News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by john_moscow on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:54PM (#19548708)
Well, it's called an exit for a reason. Essentially, a team of professional financial analysis that have models and experience pricing the stocks, and a knowledgeable PR team, decide the best time and the price to dump the stock onto the market in order to maximize the returns the existing equity holders will get. As a retail investor, you're practically betting against the house here.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by askafriend on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:02PM (#19548777)
Early Lyft investors have a 180 day lockup period - same as employees.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by nissimk on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:13PM (#19548869)
Is there any rule or provision preventing them from short selling the stock in another account?
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by nemo44x on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:18PM (#19548912)
Yes that would be a violation of their lockup agreement. They can’t buy/sell puts/calls either.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by docker_up on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:23PM (#19548962)
How would they be found out though?
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by dboreham on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:29PM (#19549003)
Through KYC processes?

They could theoretically conspire with another person who runs the trade but eventually compensates the principal. They'd only be found out through regular white collar crime fighting measures: parallel construction from NSA sigint for example.

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by docker_up on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:32PM (#19549031)
But how would Lyft know that an employee bought puts from E-trade? How is that information shared? I don't think there's any information being exchanged by every single brokerage to Lyft, is there? The lockup agreement is a contractual thing, it's not a legal document. I don't see how Lyft would have the legal rights to search.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by jedberg on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:39PM (#19549077)
How do the police know that you're cooking meth in your basement? They don't, but if you do something dumb or make a lot of money, they tend to find out.

It's the same here. Buying/selling options on Lyft as an employee is against their employment contract, and probably SEC rules. If they make a few thousand dollars doing it, chances are no one will find out.

If they make a few million, the SEC will probably look into that.

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by docker_up on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:08PM (#19549295)
Why is the SEC involved, especially if there's no insider trading involved? What if a Lyft employee quit a few months ago, and then hedges her RSUs with puts? There's no insider trading involved, why would the SEC care?
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by jedberg on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @12:46AM (#19551181)
The SEC deals with all trading irregularities and violations, not just insider trading.

The rules aren’t there just because Lyft wants to be mean, they’re there because regulations require it and also because one of the guiding principles is “no perception of insider trading”. That means you have to avoid behaviors that might look like insider trading.

A current or recent insider using hedging is very suspicious looking. What do they know?

When I left Netflix I was warned that I needed to wait at least three months before making any trade other than buy. And I was still restricted to the employee trading window for six months.

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by asynchrony on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:39PM (#19549519)
Employees are normally forbidden from trading any derivatives, short selling, or even buying shares in a margin account.

I’m not sure about the case of an employee that has left the company, but I expect that it would still qualify as insider trading through some window.

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by buttcoinslol on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:01PM (#19549246)
The SEC is the one I would be worried about if I was a Lyft employee that was secretly hedging my locked up shares with put options.

Irregular options activity does get noticed and investigated, take a look at some SEC enforcement actions for insider trading: https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/insidertrading/cases.shtml

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by docker_up on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:07PM (#19549288)
But breaking the terms of the lock up agreement isn't a crime, especially if there's no insider trading involved.

If a Lyft employee quits 2 months ago, and then buys puts on their lockup RSUs, I don't see how this is something the SEC cares about. At worst it's a contractual agreement between the employee and Lyft, no?

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by gamblor956 on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:43PM (#19549533)
Lockup agreements are actually between Lyft and the IPO underwriters.

Basically, Lyft would have agreed with the underwriters not to exchange RSUs for the underlying shares of stock, so the employees couldn't sell any shares on the market. The RSUs, by their terms, generally have restrictions on who they can be sold to--usually just back to the company or purchasers approved by the company. If those restrictions are not adhered to, then the issuer of the RSU (i.e., Lyft) can void the sale transaction.

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by dboreham on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:48PM (#19549145)
Some Google searching suggests enforcement would be after the fact so your scenario might well be permitted. Also found that Google searching "insider trading" may not be a good idea...
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by mandeepj on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:27PM (#19548988)
It's all linked via your SSA
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by rongenre on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:43PM (#19549110)
Underwriters insist on a lockup period for a reason. Everyone asks about short selling and options, and the answer is always no.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by monitorman on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:05PM (#19548800)
If things were as simple as this, you could then always short IPOs for a while, and the expected value would be positive.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by opportune on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:16PM (#19548906)
You can short sell but unfortunately (at least for retail, and to the extent of my knowledge) not trade options in the first week of trading for a newly listed stock. Which is a shame because I 100% would have bought puts in the first hours of trading when I saw the market price surge into the 80s. Lyft's float is pretty low volume so the surge of retail investors trying to add Lyft to their portfolios caused a mini bubble.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by mikestew on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:49PM (#19549158)
I'm sure you haven't looked over historical data, but if you did you'd find this to be a profitable strategy were it not for two problems: finding shares to borrow (a requirement to "short" a stock, because you borrow them and immediately sell), and if you try and fix that problem with buying put options, those won't be available for a week.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by xiphias2 on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:10PM (#19548836)
Actually so far for the last few years at least this strategy was quite profitable. New IPOs significantly underperformed S&P500
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by stevedewald on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:51PM (#19549174)
Yes, and the expected value is positive. Unfortunately for us, the banks that underwrite the IPO choose who to allocate the shares to, and they would prefer to allocate them to clients that have a history of not dumping the stock and/or lending shares out for shorts.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by gruez on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:04PM (#19549275)
You'd think that if the EV was positive, that no one would buy the IPO, and would instead but a few days/weeks later. Why buy before the dip?
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by oooshha on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:13PM (#19550437)
The entire value of the offering was traded in the first 30 mins which goes against that narrative a bit..
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by harryh on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:00PM (#19548771)
The vast majority of the shares owned by the major investors aren't sold on the day of the IPO.
Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by warp_factor on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:04PM (#19548793)
you are right and I'm not sure why you are being downvoted.

Most of the 72$ shares sold pre-IPO to retail investors were dumped on IPO day to make a quick profit. The individual investors and employees that are still in LockOut are now holding the falling knife

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by vonmoltke on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:42PM (#19549105)
> Most of the 72$ shares sold pre-IPO to retail investors were dumped on IPO day

Why do you think any retail investors got shares at $72?

Re:Lyft’s IPO Was a Success, Just Not for Investors Who Boug... by sk5t on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:59PM (#19550371)
> holding the falling knife

That is... not how that metaphor works. You want to avoid trying to catch the falling knife by placing a trade that attempts to time the market on a plummeting asset. But if you already hold it, and can't make any trades, well...