News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by jcranmer on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:00PM (#19550058)
> Most of the US freight rail system isn't electrified because the capital expenditures of doing so would be very large, and its return on investment in terms of direct monetary savings wouldn't materialize for many, many years.

There's a decent amount of mainline freight rail that was electrified 100 years ago but has since been ripped out. It turns out that electrification has a lot of operational constraints that make it a less-clearly-good proposition.

One obvious constraint is loading gauge issues--you need about another 2 feet of clearance for the wires. And if one bridge or tunnel along your entire route isn't high enough, you can't move along the double-stacked containers. You also need a lot of infrastructure for the tractive power substations, and if you don't have enough of them, you literally can't run more trains if the traffic demands it (and too many means infrastructure costs you're not benefiting from). The operational inflexibilities of electric locomotives in partially-electrified systems should have course be obvious.

That said, there are substantial benefits to having electric motors driving your wheels... which is why virtually all diesel locomotives are actually diesel-electric locomotives: electric locomotives that use a diesel generator onboard rather than hooking up to electrical catenary or third rail.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Gibbon1 on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:30PM (#19550233)
Thing that solves those issues are battery powered locomotives. This idea generally invites disbelief but when you run the numbers it works because the power to weight requirements drop as vehicles get larger.

The result you can use overhead lines where safe, cheap and convenient and avoid them where they are not, like rail switching yards.

https://www.railjournal.com/regions/north-america/bnsf-and-g...

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by PebblesRox on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @11:08AM (#19554913)
Reminds me of the old fireless steam locomotives. Instead of boiling their own water to make steam, they had reservoirs that were filled with steam from an external boiler. Not practical for long-range travel, but good for switching yards and other local uses.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fireless_locomotive

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Robotbeat on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:43PM (#19550900)
It's crazy to me that people still scoff at the idea of batteries being a serious power source for things, but you're right, they do, even though there are 100MWh batteries deployed already with 1GWh batteries being approved and nearing deployment.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @01:26AM (#19551312)
The experimental locomotive discussed in that link has 2400kwh of battery (probably significantly less in practice; you don't want full discharges). The diesel-electric locomotives they'll be working with generate about 3,000kw for as many hours as they have fuel in the tank.

Maybe (hopefully) batteries will get better, but I wouldn't go dumping my money into electric locomotive startups just yet.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by masklinn on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @05:14AM (#19552313)
The point they were making is that the train would go on batteries for the bits of the route which can't be electrified (e.g. too low tunnels), the track would otherwise be normally electrified, the battery would only be necessary to cross between electrified sections of the track.

Similar to the battery-equipped dual-mode trolleybuses increasingly getting developed / deployed[0] allowing both point-charging at stops and more independence from overhead line (so trolleys can more easily be rerouted, or can serve increasingly longer sections without overhead lines).

[0] they've existed since the 30s but mostly electric / ICE

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:33PM (#19557785)
That is basically my entire argument, hybrid battery units remove a bunch of pain points with electrification. Like having over-head lines in you switching yard, lines through tunnels, on curves, bridges and grade crossings.

I think someone else brought up that with electrification you could also put traction motors in rail cars like is done often with commuter rail systems. And there is actually no need for the battery to be part of the locomotive either. Think old steam trains with a coal car.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by sgift on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @02:58AM (#19551678)
You don't need power for the whole trip. If most of it can be electrified with wire and you only have small patches which cannot (like the tunnel mentioned) current battery technology is up to the task. We will introduce that here in the near future for a new tram line going through a park (where we don't want overhead wires).
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by vkou on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @11:59AM (#19555527)
I dearly hope not. A 1 GWh battery stores 1/10th the energy of the Hiroshima nuclear bomb, and will release it incredibly spectacularly should it ever catch fire.

I don't want that thing anywhere near a train... Or where I live.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by niftich on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:55PM (#19550659)
Peak electrification in the US was in the 1930s and began falling in the 40s, but the Class I railroad route miles were almost 2.5x that of today. Electrification generally came about to reduce the impacts of steam traction (e.g. in cities and tunnels), to gain more power on grades, or to reduce the opex on high-traffic routes vs. steam.

In the decades after WW2, diesel-electric propulsion boomed, viable again after wartime shortages were over, simpler to maintain than steam, and more flexible than electric. This was well before double-stack trains got started in the 80s, but now that double-stack is widespread in the US, overhead electrification does present another operational hurdle.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by WalterBright on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:16PM (#19550156)
One possibility is a diesel-electric locomotive that also has a pickup on the top. That way part of the lines can be electrified, and the diesel fills in the gaps.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by rwh86 on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:44PM (#19550298)
Batteries are now a viable option. They can pull power from the overhead lines or third rail when available and run on batteries when power isn't available. The LiFePO4 batteries are a drop-in replacement for existing diesel generators, so producing them is easy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9s4heZe7ChM

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:26PM (#19550804)
For a single small passenger car without any grade, maybe.

From that video: 90kw/hr of battery. At peak power output of 180kw, you could run that for 30 minutes.

The ubiquitous GE Dash-9 used in freight service here in the US generates >3000kw and can run all day. They're also usually run in multiples to pull long heavy trains.

I wouldn't expect to see battery powered trains in the US anytime soon, except maybe short passenger-only lines on the east coast (which are probably viable for electrification anyway).

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Robotbeat on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:48PM (#19550923)
You, strangely, ignored the parent's point that you would just be using the batteries to reduce the amount of overhead wires you need, i.e. one would have opportunity to recharge several times a day.

(It's not helpful to focus on the specifics of a proof of concept--unimportant in this discussion about what is feasible--versus the fundamental figures of merit of the technology... Unless one is prepared to make the case that the specifics are the limits of the technology.)

There are 100MW power, 100MWh energy lithium ion batteries installed already (with 1GWh on the way). There's no technical reason you couldn't have battery powered trains. The "batteries are too weak" argument is dead.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @01:18AM (#19551288)
I don't think you've run the numbers.

A tesla powerpack is 50kw, 210kwh, and weighs 3500lbs.

A freight train that would normally be pulled by four 3,000kw diesel electric locomotives would need 240 powerpacks, and could run for four hours before needing a full recharge. Those powerpacks would weigh 420 tons - the equivalent of say, four fully loaded freight cars, and cost around $25M (plus whatever the locomotives cost).

The diesel-electric locomotives are a couple million each, ready-to-run.

Ah hah you say, you only need the batteries between catenaries! How fast do you think you can charge those batteries? If you can charge the same as the full discharge rate, then you need 50% of your track to be electrified, and you need it every four hours (assuming you're willing to risk full discharge cycles). Trains don't move very fast, so that's pretty closely spaced. And even worse, you now need electrical infrastructure with twice the capacity - you need to charge the battery and move the train.

Sure there's no technical reason you couldn't do this, but the economics are not looking good. Batteries are too weak.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by daurnimator on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @02:29AM (#19551534)
Why assume 4 hours with a recharge? I'm thinking closer to max 15 mins without a recharge. This would allow skipping electrification in some tunnels; in rail yards; on track segments shared with non-electrified trains; and anywhere that it's too hard to run electric lines.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:08AM (#19551720)
Sure... but now you're only saving a small percentage of the total electrification cost, and paying for increased cost, complexity, and maintenance of locomotives. It's not an obvious win.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @04:25AM (#19552090)
Far as I can tell he's also off by a factor of 4.

Tesla 85hw battery pack 1200 lbs.

3000 kw X 4 hours = 1200 kwh.

1200kwh/85kw*1200 = 170,000 lbs.

A GE/NS Dash 8 weighs in at about 390,000lbs

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @10:23AM (#19554353)
210kwh for 3575 lbs comes from the tesla powepack specs:

https://www.tesla.com/powerpack

Furthermore, it makes zero sense to compare "3000kw x 4 hours" since diesel electric locomotives can run for N>>>4 hours.

Furthermore, you're comparing the weight of batteries alone compared to the weight of a whole locomotive.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @07:18PM (#19559483)
> Furthermore, it makes zero sense to compare "3000kw x 4 hours" since diesel electric locomotives can run for N>>>4 hours.

This is simply you reframing the conversation from using batteries to allow hybrid electric trains to use short sections of non-electrified tracks to hybrid electric trains won't work because they don't have the range of a diesel locomotive.

I'm going to put this down as you're unwilling to argue fairly and thus lost this argument.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by stickfigure on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @11:54PM (#19560576)
You're not comparing hybrid against diesel-electric, you're comparing hybrid against fully electric. The cost of putting batteries in your rolling stock might or might not be higher than electrifying the last 5%. Either way, it's small compared to the cost of electrifying the 95%.

Note that the eastern seaboard (with its bridges and tunnels and topography) is getting electrified; the long and flat midwest is not.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by kzrdude on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @01:57AM (#19551425)
420 tons of batteries sound like an insane resource consumption in terms or metals and rare earth metals.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by Robotbeat on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:30PM (#19568108)
You just did it again. Used specifics from one application to pessimistically (and wrongly) apply to the technology generally. Also, you keep assuming the 4 3000kW locomotives will be running flat out, which is a terrible assumption (and would cause a conventional locomotive to quickly deplete its fuel, if not destroy its engine).

Here, I'll do it for you. Good Panasonic cells get about 250Wh/kg, or 0.9MJ/kg. Assume an electric-optimized locomotive would be able to achieve about half its weight in cells, with a useful energy density of 0.45MJ/kg. Assume about 1 locomotive for every 9 cars, and with each car weighing the same as each locomotive. So the whole train's effective energy density is 0.045MJ/kg.

The "rolling resistance" of a typical train is about 0.002, conservatively. That is a weight of 1 kgf has a resistance of 0.002kgf. (EDIT: This is a good assumption that works up to 60mph, the speed limit of freight trains, but at the typical low average speed of freight trains, it's actually about half that value: https://slideplayer.com/slide/4696076/15/images/12/Freight+T... )

The range is thus just: (specific energy)/((rolling resistance) * gravity) or: 0.045MJ/kg/(.002 * 9.8m/s^2) = ~2300km. https://www.google.com/search?q=0.045MJ%2Fkg%2F.002/(9.8m%2F...

That's enough to go from the center of the continental US to the coast on a single charge. (and from what I understand, 1 engine for every 9 cars is not uncommon)

If we have one engine for every 4 cars, you can now cross the continental US on a single charge. But remember, the discussion was about multiple recharges per trip, so there's WAY more battery here than you actually need.

And to just give an idea of the power available, 130 tons is a typical car laden weight. 65 tons of Panasonic cells gives you 16.25MWh of storage. Cells like that can discharge their cells about 12 minutes. Lets make it 30 minutes, conservatively. That gives a power at the cell level of 32500 kilowatts, ten times your 3000kW locomotive. Batteries are plenty powerful.

(And the cost is offset easily in fuel costs, as long as the battery is given the usage of about one full cycle at least once a week.)

You might point out energy requirements for braking and climbing hills. But remember that one of the greatest advantages of battery-electrics is regenerative braking. Most of the energy consumed in increasing elevation can be recovered on the way back down.

(As far as costs go, the battery pack should--including the price of industrial electricity and typical costs for automotive batteries at scale--pay for itself in fuel cost savings in about 500 cycle-equivalents while the cells should last at least 1000... meaning the overall added cost is potentially negative... meaning it's a market opportunity.)

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by creato on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @01:03AM (#19551240)
Can you even transfer close to 3000 kW through any overhead wires or third rail systems? It seems like 25 kV is the max voltage overhead lines run at. That's 120 A that you need to transfer through a sliding conductor. That sounds problematic to me, but I don't really know for sure...?

And if you are proposing using batteries to reduce the amount of overhead wires you need, then the average power you need to transfer while connected to the wires increases, not decreases.

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by TylerE on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:09AM (#19551723)
The most powerful locomotives are all electric. Powerful freight locos have power outputs of over 13000kw
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by hvidgaard on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @05:12AM (#19552309)
If we take the hypothetical electric locomotive with a battery pack, it would probably decrease the peak load on the lines. You only need maximum power at acceleration and climb. The battery is perfectly capable at helping with the peaks, while recharging during the cruise when the power demand is low.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by iggldiggl on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:38AM (#19553902)
To give some ball park figures, this is the default maximum current permitted per train according to national regulations:

- UK conventional lines: 300 A @ 25 kV

- UK third rail network: 6800 A @ 750 V

- German conventional lines: 600 A @ 15 kV

- German high speed lines: 1500 A @ 15 kV

Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by cardinalfang on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:11AM (#19553175)
A TGV can take over 12MW. It uses a single contact feeding the two power cars at each end of the train to avoid problems with oscillations in the overhead line at high speeds.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by anticensor on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:26AM (#19553280)
I have also thought of that. For example, a 10MW locomotive with CAT C32 as a backup diesel would be a good freight combo. CAT C32 has an intermittent duty rating of 1800hp@2100rpm and continuous duty rating of 1350hp@1800rpm. You would still have more than 1MW of power in tracks without OHLE.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t... by thomasmg on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @02:18AM (#19551506)
Longer term, Hydrail [1] (Hydrogen) might replace Diesel-electric. I guess this will start with cities, where pollution is a problem.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrail