Even if he doesn't get to dictate the regulation (thus not achieving regulatory capture), it would still accomplish the mission of keeping the business alive. They will continue selling their ads and making money, regulation or no regulation.
If he specifically described what a transparency report would say, 99% of hot takes would be about how it's wrong or whatever. People's brains would turn off and the opportunity for a conversation would be squandered.
There's an opportunity here for more sincere activists to promote meaningful transparency, because now he's put it on the radar of otherwise low-tech-literacy audiences.
For me, true transparency is being able to look at code. If your code is interpretable, and it looks okay, it is okay.
When it's difficult to interpret, like with a collaborative filtering algorithm used to select newsfeed items, an independent group ought to be able to query the "baked" system or measure user behavior and come to its own conclusions. I wouldn't call this a "transparency report," it's more like an "independent analysis."
It would take a while to determine what questions to ask. But to actually answer them would take an afternoon: a database connection, really. After all, they have incredibly comprehensive user behavioral data, so you can pretty much answer anything you can think of.
There's no cost burden or competitive disadvantage. Their entire tech infrastructure is built around answering user behavior questions easily. And most of the value is tied up in the data, not the models.
The problems they're experiencing are related to their particular implementation of collaborative filtering. If outside groups could see that code (at least), it would be easier to say, run a simulation, and demonstrate what kind of user behavior (or enemy action as it were) makes 10% of people miss 99% of "benign user content" and see 1% of enemy action content.
Maybe you don't believe it's implementation related, and you think it's something innate to social media. Well, what if the newsfeed just showed content randomly? Clearly that would bury enemy action content, just because it's so relatively infrequent. It's important not to be too dogmatic with this sort of stuff, because it will obscure your ability to reach across the aisle to stakeholders like Facebook and get them to do stuff in a sincere way.
So at its most basic level, sharing the code can't possibly lead to regulatory capture as you describe it. It would be more advanced than the status quo, which is, "Whatever the hell Facebook wants you to hear."
I think this should really give a strong impression. Venezuela went from one of the most prosperous nations in the world to what is likely now the worst place in the world for a poor person to live in, and it only took a few decades. There's no reason the US is immune to the same fate, and it started long before socialism with things like regulatory capture.
"The Venezuelan economy has a profusion of restrictions and impositions on businesses, particularly in the areas of labor and new business formation. Only the big, well-established companies can afford the high regulatory burden. This is consistent with George Stigler’s (1971) insight on regulatory capture, which abets government creation of monopolies stymieing competition. Further, the high levels of informal or underground economic activity in Venezuela are consistent with existence of a high regulatory burden (see Diaz and Corredor 2008). Unsurprisingly for such a setting, corruption is rampant." [1]
[1] https://econjwatch.org/articles/venezuela-without-liberals-t...
I didn't find the post you're referring to as having added anything additional to the conversation and I also didn't find it entertaining, which I believe was the poster's goal.
However, I wasn't struck with some kind of "this is a bad thing from other platform" vibe.
One thing I have learned is HN readers like Weekend at Bernie’s—-where my tongue in cheek defense of the film garnered the most comment upvotes I’ve ever received.
Also on Reddit it's frustrating when I'm writing something informative and it gets hidden between the memes and the jokes, so I tend to stick to jokes there.
I’ll often have a knee-jerk post that’s either funny, caustic, or redundant. I find things go best here (with some ups and downs) when I focus on providing genuine info or insight that others aren’t likely to already possess.
This pressure is a Good Thing imo.
Otherwise I tend to just ask questions to help me understand the article from people who actually know.
But my first reaction to most articles is a dick joke. That belongs on reddit, not here.
Normally an extreme appeal to emotion. In this case excessive use of caps-lock and a fictional narrative that doesn't substantiate itself.
beering’s sibling comment made essentially the same point in direct expository form, and was much shorter, so I disagree with the suggestion that that rambling narrative is any sort of shorthand.
Thanks.
I have been on HN for more than a decade. I tire of the higher-than-thou bullshit where a dialog of context for various subjects is shunned from some taboo on delivery of the premise.
So I reject your position.
Would you like me to cite things that I know personally about FB, or cite every single compacted reference made in that comment at great length so you can feel superior in your understanding that you may not have?
I mean -- FFS - understand that there are people who want to make a condensed comment on shit that happens in the tech field but I don't want to write a diatribe wit ha bibliography on why "because screw, them, that's why" is a salient summary.
(See: on HN "google deep-sixes usenet" on FP today)
Maybe for some people. I'm honestly not at all sure what you hoped to communicate with your previous post.
Hell there was even a poster in a different facebook story talking about how it was fun to tell headhunters they refused to apply to facebook because of ethics.
"Regulatory capture is a form of government failure which occurs when a regulatory agency, created to act in the public interest, instead advances the commercial or political concerns of special interest groups that dominate the industry or sector it is charged with regulating." [0]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture