaching), something that the university is very aware of and has no problem using to their advantage.

This was more effective when the pay disparity was smaller.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by wskinner on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:45PM (#19586855)
Universities are nonprofits and pay little / no taxes.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by webmaven on Monday April 08, 2019 @09:12AM (#19604827)
You missed the point: Raising government taxes increases the funding available for those institutions.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by znode on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:09PM (#19588244)
Nobody is stealing anything. What they don't realize is that the free market will incentivize people to liberate your valuables into the private sector when gains are better than the potential losses. It's just simple economics.

Obviously facetious, but "stealing" is not some axiomatic boolean that never changes. It's judged differently by different societies depending on time, circumstances, and ideas.

"Raiding" employees was common place. Now there are non-raid agreements. If non-raid agreements became very ubiquitous it would be considered stealing.

Working employees 100 hour weeks with no overtime was commonplace. Now there are labor laws. It would be considered wage theft and exactly "stealing" if you did it today.

"Simple economics" gives you no guidelines to judge any of these things "stealing" or "not stealing".

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by GuiA on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:16PM (#19588281)
“Stealing”, in the USA in 2019, is a statutory offense punishable by law.

Making a job offer to an academic that they accept isn’t a statutory offense punishable by law, and therefore is not stealing, no matter how much you play with semantics.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by cuillevel3 on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:31PM (#19588360)
Only when used in a legal sense. Stealing someones boyfriend for example is not a statutory offense punishable by law.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by GuiA on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:43PM (#19588406)
Yes, and if an academic in an interview brought up boyfriend theft as a concern, it would be as ridiculous as this statement is.

Don’t worry about the phenomenon itself, which is 2 entities acting legally and of their own volition. Worry about the systems at play that enable the phenomenon. Universities are clearly not compensating (whether in terms of raw dollars or benefits) AI researchers sufficiently. That’s what one should be concerned about, not “theft” of AI researchers.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by UncleMeat on Friday April 05, 2019 @09:06PM (#19588495)
Maybe that's a failure of the market? If the market is pushing people to do things that aren't what we want then "its the free market" isn't a defense.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by carapace on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:04PM (#19587033)
> they [Yoshua Bengio] don’t realize ... simple economics.

Really?

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by lyxsus1 on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:27PM (#19588343)
Really. Because "they" are not "Yoshua Bengio". "They" are the journalists.

In a link from this quote: "You have expressed concern that corporations have ‘stolen’ talent from academia. Is this still an issue?" https://www.nature.com/news/ai-talent-grab-sparks-excitement... I can't find a word "stolen" or anything similar being used at all.

Seems like it was introduced by a journalist who wrote final article. And considering that, it's not hard to believe that this journalist may have some opinions on economics that are far from reality, that (probably unconsciously) triggered his word-twisting reflex.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by carapace on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:08PM (#19588942)
And Yoshua Bengio replies,

> "It’s continuing. ..."

So he's not objecting to the phrasing, eh?

The linked article has this:

> The loss of expertise in academia concerns Yoshua Bengio, a computer scientist at the University of Montreal in Canada, which has also seen a surge in graduate-student applications. If industry-hired faculty members do retain university roles — as Hinton has at the University of Toronto and Ng has at Stanford University in California — they are usually only minor, says Bengio.

So it's obvious he's not concerned about corporations literally "stealing" students and faculty somehow, like unmarked vans and burly men in black turtlenecks, eh?

> And considering that, it's not hard to believe that this journalist may have some opinions on economics that are far from reality, that (probably unconsciously) triggered his word-twisting reflex.

The word "stealing" is in quotes in TFA.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by lyxsus1 on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:37PM (#19589032)
We don't know exact question asked. And even if it contained exact "stealing" phrasing, it's possible mr. Bengio simply decided to ignore connotation for sake of productive conversation. It's clear both we and him are aware of brain drain happening but, he also have noticed mutual beneficial effects of the facts and I my personal believe is that had he felt important to object, he would, but he didn't. But that doesn't say much to support he believes it's unfair competition
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by carapace on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:10PM (#19592453)
I'm not sure where you're going with this, but my only point here is that it's silly for the OP to say that Bengio and/or the author of the piece somehow didn't understand that "more money" is part of the reason why people leave academia for industry. It was a stupid goddamned comment.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by DSingularity on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:18PM (#19587139)
Why so incredulous? Is he some smart guy or something? (Sarcasm)

I wish we would give people a chance before we dismiss people as dumb/.. .

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by i_am_proteus on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:24AM (#19583428)
How will regulating AI be any more successful than the 1990s attempts by the US to regulate cryptography?
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by jagger27 on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:34AM (#19583536)
The accessibility story is nearly identical. So I'd say nope.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by novaRom on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:07AM (#19583266)
Not a secret that largest military companies are actively investing into AI. Enormous opportunities and dangers. And it's not just computer vision and robotics - almost every aspect of modern warfare will be AI-extended.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by woliveirajr on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:03AM (#19583222)
> "has raised concerns about the possible risks from misuse of technology"

Isn't misuse possible in all (or, at least, almost all) technology?

Drugs can change humor, physical condition, hormones, and I think can be miused even as a long-term weapon over the population of some nation.

Nuclear. Explosives. Social medias. TV programs. Data processing with punch cards. Drones. Knifes. Herbicides. Small plastic rejects.

I understand the reasons Bengio tries to make, but it seems that it is the same problem with all technological stuff: someone, somewhere, will find a way to use it against others, and will cause minor or giant consequences.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by jononor on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:38PM (#19584290)
Most of your examples are covered by rules and regulation in order to try to get the most out of the technology without too much adverse effects. The point here is that we should do the same for "AI", and that we should start thinking about this now.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by naringas on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:24AM (#19583427)
in my opinion the possibility of misuse a defining trait of technology.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by novaRom on Friday April 05, 2019 @12:18PM (#19584013)
AI arms race is real. Will outcomes be good for civilization like those of space race (Internet, Communication) nobody knows.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by alwaysanagenda on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:05PM (#19585931)
Bengio is asked: What will be the next big thing in AI?

> "Deep learning, as it is now, has made huge progress in perception, but it hasn’t delivered yet on systems that can discover high-level representations — the kind of concepts we use in language. Humans are able to use those high-level concepts to generalize in powerful ways. That’s something that even babies can do, but machine learning is very bad at."

I read this as: "We have super-advanced skip-logic software that can produce specific results when provided a large enough data set, but "intelligence" as it is defined, does not exist."

AI is really just sophisticated software algorithms.

In my opinion, there is no true artificial intelligence, and it will be unlikely that we will ever create such a thing for quite some time, if at all. AI is being used as a buzzword to garner attention.

It seems much more likely that we will build a brain-computer interface before true AI, and it will prove more efficient than what we have today, which is effectively many computers churning through a super-long list of "if-then" statements.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by xthestreams on Saturday April 06, 2019 @07:01AM (#19590201)
This joke about "if-then" statements has gone too far, and when people cite it it's clear that they don't understand the basics of how ML works today.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by luxuryballs on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:21PM (#19586632)
It always seems like FUD to me when I read these articles. What is the specific concern? Can we get some examples? Sometimes people are like oh no AI is gonna take over! And I just think about how hard it is for humans to integrate two software systems and laugh. What are we afraid of it doing? If it gets out of control can’t we just you know... cut the power?
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by superhuzza on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:30PM (#19586710)
Did you even open the article?

"Killer drones are a big concern....dangers of abuse, especially by authoritarian governments...AI can amplify discrimination and biases".

Bengio is specifically talking about malicious actors using AI. So saying "just unplug it" isn't really applicable, especially when it comes to governments.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by luxuryballs on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:31PM (#19587236)
you don’t need AI to make killer drones
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by jhayward on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:36PM (#19587285)
This is an example of 'whataboutism', and is used to derail a discussion without actually responding to the point.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by luxuryballs on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:18PM (#19592192)
my original point was already a response to your quote from the article, what is there to expound on? the problem isn’t an AI problem it’s a malicious actor problem
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by peterwwillis on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:11PM (#19585416)
They keep using the term 'AI' when they seem to mean 'software'. We have all these problems regardless of how 'intelligent' the artificial machine is.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by drak0n1c on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:36PM (#19586197)
Meanwhile, Google has cancelled its AI ethics board in response to an internal employee petition complaining about a mainstream conservative being included in the 8-member committee.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jilliandonfro/2019/04/04/google...

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by Dobbs on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:38PM (#19586220)
The heritage think tank is a known anti lgbt group. They spend significant resources in the US and abroad to fight against lgbt rights.

I for one and fking sick and tired of my existence being subject to debate due in part to these groups.

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by satokema_work on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:52PM (#19586361)
What do LGBT issues have anything to do with AI discussions? I ask purely for information.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by CamperBob2 on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:42PM (#19588404)
It means you can't assume the Heritage representative is going to participate in good faith. They are bringing a religious agenda to the table, which has (or at least should have) no place in the discussion.
Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by Dobbs on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:10PM (#19587080)
AI is used to make decisions. It impacts every part of our lives. It encodes the biases of its creators into. How does that not affect LGBT folk?

When AI starts being used t decide who to hire or if someone should be offered a rental then what happens when it is biased against LGBT folk?

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by drak0n1c on Friday April 05, 2019 @04:22PM (#19586641)
Here's an article detailing their policy positions. No where do they oppose your existence:

https://www.heritage.org/civil-society/commentary/dont-typec...

Re:Yoshua Bengio: ‘The dangers of abuse are real’ by Dobbs on Friday April 05, 2019 @05:08PM (#19587065)
https://www.heritage.org/gender/heritage-explains/the-equali...

Heritage actively campaigns in the US and supports people in the U.K. who work against trans rights. Yes they do oppose my existence they just wrap it up in statements about “freedom of debate” or “women’s safety” even when those aren’t actual issues.