Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t...
by masklinn on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @05:14AM
(#19552313)
The point they were making is that the train would go on batteries for the bits of the route which can't be electrified (e.g. too low tunnels), the track would otherwise be normally electrified, the battery would only be necessary to cross between electrified sections of the track.
Similar to the battery-equipped dual-mode trolleybuses increasingly getting developed / deployed[0] allowing both point-charging at stops and more independence from overhead line (so trolleys can more easily be rerouted, or can serve increasingly longer sections without overhead lines).
[0] they've existed since the 30s but mostly electric / ICE
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t...
by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:33PM
(#19557785)
That is basically my entire argument, hybrid battery units remove a bunch of pain points with electrification. Like having over-head lines in you switching yard, lines through tunnels, on curves, bridges and grade crossings.
I think someone else brought up that with electrification you could also put traction motors in rail cars like is done often with commuter rail systems. And there is actually no need for the battery to be part of the locomotive either. Think old steam trains with a coal car.
Re:Trains are more efficient and less polluting than other t...
by sgift on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @02:58AM
(#19551678)
You don't need power for the whole trip. If most of it can be electrified with wire and you only have small patches which cannot (like the tunnel mentioned) current battery technology is up to the task. We will introduce that here in the near future for a new tram line going through a park (where we don't want overhead wires).
Maybe (hopefully) batteries will get better, but I wouldn't go dumping my money into electric locomotive startups just yet.