News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by yumraj on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:27AM (#19573423)
I think it's more or less generally agreed that Tesla has the best in class battery, charger and perhaps drive train, including motors, technology.

However, they have a single car plant and struggle with production and quality, after sales support and so on.

I wonder, as a thought experiment, if Tesla would be more successful if they become the OEM, providing their technology to the various car manufacturers. Something akin to Intel and computers, so that you can buy a car with Tesla inside. That will allow Tesla to focus on it's core strength and innovate while leaving the car manufacturing, QA, sales, support and such to traditional car companies.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by Klathmon on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:42AM (#19573624)
I don't think so. Tesla is like Apple in a way. They are both the "Brand name" and the "technology" all in one package, and splitting the 2 would lead to each one being significantly less than half their total.

Personally I think what would be best for Tesla (in a vacuum) is if they stopped trying to grow so quickly, and grew much like the other car manufacturers did, over a longer period of time, so that missteps and mistakes are speed bumps rather than mountains to get over.

Sadly I also think they can't afford to slow down, because if they do I really think the other larger car companies will eat their lunch.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by tbabb on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:18PM (#19575447)
I think if they could do one thing to improve their chances, it would be to find a check on Elon. A Gwynne Shotwell for Tesla, basically. Someone who can divert his energy towards reality, and stop him from making impulsive, insane mistakes.

Example: Trying to ramp up the 3 way too fast, and over-automating their production. Those were undoubtedly very expensive missteps, and if I recall, there were a bunch of top-level departures just before the 3's ramp-up. Where those people (rightly) telling Elon that his target was unreachable, or his method inappropriate, and getting fired for it? It sure looks like it...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by xkjkls on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:08PM (#19577134)
Is Gwynne Shotwell even the best example? It isn't like SpaceX is really in the best of a financial situation. Information on their financials is limited, as they are a private company, but most information shows they haven't reached a sustainable profit, and many of their ideas of how to reach their valuation (like Satellite internet) have hit snags.

Their last loan, they had to cut by $500 million due to lack of demand: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-19/elon-musk...

That doesn't seem like a company without turmoil either.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by tbabb on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:20PM (#19577237)
They are capital spending very heavily to advance their tech, so a lack of "profitability" I don't think says any more than it does about Tesla-- they would be fools to pocket their profit instead of turning it around to spend on growth.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by xkjkls on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:29PM (#19577310)
The fact that they could fulfill their whole loan that they wanted, and that they lost many important government satellite contracts recently seems to indicate that this is a business that hasn't reached a stage that it isn't out of the woods.

According to certain investors, this is a business worth $30 billion. That's not a company that should be struggling with these things.

United Launch Alliance had similar revenues (right around 2.5 billion) in 2018, but most only value them at $3 billion. This 10x multiple of their most obvious competitor doesn't seem to make sense.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by _Tev on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:50AM (#19583711)
Well, if you don't follow spaceflight / LVs it sure doesn't make much sense. From my PoV (very casual fan of the above) it actually is pretty spot on to value ULA at 1/10th value of SpaceX.

However reasons for that are too long to go into in one comment ... Mainly origin of & current owner structure of ULA, their current LVs cost & future and dynamics of SX launch business.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by yumraj on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:05PM (#19573929)
If we follow your analogy, Apple provides both hardware and software value. In the case of Tesla, IMHO, the value is mostly hardware as in the core technology, not, IMHO, in the car/controls/screen/ that they put around.

Again, as a thought experiment: Would customers not like a Mercedes/BMW/Lexus/Audi/Jag... with Tesla battery/drivetrain/superchargers but in a Mercedes/BMW/Lexus/Audi/Jag... car shell(for lack of a better word). I think I would love that, especially since (disclaimer: I do not own a Tesla), the Model S and 3 that I've sat in, seem very spartan from a luxury vehicle standpoint.

Moreover, to my other point: this will free Tesla to innovate like crazy on battery, charger, motor and drivetrain technology and perhaps attain a monopolistic lead , while in the car business I the competition is beginning to creep up. From a traditional car manufacturer's standpoint, this may allow them to stop spending on battery/drivetrain/superchargers/... technology and focus on making the car shell.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by rconti on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:53PM (#19575151)
The problem is, it depends on what you mean by "shell". I agree that most Tesla vehicles are fairly spartan from an interior standpoint, but I don't see that to be a drawback. I guess I'm not the target market for a "luxury" car, even though I've got a 3, and I'm also on my 2nd BMW. I simply don't care about butt massagers and cooled seats and chilled glove boxes or whatever we're supposed to mean by "luxury".

I want a quiet, comfortable car. It doesn't need the 7000 buttons that come in a new S-Class today.

But I don't want BMW to take a Model S drivetrain, and put their horrible nav system on it, their keyfobs, their UI. Part of what's so great about the Tesla is that I just walk up to it and get in, and it works. They've rethought enough of the car experience that it's hard for me to draw the line at what I'd want BMW to do.

I guess I'd want BMW... seats? and maybe interior finishes/colors? Maybe? A bit more thought into finishing the trunk? But certainly not just a BMW with a tesla battery and motor.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by jfoster on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:37PM (#19574295)
Have you talked to Tesla owners much about this? I think you'll find that they do value the package far beyond the mechanics that move the car.

In particular, I think Tesla may be well positioned in terms of autonomy. Although Waymo and Cruise might have a more robust approach, they are taking their time. I see that Tesla is very serious about bringing the benefits of autonomy to market across all their vehicles.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dragonwriter on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:49PM (#19574430)
> In particular, I think Tesla may be well positioned in terms of autonomy. Although Waymo and Cruise might have a more robust approach, they are taking their time.

Waymo has full self-driving in limited public commercial use; there is no way that they can be charscterized as “taking their time” compared to people marketing less than full autonomy now with promises of full autonomy at some unspecified time in the future.

> I see that Tesla is very serious about bringing the benefits of autonomy to market across all their vehicles.

I see that they are serious about selling vehicles today based onpromises of full autonomy tomorrow; it's less obvious they have the combination of seriousness and competence to actually deliver on that promise.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:08PM (#19574641)
So the Navigate on Autopilot that now will change lanes on its own (without driver input) isn't a step towards full autonomy? There are currently zero other companies that have anything as close in normal vehicles, zero. (Waymo is too niche and only really works in perfect weather like in AZ, so I'm counting them out.)
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:27PM (#19574873)
1 step forward on changing lanes automatically, 2 steps backwards on driving into concrete dividers automatically and killing the driver.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by windexh8er on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:17PM (#19576075)
> 1 step forward on changing lanes automatically, 2 steps backwards on driving into concrete dividers automatically and killing the driver.

People die in cars: true. Telsa features have played a role in human death: also true. However it's overly simplistic to point a finger at a popular (to love and hate) brand. However, human ignorance has also played a role in those deaths. Tesla isn't fully autonomous and they make no claims their cars are today. This isn't the same as making futures claims. So while Tesla features have failed you also turn a blind eye in your statement to the lives saved. Those are less well publicized because they are not as interesting with regard to headlines.

How many lives saved quantifies the risk of loss of life? While I'm not saying with hard data that Tesla has saved more lives than it's killed with features it provides, but if I were to wager a guess my money would be on the lives saved side of the tally.

The path to fully autonomous is a rocky one. There's so many things that will be huge hurdles the closer we get. But, take a step back. Look at the forest instead of a broken branch. We all benefit from these strides and mistakes overall. The media does a great job of removing all considerations of a story's context when it's convenient for a sensational article. Realize there is an ownership of the situation lacking in your argument. People die every day because of bad choices and mistakes of their own volition and those should be given a more equal weighting when armchair quarterbacking these types of positions.

Driver chose to ignore safe operational procedures of heavy machinery and died.

...is much different than...

Tesla car collides with wall, killing driver, while Autopilot engaged.

Both are true.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dragonwriter on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:30PM (#19574910)
> So the Navigate on Autopilot that now will change lanes on its own (without driver input) isn't a step towards full autonomy?

It's a step toward it, yes.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:06PM (#19574627)
Disclaimer: I do own a Tesla, and it does not drive like any other car I've drove or ridden in during my lifetime. My Dad says it is like being in a space ship.

No, no, and no. Would I like Mercedes/BMW/Lexus/Audi/Jaguar to have electric vehicles? Yes I absolutely would! But would you have over the air updates, a push towards self driving (even if they're not there yet!), and a very strong push towards sustainable manufacturing if Tesla was just an OHM that sold to those companies? You would not, because they have to cannibalize their own ICE business to fund / push their EVs. The world is better off with Tesla standing alone as a single company, whether or not they succeed.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by gnicholas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:33PM (#19575632)
Not only do ICE car companies not issue OTA software updates, some use the same software for driver assist features for years in a row. I had heard good things about Subaru's EyeSight system and went to check out the 2019s Outback. I was floored to learn that the system is no smarter than it was in 2017, when this version came out.

Are they not learning from the millions of miles their customers have driven in the last two years? One would think that there would be at least some incremental optimizations (either for common cases or edge cases) to make the systems safer.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by Rebelgecko on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:44PM (#19577407)
Some people actually prefer a car whose characteristics stay similar after they buy it. Sometimes these updates are beneficial, like when Tesla improved the braking performance by 20% after getting ragged on by Consumer Reports. But on the other hand I would be pissed if I bought a car that started trying to kill me after an OTA tweaks some weights in a neural net(e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/8a0jfh/autopil...)
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by gnicholas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:16PM (#19578073)
I understand the risks of OTA updates, but it should be possible for them to release a 2019 model that has more nuanced algorithms than the 2017 model.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by weaklearner on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:52PM (#19575817)
Another data-point is that I literally just went to talk by a researcher from Toyota's self-driving car group and they 1) mentioned some OTA updates they made on their auto-pilot features in the last several months. 2) talked about their data collection efforts from production cars- order of petabytes/day

I don't know much about subaru but other companies are definitely integrating advanced driver assist features/updates. No idea how they compare to Tesla's and in frequency of improvements but this is definitely a thing other companies are working on.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by gnicholas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:22PM (#19576127)
Glad to hear this. I recently test-drove the new RAV4 Hybrid, which just came out. I was unimpressed by their "lane tracing" system, which seemed noticeably worse than the CRV's equivalent.

I would be much more likely to pull the trigger on the Toyota (which gets much better gas mileage, due to the hybrid powertrain) if there was a hope of software updates.

I am hesitant to spend $30,000 on a vehicle whose driver assist features are currently subpar, and will only fall further behind over the lifetime of the vehicle. Makes me just want to lease, despite being generally opposed to leasing.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by FireBeyond on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:34PM (#19576261)
> Not only do ICE car companies not issue OTA software updates

Not true. In fact Jeep did this. And many of the same people who praised Tesla were saying "OMG, vulnerability vector" when it was Jeep.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by gnicholas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:15PM (#19576632)
Sorry, didn't mean that no ICE car companies do this, but that the vast majority do not (and I wasn't aware of any that do. Good for Jeep!
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dustindiamond on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:48PM (#19575770)
I don’t think they designed the system to continually exfiltrate data to be used for further improvement of the technology.

Not much LTE uploads is my guess.

Tesla has so much more sensor data to guide engineering efforts with.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by gnicholas on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:19PM (#19576098)
Even without LTE uploads, they could at least pull data down when vehicles are in for repairs, oil changes, etc. I realize they can't store infinite amounts of data on the vehicle, but they could definitely keep a little data about disengagements or other important events.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by uhhhhhhh on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:06PM (#19574629)
Once you become an OEM< you're giving up power and manufacturers will want some ability to dictate what and how things are done. That seems more restrictive than their current model.

As far as Merc/BMW/Lexus/Audi etc... they're all in the electric game now because tesla popularized it and proved the market. If they hadn't done that, its unlikely those brands would be releasing top luxury vehicles with electronic options now/in the near future.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dmode on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:18PM (#19578089)
As a Tesla owner I absolutely want Tesla to sell the whole package. I was a long time BMW owner and hated their joke of an iDrive system. Tesla is a software first company and constantly improves the customer experience. My car today is actually way better than when I bought it. I don’t care about drive train and motor. I mostly care about Tesla’s approach to toward constantly improving the owner’s experience during the lifetime of the car
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by xkjkls on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:11PM (#19577166)
To elaborate, there are many many automotive suppliers for engines, brake pads, wiper blades, tires, wheels, et cetera, that many current automotive manufacturers utilize to attempt to create their cars. They aren't the major value in the chain. Those products end up getting commoditized quickly. No one buys a car because it comes with AC Delco brake pads.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by beamatronic on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:39PM (#19575693)
I would sure as hell buy, say, a GM (Camaro) or Honda (Odyssey) electric car featuring a Tesla battery. Let everyone focus on their core competencies.

Edit: autocorrect

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by mcguire on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:59PM (#19574550)
They cannot afford to slow down because their market cap will fall and (1) they won't be able to get more money, and (2) they won't attract fans and media.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by bufferoverflow on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:02PM (#19574576)
They get money by selling cars at a profit.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by mcguire on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:00PM (#19575250)
I'm simply referring to the normal reasoning on why Musk doesn't like shorts.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by maxerickson on Thursday April 04, 2019 @09:19PM (#19578772)
They literally can't afford to slow down because they are carrying a massive amount of debt and the only way to pay it off is to sell an awful lot of cars.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by bksenior on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:37AM (#19573571)
You think thats bad. Tesla is about to have to head to head with all the majors who are now starting to finally harvest about a decade of their own research in the space (prompted by Teslas early success).

Musks ambitions and outbursts strike me as a man who suffers from the top killer of successful entrepreneurs, The skill/talent portability fallacy. It's this idea because you did something similar well, that your ability should port to "things like it." Seems like Tesla is going to extend itself to death.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by blhack on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:03PM (#19574590)
>It's this idea because you did something similar well, that your ability should port to "things like it."

Except that Elon Musk has:

Completely disrupted online payments

Completely disrupted space travel

Completely disrupted automobiles.

It wouldn't matter if SpaceX and Tesla disappeared at this moment. The history books would still be written about how Tesla and SpaceX were the things that instigated the change.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by philwelch on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:38PM (#19576861)
Musk was one of many founders of PayPal. SpaceX is actually run by Gwynne Shotwell.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by scottie_m on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:49PM (#19575780)
I’m pretty sure that Tesla investors with lots of money on the line invested in a car company, not Elon Musk’s hagiography.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:10PM (#19574677)
He also did zip2 (to fund x.com which he sold and became paypal), which was essentially one of the first online phone books / business directories.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dustindiamond on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:50PM (#19575794)
Copyright infringement from a purchased CD-ROM.

He is good.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by bleriot on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:01PM (#19576495)
I agree that zip2 was not a great accomplishment aside from making money, but it certainly wasn’t copyright infringement.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by rconti on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:54PM (#19575182)
I don't disagree, but this reminds me SO much of when I bought my first Mac in 2002 (mind you, I was switching from Linux, not from Windows) and all the nay-sayers were claiming stupid stuff like "MAC doesn't have virus problems because who writes viruses for 2% of the market?" My basic attitude was "I'll enjoy what I've got while I have it."

I've only OWNED a Tesla for 6 months, but man it feels like the other manufacturers have been about to release a Tesla killer Real Soon Like Now for a whooole lot of years. I certainly don't think Tesla's lead is insurmountable, but it sure seems like the competition is doing its best to drop the ball.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by xedeon on Thursday April 04, 2019 @09:01PM (#19578673)
> but man it feels like the other manufacturers have been about to release a Tesla killer Real Soon Like Now for a whooole lot of years.

Yes, decades and counting of nothing but vaporware and concept cars. Like this article from 2009:

https://www.wired.com/2009/12/audis-electric-e-tron-is-real-...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by beamatronic on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:44PM (#19575739)
I don’t know if anyone could release a real “Tesla killer” except for Porsche. It has to be sexy after all.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by bksenior on Friday April 05, 2019 @03:54PM (#19586381)
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by notfromhere on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:31PM (#19574225)
It's probably going to turn out that the guys who've been building cars for a century can figure out battery technology faster than the battery guys figuring out how to scale auto manufacturing
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by pmart123 on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:53PM (#19574472)
I'd be skeptical about this. The extreme/rare event is Tesla got hundreds of thousands of people to put a down payment on a car with zero marketing costs. Unfortunately, Solar-city and taking on convertible debt vs. equity have shrunk down their runway. Had they not done the related party transaction and issued equity, I think they could ramp production at a slower rate without the quality issues you hear about. I don't think Elon's episodes have helped his case either the last year. An interesting question though is whether there was anyone else in the world who could have created a car company in the 21st century, and gotten it to as far as he has?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by bjl on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:04PM (#19574597)
> The extreme/rare event is Tesla got hundreds of thousands of people to put a down payment on a car with zero marketing costs.

According to their SEC filings Tesla spends tens of millions of dollars per quarter on marketing costs. Where does the idea that they spend zero on advertising come from?

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by xedeon on Thursday April 04, 2019 @08:44PM (#19578573)
Marketing != Advertising. You might want to look up the definitions.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by pmart123 on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:31PM (#19575600)
Zero is an under statement, but relative to the $4B Ford spends for example, Tesla's $70M advertising costs are tiny. You could also say that about the number of cars Tesla has sold too, but auto companies typically have an incredibly large ad spend.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dragonwriter on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:41PM (#19575707)
> Zero is an under statement, but relative to the $4B Ford spends for example, Tesla's $70M advertising costs are tiny. You could also say that about the number of cars Tesla has sold too.

Yeah, from the numbers I can find, Tesla sold around 255,000 cars in 2018, Ford sold around 6 million. While I'm not sure what time period those advertising figures are, per car sold in 2018 they aren't wildly in different leagues; Tesla's are lower, but presumably marketing has diminishing marginal returns.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by cromwellian on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:44PM (#19574372)
Isn’t that sorta like what Steve Ballmer said about the iPhone, and then laughed?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by notfromhere on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:02PM (#19575266)
Cars don't have network effects like smartphones do
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by jhayward on Friday April 05, 2019 @08:30AM (#19581838)
People talk to each other about their cars and whether they like them. That's a network effect.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dustindiamond on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:01PM (#19575914)
All the German car manufacturers have in terms of engineerig talent and cultural is mostly mechanical, and brilliantly so.

But, the electronics suck.

Some of the most talented chemical, physical materials and electrical engineers work for Musk’s companies.

You can just tell that Tesla’s were not designed with teams in silos. I don’t think car makers are currently capable of that.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by sangnoir on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:33PM (#19576245)
Germany has a lot of electric and chemical engineering talent - you might have heard of Bosch and BASF. These companies are already involved in the car manufacturing supply chain. "Working in silos" allows engineers to specialize and get in-depth knowledge.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by philwelch on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:43PM (#19576912)
> You can just tell that Tesla’s were not designed with teams in silos. I don’t think car makers are currently capable of that.

Toyota was, at one point. I don't know if they are anymore.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by notfromhere on Monday April 08, 2019 @02:21PM (#19607728)
uhh, Germany has been the center of the chemicals industry since the late 19th century
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dmode on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:21PM (#19578111)
You mean like GM and Bolt ?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:11PM (#19574680)
One word... patents
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by ajross on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:30PM (#19575584)
TSLA has a market cap of something like $40B. Seems like the window closed on a determination of "successful" a few years back. Your argument seems to be that it's going to have to compete once the market matures and won't take over the entire industry. And that's... a flaw?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by pbreit on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:19PM (#19574076)
What has Elon done or think he has done that is similar?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by ineedasername on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:24PM (#19574150)
I don't think so. They may have a lead on battery tech etc., but I wouldn't say it's a commanding lead. Given a few other EV options that come close in range, other manufacturers seem likely to keep plugging away on their own tech rather than rely on someone else with marginal & decreasing advantages. On drive train, motors, etc., established manufacturers have decades more comparable experience they can bring to bear on these things.

For me the main question of Tesla is whether or not they can lower the cost fast enough to avoid having big manufacturers gobble up the low end of the market first. Volkswagen's MEB platform, for example, is set to come online with about 150,000 vehicles in 2020, a projected range around 300 miles, and cost in the $21,000 area. Will Tesla's still be nicer? Very likely. Will that matter? Not to people looking to spend under $30,000 for the their next car.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:16PM (#19574745)
They have an exclusive tech partnership with John B Goodenough (yes that is his real name), who is literally one of the inventors of lithium ion batteries. He's made a few breakthroughs[1] recently wrt max duty cycles, and only Tesla is getting that technology. It means their batteries will last longer than anyone else. It is one of the reasons the Tesla batteries have less nickel and cobalt, which is completely unrivalled and makes the tesla batteries cheaper to manufacturer. There are also patents around several of the chemistry specific things that ensures Tesla will in fact stand alone for some time in these areas. When it comes to battery tech, Tesla handily stands on their own.

[1] https://www.inc.com/wanda-thibodeaux/the-inventor-of-lithium...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by sgift on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:42PM (#19575038)
> Goodenough and his team aren't quite finished with the new battery. They've only created the glass-based anode. But they're working out kinks with the cathode, and soon they'll be able to make some large-scale cells.

This seems like one of these sentences which you kind of miss on the first read and many years later when you wonder "what happened to that wonder battery?" "Remember the cathode we thought was almost done? Turns out it wasn't." Until they have produced that thing at scale it is still part of a long list of research products in the battery sector, which may never be available.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by SEJeff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:52PM (#19575142)
But when they do, Tesla will be the first and only company to have it! Think about that for a moment. It makes it harder (read: more expensive) for the competition, when Tesla is already making better batteries (per independent analysts) than all of their competition.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by ineedasername on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:15PM (#19576048)
If they do. Not when. And there are any number of other promising areas of battery research that another manufacturer might bring to fruition and would eliminate this competitive advantage. If we're speculating on breakthroughs, that's a sword that cuts both ways.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by ineedasername on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:25PM (#19576155)
"Good enough" is, I think, the operative phrase. Most people don't get their cars near to 100,000 miles before buying/leasing a new one. (people average a car per 6 years [0], about 13,000 miles/year[1])

If the cars keep most of their capacity that long, it won't matter all that much to the average consumer that Tesla keeps theirs better. I'm not saying Tesla wouldn't have a place in the market, only that other manufacturers are showing the potential to eat up most of the lower end market before Tesla ever gets there.

[0]https://www.autotrader.com/car-shopping/buying-car-how-long-...

[1]https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ohim/onh00/bar8.htm

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by mrnobody_67 on Thursday April 04, 2019 @08:32PM (#19578519)
Seems like there's new & better lithium ion battery tech in the pipeline - though not specific to Tesla:

https://interestingengineering.com/new-lithium-ion-battery-b...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by Domenic_S on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:30PM (#19574915)
This take seems really dismissive of the technological lead Tesla has vs competitors, the difficulty of the engineering work, and seems to assume that Tesla will stay still while competitors move closer.

There are some nice teardowns comparing T's battery system vs. the BMW i3 and Bolt showing the substantial differences/advantages in tech.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by ineedasername on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:35PM (#19576262)
I'm not dismissing the tech itself, I'm dismissing it's capabilities relevant to competitors as being insufficient to make those competitors rely on a competing manufacturer for a core component of their car. And also that upcoming competitor vehicles are poised to capture the lower end market before Tesla gets there. Once Tesla gets there they'll have quality associated with their brand to carry them some way, but it may be an uphill battle against competitors who've been entrenched for a few years.

I'm not discounting their chances, I'm just saying it's very, very far from an automatic win for them. Far from a pivot to OEM, I'd be more inclined to bet that one of the big manufacturers that is lagging on EV's acquires them.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by dragonwriter on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:32PM (#19574238)
> I think it's more or less generally agreed that Tesla has the best in class battery, charger and perhaps drive train, including motors, technology.

Isn't the battery tech, at least in significant part, licensed, non-exclusively, from Panasonic?

> I wonder, as a thought experiment, if Tesla would be more successful if they become the OEM, providing their technology to the various car manufacturers.

Possibly, on an expected value basis, but Tesla is being run on a swing for the fences basis not a maximizing expected value basis.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by stcredzero on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:36PM (#19574275)
Isn't the battery tech, at least in significant part, licensed, non-exclusively, from Panasonic?

It's producing the whole battery unit that's the hard part. Toyota gets their automatic transmissions from another company.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by webXL on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:39AM (#19573588)
> to the various car manufacturers

Or to Apple/Google. While I'm a big fan, I fail to see how they become a dominant player in the industry, especially when most of their much larger competitors have committed to producing similar cars. Transportation as a service seems like it has more room for growth.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by zaksoup on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:27PM (#19574186)
Tesla tried this with Toyota on the Rav4 EV, for which Tesla provided battery and drivetrain. Toyota decided Tesla was so hard to work with that it was worth ending all future partnerships. Tesla also provided the full battery and Drivetrain for the Mercedes-Benz B-class EV and Daimler ultimately cancelled the project to bring the technology in-house. I don't think the issue is that Tesla is unwilling to be an OEM, but that their customers are unwilling to out-source development of extremely competitive technologies to a relatively volatile supplier.

https://insideevs.com/insight-toyota-tesla-partnership-marre...

https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a15340139/bye-bye-baby-b-m...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by jmpman on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:37PM (#19574998)
The RAV4EV and Mercedes were built as California compliance cars. They’re fantastic vehicles (I own a RAV4EV), and with a bit more range, I’d prefer that over the Model Y. Notice that these were released back in 2012, and almost 7 years later, there isn’t a comparable SUV for less than $75k. Once Toyota produced their required 2600 cars to get sufficient California credits, they ended the program.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by zaksoup on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:37PM (#19575675)
I don't disagree that they're great cars (I tried very hard to find and purchase a b class), but the reporting I linked suggests strongly that both Daimler and Toyota intended to continue the partnership past just the CARB complaince models but ultimately changed their minds. This was not a limited partnership that was always ended to end at 2600 models.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by jmpman on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:00PM (#19579281)
Maybe it was intended to last longer. The vehicle pricing was up in the $50k+ range, and I think deep discounting was required to move them. Rumor is that Toyota lost many millions. Cars.com allows you to search for the Rav4EV and B-class rather easily. The RAV4EV is going for around $14k these days. It’s a great commuter car, but doesn’t have the distance to make it a very practical solo vehicle. I supplement mine with a huge Suburban.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by zaksoup on Friday April 05, 2019 @02:40AM (#19580259)
Sure. I think we're maybe off-topic from my original point which is just that Tesla has done the OEM thing in the past and for whatever reason it hasn't expanded into a larger set of supply contracts.

And yeah, I ended up with a Ford Focus because I want to actually be able to make it from Oakland to Truckee without having to stop to charge...

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by jmpman on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:10PM (#19579332)
BTW, the Mercedes B has a silly range of just 84 miles. The additional 20 miles in the Rav4EV makes or breaks it for my needs.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by smacktoward on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:44PM (#19575732)
It's really hard to spend 15 years telling the world that you are going to put a bunch of other companies completely out of business, and then pivot to becoming a supplier to those companies.
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by thebeefytaco on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:30AM (#19573477)
Didn't Tesla already open source all their patents?
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by yumraj on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:07PM (#19573957)
There are patents and then there are trade secrets.

I would guess that Tesla's trade secrets are equally or a lot more valuable, and perhaps pertain to manufacturing processes, than their patents.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by softwaredoug on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:38AM (#19573578)
There’s a big difference between a patent and a working product
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by sangnoir on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:48PM (#19576381)
Only if you never sue Tesla for anything - including them infringing your patents
Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by uhhhhhhh on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:04PM (#19574596)
maybe now that would work, but initially tesla wouldn't have succeeded.

They reinvented the electric as a cool, sexy, fast and popular vehicle. Without that I imagine many other manufacturers would never have made the changes they're making now for electrics.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by quest88 on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:25PM (#19576154)
Tesla just buys panasonic batteries (https://electrek.co/2018/07/31/tesla-gigafactory-panasonic-b...). The technology is kinda shit - why distract the driver with a touch screen instead of physical buttons and knobs (those are considered technology too)?.

The only thing Tesla has is some form of self driving, and that won't be enough.

Re:Tesla’s First-Quarter Deliveries Plummet by iknowstuff on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:36PM (#19576274)
They manufacture cells WITH Panasonic and they have their unique chemistry, as seen in the more durable cells manufactured for Powerwall/Powerpack.

The touchscreen allows for amazing software updates and looks cleaner. The most important functions are on the steering wheel and the - pretty great - voice control available via a press of one of the wheels on the steering wheel.